The aim of this project was to explore and compare women’s knowledge and attitudes towards the menopause to identify ways in which to improve menopause education and ease the menopause transition.
Menopause Knowledge And Education
The survey found that women’s knowledge of the menopause was limited. The majority of women did not feel informed at all or only had some knowledge of the menopause before the age of 40. This is congruent with the growing body of evidence indicating that women generally have a low level of knowledge pertaining to the menopause and its treatments (13–17). This is concerning as although menopausal symptoms can worsen quality of life (QoL), a better knowledge of the menopause is associated with a greater QoL (18). Interestingly the post-menopausal women felt they were significantly more informed than the other groups, probably because they were through the perimenopause and had learnt along their way.
When asked when they had first started thinking about the menopause, the most common age range for answers was between 40 and 49. This suggests that many women only begin to think about the menopause when they near the age of experiencing it. Reinforcing this, many women stated that they had only first started thinking about the menopause when symptoms began, or in cases of induced, or early menopause. This indicates a lack of preparedness for the menopause which is likely to make the process more overwhelming and psychologically taxing. Since many women do not know what symptoms are caused by the menopause, this lack of knowledge will certainly lead to delays in diagnosing the perimenopause and delays in advice and treatments.
The majority of respondents felt that the menopause should be taught at school. Despite this, the overwhelming majority of women in all three groups had failed to receive any menopause education at school, with postmenopausal women (who tended to be older than the other two groups) being significantly less likely than the other two groups to have received even basic menopause education. This highlights the failure of the education system to provide women with necessary and desired information about their own bodies. It is therefore promising that the topic of menopause was introduced to the UK school curriculum in 2019, although the quality and long-term impact of this education remains to be seen (19). Teaching the menopause in school is particularly advantageous as it introduces the topic to both pupils from an early age. Hopefully it will help them understand when their mother and teachers go through the perimenopause. Additionally, it has the potential to reach almost every member of the population, as full-time education is compulsory in the UK (20). However, it should be noted that many countries worldwide have low rates of school attendance, especially among girls, thus limiting the effectiveness of school menopause education in these areas (21).
The second most common answer from all three groups was that the menopause should be taught in a doctor’s surgery. This may reflect a high level of trust in the medical profession and is consistent with the major role of physicians to provide patient education. However, there are issues involved with this method of menopause education. As the average General Practitioner (GP) appointment in the UK is limited to only 9.2 minutes, it is unlikely that patients will be able to gain a comprehensive understanding of the menopause in this time (22). One survey of healthcare professionals found that only half had received any menopause training and only 66% felt confident in managing the menopause (23). Our perimenopause paper found that many women felt distressed, confused and angry at their GPs’ lack of knowledge of the menopause and its treatments (4). Until sufficient menopause education is provided to clinicians and other healthcare workers, it is impossible for them to pass on the necessary information to their patients. Menopause education in a doctor’s surgery is also likely to occur much later in life, as most women will only make an appointment to discuss the menopause when they begin to experience symptoms.
The perimenopausal group felt that the menopause should be taught via apps, such as period trackers and fertility apps. It is likely that this disparity is associated with the younger age of the perimenopause group, as the usage of both smartphones and fertility tracking apps (FTAs) has been shown to decrease with age (24, 25). In line with this finding, the survey found that the perimenopause group was significantly more likely than the postmenopausal group to have sought menopause information via digital sources, such as websites, social media and YouTube. This suggests a need for a shift in the way that menopause information is delivered. With the huge increase in the use of telehealth as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, this highlights the benefits of delivering healthcare information online (26). Although menopause apps exist, there is currently little to no research evaluating their impact.
Among the benefits of online menopause education is the ease of accessibility of this information from home. This is particularly beneficial for people who struggle to leave the house, such as full-time carers and those with mental or physical disabilities. The immediate availability of online information also alleviates the delays associated with making and waiting for an in-person consultation, with a 2021 report finding that 16% of patients waited a week or more for a GP appointment (27). It may therefore reduce the number of unnecessary appointments made, thus reducing pressure on overstretched National Health Service (NHS) services. Online resources can quickly and easily be reviewed at any time; this is extremely valuable for education as studies have shown that 40–80% of medical information provided by healthcare practitioners is immediately forgotten, and almost half of what is remembered is incorrect (28). Visual aids and translation software can make online information easier to understand for a range of recipients. Finally, online information can be accessed by anyone; in the context of menopause education, this allows younger women and men to be exposed to information that they would not otherwise seek out.
Despite its many merits, there are limitations of providing menopause education online. This mode of delivery is far less personalised than a face-to-face appointment or lecture and does not account for individual circumstances. The lack of direct communication between the creator of the resource and the user creates a risk that information may be misinterpreted, potentially having a detrimental impact on their understanding of the menopause. Although technology has become a ubiquitous part of society, people from lower-income communities, both in the UK and worldwide may not have access to online information. Furthermore, older people or those with learning disabilities may lack the technological proficiency required to utilise online resources.
Both the perimenopausal and postmenopausal women in the survey were more likely to have sought menopause information from other websites than official websites. This creates concerns about the quality and reliability of information received due to the high prevalence of health misinformation online, with only approximately 50% of medically-related sites having their content reviewed by doctors (29, 30). Exacerbating these concerns is the fact that false information online has been shown to spread faster and further than the truth (31). The reasons for women’s preference for unofficial websites is unclear; however, it is possible that this stems from a lack of awareness of official sources. Additionally, the use of medical jargon may discourage non-healthcare professionals from using official websites. To alleviate this, official websites providing menopause education to the public should ensure that information is delivered in a clear, concise and comprehensible way by engaging the public in their design.
Management Of Menopausal Symptoms
Over half of the peri and post menopausal women had spoken to a health professional (51.2% and 57.7% respectively). Similarly, approximately half of the women surveyed in a recent Italian study had sought help for the menopause from the Italian National Health System (32). Conversely, the majority of those in the other group had not done so.
Research suggests that public trust in the medical profession has declined over recent years and it is also well-documented that female patients often receive inferior healthcare due to gender bias exhibited by clinicians (33, 34). Hence, women may be reluctant to see a healthcare professional due to general mistrust or fear of discrimination. Echoing this, our perimenopause paper found that a number of women were sceptical of their GP or the NHS in general in regards to menopause guidance (4). Additionally, the menopause is still a taboo topic for many people and can be associated with social stigma in certain communities (35). Many patients, especially older adults, shy away from discussing sexual health issues with physicians (36, 37). Therefore, it is possible that a significant proportion of perimenopausal or menopausal women could benefit from the help of a healthcare professional, but choose not to seek one out.
The peri and post menopausal group had mainly used exercise to alleviate menopause symptoms. This is encouraging, as exercise is not only associated with a greater QoL in menopausal women and decreased menopause symptoms, but also general health benefits such as reduced cancer risk, improved cardiovascular health and improved mental health (38–43). A number of forms of exercise are free and do not require specialist equipment or training (for example walking or running), making it a highly accessible method of menopause management. In our survey asking women if cold water swimming affects menopause symptoms, we found that many reported positively (in preparation). Additionally, the internet provides an abundance of information on exercise, with the NHS website providing exercise guidelines for different age groups and YouTube hosting over 30 million fitness videos (44, 45).
Perimenopausal women were significantly more likely than postmenopausal women to manage symptoms with exercise or nutrition changes such as reduced alcohol or caffeine intake, and significantly less likely to use HRT. This suggests that younger, perimenopausal women may have a greater preference for lifestyle changes and other non-hormonal methods to treat menopausal symptoms. A potential explanation for this observation would be the widespread controversy over the use of HRT which began in the 2000s, largely in part due to the publication of the preliminary results of a Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) study examining the effects of combined oestrogen and progestin hormone therapy (46) which has now been overturned. The current NICE guidelines recommend the use of HRT to alleviate menopausal symptoms (47). Despite this, public opinion on HRT is mixed and its use remains low, suggesting that many women still have doubts regarding its safety (48).
Additionally, research shows that a large number of women have a poor knowledge of HRT, with a 2020 study by Baquedano et al. (13) finding that a lack of information was the main reason for rejecting menopause hormone therapy (16, 17, 49). Our perimenopause paper also found that many women struggled to get a prescription for HRT for up to ten years due to their GPs’ lack of knowledge (4). Many women who are able to get an HRT prescription fail to adhere to the medication due to lack of motivation, or side effects such as headaches, breast tenderness and gastrointestinal disturbances (50, 51).
Attitudes Towards The Menopause
There were notable differences between women’s attitudes towards the menopause based on their menopause status. The other group generally had the most negative attitude towards the menopause, with the most common response in this group being that they were dreading it. The perimenopause group and postmenopausal group had similar attitudes overall; compared with the postmenopausal group, the perimenopause group was significantly more likely to be accepting or dreading, but significantly less likely to be neutral. Our menopause survey in the under 40s also found a negative narrative towards the menopause (5). These findings are consistent with other works which show that postmenopausal women generally have more positive attitudes towards the menopause than premenopausal women (52, 53, 54).
There are a number of factors which may contribute to premenopausal women’s negative attitudes towards the menopause. It is possible that a lack of knowledge contributes to a fear of the unknown as women approaching the menopause are unsure what to expect until they begin to experience it for themselves. This aligns with studies which show that greater knowledge of the menopause is associated with more positive attitudes (16, 55). Compounding this issue is the societal stigma and shame associated with the menopause. Not only does this promote negative attitudes, but can also exacerbate the issue of insufficient education by posing a barrier to women gaining knowledge of the menopause (35).
Over half of postmenopausal women said that they had found the menopause difficult, or very difficult. This aligns with numerous studies which show that the menopause can decrease quality of life, sexual wellbeing and cause issues in the workplace (18, 56, 57). Unsurprisingly, there is evidence to suggest that worse menopausal symptoms contribute to more negative attitudes towards the menopause (52, 58).
The survey found that one aspect of the menopause which women generally had positive attitudes was the onset of amenorrhoea. The majority of women in all three groups described themselves as feeling happy at the thought of no longer having periods; this finding has also been observed in similar studies (52, 59). However, one of the four themes identified in the qualitative analysis was loss of fertility, which women strongly associated with periods ceasing. Yet, what most women failed to acknowledge was that fertility decline begins many years before the menopause. This was perhaps suggestive of a lack of understanding that female fertility declines rapidly from the mid-30s (60). This would be consistent with numerous studies which highlight the lack of awareness of age-related fertility decline in women (61, 62). By placing emphasis on menstruation as the main marker of fertility, rather than age, women may delay childbearing until too late in life, hence compromising their ability to successfully conceive (63). Additionally, advanced maternal age is a risk factor for pregnancy, being associated with chromosomal abnormalities, preterm birth, ectopic pregnancy, foetal loss and maternal mortality (64, 65, 66, 67). Exacerbating this, high-risk pregnancies themselves are likely to provoke fear and anxiety during the gestation period, especially in the era of the COVID-19 pandemic (65, 68).
It is therefore important that women are made aware of fertility decline with age so that they may take appropriate family planning measures and maximise the likelihood of achieving their intended reproductive outcomes. The International Fertility Education Initiative was founded to improve fertility awareness through education, for example by displaying fertility awareness posters in doctor’s surgeries, family planning clinics and schools (4). Encouraging women to have children earlier in life may reduce the number of involuntarily childless perimenopausal and menopausal women, thereby mitigating some of the negative emotions induced by the onset of amenorrhoea. Nonetheless, it is likely that this aspect of the menopausal transition will always elicit certain negative emotions due to the association of periods with youth and identity, as identified in the qualitative analysis and in other studies (59).
Not only do worse menopausal symptoms contribute to negative attitudes of women towards the menopause, but it has been suggested that negative attitudes themselves can exacerbate menopausal symptoms, thus having significant implications on health (11, 52, 58, 69). Additionally, there is evidence to suggest that husbands’ attitudes towards the menopause can also influence the severity of women’s symptoms (69, 70). This highlights the importance of providing menopause education and promoting positive attitudes to both men and women alike.
Limitations
The majority of respondents in the survey were white, heterosexual, university postgraduates living in the UK, thus compromising diversity. The age of respondents was limited to those 40 or over, although a similar survey for younger women was launched in February 2022. Men were not included in the survey, despite the fact that their attitude and knowledge towards the menopause can have a major impact on women’s experiences of the menopause. Additionally, transgender men also undergo the menopause but were not included in this survey as they would require a different set of questions. The promotion of the survey on social media created a risk of selection bias towards followers of the people promoting the survey. There was also a risk of recall bias for certain questions; for example, when asking women the age at which they had started to think about the menopause, as for some, this may have required them to think back many years into the past. The analysis was dependent on respondents’ self-identification as perimenopausal, postmenopausal or other; although menopause can generally be self-diagnosed, there was a risk that some women were incorrect about their own menopause status, hence skewing the results. The other group of women would have possibly consisted a mix of all the following - peri menopausal women who did not know they were in peri menopause, postmenopausal women who did not correctly understand they were post menopause, women who were still continuing with regular menstrual cycles and those of different forms of hormonal contraception which could have altered their symptoms and menstrual pattern.