DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-233683/v1
Background
Clinically significant disc herniations in the thoracic spine are rare accounting for approximately 1% of all disc herniations. In patients with significant spinal cord compression, presenting symptoms typically include ambulatory dysfunction, lower extremity weakness, lower extremity sensory changes, as well as bowl, bladder, or sexual dysfunction. Thoracic disc herniations can also present with thoracic radiculopathy including midback pain and radiating pain wrapping around the chest or abdomen. The association between thoracic disc herniation with cord compression and sleep apnea is not well described.
Case Presentation
The following is a case of a young male patient with high grade spinal cord compression at T7-8, as a result of a large thoracic disc herniation. The patient presented with complaints of upper and lower extremity unilateral allodynia and sleep apnea. Diagnosis was only made once the patient manifested more common symptoms of thoracic stenosis including left lower extremity weakness and sexual dysfunction. Following decompression and fusion the patient’s allodynia and sleep apnea quickly resolved.
Conclusions
Thoracic disc herniations can present atypically with sleep apnea – a symptom which may resolve with surgical treatment.
Symptomatic thoracic disc herniations account for approximately 1% of all disc hernations with T11-12 most commonly involved.1–3 The levels T8-12 account for around 75% of all thoracic disc herniations.2,4–6 Symptomatic thoracic herniations typically presents with leg weakness, paraesthesias, and gait instability.7 They can also result in bowel and bladder or sexual dysfunction.8 Less frequently, thoracic herniations can present with lower extremity allodynia.9,10 Operative treatment for symptomatic thoracic disc herniations includes decompression and possibly instrumented fusion.3 The approach to thoracic disc depends on location (central vs paracentral) and degree of calcification.11 The classic teaching is that central discs should not be approached via laminectomy alone.12,13
At present, there have been no documented cases of thoracic disc herniations presenting as parasomnias. Here, we present an individual with a thoracic disc herniation who developed progressive myelopathic symptoms, upper and lower extremity allodynia, and clinically significant sleep apnea. All symptoms improved rapidly following surgical treatment with immediate resolution of the sleep apnea
A non-obese 30-year-old male initially presented to neurology 2 years prior to diagnosis with primary complaint of left upper and lower extremity allodynia. The patient initially had left worse than right subtle lower extremity weakness, and ambulatory dysfunction. Additional symptoms included sleep apnea and sexual dysfunction. The patient had imaging of the brain and cervical spine which was normal. The patient’s symptoms progressed over time and ultimately the patient was referred to Neurosurgery after a thoracic MRI demonstrated a large left paramedian disc herniation at T7-8 (Figure 1). By time of neurosurgical evaluation, the patient had symptoms of thoracic myelopathy for several years. The patient had left greater than right lower extremity weakness, sexual dysfuncton, and mild bowel and bladder dysfunction. Approximately six months prior to presentation, the patient was diagnosed with sleep apnea requiring the use of a continuous positive airway pressure device.
On physical exam, the patient demonstrated significant motor weakness in his proximal lower extremities left worse than right. Patellar reflexes were hyperreflexic (3+) bilaterally. There was an imbalance of tandem gait, as well as allodynia in the upper and lower extremities.
MRI of the thoracic spine demonstrated a large left paracentral T7-8 disc herniation causing significant stenosis. Computed tomography scan showed the disc to be heavily calcified (Figure 2). It was recommended that the patient undergo operative treatment due to the patient’s progressive neurologic decline.
The patient underwent posterior instrumented fusion T6 through T10, including laminectomy left T7-8 costotransversectomy, partial corpectomy and discectomy (Figure 3). The patient’s postoperative course was uneventful. After surgery, the patient reported improvements in sleep, sensation in the upper and lower extremities, and strength in the lower extremities following surgery (Figure 4). Sleep studies prior to the surgery suggested a diagnosis of sleep apnea. Following surgery, the patient reported immediate resolution in his sleep symptoms.
Clinically symptomatic thoracic disc herniations that require surgical intervention are relatively rare.7,14 Patients typically present with symptoms of thoracic myelopathy or radiculopathy.15 An association between sleep apnea and thoracic stenosis as a result of a disc herniation has not been documented in the literature. In this case, delayed diagnosis was caused by both the atypical presentation of sleep apnea as well as the the upper and lower extremity allodynia.5 Allodynia has been associated with thoracic disc herniation – though it is less common.16 When present, allodynia typically occurs at the level of the herniation itself.9 In this patient, both upper and lower extremity involvement in allodynia were atypical. Furthermore, the sleep apnea itself was also atypical.
We acknowledge that it is difficult to associate direct causality of the resolution of the patient’s sleep apnea with his discectomy. It is possible that the resolution of the sleep disturbance was due to the resolution of pain following decompression of the thoracic spinal cord. However, such is unlikely because the patient’s obstructive sleep apnea was documented in sleep studies – and less-likely due to symptoms of pain. It is more likely that the sleep apnea and its resolution is related to the disc herniation and treatment.
Sleep apnea is caused by anatomic or partial obstruction of the airway during sleep.17,18 The estimated prevalence of sleep apnea is around 3% to 7%.19 While studies have associated spinal cord injury with sleep apnea – particularly within the cervical region – there has been little research about the association of sleep apnea and thoracic disc herniation.20 One documented case reported transient onset of central sleep apnea, following cervical laminectomy.21 However, to date, no studies have explored an association between thoracic herniations and such sleep pathology. Because sleep apnea is caused by airway pathology and the thoracic and cervical spinal cord is closely related, it is possible that the relationship between thoracic nerves and chest wall muscles may be involved. T1 through T11 are associated with chest wall movement and there have been studies associating thoracic spinal cord injury with sleep apnea.22–24 It is thought that weakness in chest muscles, caused by spinal cord injury, produces symptoms of sleep apnea. Specific to the cervical region, cervical spine-related sleep apnea is caused by injury to neck muscles that affect airway patency – a pathophysiologic relationship which is reversible upon treatment of the cervical pathology.17 This phenomenon could be applicable to the thoracic region, too. Possibly, thoracic herniation mimicked pathology similar to that induced by spinal cord injury and chest wall muscle strength – as it relates to sleep apnea; the symptoms of sleep apnea were therefore resolved, following resolution of the pressure from spinal cord injury. Without further case reports and studies, however, we are unsure of whether or not this is the underlying pathophysiologic mechanism behind the resolution of apnea in this case report.
Here we presented the case of a patient with thoracic disc herniation treated surgically. The patient presented with sleep apnea as part of his symptomatology – a complaint that was completely resolved, following treatment of the thoracic HNP alone. We hypothesize that the herniation produced symptoms of sleep apnea, in line with the way thoracic spinal cord injury has produced symptoms of sleep apnea. In the case of the thoracic HNP, because it was treatable surgically, the apnea resolved. Additional work needs to be done, in order to explore this relationship further.
HNP = disc herniation
The authors of this manuscript have no disclosures related to the aformentioned case report.
Consent To Publication
Due to the nature of the study and IRB approval, patients waive consent to publication. IRB and approval waiver are both attached and available.
Availibility of Data and Materials
Data and materials are not available to be shared publically, due to the nature of this article.
Competing Interests
Not applicable.
Funding
Not applicable.
Author’s Contributions
All authors contributed to the ideas in the report – as well as the drafting, reviewing, and approval of the article.
Acknowledgements
Not applicable.