3.1 Identification and synteny analysis of VQ genes families
Sixty-one candidate NtVQ genes were identified in the tobacco genome sequence. The coding length of sixty-one NtVQ gene sequences ranged from 216 to 1404 bp (Table 1). The exon numbers of NtVQ genes ranged from one to nine, and 77.05% of these genes had one exon. The isoelectric points of thirty NtVQ proteins were alkaline and these of the remaining proteins were acidic, which indicated that NtVQ gene family had nearly harmonious relationship between alkaline and acidic amino acids.
As shown in Fig. 1a and Table 2, a total of nineteen NtVQ genes were clustered into twelve tandem duplication event regions on tobacco chromosome 2, 4, 5, 8, 10, 14, 15, 17, 20, 21, 22 and 24, indicating that less than half of the NtVQ genes were generated by tandem duplication. A synteny analysis from tobacco and Arabidopsis further showed five syntenic relations that contained four NtVQ genes and five AtVQ genes (Fig. 1b, Table 3).
Table 1
Tobacco VQ genes and accession numbers. CDS: coding sequence.
Gene Locus | Gene Length | Start | End | Exon Number | CDS (bp) | Protein (aa) | Amino acid proportion (%) | pI |
Alpha helix (Hh) | Beta-sheet (E) | Loop/Random coil (L/C) |
Nitab4.5_0002305g0070.1 | 588 | 399194 | 399781 | 1 | 588 | 195 | 28/14.36% | 33/16.92% | 134/68.72% | 5.83 |
Nitab4.5_0000138g0140.1 | 564 | 1093775 | 1094338 | 1 | 564 | 187 | 29/15.51% | 28/14.97% | 130/69.52% | 5.92 |
Nitab4.5_0000443g0160.1 | 627 | 826332 | 826958 | 1 | 627 | 208 | 27/12.98% | 36/17.31% | 145/69.71% | 4.98 |
Nitab4.5_0008965g0010.1 | 648 | 78700 | 79347 | 1 | 648 | 215 | 26/12.09% | 45/20.93 | 144/66.98% | 6.29 |
Nitab4.5_0008708g0020.1 | 675 | 84655 | 85329 | 1 | 675 | 224 | 54/24.11% | 43/19.20% | 127/56.70% | 4.72 |
Nitab4.5_0000443g0140.1 | 675 | 852301 | 852975 | 1 | 675 | 224 | 60/26.79% | 43/19.20% | 121/54.02% | 4.97 |
Nitab4.5_0002570g0040.1 | 603 | 93406 | 94008 | 1 | 603 | 200 | 34/17.00% | 28/14.50% | 137/68.50% | 10.6 |
Nitab4.5_0000073g0510.1 | 600 | 1448350 | 1448949 | 1 | 600 | 199 | 27/13.57% | 30/15.08% | 142/71.36% | 8.34 |
Nitab4.5_0000170g0400.1 | 744 | 926895 | 927638 | 2 | 529 | 202 | 31/15.35% | 32/15.84% | 139/68.81% | 10.46 |
Nitab4.5_0002232g0070.1 | 612 | 396497 | 397108 | 1 | 612 | 203 | 25/12.32% | 31/15.27% | 147/72.41% | 10.32 |
Nitab4.5_0005431g0010.1 | 1203 | 72449 | 73651 | 1 | 1203 | 400 | 68/17.00% | 37/9.25% | 295/73.75% | 6.45 |
Nitab4.5_0000421g0040.1 | 894 | 164669 | 165562 | 1 | 894 | 297 | 31/10.44% | 25/8.42% | 241/81.14% | 6.22 |
Nitab4.5_0002098g0010.1 | 879 | 132258 | 133136 | 1 | 879 | 292 | 24/8.22% | 31/10.62% | 237/81.16% | 5.95 |
Nitab4.5_0008140g0010.1 | 1674 | 39111 | 40784 | 3 | 1338 | 445 | 43/9.66% | 25/5.62% | 377/84.72% | 7.33 |
Nitab4.5_0001729g0010.1 | 1404 | 94292 | 95695 | 1 | 1404 | 467 | 32/6.85% | 44/9.42% | 391/83.73% | 6.49 |
Nitab4.5_0001270g0170.1 | 660 | 438569 | 439228 | 1 | 660 | 219 | 49/22.37% | 31/14.16% | 139/63.47% | 5.91 |
Nitab4.5_0000123g0220.1 | 660 | 409929 | 410588 | 1 | 660 | 220 | 45/20.55% | 21/9.59% | 15./69.86% | 6.3 |
Nitab4.5_0000062g0280.1 | 657 | 1034829 | 1035485 | 1 | 657 | 218 | 35/16.06% | 19/8.72% | 164/75.23% | 9.16 |
Nitab4.5_0010768g0030.1 | 10278 | 14633 | 24910 | 9 | 1347 | 449 | 144/32.07% | 90/20.04% | 215/47.88% | 5.57 |
Nitab4.5_0016059g0010.1 | 593 | 9637 | 10229 | 2 | 321 | 106 | 21/19.81% | 11/10.38% | 74/69.81% | 9.74 |
Nitab4.5_0008385g0010.1 | 863 | 402586 | 41148 | 2 | 645 | 214 | 33/15.42% | 24/11.21% | 157/73.36% | 8.34 |
Nitab4.5_0000680g0150.1 | 516 | 696743 | 697258 | 1 | 516 | 171 | 30/17.54% | 18/10.53% | 123/71.93% | 6.56 |
Nitab4.5_0000680g0130.1 | 7468 | 604651 | 612118 | 2 | 1167 | 388 | 84/21.65% | 36/9.28% | 268/69.07% | 9.08 |
Nitab4.5_0008385g0020.1 | 9020 | 59372 | 68391 | 2 | 1143 | 380 | 98/25.79% | 26/6.84% | 256/67.37% | 9.28 |
Nitab4.5_0008558g0010.1 | 2332 | 7920 | 10251 | 3 | 969 | 322 | 93/28.88% | 40/12.42% | 189/58.70% | 10.24 |
Nitab4.5_0000786g0140.1 | 875 | 3998189 | 399045 | 2 | 804 | 267 | 89/33.33% | 35/13.11% | 143/53.56% | 10.46 |
Nitab4.5_0004604g0010.1 | 948 | 94021 | 94968 | 1 | 948 | 315 | 21/6.67% | 14/4.44% | 280/88.89% | 10.67 |
Nitab4.5_0000256g0320.1 | 948 | 966518 | 967465 | 1 | 948 | 315 | 22/6.98% | 16/5.08% | 277/87.94% | 10.67 |
Nitab4.5_0003157g0050.1 | 558 | 13932 | 139880 | 1 | 558 | 185 | 26/14.05% | 22/11.89% | 137/74.05% | 9.51 |
Nitab4.5_0001271g0090.1 | 537 | 577237 | 577773 | 1 | 537 | 178 | 30/16.85% | 23/12.92% | 125/70.22% | 9.79 |
Nitab4.5_0003072g0110.1 | 567 | 198841 | 199407 | 1 | 567 | 188 | 22/11.70% | 29/15.43% | 137/72.87% | 9.99 |
Nitab4.5_0004013g0040.1 | 567 | 191866 | 192432 | 1 | 567 | 188 | 24/12.77% | 23/12.23% | 141/75.00% | 9.9 |
Nitab4.5_0001652g0050.1 | 783 | 103509 | 104291 | 1 | 783 | 260 | 28/10.77% | 26/10.00% | 206/79.23% | 9.42 |
Nitab4.5_0009099g0040.1 | 783 | 73650 | 74432 | 1 | 783 | 360 | 30/11.54% | 21/8.08% | 203/78.00% | 9.45 |
Nitab4.5_0001241g0040.1 | 687 | 263071 | 263757 | 1 | 687 | 228 | 32/14.04% | 23/10.09% | 173/75.88% | 9.77 |
Nitab4.5_0001336g0060.1 | 684 | 557974 | 558657 | 1 | 684 | 227 | 32/14.10% | 26/11.45% | 169/74.45% | 9.77 |
Nitab4.5_0003481g0110.1 | 453 | 209282 | 209734 | 1 | 453 | 150 | 58/38.67% | 16/10.67% | 76/50.67% | 6.31 |
Nitab4.5_0005808g0010.1 | 474 | 8127 | 8600 | 1 | 474 | 157 | 54/34.39% | 21/13.38% | 82/52.23% | 5.41 |
Nitab4.5_0000812g0090.1 | 426 | 586770 | 587195 | 1 | 426 | 141 | 31/21.99% | 17/12.06% | 93/65.96% | 5 |
Nitab4.5_0004588g0030.1 | 474 | 228189 | 228662 | 1 | 474 | 157 | 44/28.03% | 31/19.75% | 82/52.23% | 5.96 |
Nitab4.5_0000349g0050.1 | 10775 | 152011 | 162785 | 2 | 216 | 71 | 39/54.93% | 7/9.86% | 25/35.21% | 8.85 |
Nitab4.5_0002640g0020.1 | 1582 | 61688 | 63269 | 2 | 294 | 97 | 49/50.52% | 15/15.46% | 33/34.02% | 9.94 |
Nitab4.5_0000687g0100.1 | 345 | 345785 | 346129 | 1 | 345 | 114 | 33/28.95% | 15/13.61% | 66/57.89% | 6.59 |
Nitab4.5_0008548g0020.1 | 351 | 19094 | 19444 | 1 | 351 | 116 | 33/28.45% | 15/12.93% | 68/58.62% | 5.87 |
Nitab4.5_0000930g0040.1 | 309 | 607049 | 607357 | 1 | 309 | 102 | 29/28.43% | 14/13.73% | 59/57.84% | 5.47 |
Nitab4.5_0022515g0010.1 | 309 | 2522 | 2830 | 1 | 309 | 102 | 23/22.55% | 10/9.80% | 69/67.65% | 6.58 |
Nitab4.5_0000930g0050.1 | 309 | 662450 | 662758 | 1 | 309 | 102 | 31/30.39% | 9/8.82% | 62/60.78% | 6.25 |
Nitab4.5_0009599g0020.1 | 318 | 77300 | 77617 | 1 | 318 | 105 | 29/27.62% | 12/11.43% | 64/60.95% | 5.4 |
Nitab4.5_0000639g0190.1 | 306 | 579499 | 579804 | 1 | 306 | 101 | 36/35.64% | 15/14.85% | 50/49.50% | 9.63 |
Nitab4.5_0000505g0120.1 | 297 | 773483 | 773779 | 1 | 297 | 98 | 37/37.76% | 15/15.31% | 46/46.94% | 9.17 |
Nitab4.5_0005080g0020.1 | 360 | 140722 | 141081 | 1 | 360 | 119 | 45/37.82% | 15/12.61% | 59/49.58% | 5.34 |
Nitab4.5_0001924g0010.1 | 375 | 39051 | 39425 | 1 | 375 | 124 | 51/41.13% | 12/9.68% | 61/49.19% | 5.79 |
Nitab4.5_0002906g0010.1 | 471 | 82252 | 82722 | 1 | 471 | 156 | 14/8.97% | 26/16.67% | 116/74.36% | 5.45 |
Nitab4.5_0000489g0090.1 | 552 | 590481 | 590132 | 1 | 552 | 183 | 24/13.11% | 23/12.57% | 136/74.32% | 5.7 |
Nitab4.5_0001674g0050.1 | 417 | 331009 | 331425 | 1 | 417 | 138 | 14/10.14% | 23/16.67% | 101/73.19% | 9.17 |
Nitab4.5_0006679g0010.1 | 1554 | 144320 | 145873 | 2 | 455 | 184 | 28/20.65% | 24/13.64% | 122/66.30% | 9.3 |
Nitab4.5_0000633g0120.1 | 702 | 299447 | 300148 | 2 | 510 | 169 | 38/22.49% | 14/8.28% | 117/69.23% | 9.41 |
Nitab4.5_0000299g0270.1 | 765 | 884677 | 885441 | 1 | 765 | 254 | 58/22.83% | 26/9.45% | 172/67.72% | 7.83 |
Nitab4.5_0000427g0090.1 | 753 | 785763 | 786515 | 2 | 506 | 167 | 38/22.75% | 15/8.98% | 114/68.26% | 9.41 |
Nitab4.5_0004813g0010.1 | 678 | 31487 | 32164 | 1 | 678 | 225 | 43/19.11% | 25/11.11% | 157/69.78% | 5.89 |
Nitab4.5_0002121g0030.1 | 678 | 283134 | 283811 | 1 | 678 | 225 | 38/16.89% | 25/11.11% | 162/72.00% | 5.89 |
Table 2
The details of syntenic regions of tobacco VQ genes.
Number | Gene of Nicotiana tobacum | Block 1 | Gene of Nicotiana tobacum | Block 2 |
Chr | Start | End | Chr | Start | End |
1 | Nitab4.5_0002098g0010.1 | 20 | 68708367 | 73291850 | Nitab4.5_0000421g0040.1 | 15 | 20669917 | 21423296 |
2 | Nitab4.5_0000639g0190.1 | 8 | 99547870 | 101524099 | Nitab4.5_0000505g0120.1 | 21 | 52580931 | 54121620 |
3 | Nitab4.5_0000073g0510.1 | 21 | 70839788 | 71923681 | Nitab4.5_0000170g0400.1 | 2 | 104854013 | 107232470 |
4 | Nitab4.5_0000073g0510.1 | 21 | 71824456 | 72399223 | Nitab4.5_0002570g0040.1 | 8 | 103491312 | 103894013 |
5 | Nitab4.5_0000073g0510.1 | 21 | 70130728 | 72003347 | Nitab4.5_0002232g0070.1 | 10 | 107561581 | 113593166 |
6 | Nitab4.5_0000138g0140.1 | 17 | 57874512 | 58956217 | Nitab4.5_0000443g0140.1 | 17 | 199091884 | 200293163 |
7 | Nitab4.5_0001270g0170.1 | 5 | 138747 | 1534446 | Nitab4.5_0000123g0220.1 | 24 | 50020237 | 50809798 |
8 | Nitab4.5_0000812g0090.1 | 17 | 66442094 | 66154875 | Nitab4.5_0004588g0030.1 | 5 | 43332771 | 43890275 |
9 | Nitab4.5_0001674g0050.1 | 22 | 70052300 | 78283777 | Nitab4.5_0000489g0090.1 | 14 | 73104160 | 79702893 |
10 | Nitab4.5_0000170g0400.1 | 2 | 107224367 | 108805080 | Nitab4.5_0002232g0070.1 | 10 | 106939084 | 107784401 |
11 | Nitab4.5_0000062g0280.1 | 24 | 8997624 | 9896916 | Nitab4.5_0000123g0220.1 | 24 | 48998617 | 50487060 |
12 | Nitab4.5_0003072g0110.1 | 4 | 15579277 | 17796517 | Nitab4.5_0001271g0090.1 | 20 | 92064219 | 93658586 |
Table 3
The details of syntenic regions between tobacco and Arabidopsis thaliana VQ genes.
Number | Gene of Nicotiana tobacum | Block 1 | Gene of Arabidopsis thaliana | Block 2 |
Chr | Start | End | Chr | Start | End |
1 | Nitab4.5_0001336g0060.1 | 10 | 67145787 | 75458550 | AT3G15300 | 3 | 5025184 | 5196591 |
2 | Nitab4.5_0001336g0060.1 | 10 | 67187464 | 71464670 | AT5G53830 | 5 | 21822323 | 21914866 |
3 | Nitab4.5_0002906g0010.1 | 4 | 8900255 | 13115923 | AT3G18360 | 3 | 6154363 | 6399337 |
4 | Nitab4.5_0003072g0110.1 | 4 | 15178772 | 15579843 | AT1G80450 | 1 | 30243430 | 30280359 |
5 | Nitab4.5_0001924g0010.1 | 10 | 74607412 | 80668737 | AT1G78410 | 1 | 29540984 | 29468394 |
3.2 Phylogenetic analysis of VQ gene families
According to the phylogenetic tree (Fig. 2), ninety-five VQ proteins derived from N. tobacum and A. thaliana were clustered into seven groups named from I to VII. Group I - VI contained VQ proteins from both tobacco and Arabidopsis, and group VII contained only tobacco VQ proteins. Group III (29.50%) contained the largest number of genes, followed by group I (16.39%), group IV (14.75%), group II (13.11%), group VII (13.11%), group V (6.56%) and group VI (6.56%). Moreover, a subset of the Arabidopsis VQ proteins phosphorylated by the MPK3a and MPK6 (named as MVQs) were uniformly clustered into the group I and II (Pecher et al. 2014), which predicated that eighteen tobacco VQ proteins from group I and II may be involved in the cellular process of protein phosphorylation. This comparison between VQ proteins clarified that genes in the same group may have similar functions.
3.3 Structure and phylogenetic analysis of NtVQ gene family
A phylogenetic tree was constructed using sixty-one NtVQ protein sequences (Fig. 3a). The NtVQ genes could be divided into thirty-four categories (NtVQ1 to NtVQ34) marked with different colours. The analysis of protein domain organization showed that all NtVQ proteins delineated the VQ-motif using SMART database and NCBI, and protein structures were highly similar (Fig. 3b). Protein structure of NtVQ3 (Nitab4.5_0000443g0140.1) contained a coiled-coil region. Protein structures of NtVQ16 (Nitab4.5_0008558g0010.1 and Nitab4.5_0000786g0140.1) had two transmembrane helix regions, respectively. The analysis of gene structure showed that NtVQ genes in the same branch shared a similar exon-intron distribution, except NtVQ5, NtVQ8, NtVQ16 and NtVQ33 (Fig. 3c). Fourteen NtVQ genes contained introns in the genomic sequences, the number of introns varied significantly from one to eight, indicating that NtVQ genes usually varied in the exon-intron distribution profile and gene length of the tobacco genomic sequences.
3.4 Tissue expression pattern of NtVQ genes
To determine the potential functions of NtVQ genes in tobacco development, the expression profiles of thirty-four NtVQ genes were conducted in four tissues and three types of trichomes. Lots of trichomes were shown on the surface of stem and leaf, and tobacco root and flower were also covered with epidermis (Fig. 4a). As shown in Fig. 4b, the result of tissue expression profiles showed that NtVQ11 and NtVQ30 were barely expressed in different tissues including trichomes, NtVQ16 were barely expressed in tissues, and NtVQ19 were barely expressed in different type of trichomes. Seven genes (NtVQ3, NtVQ8, NtVQ17, NtVQ25, NtVQ27, NtVQ29 and NtVQ32) were highly expressed in root, and NtVQ28 was expressed only in root. Five genes (NtVQ9, NtVQ13, NtVQ18, NtVQ21 and NtVQ26) were highly expressed in stem. Eight genes (NtVQ2, NtVQ5, NtVQ10, NtVQ12, NtVQ20, NtVQ22, NtVQ24 and NtVQ33) were highly expressed in leaf. NtVQ15 was highly expressed in flower, NtVQ1 and NtVQ8 were barely expressed in flower. These results forecasted that NtVQ genes played essential roles in tobacco tissues growth and development. Besides, eleven genes (NtVQ8, NtVQ9, NtVQ12, NtVQ13, NtVQ16, NtVQ22, NtVQ24, NtVQ25, NtVQ26, NtVQ31 and NtVQ34) were highly expressed in mT. Four genes (NtVQ1, NtVQ2, NtVQ17 and NtVQ20) were highly expressed in gT. Five genes (NtVQ3, NtVQ4, NtVQ5, NtVQ28 and NtVQ33) were highly expressed in nT. The expression profiles in different type of trichomes firstly clarified the important functions of NtVQ genes in glandular- and nonglandular-trichome formation and development.
3.5 Expression patterns of NtVQ genes following phytohormone treatments and abiotic stresses
To elucidate the roles of NtVQ genes under different phytohormone, sqRT-PCT was conducted to achieve the relative expression values of each NtVQ gene (Fig. 5). The expression levels of thirteen genes (NtVQ3, NtVQ4, NtVQ6, NtVQ13, NtVQ15, NtVQ16, NtVQ20, NtVQ22, NtVQ28, NtVQ29, NtVQ31, NtVQ33 and NtVQ34) increased following MeJA treatment. The expression levels of twenty-two genes (NtVQ3, NtVQ4, NtVQ5, NtVQ7, NtVQ9, NtVQ10, NtVQ12, NtVQ14, NtVQ15, NtVQ16, NtVQ17, NtVQ18, NtVQ19, NtVQ21, NtVQ23, NtVQ24, NtVQ25, NtVQ29, NtVQ31, NtVQ32, NtVQ33 and NtVQ34) increased following SA treatment. The expression levels of eleven genes (NtVQ2, NtVQ7, NtVQ10, NtVQ16, NtVQ20, NtVQ23, NtVQ26, NtVQ27, NtVQ29, NtVQ33 and NtVQ34) increased following GA treatment. The expression levels of eight genes (NtVQ1, NtVQ4, NtVQ6, NtVQ7, NtVQ9, NtVQ14, NtVQ15 and NtVQ29) increased following ETH treatment. Among these genes, the expression levels of NtVQ29 was simultaneously up-regulated following the four phytohormones treatments. These results uncovered that all NtVQ genes were involved in the intricate signaling pathways and each gene had different regulatory characteristics.
A systematic expression analysis of NtVQ genes was conducted following the abiotic stresses. The expression levels of eight genes (NtVQ5, NtVQ18, NtVQ20, NtVQ21, NtVQ24, NtVQ26, NtVQ28 and NtVQ34) increased following high salinity stress. The expression levels of six genes (NtVQ2, NtVQ7, NtVQ12, NtVQ16, NtVQ20 and NtVQ24) increased following PEG stress. NtVQ20 and NtVQ24 were simultaneously up-regulated following these two stresses. While the expression levels of fifteen genes (NtVQ1, NtVQ3, NtVQ4, NtVQ6, NtVQ8, NtVQ13, NtVQ15, NtVQ17, NtVQ19, NtVQ22, NtVQ23, NtVQ25, NtVQ29, NtVQ32 and NtVQ33) were simultaneously down-regulated. These results predicated that most NtVQ genes showed the negative regulatory responses to abiotic stress.
3.6 Transcriptional activity analysis of NtVQ genes
Several NtVQ genes have been chosen to investigate the potential transcriptional activity (Fig. 6). Compared with the control, pGBKT7-NtVQ4, pGBKT7-NtVQ28 and pGBKT7-NtVQ29 could only grow on SD/-Trp medium, while pGBKT7-NtVQ17 grew normally on both selective media and showed alpha-galactosidase activity, which speculated that most NtVQ genes might have no transcription activity.