Out of the 69 extracted publications, 29 full-text publications were included for the scoping review [5,11–38] (Table 2). 16 studies presented clinical findings of COVID-19 among pregnant women, which includes six original articles [12,13,20–22,38], three case reports [15,32,33], two case-reviews [29,36], two research letters [18,37], and one correspondence [34], rapid review [24] and systematic review and meta-analysis [14] each. Out of these 16 studies, only 13 reported original data [12,13,15,18,20–22,24,32–34,37,38] and three study [14,29,31] reviewed data from existing studies (Table 3). Cumulatively clinical features of 229 pregnant women were reported in this review – ranging from a single [18,32–34,37] to 41 pregnant women [14,21]. It is possible that duplication of clinical cases presents between studies – however – we have actively tried to remove duplicate findings from the result. Most of the pregnant women suffering from COVID-19 cases were in their third trimester. Liu et al. [20] presented a case of early pregnancy in its 12th week. Real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) test was used for COVID-19 confirmation for all studies, except for Liu et al. [21], where 25 participants (out of 41) were laboratory negative for SARS-CoV-2 but had clinical features of COVID-19. Seven studies reported both clinical findings and recommendations for the management of COVID-19 during pregnancy, which included four original articles [12,13,21,38], two case-reports [15,33], and one correspondence [34]. Twelve studies exclusively discussed management recommendations. Among these studies, three were correspondences [16,23,31], two were commentaries [26,27], two were opinion pieces [25,35], one of case review [36], expert consensus [11], expert review [28], review article [5], and special editorial [19] each (Table 4).
Table 2: Specifications of published studies (1 January 2019 to 31 March 2020) on pregnancy and Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) between
Reference
|
Study Type
|
Country
|
Number of Pregnant Woman
|
Original Finding Reported
|
Recommendation Reported
|
Chen et al.[11]
|
Expert consensus
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Chen et al. [12]
|
Original article
|
China
|
9
|
Yes
|
No
|
Chen et al. [13]
|
Original article
|
China
|
17
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Di Mascio et al. [14]
|
Systematic review & meta-analysis
|
China
|
41a
|
No
|
Yes
|
Fan et al. [15]
|
Case report
|
China
|
2
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Favre et al. [16]
|
Correspondence
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Jiao[17]
|
Commentary
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Li et al. [18]
|
Research letter
|
China
|
1
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Liang & Acharya [19]
|
Special editorial
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Liu et al. [20]
|
Original article
|
China
|
15
|
Yes
|
No
|
Liu et al. [5]
|
Review article
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Liu et al. [21]
|
Original article
|
China
|
41b
|
Yes
|
No
|
Liu et al. [22]
|
Original article
|
China
|
13
|
Yes
|
No
|
Moro et al. [23]
|
Correspondence
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Mullins et al. [24]
|
Rapid review
|
..
|
32
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Poon et al. [25]
|
Opinion
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Qiao [26]
|
Comment
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Rasmussen & Jamieson [27]
|
Commentary
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Rasmussen et al. [28]
|
Expert review
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Schwartz [29]
|
Case review
|
China
|
38
|
No
|
No
|
Schwartz & Graham [30]
|
Correspondence
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
No
|
Wang et al. [31]
|
Correspondence
|
China
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Wang et al. [32]
|
Case report
|
China
|
1
|
Yes
|
No
|
Wang et al. [33]
|
Case report
|
China
|
1
|
Yes
|
No
|
Wen et al. [34]
|
Correspondence
|
China
|
1
|
Yes
|
No
|
Yang et al. [35]
|
Opinion
|
..
|
..
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yu et al. [36]
|
Case review
|
China
|
7
|
No
|
Yes
|
Zambrano et al. [37]
|
Research letter
|
Honduras
|
1
|
Yes
|
No
|
Zhu et al. [38]
|
Original article
|
China
|
9
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Note: a = Out of the 79 pregnancies affected by Corona Virus infections, 41 were affected by SARS-CoV-2 b = Out of 59 patients with COVID-19, 41 were pregnant
|
Table 3: Findings on pregnancy and Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) reported in published literature (1 January 2019 to 31 March 2020)
Reference
|
Study Type
|
Patients Characteristics
|
Findings
|
Chen et al. [12]
|
Original article
|
All nine pregnant women were confirmed COVID-19 were in their third trimester
|
· Seven women were presented with fever without chill
|
· Other symptoms included cough, myalgia, sore throat and malaise
|
· None of the women developed severe pneumonia
|
· Lymphopenia, elevated C-reactive protein, aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST) were observed among several patients
|
· Eight out of nine pregnant women presented patchy ground-glass opacity in the lung in CT scan
|
· All pregnant women underwent cesarean section
|
· All deliveries resulted in live births with no evidence of vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2
|
· The sARS-CoV-2 virus was not present in amniotic fluid, cord blood, neonatal throat swab, and breastmilk
|
Chen et al. [13]
|
Original article
|
All 17 pregnant women were tested positive by RT-PCR for SARS-CoV-2
|
· Four women were presented with mild fever and chill
|
· Other symptoms included cough, fatigue, chest distress, overt dyspnea, and diarrhea
|
· Lymphopenia and elevated C-reactive protein were reported for some patients. However, all patients had a normal level of ALT, AST, creatinine and blood urea nitrogen
|
· All pregnant women presented patchy ground-glass opacity in the lung in CT scan
|
· All pregnant women underwent cesarean section
|
· 14 pregnant women received epidural anesthesia, and 12 of them experienced intraoperative hypotension
|
· Three patients received general anesthesia with tracheal intubation due to deteriorating clinical condition
|
· All deliveries resulted in live births, and none of the newborns were tested positive for SARS-CoV-2
|
Di Mascio et al. [14]
|
Systematic review and meta-analysis
|
All nine pregnant women were confirmed COVID-19 were in their third trimester
|
· Most common symptoms of COVID-19 were fever, cough, and lymphopenia
|
· Radiological findings of pneumonia were presented in most of the cases
|
· No data were presented on miscarriage during the first trimester related to COVID-19 infection
|
· While the sample size is very limited, compared to MERS and SARS, COVID-19 infection resulted in higher rates of miscarriage, preeclampsia and preterm birth
|
· Preterm birth was reported most of the cases (41% before 37 weeks and 15% before 34 weeks)
|
· Preterm rupture of membranes reported for 19%, whereas only one pregnant woman suffered from Pre-eclampsia and no fetal growth restriction were reported
|
· No maternal death was reported
|
· Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported for any newborns
|
Fan et al. [15]
|
Case report
|
Both pregnant women were physicians with confirmed COVID-19 were in their third trimester
|
· Fever and nasal congestion were reported in both cases
|
· One of the patients presented a rash on her abdomen
|
· CT scan of the chest showed patchy consolidations indicating pneumonia
|
· Complete blood count was indicative of lymphopenia only in one of the cases
|
· Oseltamivir and Lianhua Qingwen capsules were prescribed for both cases. However, one of the pregnant women received Ceftazidime as antibiotic treatment - whereas - the other women received Azithromycin.
|
· One of the cases received methylprednisolone for pneumonia
|
· Both pregnant women underwent cesarean section
|
· Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported, and the newborns or any products of conception was not tested positive for SARS-CoV-2
|
Li et al. [18]
|
Research Letter
|
The pregnant women were in 35th week of pregnancy with confirmed COVID-19
|
· Clinical symptoms started with dry cough and fever
|
· Radiography of chest presented multiple patchy and scattered infiltrates in both lungs
|
· Antiviral drugs (Lopinavir and Ritonavir) and methylprednisolone were given to the patient.
|
· Emergency cesarean section was conducted on 36th week of the pregnancy, and the women delivered a live and healthy baby
|
· The newborn was not tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 in repeated testing during the postnatal period
|
Liu et al. [20]
|
Original article
|
All 15 pregnant women were confirmed for COVID-19 pneumonia with gestational age ranging from 12-38 weeks
|
· Most prevalent clinical symptoms were fever and cough
|
· Fatigues, muscle ache, dyspnea, sore throat, and diarrhea were observed in fewer patients
|
· Lymphopenia and elevated C-reactive protein was observed among 12 and 10 patients accordingly, which were returned to normal
|
· Early CT scan of the chest indicated ground-glass opacities in the lungs which developed into crazy paving pattern and consolidations
|
· Among the 15 women, ten underwent cesarean section, and one delivered vaginally
|
· The 11 women, who delivered, received antiviral treatment after delivery. The other four women did not receive antiviral treatment. All 15 women received antibiotic treatment
|
· No neonatal complication was observed, and the newborns were not tested positive for SARS-CoV-2
|
Liu et al. [21]
|
Original article
|
Among 41 pregnant women, 16 were laboratory positive SARS-CoV-2, 25 were clinically-diagnosed COVID-19 cases. Their gestational age ranging from 22-40 weeks
|
· Initially, the pregnant women presented normal body temperature compared to the non-pregnant group
|
· Leukocytosis and elevated neutrophil ratio were also presented among pregnant women
|
· In the scan of the chest, a higher proportion of pregnant women presented mixed and complete consolidation compared to the non-pregnant group. However, pure ground-glass opacity was more common among the non-pregnant group
|
· Six laboratory-positive and 8 CT-confirmed pregnant women receive Antiviral therapy.
|
· Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported for any newborns
|
Liu et al. [22]
|
Original article
|
Among 13 pregnant women with SARS-CoV-2 positive, two women were less than 28 weeks of gestation, and 11 were in their third trimester
|
· Most of the patients reported fever and fatigue. Other less prevalent feature included dyspnea
|
· After treatment, three pregnant women were discharged.
|
· Ten pregnant women went through the cesarean section. Among them, five underwent emergency cesarean section due to complications (such as fetal distress [three], premature rupture of the membrane [10] and stillbirth [one])
|
· Six pregnant women experienced preterm birth
|
· One pregnant woman developed severe pneumonia with multiple organ failure, acute respiratory distress syndrome, acute hepatic failure, acute renal failure, and septic shock. Her respiration was supported by extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in the intensive care unit (ICU)
|
· No vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was reported among the live births
|
Mullins et al. [24]
|
Rapid review
|
32 pregnant women with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection
|
· fetal growth was not affected, and no information is available related to placental pathology
|
· Of the 32 pregnancies, 30 babies were delivered. Seven women were asymptomatic, and two were admitted to the intensive care unit. However, no maternal death was reported
|
· 47% (15 out of 32) pregnant women delivered prematurely. And most of the delivery was conducted by cesarean section
|
· No vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was reported among the live births
|
Rasmussen et al. [28]
|
Expert review
|
--
|
· Currently, there is no evidence suggesting pregnant women are more suspectable to COVID-19
|
· Most common symptoms of COVID-19 are fever and cough, while lymphopenia was also common in several cases
|
· Premature birth and cesarean section were reported in several studies
|
· Any abnormality of fetal heart rate may indicate an early sign of the mothers’ respiratory deterioration.
|
· There is limited information on perinatal or postnatal modes of transmission
|
Schwartz [29]
|
Case review
|
All 38 pregnant women were in their third trimester in pregnancy, and 37 had confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection
|
· Clinical features included fever, cough, myalgia, sore throat, malaise, gastrointestinal symptoms and shortness of breath
|
· Laboratory features were indicative of lymphopenia and elevated C-reactive protein, ALT, and AST.
|
· Patchy ground-glass opacity and pulmonary consolidation is observed in lung CT scan
|
· Premature rupture of membranes was observed most of the cases, which lead to premature birth by cesarean section was reported in most of the cases
|
· No vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was reported
|
· One study from the review reported several newborns presented gastrointestinal (gastric bleeding, refusal to feed, bloating and food intolerance) and respiratory symptoms (abnormalities in chest radiography, respiratory distress syndrome, and pneumothorax). Two children developed thrombocytopenia. One premature newborn died on the 9th day due to multiple organ failure, refractory shock, and disseminated intravascular coagulation
|
Wang et al. [32]
|
Case report
|
The pregnant women were in her 40th week of pregnancy with COVID-19
|
· The pregnant women developed low-grade fever two hours after having small vaginal bleeding and lower abdominal pain
|
· Chest CT scan indicated ground-glass opacities in the lung (left upper and lower lobes)
|
· Laboratory diagnostic presented lymphopenia, neutrophilia, elevated C-reactive protein
|
· Though there was no fetal distress, emergency cesarean delivery was performed, and meconium-stained liquor reported during the operative process
|
· Immediate after delivery, the mother was asymptomatic, but later developed a fever. She received antiviral (Interferon α1b and Ganciclovir) and antibiotic (Abipenem and Moxifloxacin) and methylprednisolone.
|
· The newborn was separated from the mother after the delivery. The infant appeared to be healthy but presented lymphopenia, elevated AST, total bilirubin, indirect bilirubin, and creatine kinase
|
· The pharyngeal swab of the newborn was tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 at 36 hours after birth. However, the cord blood, placental specimens, and breast milk samples were tested negative for SARS-CoV-2.
|
· The CT scan of the infant’s chest presented high-density nodular shadow which evolved into scattered with small pieces of patchy shadow in the upper lobe of the right lung
|
Wang et al. [33]
|
Case report
|
A 30-week pregnant woman with COVID-19
|
· The pregnant women presented with fever for one week.
|
· Laboratory findings presented a low level of lymphocytes and albumin
|
· Chest CT scan of lung indicated ground-glass opacities (right side) and subpleural patchy consolidation (left side), which evolved into bilateral ground-glass opacities
|
· To prepare for emergency cesarean delivery, the mother was provided with antivirals (Arbidol, Lopinavir, and Ritonavir), antibiotic (Cefoperazone Sodium and Sulbactam Sodium), Human Serum Albumin, dexamethasone and magnesium sulfate
|
· Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported, and the newborns or any products of conception was not tested positive for SARS-CoV-2
|
Wen et al. [34]
|
Correspondence
|
A 30-week pregnant woman with COVID-19
|
· During the initial presentation, the pregnant women were presented with mild diarrhea; however, she was afebrile, breathing normally and without any cough or chest pain
|
· The chest CT scan of lung indicated ground-glass opacities and patchy consolidation in multiple regions. The lesions were “distributed along with the bronchial bundles or within the subpleural lung regions.” A small collection of fluid found in the left pleural cavity
|
· The patient received interferon, antiviral (Lopinavir and Ritonavir)
|
· The pregnant women were discharged after her nasopharyngeal swabs were negative for SARS-CoV-2 and clinical condition was improved
|
Yu et al. [36]
|
Original article
|
Seven pregnant women with COVID-19 between 37 weeks to 41 weeks of the gestational period
|
· The reported incubation period ranged from two to nine days.
|
· Major clinical feature of six out of seven patients was fever, with few patients reporting cough, shortness of breath and diarrhea
|
· Laboratory report indicated normal leukocyte count and elevated D-dimer for all patients. Five of the women had Neutrophilia, five had Lymphocytopenia, two had thrombocytopenia, and two had elevated ALT and AST.
|
· Chest CT scan of the lung of all seven women was indicative of pneumonia
|
· Antiviral medication (oseltamivir, ganciclovir, interferon, and Arbidol) and antibiotic (cephalosporins, quinolones, and macrolides) were given to the patients, along with traditional Chinese medications. Five women were treated with methylprednisolone at the postpartum stage
|
· All patients underwent cesarean section with combined spinal and epidural anesthesia (six patients) or general anesthesia (one patient)
|
· Among the seven neonates four were not tested for SARS-CoV-2, three were tested for SARS-CoV-2, and one neonate was tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 after 36 hours of birth
|
Zambrano et al. [37]
|
Research letter
|
Pregnant women with 31 weeks of gestation with COVID-19
|
· The initial presentation of the pregnant woman was fever, dry cough, myalgia, and headache. The patient also presented bilateral conjunctival hyperemia.
|
· There was no other clinical feature reported which was related to COVID-19
|
Zhu et al. [38]
|
Original article
|
Nine pregnant women were confirmed with COVID-19 (gestational age 31-39 weeks)
|
· In most of the cases, fever and cough were the onsets of symptoms, with only one patient having diarrhea.
|
· CT scan of the chest indicated viral pneumonia with bilateral ground-glass opacities with patchy lung consolidation and blurred borders of the lungs. After treatment, the lesions resolved significantly.
|
· Several prenatal complications were reported which includes intrauterine distress (six women), premature rupture of membranes (three women), abnormality of amniotic fluid (two women) and umbilical cord (two women), and placenta previa (one woman)
|
· Five women received antiviral therapy (oseltamivir) after delivery. Among them, one received oseltamivir and interferon combination
|
· Seven women underwent cesarean sections, and two had vaginal deliveries.
|
· Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported for any newborns
|
· Several newborns presented gastrointestinal (gastric bleeding, refusal to feed, bloating and food intolerance) and respiratory symptoms (abnormalities in chest radiography, respiratory distress syndrome, and pneumothorax). Two children developed thrombocytopenia. One premature newborn died on the 9th day due to multiple organ failure, refractory shock, and disseminated intravascular coagulation
|
Table 4: Recommendation related to pregnancy and Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) reported in the published literature (1 January 2019 to 31 March 2020)
Recommendation
|
Caution
|
References
|
Prevention
|
|
|
· It is recommended to maintain social distancing, refrain from unnecessary travel and crowds
|
|
[19,28]
|
· Maintain personal and social hygiene
|
|
[19,25,27]
|
· Provide pregnant women with necessary psychological support to prevent stress and anxiety
|
|
[19]
|
Isolation and screening
|
|
|
· The screening process should begin before the pregnant woman arrives in the facility. If possible, detailed of clinical features and respiratory signs and symptoms should be discussed and noted over the telephone or using any online portal
|
|
[28,31]
|
· Immediate isolation of the suspected pregnant women in a single room for screening
|
|
[11,19,25–28,31,38]
|
· Travel history, contact history, and patient’s location in a known clustering occurrence need to be investigated during the initial assessment
|
|
[11,25,28,31,38]
|
· Movement of the suspected pregnant women should be restricted throughout the facility
|
|
[11,27,28]
|
Diagnostic procedures
|
|
|
· Even if asymptomatic, a pregnant woman with a travel history within the previous 14 days or reported contact with a confirmed SARS-CoV-2 patient should be tested for SARS-CoV-2 as soon as possible using real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) test
|
· For diagnostic confirmation repeated testing may be required
|
[11,16,19,20,25,28,31]
|
· X-ray and computed tomography (CT) with abdominal shielding can be performed.
|
· May cause radiation exposure to the fetus
|
[5,11,19,24,25,31]
|
· Imaging is particularly important as a pregnant woman with imaging characteristics of COVID-19 should be considered as a clinically diagnosed case even if laboratory confirmation of SARS-CoV-2 is negative
|
|
[31]
|
· One study recommended application of lung ultrasound to identify pathological lesion indicative of COVID-19
|
|
[23]
|
· The blood sample should be collected for microbial cultures to investigate any secondary bacterial infection for pneumonia and sepsis,
|
|
[19,25,28]
|
Management of suspected cases
|
|
|
· Supportive care (e.g., adequate rest, sleep and caloric intake; maintain electrolyte and fluid balance; and provide symptomatic medications such as antipyretic, antidiarrheal)
|
|
[25,28]
|
· Monitor oxygen saturation and vital signs
|
|
[25]
|
· Perform arterial blood gas analysis
|
|
[25]
|
· Perform chest imaging for monitoring
|
|
[25]
|
· Monitor fetal health using ultrasound or doppler assessment
|
|
[25]
|
Management of confirmed cases
|
|
[25]
|
· Treatment should be performed in a negative pressure room or isolation word
|
|
[11,19,25,28,38]
|
· Pregnant women with the critical illness must be transferred to the intensive care unit with negative pressure
|
|
[11,16,19,25]
|
· A multidisciplinary team must do the management of pregnant women
|
|
[25,28,31,36]
|
· Pregnant women need to be classified as Mild: Symptomatic but vital signs are stable Severe: Respiration rate is ≥30/min, resting oxygen saturation is ≤93%, arterial blood oxygen partial pressure/oxygen concentration ≤300 mmHg Critical: Respiratory failure with the need for mechanical ventilation, shock with organ failure or refractory hypoxemia
|
|
[19]
|
· Supportive care (e.g., adequate rest, sleep and caloric intake; respiratory support by oxygen supplement; maintain electrolyte and fluid balance)
|
|
[11,19,25,27,28]
|
· Suggest lateral-decubitus position for better oxygenation of the fetus
|
|
[11,25]
|
· Broad-spectrum antibiotic (Ceftriaxone) was suggested to prevent community-acquired pneumonia.
|
· Bacterial culture and sensitivity results need to be performed
|
[11,19,25]
|
· Antiretroviral agents (e.g., Alpha-interferon, Lopinavir/ritonavir) were recommended in some studies. Traditional Chinese medicines were prescribed in some studies from china
|
· It is necessary to understand the teratogenic effect, impact on fetal growth and development before prescribing any specific drug. No safety data was available for the traditional Chinese medicines
|
[11,19,20,24,25,31]
|
· Clinical trials are currently ongoing for Remdesivir (nucleotide analog) and chloroquine (an antimalarial drug). However, there is no conclusive evidence on their effectiveness at this moment
|
|
[19,24]
|
· Short term methylprednisolone may be used to reduce dyspnea and hypoxemia during pneumonia; however, the evidence is not conclusive
|
· Use of long-term corticosteroids treatment is not recommended
|
[19]
|
· Hemodialysis for sepsis-induced severe acute renal failure
|
|
[11]
|
· in case of reparatory failure, beyond mechanical ventilation, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) was suggested by some literature
|
|
[22,28]
|
· “If the temperature reverts to normal for more than three days, the respiratory symptoms improve significantly, the lung imaging shows obvious absorption of inflammation, and the nucleic acid test for respiratory pathogens shows negative for two consecutive times (sampling interval at least one day), the patient could discharge from the hospital or be transferred to the appropriate department for treatment according to other illnesses.”
|
|
[31]
|
Clinical monitoring of confirmed cases
|
|
|
· Monitor oxygen saturation and vital signs
|
|
[11,19]
|
· Perform arterial blood gas analysis
|
|
[11]
|
· Perform chest imaging for monitoring
|
|
[11]
|
· Monitor organ functions using complete blood count, metabolic panel, C-reactive protein, lactate, renal function, liver function, and cardiac enzymes, etc.
|
|
[11,19]
|
· Monitor fetal health using ultrasound or Doppler assessment
|
|
[11,25]
|
· Amniocentesis is not recommended
|
|
[11]
|
Management during the antenatal stage
|
|
|
· Due to the evolving pandemic, very little is known about the effect of COVID-19 on during first and second trimester of the pregnancy. Regular monitoring and further research are needed.
|
|
[17,5]
|
· Asymptomatic pregnant woman with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection must self-monitor herself at home for 14 days
|
|
[16,25,28]
|
· Routine antenatal care should be provided in a negative pressure room by healthcare providers using proper personal protection equipment
|
|
[11,25–27,31]
|
· Regular ultrasounds and doppler assessment were recommended to monitor fetal growth
|
|
[16,19,25,31]
|
Management during the delivery stage
|
|
|
· COVID-19 is not an indication of pregnancy termination
|
· For Severe and critical cases or obstetric indications needs to be evaluated by physicians and care, management team
|
[11,31]
|
· COVID-19 alone should not be an indication of early delivery. Mother’s clinical status, gestational age and fetal well-being needs to be prioritized
|
· Deteriorating fetal condition may warrant early delivery
|
[11,14,16,19,25,28,36]
|
· The mode of delivery should be based on obstetric indications. While there is no indication of cesarean section, complications (such as acute organ failure, septic shock or fetal distress) may prompt for emergency cesarean section
|
|
[11,16,19,25,35]
|
· The anesthesiology team should indicate the mode of analgesia. Though during cesarean delivery epidural or general anesthesia can be safely used, neuraxial anesthesia may reduce pulmonary complications due to intubation
|
· Hypotension needs to be managed during epidural anesthesia
|
[11,13,25]
|
· Endotracheal intubation may be used for poor maternal status
|
|
[11]
|
· Use of steroids (dexamethasone or betamethasone) for lung maturation of the fetus needs to be evaluated by physicians
|
· Use of antenatal steroid can worsen the disease condition
|
[25]
|
· Tocolysis is not recommended to delay spontaneous preterm labor for administering antenatal steroids
|
|
[25]
|
· Pregnancy-related by-product needs to be treated as biohazardous waste and disposal of them needs to abide by the proper biosafety regulation of the country
|
|
[11,25]
|
· Delivery should be performed in a negative pressure room with proper biosafety precautions for medical staff
|
|
[11,13,18,19,25,35]
|
Management during the postnatal stage
|
|
|
· Delayed cord clamping is not recommended. However, recommendation varies across studies
|
|
[11,19,24,25]
|
· Newborns should be isolated from suspected or diagnosed COVID-19 mothers for 14 days
|
|
[11,19,25,26,28,35,38]
|
· Any recommendation for breastfeeding is not conclusive. However, to prevent human-to-human transmission (via direct contact, fomites, or potential aerosol), direct breastfeeding is discouraged.
|
· Pumping breast milk can be an alternative option considering proper hygiene is maintained. Breastfeeding is not recommended when the mother is taking antiviral drugs (Lopinavir/ritonavir)
|
[11,15,24–26,28,31]
|
· Provide the mother with necessary psychological support to prevent stress and anxiety
|
|
[25]
|
Clinical presentation and diagnostics of COVID-19 among pregnant women
The most common and earliest clinical presentation of COVID-19 is fever, accompanied by dry cough, myalgia, and malaise. Sore throat is the most common initial respiratory symptom; however, dyspnea and chest distress were also reported by pregnant women. Four studies reported gastrointestinal symptoms (diarrhea) [13,20,34,36]. Abdominal rash [15], and bilateral conjunctival hyperemia [37] were reported as atypical findings.
Apart from RT-PCR, computerized tomography (CT) scan of the chest was the primary mode of investigation to diagnose COVID-19 infection. Patchy ground-glass opacity (GGO) with or without consolidation was the most common feature of COVID-19 pneumonia, which resolved with time. Liu et al. [20] further elaborated on the progression of the lesion into paving patterns and consolidations. Other than lung parenchymal change, pleural effusion was identified as an atypical finding in a 30-week pregnant woman who presented with [20].
Common laboratory finding includes lymphopenia and elevated C-reactive protein [12–15,20,28,29,32,33,36]. Impaired liver function was also observed, which is reflected by increased alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST) [12,18,29,32,36]. Three studies reported neutrophilia [21,32,36]; one reported leukocytosis [21]; one reported lower albumin level [33]; one reported elevated D-dimer and thrombocytopenia [36] among the pregnant women.
Medication prescribed to the COVID-19 cases
Antiviral drugs were most commonly used to treat pregnant women with COVID-19, and the most frequently used antiviral drugs were – atomized inhalation of interferon-ALPHA [32,34,36,38], Oseltamivir [15,34,38], Lopinavir [18,34,34], and Ritonavir [18,33,34]. Ganciclovir [32] and Arbidol [33,36] were reported to be used for treatment. Secondary bacterial pneumonia was treated with a wide range of antibiotics, which included – Beta-lactam [32,33] (Abipenem and Sulbactam Sodium), Cephalosporins [15,33,36] (Cefoperazone Sodium and Ceftazidime), Macrolides[15,35] (Azithromycin), and Quinolones [32,35] (Moxifloxacin). Supportive treatment with methylprednisolone was also provided for pneumonia [15,18,32,36].
Two studies [15,36] reported the use of traditional Chinese medications along with antiviral and antibiotic treatment. Wang et al. [33] reported a 30-week pregnant woman with COVID-19 was given Human Serum Albumin, dexamethasone, and magnesium sulfate to prepare her for an emergency cesarean delivery. The clinical condition of all the pregnant women – except two [22,24] – improved after the treatment. However, none of the studies commented on the efficacy or effectiveness of the medication given to pregnant women for the management of COVID-19.
Maternal Outcomes
Rasmussen and colleagues [28] reported that there is no evidence suggesting higher susceptibility of COVID-19 among pregnant women, and no maternal death was reported in any study included in this scoping review. The incubation period among pregnant women ranges from two to nine days [36]. The development of severe pneumonia was not reported by the majority of the studies. Two studies – Liu et al. [22] and Mullins et al. [24] – reported that two pregnant women developed severe pneumonia, which required mechanical ventilation support in the intensive care unit (ICU).
It is essential to mention that, except for one pregnant woman – in her 12 weeks of gestation [20] – most confirmed COVID-19 cases were in their third trimester of pregnancy. Therefore, little is known about COVID-19 in the earlier stages of pregnancy. In their systematic review, Di Mascio et al. [14] reported no evidence was obtained of miscarriage in the first trimester, which was related to COVID-19 infection. However, with a limited number of cases and without proper controls, we cannot assume the association between miscarriages and SARS-CoV-2 infection.
Eight studies [12,15,18,24,29,33,36,38] specifically mentioned the duration of onset of symptoms to delivery, which ranged from one [12,29,38] to 13 days [24]. The duration of hospitalization was inconsistently mentioned. Preterm births was the most common feature among pregnant COVID-19 cases. Seven studies – including original articles [22,38], case review [29], research letter [18], and reviews[14,24] – reported preterm births. Preterm births were also accompanied by other pregnancy-related complications – such as preterm rupture of membranes [14,29,38], abnormality of amniotic fluid [32,38], pre-eclampsia [14], intrauterine distress [38], abnormality of the umbilical cord [38], and placenta previa [38].
While these complications can be the indications for cesarean section, the majority of the pregnancies underwent cesarean section [12,13,15,18,20,22,24,29,32,33,36,38], yet specific indication for cesarean section was not always reported. Two of the articles specified that type of anesthetic agent (either epidural or general) used in the cesarean sections, and Chen et al. [13] reported 12 out of 14 pregnant women who received epidural anesthesia experience intraoperative hypotension. Only three vaginal deliveries were reported [20,38], and no peripartum or postpartum complications were mentioned for them.
Except for one stillbirth [22] – from a 34 weeks pregnant woman with fever and sore throat – all pregnancies resulted in live births. The study conducted by Zhu et al. [38] – this finding was also reported by Schwartz [29] – reported several newborns presented gastrointestinal (gastric bleeding, refusal to feed, bloating and food intolerance) and respiratory symptoms (abnormalities in chest radiography, respiratory distress syndrome and pneumothorax). Two children developed thrombocytopenia [38]. One premature newborn died on the 9th day due to multiple organ failure, refractory shock, and disseminated intravascular coagulation, which was the only postnatal death of newborns reported in the studies [29,38].
Vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was not reported by any studies [12–15,18,20–22,24,28,29,33,36,38], as the newborns or any products of conception were not tested positive for SARS-CoV-2. Yu et al. [36] reported that one neonate was tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 after 36 hours of birth. However, the placenta and cord blood of the mother of the child tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 after delivery. Thus, it is not clear if this is a case of intrauterine vertical transmission.
Management recommendations for COVID-19 during Pregnancy
We have reported the findings on management recommendation across the following thematic area: prevention, isolation and screening, diagnostic procedures, management of suspected cases, management of confirmed cases, clinical monitoring of confirmed cases, antenatal, delivery, and postnatal stage.
Prevention [19,25,27,28]
Maintaining personal and social hygiene is the primary recommendation for preventing COVID-19. Due to the long incubation period, an asymptomatic individual can infect an unaware pregnant woman. Thus, maintaining social distancing measures (limiting unnecessary travel, avoiding the crowd and public transport and wearing a face mask), frequently washing hands using soap, using hand sanitizer, and avoid touching face (the areas around the mouth, chins, nose, and eyes) are extremely necessary. Also, it is crucial to take care of the mental health of pregnant women by providing her necessary psychological support to prevent stress and anxiety.
Isolation and screening [11,19,25–28,31,38]
Innovative use of technology can significantly help the screening of suspected pregnant women with COVID-19 infection. Initial screening and triage of the probable cases using the telephone, mobile, or online portal can reduce the spread of the infection. Within a healthcare facility, it is critical to immediately isolate any suspected pregnant women in a single room – if possible, with negative pressure – for screening, contact tracing, and history taking.
Diagnostic procedures [5,11,16,19,23–25,28,31]
Though asymptomatic, a pregnant woman with a travel history within the previous 14 days or reported contact with a confirmed SARS-CoV-2 patient should be tested for SARS-CoV-2 as soon as possible using an RT-PCR test. CT scans can also provide diagnostic support for COVID-19 cases. A pregnant woman with positive radiological findings should be considered as a clinically diagnosed case even if laboratory confirmation of SARS-CoV-2 is negative.
However, precautions need to be taken while using the CT scan with radiation exposure at its lowest achievable limit. It is also essential to assess the risk-benefit for each CT examination, and informed consent must be acquired before the procedure [39]. The blood sample should be collected and analyzed for microbial cultures to investigate any secondary bacterial infection for post-viral infection pneumonia and sepsis. One study recommended the application of lung ultrasound to identify pathological lesion indicative of COVID-19 [23]. While the RT-PCR test is yet not available everywhere, available ultrasound tests can significantly improve the accessibility of the diagnostic and treatment of COVID-19.
Management of suspected cases [25,28]
Management of probable cases of COVID-19 among pregnant women mostly includes supportive treatment and monitoring of the health status while keeping her in isolation. Supportive treatment must ensure adequate rest, sleep, and caloric intake; maintain electrolyte and fluid balance, and provide symptomatic medications such as antipyretic and antidiarrheal. In addition, oxygen saturation and vital signs need to be assessed, and arterial blood gas analysis, chest imaging, and fetal ultrasound or doppler assessment need to be performed as monitoring purposes.
Management of confirmed cases [5,11,16,19,22,24,25,28,31,36,38]
Treatment of pregnant women with COVID-19 needs to be performed in a negative pressure room – if possible – or in the isolation ward. Worsening cases of COVID-19 pneumonia must be transferred to the intensive care unit with mechanical ventilation support. A multidisciplinary team consisting of an obstetrician, intensive care medicine specialist, microbiologist, pathologist, anesthetist, and neonatologist must provide the care for pregnant women with COVID-19 infection. When prescribing antiviral or antibiotic therapy to a pregnant woman, it is necessary to understand the teratogenic effect of the drugs, which may impact on fetal growth and development.
Clinical monitoring of confirmed cases [19,25,28,40]
Preterm delivery and associated obstetric complications were observed among pregnant women with COVID-19 infection. Furthermore, existing comorbidities can lead to life-threatening conditions [40]. Thus, clinical monitoring of the patient during pregnancy is critical. Monitoring fetal health using ultrasound or Doppler assessment may also provide waning for the maternal condition. Any abnormality of fetal heart rate may indicate an early sign of the mother’s respiratory deterioration [28]. Amniocentesis is not recommended at this stage as it can lead to intrauterine transmission of the infection.
Management during antenatal stage [5,11,16,17,19,25–28,31]
Very little is reported about the effect of COVID-19 during the first and second trimester of the pregnancy. Thus, asymptomatic pregnant women with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection are recommended to self-monitor their health by isolating themselves at home for 14 days. One should not stop receiving routine antenatal care due to COVID-19. Moreover, special attention must be given to monitoring fetal health and growth.
Management during delivery stage [11,13,14,16,18,19,25,28,31,35,36]
COVID-19 is not an indication of pregnancy termination or conducting an emergency cesarean section. The mother’s clinical status, gestational age, and fetal well-being need to be prioritized, and the mode of delivery should be based on obstetric indications. Delivery should be performed in a negative pressure room –whenever possible – with proper biosafety precautions for medical staff. While COVID-19 alone is not an indication of cesarean section, new and emerging obstetric or health complications (such as acute organ failure, septic shock, or fetal distress) may prompt for emergency cesarean section. The anesthesiology team should indicate the mode of analgesia. Evidence suggests, either epidural or general anesthesia can be safely used during cesarean delivery. The use of neuraxial anesthesia may reduce pulmonary complications due to intubation.
As preterm births appear to be more prevalent among COVID-19 patients, the use of steroids (dexamethasone or betamethasone) for lung maturation of the fetus needs to be evaluated by physicians as it can worsen the maternal disease condition. Tocolysis is not recommended to delay spontaneous preterm labor for administering antenatal steroids. No study included in this scoping review indicated vertical transmission of the SARS-CoV-2. All pregnancy-related by-product needs to be treated as biohazardous waste, and disposal of them needs to abide by the proper biosafety regulation.
Management during postnatal stage [11,15,19,25,26,28,31,35,38]
Though recommendation varies across studies, some studies did not recommend delayed cord-clamping to prevent potential vertical transmission of SARS-CoV-2. Newborns should be isolated from suspected or diagnosed COVID-19 positive mother for 14 days. Recommendation on breastfeeding is not conclusive. However, to prevent human-to-human transmission (via direct contact, fomites, or potential aerosol), direct breastfeeding is discouraged. Pumping breast milk can be an alternative option considering proper hygiene is maintained. Mother receiving antiviral drugs should not breastfeed the child. Last but not least, it is imperative to provide psychological support for the mother to prevent stress and anxiety.