The findings of this study indicate that passive repetitive stretching for 2 weeks induced an increase in skeletal muscle mass and fiber size and promoted a positive protein turnover in the skeletal muscle via Akt-mTOR signaling pathways, accompanied by an elevated expression level of MuRF1, which is involved in protein degradation, in the senescent skeletal muscles of SAM-P8 mice. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to demonstrate muscular hypertrophic adaptation to passive repetitive stretching in aged mice in vivo.
The theoretical basis for stretch-induced skeletal muscle hypertrophy dates back to in vitro studies. Goldberg et al. found that repetitive stretching applied to cultured skeletal muscle cells provided mechanical stimuli and triggered cellular biomarkers essential for muscle growth20. Indeed, robust hypertrophy was observed after progressive stretch overload of the wing muscles in birds21. Stretch parameters such as frequency and duration have been identified as important factors that potentially affect the skeletal muscle adaptive process, as the gene expressions involved in muscle growth and atrophy are responsive to the number of stretch sessions22,23. Sarcopenia is an age-related reduction in both muscle mass and quality1.2. Although prior studies have demonstrated that senescent muscles preserved the capacity to undergo hypertrophy, the ability to perceive and respond to mechanical inputs and translate them into biochemical signals, which is called “mechano-transduction,” was reportedly blunted during aging11. The impact of aging on the cellular mechano-transduction process is rooted in multiple factors such as modifications in cell cytoskeleton structures, alterations in mechanosensitive signaling, and the extracellular matrix environment11. Zotz et al. found that 1 week of intermittent stretching in aged rats resulted in an unchanged muscle mass, accompanied by reduced fiber size12. Hotta et al. reported an increase in soleus and plantaris muscle weights after 4 weeks of continuous stretching without further histological analysis of muscle characteristics13. As the rats were awake during continuous muscle stretching, it became difficult to isolate the effects of stretching from isometric contractile activity. In another study, contractions were eliminated by animal anesthesia during stretching, while muscle weight and fiber area remained unaltered24. In our study, we found that clinically feasible protocols of passive repetitive stretching markedly increased the gastrocnemius muscle mass and myofiber size. This has been proven to be a practical therapeutic approach to induce muscle hypertrophy in senescent muscles. Sarcopenia predominantly affects type 2 muscle fibers, whereas type 1 fibers are less affected2. Guo et al. demonstrated that type 2 muscle fibers, which made up the largest proportion of the gastrocnemius muscle, peaked at 8 months, followed by a gradual decline in SAM-P8 mice19. However, it appears that muscle fiber-type composition seemed not to be susceptible to regulation within 2 weeks of stretching. Fiber-type plasticity within skeletal muscle is regulated by a sophisticated signaling network with two major pathways, calcineurin signaling and AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) signaling with a major mediator, PGC-1α25. Our observations suggest that the hypertrophic effect of passive repetitive stretching occurred without modifying the fiber-type composition within a short duration of 2 weeks.
The regulation of muscle mass and fiber size substantially reflects changes in protein homeostasis, i.e. the balance between protein synthesis and degradation15. Therefore, to decipher the mechanism of action behind the hypertrophic effect of passive repetitive stretching, we first verified whether the Akt/mTOR pathway, which predominantly controls muscle protein synthesis, was involved in muscular adaptation. Akt is an upstream regulator of mTOR, and it is widely recognized that signaling by mTOR is a core module of the pathway through which mechanical stimuli regulate protein synthesis and muscle growth26. The regulation is primarily mediated by two downstream targets of the mTOR complex 1 (mTORC1), translational suppressor 4E-BP1 and ribosomal protein p70S6K27. It has been reported that skeletal muscle stretching activates these signaling molecules, including Akt, p70S6K, and 4E-BP1 in vitro28,29. Enhanced Akt, p70S6K, and 4E-BP1 phosphorylation were observed in denervated mice soleus muscles when subjected to repetitive stretching in vivo9. Several studies have demonstrated that the responsiveness of Akt/mTOR signaling is diminished in overload-induced muscle growth during aging, suggesting limited plasticity for aged muscle hypertrophy30. This study provides evidence that in vivo repetitive stretching strongly increases the expression of Akt, p70S6K, and 4E-BP1 in senescent skeletal muscles at the transcriptional level. The stretch-activated Akt/mTOR signaling pathway involved in skeletal muscle protein synthesis is intact in aged mice.
Moreover, Akt normally blocks the upregulation of several ubiquitin-proteasome genes related to protein degradation in skeletal muscles by negatively regulating FoxO transcription factors15. In skeletal muscles, the major muscle-specific ubiquitin ligases include MAFbx/atrogin-1 and MuRF1, which are associated with myonuclear apoptosis and muscle atrophy15. However, an expected suppressive effect on MuRF1 and MAFbx was not observed in our study. Peviani et al. found an increase in MAFbx expression in the soleus muscles of rats when daily bouts of stretch were performed23. Russo et al. reported that stretching could reduce the accumulation of MAFbx and MuRF1 in a denervated rat skeletal muscle22. Furthermore, Soares et al. showed time-course alternations of MAFbx and MuRF1 that decreased drastically after 24-h stretching and then partially recovered after 48- and 96-h stretching in immobilized muscles31. These divergent findings suggest that proteasome activity is potentially influenced by stretching protocols or responds differently under physiological and pathological conditions. The alternation of MAFbx and MuRF1 expression in aged skeletal muscle has been reported to be inconsistent. Several studies found that the expression levels of MAFbx and MuRF1 increased in skeletal muscles with aging, which may contribute to sarcopenia32,33. However, unaltered and even decreased expression levels of MAFbx and MuRF1 have been shown in other studies34,35. In our study, MuRF1 mRNA expression was elevated, indicating the involvement of the cellular degradation pathway in aged skeletal muscle adaptation to passive stretching. In combination with the greater muscle mass and increased muscle fiber size, this may suggest that stretch-induced hypertrophy of senescent muscles may result from relatively enhanced overall rates of protein synthesis that possess a superior position in protein homeostasis during the experimental period. Likewise, differential expression patterns of myostatin in stretching have been observed in previous reports22,23,36. Myostatin negatively regulates skeletal muscle growth, primarily by acting via activin type II receptors (ActRII), resulting in the activation of Smad signaling14,15. Smad signaling suppresses Akt signaling and its downstream effectors such as mTOR and FoxO to regulate muscle growth14,15. Alterations in myostatin expression and signaling activity in the context of aging are not completely understood. We could speculate that passive stretching is a potential intervention to counter, at least in part, sarcopenia via myostatin inhibition. However, myostatin expression was not affected by stretching in our study. A further time-course study may help to define the myostatin expression alternation in response to passive repetitive stretching of senescent skeletal muscles.
In addition to protein turnover within individual myofibers, as stated previously, skeletal muscle hypertrophy can also be induced by the activation of muscle satellite cells. In mature muscles, satellite cells are generally quiescent but become activated in response to various stimuli or under muscle regeneration to form new myofibers37. When activated, a surge of MRFs, including MyoD, Myf5, and myogenin expression, is required owing to the role of MRFs in driving the differentiation of myoblasts to mature myotubes17. Previous studies have shown that mechanical stretching can induce activation of skeletal muscle satellite cells5. Elevated expression levels of MRFs have also been observed after short-term passive repetitive stretching7. Pax7 expression has been recognized as a marker of satellite cells. To elucidate whether passive repetitive stretching triggered an active regenerative process that may contribute to senescent skeletal muscle hypertrophy, we first sought to detect Pax7 + cells by immunohistochemical analysis. Pax7 + cells were rare, and there was no significant difference in the number of Pax7 + cells between the stretched and unstretched muscles. Therefore, satellite cell content wasn’t stimulated by passive repetitive stretching during the experimental period. As also observed in a human study, satellite cell response during post-exercise recovery is blunted with aging38. The expression of MyoD was unchanged, whereas the Myf5 and myogenin mRNA expressions were upregulated in the stretched side when compared with the unstretched side. It has also been reported that MRFs mRNA increases occur in muscles, even in the absence of proliferating satellite cells39. We are not convinced of the possibility of stretch-induced myogenesis without an increase in MyoD and Pax7 expression levels. Overload-induced muscle hypertrophy requires the involvement of satellite cells in growing mice, whereas it is not necessary for hypertrophic growth in mature adult mice40.