It is worth mentioning that from preclinical discovery to clinical development, PCSK9i has been authorised for clinical application for only a few years, potential adverse outcomes, and yet requires extra investigation. In addition to the most frequently reported side effects, including injection-site reactions and upper respiratory tract infections (34), accumulating evidence also indicates that PCSK9i increases the rate of adverse events such as diabetes and neurocognitive deficits. Specifically, participants receiving PCSK9i reported an absolute increase in fasting blood glucose and HbA1c as well as an increased risk of incident diabetes (35).. Additionally, both alirocumab and evolocumab are reportedly associated with an increased risk of adverse neurocognitive events compared to a placebo (6, 11). Notably, the safety of using PCSK9i during pregnancy is yet to be clearly established, particularly as PCSK9i has been shown to cross the placental barrier (18). Our prior research as well as a recent study identified lower PCSK9 expression in the serum of pregnant women with NTD fetuses (12, 15), assuming that NTDs could be possible side effects among pregnant women exposed to PCKS9i. However, there is no evidence to manifest the safety of PCSK9i with regard to foetal NTDs.
In this work, we demonstrated that PCSK9 knockout mice noticeably increased the incidence of ATRA-induced adverse pregnancy outcomes, particularly NTDs, although PCSK9 knockout embryos alone did not exhibit any NTD phenotypes. Nevertheless, whether other risk factors interacting with PCSK9 deficiency generate rising incidence of adverse pregnancy outcomes remains unclear. Lipids known to be involved in the formation of NTDs (32)notwithstanding, lipidomic profiling of NTDs has never before been surveyed. This study utilised lipidomics to investigate the global pattern of lipid profiles in the serum of pregnant rats with NTD, as well as in the neural tubes of NTD embryos. Interestingly, we observed higher TG levels, both in lipid species and lipid classes, in the NTD group than in the control group. In further animal experiments, our data showed that PCSK9i treatment (SBC-115076 or evolocumab) raised the occurrence of stillbirths and defects, including exencephaly, spina bifida, and cleft lip palate, in HFD embryos, indicating the risk of PCSK9i and HTG interaction for adverse pregnancy outcomes, especially NTDs. Thus, a vital issue arose: might this novel medicine is safe and beneficial for all patients?
Despite the potent clinical benefits of PCSK9i, large gaps remain in our understanding of PCSK9i effects. PCSK9i causes an increase in LDLR by disrupting the binding and degradation of PCSK9 to LDLR, thereby decreasing circulating cholesterol levels, which have been widely described in the liver (4). PCSK9, however, has less well-known functions and target proteins in extrahepatic tissues, which will aid to determine the hidden adverse effects of targeting PCSK9. PCSK9 has been reported to cause a reduction in ABCA1, which facilitates the pro-atherosclerotic status of macrophages in the vasculature (36). Here, we provide evidence that PCSK9 expression in the neural tube of normal foetal rats gradually elevated with embryonic neurulation; meanwhile, decreased significantly in NTD foetuses at each embryonic day.
Furthermore, detailed profiling was performed under PCSK9-deficient conditions in neural stem cells by proteomic analysis. Impaired mitochondrial function, consisting of thermogenesis, oxidative phosphorylation, the TCA cycle, and the succinate metabolic process, paralleled by the enhanced biological processes of response to ROS and oxidative stress, are revealed to be associated with PCSK9 deficiency. As further assessed by biological functions as well as mitochondrial morphology, the current work firstly provides firm evidence for the impact of PCSK9 deficiency on mitochondrial dysfunction, with subsequent ROS production and apoptosis in the nervous system, which are pivotal causes of NTD formation. Overwhelming evidence, including our previous studies, has documented that impaired mitochondrial function, followed by ROS production and apoptosis, causes an insufficient number of neuroepithelial cells within the neural folds, which is a pivotal cause of NTD formation (29, 37, 38). Although some existing studies have shown the dual behaviour of PCSK9 in the regulation of apoptosis in neurodegenerative diseases (39), increasing evidence suggests that PCSK9 regulates apoptosis in CVD and tumourigenesis (40–44).
Among the related proteins in functional pathway analysis of the proteome following PCSK9i treatment, SDHA is of utmost concern. We further confirmed the regulation of PCSK9 on SDHA both in vitro and in vivo, which has not been previously elucidated. SDHA, the most important catalytic subunit of complex II, serves as a key enzyme involved in both oxidative phosphorylation and TCA cycle in mitochondrial respiration, and is responsible for catalysing succinate to fumarate and maintaining ROS homeostasis (45). SDHA deficiency-induced succinate accumulation drives ROS production and subsequent apoptosis (46, 47). However, no previous research has characterised the critical role of SDHA in NTD development. Herein, we discovered that PCSK9 deficiency mediates NTD induction by causing mitochondrial damage followed by ROS production and apoptosis, probably via the inhibition of SDHA.
Despite the reported connection between hypertriglyceridaemia in pregnant women and foetal NTDs (22, 23), to date, the underlying mechanisms remain undefined. Our findings from both animal models and cell experiments support the hypothesis that mitochondrial dysfunction arises from both TG accumulation and PCSK9i-induced SDHA deficiency, is responsible for ROS production and subsequent apoptosis that disrupts closure of the neural tube. Despite compelling evidence that susceptibility to NTDs is determined by genetic and environmental factors (48), the precise nature of the link is poorly understood. Our findings revealed that PCSK9 deficiency did not cause NTDs in ND-fed mice but caused a significant rising in NTD occurrence among HFD-fed embryos, demonstrating a gene-environment interaction between the loss of PCSK9 and HTG. Succinate accumulation from fatty acid overload due to HTG coupled with PCSK9i-induced SDHA deficiency, which drives ROS production and subsequent apoptosis, may provide an explanation for the synergistic effects of the environment and genes. However, further clinical investigations based on large-scale, multicentre population studies will be required to support the results from animal experiments. Additionally, continued research into the exact molecular mechanisms should address the regulatory effect of PCSK9 on SDHA.
With the rapid progress of PCSK9i agents, more attention should be directed to the safety issues associated with this novel therapeutic agent. Here, we identified an increased risk of adverse pregnancy outcomes following PCSK9i treatment harnessing an HFD-based female mouse model, which revealed a previously unknown side effect of PCSK9i. We also defined a mechanism whereby PCSK9i-induced SDHA deficiency and hypertriglyceridemia-induced TG accumulation cooperatively give rise to ROS production and subsequent apoptosis, which in turn leads to adverse pregnancy outcomes(Fig. 7). These findings highlight the potential safety challenges of PCSK9i therapy for hypercholesterolaemia and CVD in pregnant women.