Course design
The experts in leadership designed the two-day workshop plan specifically tailored to teach essential leadership knowledge and skills needed in the healthcare sector. Course participation was opened to all dental students, but it was intentionally limited to 20 participants to foster in-depth small-group discussions, significant group engagement, and practical teamwork activities. All the participants received a certification upon completion of the program. The first day of the program included: Participants' introduction, the difference between Leadership and management, Team building activities, Leadership from Inside-out: personal values, and social identities.
The second day included: Practicing creativity and innovation, leadership from a communication perspective: Interpersonal communication and effective presentation skills, and a reflective personal visioning exercise.
The course's overall objective was to introduce the concept of "leadership," increase awareness and give necessary tools to dental students to apply to their work. In addition, specific objectives were for students to gain a better understanding of the following concepts:
-
The difference between management and leadership skills
-
Emotional intelligence and its relationship with self-awareness, self-regulation, empathy skills, and social skills
-
The importance of having teamwork skills and their application to have an effective team
-
The idea that personal values impact leadership styles
-
To have the opportunity to create a unique vision
During the workshop, a series of books on leadership were available for students to further their knowledge.
In the following, an overview of the modules covered in the course is provided.
Module 1: Participants' introduction
The program started with a participant introduction, using an engaging creative conversation. They were given a set of visual cards and were asked to pick a picture that represented how they defined leadership. Visual cards were a powerful tool to encourage authentic conversations and effective dialogue in a safe learning environment. This set of visual cards uses diverse images to create a visual vocabulary that helps participants express themselves through stories, metaphors, intuition, and emotion. Given the cultural diversity of the participants, their interpretation and conceptualization of effective leadership were slightly different. However, the common fundamental themes described were vision, strategy, and direction for effective leadership.
Module 2: Difference between Leadership and Management
This module was designed to highlight the differences between management and leadership. As Bennis summarized, "managers do things right, while leaders do the right thing" (15). The instructor presented slides about these two concepts and introduced the different aspects of leadership and management. The role of emotional intelligence was also argued in the workshop. The skills required for a leader were discussed based on Goleman's study (16).
Module 3: Leadership from Inside-out
This module focuses on self-awareness and a deeper understanding of self as a leader. Individuals must reflect on themselves, their core values, strength, behavioral patterns, aspirations, goals, and developmental plans. The self-reflection approach included Boyatzis's theory of Intentional Change Model learning (17). This model offers five discoveries, and each of them serves as the starting point for a learning process. Taken together, they provide a coherent and integrated model that supports an intentional personal development plan as a guide to move towards action.
These discoveries were as follows:
-
My ideal self (who do I want to be?)
-
My authentic self (who am I?)
-
Building on my strengths while reducing gaps
-
Experimenting with new behaviors, thoughts, and feelings and practicing them
-
Developing trusting relationships that help and support each step
To enable each participant to find out about his authentic self, the facilitators give them a list of values and ask them to prioritize them based on their values. Finally, the module concluded with discussions about 1) self-awareness, 2) self-regulation, 3) self-motivation, 4) empathy, and 5) social skills underpinning other approaches to leadership. Students also came up with situations where dentists should be careful about their emotional aspects of leadership roles. Such skills are considered crucial since health care leadership is more than a practice; it is also an interpersonal interaction. There may be a movement away from practice owners' historical emphasis on autocratic leadership styles toward a more democratic team-based leadership style.
Module 4: Personal Vision
Participants were also introduced to the concept of creating a personal vision. They were asked to do a reflective exercise to explore their personal and professional vision. According to Kotter, vision represents a leader's capability to perceive the future accurately and increases motivation and responsibility to achieve a goal (18). As described in "In A Whole New Mind" by Daniel Pink, being a synthesizer is vital to dental education leaders. Being a synthesizer means seeing the big picture, crossing boundaries, and combining disparate pieces into an arresting new whole (19).
Module 5: Team building games/activities
The third module was dedicated to the concept of building a team environment, led by the facilitator and a co-facilitator. This environment was created through the practice of teamwork practices. At the end of the activities, each delegate shared his own experience. The objective was to understand each other's roles in teamwork and how building a trusting team environment can decrease mistakes and improve task effectiveness. Despite the solitary nature of dental practice and the mentality of many dentists, even the smallest dental practice setting is a teamwork environment, and networking is likely to be a new way of working for those who historically have operated as autonomous practitioners in their own small business.
Module 6: Creativity and innovation
This module on creativity and innovation aims to prepare participants for the constantly changing work and life environment as we know it. The key considerations for this section were the ability to think outside the box, create new visions and solutions, and adapt to the uncertainty and complexity of challenges they face in their workplace and with their teams. In addition to sharing best practices in this module, practical games and group discussions were used to enhance the learning. Participants were encouraged to see challenges and opportunities with fresh eyes and practice creativity and innovation as a key skillset in their leading change.
Module 7: Effective presentation skills
In this module, the focus was on leadership from a communication perspective. The importance of knowing the audience, and the ability to have clear and effective communication was discussed. Often, leaders have a great vision, but only those who can present their vision are able to succeed. This section included characteristics and requirements of effective presentation and offered tips on public speaking with high impact. Verbal and non-verbal communication, executive presence, and how it affects a leader's capacity to influence, inspire, and motivate others were explained. Participants were then asked to practice presenting a topic of their choice to the whole group and received feedback on improving this skillset.
Course Assessment
A mixed-method (qualitative/quantitative) approach was used with open-ended and closed-ended questionnaires and an in-person interview to evaluate whether the students found value in this pilot program. The course was anonymously evaluated twice, one right after the workshop (initial survey) and the other six months after (follow-up survey), to obtain a broad scope of feedback. The study protocol was exempted by the Alborz University of Medical Sciences Institutional Review Board.
The first feedback sheet was designed to see whether the participants had found value in this experience, mentioning the most challenging and the most influential part of the course while rating each part of the plan on a scale of 1 to 5 (1: completely dissatisfied − 5: completely satisfied)
The follow-up survey consisted of two parts. In the first part, the qualitative data was collected using an in-person interview; the students were asked about their experience during six months in dental school and how they used the gained skills, providing a self-reflection opportunity. In the second part, participants completed another feedback sheet; they had to prioritize the five most essential leadership skills required for a dentist to be included in future leadership programs. Finally, the students were asked about their preferences and needed for a future leadership course.
Ethics
The study protocol was approved by Alborz University of Medical Sciences Ethics committee and all the methods were carried out in accordance with relevant guidelines. Informed consent was obtained from all participants and their names and information remained confidential.