Assessment of air pollution tolerance index (APTI) and anticipated performance index (API) of selected roadside plant species for the green belt development at Ratnagiri City in the Konkan region of Maharashtra, India

Small towns are becoming hotspots of pollution due to industrial, urbanisation, and domestic activities. Air pollution affects human health and it is also responsible for physiological changes in plants. Green belt development programmes are cost-effective for the minimisation of air pollution. In the present study, to calculate air pollution tolerance index (APTI) and anticipated performance index (API), samples of 25 plant species were collected from each area i.e. the industrial (I), urban (U), and rural (R) areas and analysed for different parameters. Amongst all three areas, APTI of Artocarpus heterophyllus (46.74), Calotropis gigantea (43.63), and Bauhinia racemose (42.11) have shown the highest values and these plants can act as an inhibitor of air pollution. Also, the APTI of Ocimum tenuiflorum has found to be the lowest (12.05, 11.32, 12.86) as compared to other plant species amongst the three areas. Statistical analysis reveals that values of R2 are consistent in case of total chlorophyll (TC) and ascorbic acid (AA). API index showed the efficiency of Calotropis gigantea (excellent), Artocarpus heterophyllus (very good), and Mangifera indica (very good) for the green belt development around the selected areas. It is recommended to plant above-mentioned plant species along the roadside by considering their air pollution tolerance ability and medicinal as well as economic importance. Furthermore, it is suggested to plant species of Artocarpus heterophyllus (jackfruit) and Mangifera indica (Alphonso mango) which will generate income source for the local government bodies (Ratnagiri Municipal Council), as the fruits and wood of these plants can be exported and sold.

APTI and API can be considered good tools to select the best plant species for green belt development (Singh et al., 1991;Gupta et al., 2016;Hozhabralsadat et al., 2022;Pandeya et al., 2015a;Pandeya et al., 2015b;Kaur & Nagpal, 2017;Molnara et al., 2020). Also, the environmental stress on the flora is measured by APTI and the four biochemical parameters viz. pH (P), relative water content (RWC), ascorbic acid (AA), and total chlorophyll (TC) are used to calculate APTI (Nayak et al., 2015;Mandal & Dhal, 2022;Sarkar et al., 2021) and other biological and socioeconomic parameters observed to calculate API (Singare & More, 2020;Verma et al., 2023). Ascorbic acid acts as an antioxidant and imparts resistance to air pollution in plants, and higher values of pH, total chlorophyll, and relative water content in plants favour tolerance to pollutants (Ogunkunle et al., 2015;Sahu et al., 2020). The APTI and API study is beneficial for green belt development in a polluted area of cities or urbanising towns (Gharge & Menon, 2012;Ochoa et al., 2022;Tak & Kakde, 2020). Many researchers have studied APTI and API for metropolitan or mega cities (Joshi et al., 2016;Alotaibi et al., 2020;Mondal & Singh, 2022), but there is a very limited approach towards the studies for small towns or urbanising cities in Maharashtra.
Ratnagiri is an urbanising city in the Konkan region which is leading towards increasing air pollution-related activities, and it will be an emerging need for green belt development towards air pollution. According to the studies, it is needful to make people aware of air pollution and to develop green belts in urbanising cities or small towns. Considering the ecological aura of the Konkan region, the present study area is more suitable for APTI study. According to several studies, APTI and API for green belt development of Ratnagiri City have not been conducted by researchers before. In the present study, the economic and air pollution tolerance values of Calotropis gigantea (Rui), Artocarpus heterophyllus (jackfruit), and Mangifera indica (Alphonso mango) were studied. These native plants have a significant contribution to the study. Also, this is a first attempt towards the study for green belt development and APTI as well as API of 25 roadside plant species selected at each of the three areas in Ratnagiri City. However, the present study leans towards green belt development and recommends planning environmental awareness programmes for Ratnagiri City.

Description of study area
Ratnagiri district in the Konkan region of Maharashtra has a great ecological diversity. It is famous for the Alphonso mango and cashew nut production and its export. Also, this city has vast biodiversity including endemic and rare medicinal plants. The sampling points were selected around Ratnagiri City, Maharashtra (latitude: 16° 59′ N; longitude: 73° 18′ E) (Fig. 1). As per the distribution, surrounding, and pollution-related activities, three areas viz. industrial (I), urban (U), and rural (R) were selected for the study. The first is an industrial (I) area (17°00′49.0″N; 73°20′21.5″E) surrounded by several industries such as food packaging, marine products, chemical industries, and casting of aluminium as well as iron and other small-scale industries. Also, the main road passes through the sampling locations. The second one is an urban (U) area around the Hindu Colony (residential area) and the Jaystambh Chowk (16°59′05.9″N; 73°18′30.3″E). This site represents commercial and residential areas having moderately trafficular activities. Also, the third area which is the least trafficular area outside the city limits, i.e. Mazgaon Road -Patilwadi Road, is considered a rural (R) area (17°01′28.1″N; 73°19′51.6″E).

Collection of samples
This study was performed during the summer season of 2022 (Feb-May). The study areas experienced hot summer. In the study area, the temperature varies from 11.6 to 26 °C, 14.4 to 27.4 °C, 18.9 to 32.3 °C, and 20.8 to 30 °C during the month of February, March, April, and May, respectively. For the present study, 25 plant species (roadside plants) (Table 1) were selected from industrial (I), urban (U), and rural (R) areas respectively. Also, the same species were selected from each area (roadside plants). Then, the samples were collected during the daytime and were stored in polyethene bags, quickly taken to the laboratory and preserved (4 °C) (Bhadauria et al., 2022). Then, the samples were analysed for different parameters in the laboratory of the Department of Environmental Science, Ratnagiri Sub-Campus, University of Mumbai.

Analytical methods
Collected and preserved leaf samples were brought to the laboratory for analysis. Each sample was then washed with distilled water to clear dust and other physical impurities. pH (P) of leaf extract was analysed according to the method described by Sharma et al. (2020), using a digital pH metre. The determination of relative water content (RWC) and total chlorophyll (TC) was carried out as per the proposed method and formula by Sahu et al. (2020). Ascorbic acid content (AA) was calculated considering Banerjee et al. (2021).

APTI
Calculation of the APTI was done as per the formula described by Singh and Rao (1983)  AA = ascorbic acid content of leaf mg/g dry weight TC = total chlorophyll content of leaf mg/g dry weight P = leaf extract pH RWC = percent relative water content of the leaf. The total sum is divided by 10 to get a manageable value API The air pollution tolerance index (APTI) of selected plant species was calculated for three areas such as industrial, urban, and rural areas. The anticipated performance index (API) was computed by using final APTI values and characters such as biological and socioeconomic. For the particular tolerant plant species for green belt development, grades (+ , −) have been allocated to the plant species according to the final values. API, percentage score, and grade allocation were done according to several studies (Enitan et al., 2022;Malav et al., 2022;Rai & Panda, 2014;Govindaraju et al., 2012).
(2) %Score = No of (+) obtained by any plant species Maximum No of (+) for any plant species × 100

Statistical analysis
Standard deviation and basic statistical applications were performed by using MS Excel 2007. Correlation and regression were calculated in VassarStats (http:// vassa rstats. net/). Graphical presentations were done by using Origin software.

Results and discussion
pH of leaf extract (P) In the physiological process of plants, pH has an important role as it determines the rate of photosynthesis of plants (Zouari et al., 2018). In the present study, pH values ranged from 3.7 to 7.85 in the I area, 3.23-6.72 in the U area, and 3.96-7.92 in the R area (Table 2). Amongst all three areas, most of the plants have shown acidic pH. At the R area, Hibiscus rosa-sinensis has the highest pH (7.92) as compared to the I and U areas. Also, Tectona grandis has the lowest pH (3.7) at the I area. Total chlorophyll (TC) The productivity of plants is indexed by chlorophyll and its highest content is favourable for plants to tolerate pollutants (Yannawar & Bhosale, 2014 (Malav et al., 2022). In the I, U, and R areas, RWC has ranged from 25.11 to 70.34%, 24.57-71.11%, and 25.56-72.01% respectively (Table 2). Along the three areas, Bauhinia racemose had shown higher RWC (Table 2).
Ascorbic acid (AA) AA acts as an antioxidant and influences plants' resistance to air pollution (Alotaibi et al., 2020). Along the three areas, Osmunda regalis plant has shown the maximum values viz. 8.50 mg/100 ml at I, 8.75 mg/100 ml at U, and 8.51 mg/100 ml at R area (Table 2). Minimum values of Ocimum tenuiflorum at I, U, and R (3.40, 3.24, 3.54 mg/100 ml) areas respectively. Although AA varies depending on various environmental factors (Saleem et al., 2022), the study areas acquainted similarities in the  (Bhat et al., 2015), has minimum APTI viz. 12.05, 11.32, and 12.86 at I, U, and R areas respectively. Artocarpus heterophyllus had shown higher APTI in all three areas followed by Calotropis gigantea and Bauhinia racemose (Table 3). Artocarpus heterophyllus, commonly named jackfruit, is a native plant of the Konkan region (GOM, 2016) having ease of availability. However, the results of APTI resemble the similarity between the three areas. Identical vehicular influences were found in these areas, which are important precursors for roadside plants. The studies performed on air pollution in Ratnagiri City clarified that the coastal area and lesser emission sources are the main precursors for lower air pollution (Patil et al., 2021(Patil et al., , 2022. Also, a study by Kadam et al. (2015) concluded that the tolerance of plants to air pollution reflected according to the site specification.  Grade allocation and API index are shown in Tables 4 and 5 respectively. API score, allotted grades, and categorised index of plants at I, U, and R areas are shown in Tables 6, 7 and 8 respectively. Maximum API grades have been shown in Artocarpus heterophyllus (5) and Calotropis gigantea (5) at the I area (Table 6), Mangifera indica (4), Calotropis gigantea (4), and Artocarpus heterophyllus (5) at the U area (Table 7), and the highest amongst all plants have shown in Calotropis gigantea (6) at the R area (Table 8). Considering the grades allotted, the API index indicates the utility of the plant species for the green belt development (Timilsinaa et al., 2021). API index showed the suitability of Artocarpus heterophyllus, Calotropis gigantea, and Mangifera indica for green belt development (Tables 6,7,and 8). In the industrial area, Artocarpus heterophyllus and Calotropis gigantea were under the very good category (Tables 5 and 6), in the urban area, Artocarpus heterophyllus (Tables 5 and 7) was under the very good category, and in the rural area, Calotropis gigantea (Tables 5 and 8) was under excellent category. Mangifera indica has been categorised as good at the I as well as the U area and very good at the R area. All three plants are common as well as native plants of the Konkan region, which are beneficial for the green belt development in the city. Only in the U area, Thevetia peruviana and Catharanthus were under the not recommended (0) category which relates to the non-feasibility for the green belt development (Tables 5 and 7). Several researchers have observed variations in APTI according to the site nature and pollution activities around the selected sites. When exposed to pollution, plant species have shown better tolerance ability at polluted sites than at the control sites (Agbaire, 2009;Gharge & Menon, 2012;Sahu et al., 2020). In this study, we found the excellent API category only in the rural area. However, in industrial and urban areas, most of the plant species were under the very poor category. Table 9 shows the studies carried out by researchers in India about APTI and API of Calotropis gigantea, Artocarpus heterophyllus, and Mangifera indica. From the studies, it was observed that Calotropis gigantea has been the least studied and, also, found non-feasibility for green belt development. But in the present study, Calotropis gigantea at the I, U, and R areas have shown the second highest APTI and was found excellent for the green belt development according to the API index. Calotropis gigantea commonly named Rui has several medicinal aspects according to referred studies (Kumari & Sood, 2020;Seyed & Siddiqua, 2020). Having medicinal importance as well as excellent API, this plant is especially recommended for green belt development. Also, it was observed that Artocarpus heterophyllus and Mangifera indica have the feasibility for green belt development. It is well known that the fruits Mangifera indica (Alphonso mango) especially from the Konkan region are internationally
The consistency between three areas in terms of R 2 was found in the case of TC and AA (Fig. 2). APTI distribution in Fig. 3a, b and c shows similar variations of the values in the I, U, and R areas. Here, the distribution is equalised between the three areas. Figure 4a, b, c and d configure the distribution of pH, TC, RWC, and AA accordingly between the three areas. It also indicates the equalised distribution of selected plant species between the three areas. Figures 5, 6 and 7 show APTI and API distribution amongst the I, U, and R areas respectively. Figure 8 shows the total number of plants under the API category in three areas. In the R area, a total of 9 plants are under the good category and only one is under the excellent category. Also, 7 plants were under the very    poor category at the I and 10 plants under the poor category at the U areas respectively. This indicates that the site nature and surroundings are the important precursors for plant formability.

Conclusions
This research concludes the simplified study of APTI and API of common and native plant species at Ratnagiri City in the Konkan region of Maharashtra. The present study derivates the approach towards green belt development in consideration of the native plants in this region. The statistical analysis showed the consistency between three areas, in the case of TC and AA. According to the API index, the industrial area has the most number of very poor categories of plants and excellent categories were found only in the rural area. Whereas, in the urban The study further concluded that the APTI and API values differ according to the nature of the site and surrounding pollution-related activities. This is the first attempt to assess the APTI constituting with API for Ratnagiri City, which will lead to better green belt development. Calotropis gigantea in rural areas was under the excellent category, which can be used as an inhibitor around the industrial and urban areas. This plant is especially recommended for the green belt as this plant exhibits medicinal aspects, excellent API, and air pollution tolerance ability. While Ocimum tenuiflorum which has a great medicinal value showed the lowest APTI and was also categorised as very poor according to the API. Mangifera indica and Artocarpus heterophyllus have air pollution tolerance ability and these plants also come under the very good API category. These are readily available native plants of the Konkan region. Both these plants are recommended to plant around the well-planned city area as they have air pollution tolerance ability and great economic importance. Also, to create awareness amongst the people, there is a need to conduct environmental awareness programmes in Ratnagiri City.