According to a study conducted by The Anaesthesia Practice in Children Observational Trial (APRICOT) on children under 15-year-old who underwent 31,127 procedures with anaesthesia in 261 hospitals in Europe, the incidence of the critical airway is 5.2%. The events ranged from laryngospasms, bronchospasms, bronchial aspirations, and post-anaesthesia stridor. Patients predicted to be difficult to intubate experience critical airway events more frequently. The Paediatric Difficult Intubation Collaborative's study showed a similar finding – critical airway events happened to 20% of 1018 paediatric patients with difficult airways in 13 hospitals. The complications recorded in the study mentioned above were cardiac arrest, hypoxemia, laryngospasm, and airway trauma. (4)
Comprehension of various factors that might contribute to difficult airways in paediatric patients can minimise and prevent events that might lead to morbidity or mortality of the patients. Several potential errors (error traps) in paediatric airway management can be categorised into preparation errors, performance errors, and proficiency errors. (5)
Preparation Errors
Paediatric patients with difficult airways can be divided into three categories, as shown in Table 1. Patients with facial tumours fall into patients with difficult airways; therefore, treatments and procedures done on the patients have to be done in a well-equipped hospital with experienced personnel to ensure patients' safety. The presence of a surgical operator when induction is being performed is an essential factor because, often, a tracheostomy procedure is the only reliable option to rescue a patient's airway.
Table 1
Classification of Difficult Airways in Paediatric Patients
Unexpected difficulties in normal airways
|
Anatomical obstruction
Functional obstruction
|
Disturbances of normal paediatric airways
|
Inflammation
Foreign bodies
Allergy
Trauma
|
Difficult airways
|
Abnormality of head, neck, or airway morphology
Congenital malformations associated with syndromes
Acquired malformation (burn injuries, scars)
Mass or tumour
Abnormality in the subglottic or tracheal region
Anterior mediastinum mass
|
Table 1. Difficult Airways Classification
Source: Krishna SG, Bryant JF, Tobias JD. Management of the Difficult Airway in the Paediatric Patient. J Paediatr Intensive Care. 2018
In this case series, both of the patients planned to have a tracheostomy to rescue their airways since there had been signs of obstruction – inspiratory and expiratory stridor when the patients were awake. The patients were both categorised as patients with difficult airways. Hence, it is not recommended to sedate the patients in a facility without a multidisciplinary team with experts in paediatric airway management. Performing tracheostomy procedures without sedation in these patients was very difficult because the patients were not cooperative, unlike adults. Preparation to anticipate a difficult airway can be done with preoperative assessment (Table.2) (1)
Table 2
Anticipation for Difficult Airway
1. Is the procedure or surgery elective or urgent or emergent?
|
2. In the event of failure to secure the airway, can the patient be awakened and can an alternative airway strategy be planned for a later time?
|
3. Are any further evaluations necessary to define the airway?
|
4. Can the airway be optimized further before anaesthesia or sedation?
|
5. What is the level of sedation that will be required: awake (rare in paediatric patients), sedated, or anaesthetized?
|
6. If sedation or anaesthesia is attempted, can a patent airway and spontaneous ventilation be preserved?
|
7. Should a surgical airway be electively performed?
|
8. What is the preferred route for endotracheal intubation: oral or nasal?
|
9. What is the method of securing the airway: FOB intubation, use of a supraglottic airway (e.g., LMA) or indirect video laryngoscopy?
|
10. Is the difficult airway cart accessible and what equipment will be utilized to secure the airway?
|
11. If there is a loss of airway control at any point, what is the rescue route and pathway?
|
12. Is there a need for emergency surgical access? If so, would it be prudent to have an ENT surgeon in the room?
|
13. Is there a need to be prepared for complex advanced rescue procedures, such as emergency tracheostomy, emergency sternotomy, or vascular access for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation?
|
Source: Krishna SG, Bryant JF, Tobias JD. Management of the Difficult Airway in the Paediatric Patient. J Paediatr Intensive Care. 2018
Preparation of the airway device
-
Ventilation device: face mask, nasal cannula (HFNC, LFNC), supraglottic airway (6, 7, 8)
-
Intubation device: direct laryngoscopy, angulated video laryngoscopy, hyperangulated video laryngoscopy, fiberoptic bronchoscopy. (6, 7, 8)
-
Front of neck airway device. (6, 7, 8)
Endotracheal tubes with various numbers, suction catheter, stylet, and emergency trolley are available and easy to reach before starting the induction. (6, 7, 8)
Inter-team Communication
Awareness of risk factors for difficult airways and preparation to address those are essential components in dealing with children with difficult airways. It is not uncommon that the difficult airways are caused by not only anatomical factors but also physiological factors, cardiopulmonary reserve, airway secretions, blood in the airway, etc. Communicating with more experienced anaesthesiologists, including a team of surgeons, such as ENT surgeons, to devise a plan for airway management; using a standardized checklist during a time out could result in a favourable outcome when facing a child with a difficult airway. These actions may also improve the level of care provided for the next surgeries since effective communication has been built, and every team member has been given a specific task according to their area of expertise. The number of paediatric airway complications, morbidity, and mortality also can be decreased if the actions mentioned above are implemented. (5)
Table 3
Airway Management Time-out Checklist
Example of a Structured Airway Management Time-out
|
Introduction and Roles
|
- Intubation
- Assistance for adjunct maneuvers
- Monitoring patient and medication administration
- Equipment setup
|
Approach
|
- Awake or after induction
- Consider patient status (cardiopulmonary reserve, resuscitation needs)
|
Ventilation Strategy
|
- Spontaneous or controlled
- Passive oxygenation plan
|
Airway Plan
|
- Plan A, B, C delineated, including device to be used
- Appropriate equipment available and set up, including backup plans
- Availability of appropriate experienced help and list of phone numbers of: other anesthesiologists, otolaryngologists, ECMO team
|
Sohn L, Peyton J, von Ungern-Sternberg BS, Jagannathan N. Error traps in paediatric difficult airway management. Paediatr Anaesth. 2021
In the first case, after the intubation attempts failed, we experienced difficulties in finding front neck access. Learning from that incident, we conducted a pre-surgery briefing led by anaesthesiologists to decide the course of action for airway management if there were any difficulties in the second case's surgery. Difficult airway management guidelines (Picture 3) were very accommodating in aiding each team member in understanding their role. (1)
Pre-formulated Airway Management Plan for the 2nd Patient
Performance Errors
To minimize the risks of airway complications, endotracheal intubation should be successful in the first attempt. There are several ways to achieve that, such as:
1. Adequate passive oxygenation before an endotracheal intubation attempt
Adequate oxygen supplementation can reduce the risk of hypoxemia. There are a few means to give passive oxygenation: using a nasal cannula, modified nasopharyngeal airway, modified Ring-Adair-Elwyn (RAE) TT, and high flow nasal cannula, as shown in Figs. 3 and 4. (9)
We performed a face mask simulation on the 2nd patient to fit the face mask accommodating to the patient's anatomical difference and conduct passive oxygenation via the face mask, as shown in Fig. 5 (4, 10)
2. Implementing an advanced airway technique as an initial attempt and choosing medications according to the patient's condition.
In a potentially difficult airway case, a child's uncooperativeness often hinders an awake FOB intubation attempt. On that condition, FOB intubation with sedation or anaesthesia could be an option. (11) Complications that often arise with sedation and anaesthesia are airway obstruction due to loss of consciousness and respiratory depression. Intravenous sedation agents, such as Ketamine, Dexmedetomidine, or Midazolam, are several agents that have minimal effect on respiratory control and can be used in such cases.
In the 2nd case, we used a combination of 1 mcg/kg/hour of intravenous Dexmedetomidine and 1.5 mcg/kg of intravenous Fentanyl. To further deepened the anaesthesia, inhalation of 6%vol of Sevoflurane was used. During the process of FOB, the depth of anaesthesia was preserved, and the patient kept breathing spontaneously without airway obstruction.
When the depth of the anaesthesia is adequate, airway management can be done with:
-
Indirect video laryngoscopy (9, 11)
-
Intubation using FOB (9, 11)
-
Intubating LMA (4, 10)
Video laryngoscopy has advantages over direct laryngoscopy: better field of view in patients with difficult airways without having to align oral, pharyngeal, and laryngeal axes; better view of the anterior portion of glottis; lower risk of injuring intraoral soft tissues, although there have been some reports regarding this; and often tongue displacement is not necessary. However, there are several setbacks to indirect video laryngoscopy: Good hand-eye coordination is needed; it cannot be used in patients with limited mouth opening and/or copious intraoral secretion or blood as secretion and blood will obstruct the lens. (12, 13)
In patients potentially difficult to ventilate, awake FOB can be a choice if there are no other safer options, especially for special populations, such as infants and neonates. Airway block can be performed on cooperative patients if local anaesthetic nebulization is impossible. Airway block has to avoid toxic doses of local anaesthetics. (5)
Airway Ultrasonography (USG)
Airway USG can be used to (a) determine the correct tracheal tube (TT) size; (b) confirm TT placement; (c) identify the cricothyroid membrane before anaesthesia induction on patients with difficult airways; (d) qualitatively or quantitatively determine gastric contents before induction. (14, 15). Figure 6, 7, and 9 shows the ultrasound of the trachea on a patient.
Proficiency Errors
All airway management techniques require team proficiency to be executed well. Declining performance and skill could happen if one does not constantly learn and train. Knowing and being able to execute various techniques are musts when facing an unusual case. Recognizing every piece of equipment that will be used is crucial. Pressure and stress when facing a difficult airway can lead to a significant increase in errors. (3, 12, 16, 17)
Not all airways devices can be used in every different situation. Recognizing the advantages and disadvantages of every device used before a procedure could help the operator to arrange a plan. Acknowledging one's limitation in performing certain procedures will give realization to consult the experts and call for help earlier.3 Technicians and assistants to assist in operating machinery also need to be prepared. To improve the skill of handling cases with difficult airways, individual and team training and simulation need to be conducted. (18, 19)
In the 2nd case, expert consults were obtained earlier, and a preoperative briefing was also performed to ensure each team member knew their role, ability, and limitation. After the procedure, a debriefing with anaesthesiologists, ENT surgeons, surgical nurses, anaesthetists, residents, and technicians was carried out to review the process and as a lesson for future improvement of patient care and safety
Difficult airway management in paediatric patients with mandibular tumours can generate high pressure and stress for anaesthesiologists. Failure to do so can result in fatal complications resulting in death. To avoid error traps that might happen in the limited time and high-pressure environment, several steps can be done:
-
Good preparation: thorough assessment, build an effective intra- and inter-team communication, devise mitigation plans
-
During the "performance": perform adequate preoxygenation, and opt for a suitable anaesthesia technique and airway device.
-
Proficiency: acknowledge own limitations, keep learning and improving from past experiences.