Our meta-analysis of 7 RCTs provided evidence for the SGLT2i-mediated protection and safety against cardiovascular events among patients with renal insufficiency at various baselines. Based on our data, SGLT2i strongly reduced incidences of MACE, cardiovascular death, and hospitalization for heart failure.
Relative to controls, the SGLT2i also reduced the safety index, particularly, incidences of acute renal injury, hypoglycemia, diabetic ketoacidosis, and amputation. Given these evidences, SGLT2i application in preventing cardiovascular events among renal insufficiency patients has broad prospects and important clinical significance.
Previous demonstrations of the SGLT2i-based cardiovascular protective effect on patients with renal insufficiency was based on the analysis of pre-specified results or secondary analysis of prior trials. Till now, there has not been a meta-analysis to confirm that the included patients were from RCTs of renal insufficiency. Hence, this meta-analysis is the first comprehensive and systematic demonstration of this conclusion.
The underlying mechanism of the SGLT2i-mediated protection against cardiovascular events is not entirely clear. However, the potential cardiovascular mechanism can be understood from the following aspects. First, it is well established that the SGLT2i-induced improvements in cardiovascular recognized risk factors, namely, blood pressure, weight, uric acid, and proteinuria can be a contributing factor to enhancing the overall cardiovascular health. Second, the reduction of fluid overload and enhancement of natriuresis, caused by osmotic diuresis, as well as the reduction of arterial stiffness and improvement of vascular endothelial function, also critically modulate hemodynamic alterations to a certain extent. Third, SGLT2i directly acts upon the myocardium to reduce myocardial stretch, low-grade inflammation, and oxidative stress, as well as inhibit Na+– H + exchanger 1 (NHE1) activity, and enhance energetics due to using ketone as fuel. Fourth, SGLT2i may also positively modulate the endocrine system by increasing glucagon, decreasing the sympathetic tone, and enhancing the angiotensin converting enzyme angiotensin 1–7 pathway (ACE-ANG1-7) activity [24–27]. These aforementioned mechanisms involve the endocrine, circulatory, immune, and biochemical systems. They are not mutually exclusive of one another, however, they play their own roles. Since this is a hypothesis, there is no relevant test to prove its mechanism of action at the present time. Further basic test verification, special research, and confirmation are needed to elucidate and validate the mechanistic findings [28–32].
Apart from its role in reducing blood glucose, arterial blood pressure, and arteriosclerosis, SGLT2i also produces certain beneficial effects on the kidney, which can be understood from the following aspects. First, SGLT2i activates the intrarenal anti-inflammatory and anti-fibrosis pathways [33–35], improves renal oxygenation and mitochondrial function [36], and restores the tubular bulb feedback mechanism [28]. It also promotes the contraction of the small artery entering the glomerulus and the reduction of the intra glomerular hyperfiltration [20, 37, 38]. Second, since SGLT2i reduces blood glucose concentration, the kidney and other important organs are protected from glycotoxicity, which is conducive to reducing kidney growth, inflammation, and damage [31]. Third, SGLT2i also reduces the blood pressure, volume and weight of patients with renal insufficiency to a certain extent, which may, in turn, diminish the renal and cardiovascular burden [31, 39, 40]. Fourth, SGLT2 is generally co-expressed with the Na+/H + exchanger 3 (NHE3) membranal protein in the early proximal tubule, and it may accelerate natriuria, which may, in turn, have a positive effect on reducing blood pressure, thereby protecting the kidney [31]. Fifth, SGLT2i is related to glucagon levels, and glucagon partially contributes to maintaining renal function [31]. Glucagon dilates renal blood vessels, increases renal plasma flow, promotes glomerular filtration rate, and enhances electrolyte excretion. Other potential protective mechanisms include SGLT2 inhibitors which may reduce arterial stiffness and vascular resistance, lower uric acid level, and inhibit the angiotensin aldosterone system [41]. There may be more potential effects of SGLT2i on cardiovascular and kidney health, and further exploration of these potential mechanisms are necessary in patients with renal insufficiency.
In conclusion, for patients with renal insufficiency, SGLT2i significantly improves the incidence rate of cardiovascular disease, acute renal injury, hypoglycemia, diabetic ketoacidosis, and amputation. Regardless of whether a patient has diabetes or not, the SGLT2i-based mechanism of cardiovascular and kidney protection requires additional investigation and validation.
Advantages Of This Article
Herein, we present the first systematic review and meta-analysis on the cardiovascular protection and safety of SGLT2i among patients with chronic renal insufficiency. This investigation was conducted with strict standard research scheme and inclusion and exclusion criteria. In all, 7 RCTs were included for analysis, and these included a total of 26739 people. The selected RCT data were analyzed and the protective effect of SGLT2i on the cardiovascular system was evaluated. Our conclusions provided strong evidence for the cardiovascular protective effect of SGLT2i, as well as the effectiveness and safety of the drug SGLT2i.
Results Of Other Studies And Reviews
Although prior clinical trials supported the SGLT2i-mediated protection of the heart and kidney among patients with diabetic nephropathy or stage 3a/3b CKD, till date, there is no relevant meta-analysis on patients with non-diabetic nephropathy or renal insufficiency induced by other causes.
In all, 7 RCTs examining SGLT2i were included in our analysis. Among them, the CREDENCE trial consisted of patients with eGFR of 30–90 mL per minute per 1.73 m2, accompanied with proteinuria of varying stages. The test conclusion was that among patients with type 2 diabetes and kidney disease, the renal failure and cardiovascular event risk among patients administered with cagelin was drastically lower than among patients administered with placebo [2]. This is consistent with the results of the cardioprotective effect of cagilegin in the CANVAS project [42]. Moreover, the EMPA-REG test confirmed that the heart protection experienced by the engegliptin group was better than the placebo group [43]. The famous DAPA-CKD test validated that the mortality risk due to kidney or cardiovascular causes among patients given daggliptin was significantly lower than patients given placebo [1]. This, together with the DECLARE – TIMI and DAPA-HF trials, support that SGLT2i substantially minimizes incidences of cardiovascular deaths and hospitalization for heart failure [9, 44]. In particular, diabetic ketoacidosis and hypoglycemia did not occur in the DAPA-CKD test. In terms of the trials involving bexagliflozin and sogliflozin, the safety and effectiveness of using bexagliflozin among CKD were the primary endpoints. Therefore, the indicators of interest were not kidney- and cardiovascular-related outcome indicators [21, 22]. Although these articles did not group cardiovascular basic diseases, patients with chronic heart failure and reduced ejection fraction were grouped in the meta-analysis of the DAPA-HF and empagliflozin outcome trials. Zannad et al. reported that SGLT2 inhibitors usage strongly diminished the risk of comprehensive outcome of hospitalization for heart failure or cardiovascular death among patients without diabetes by 25% [45]. In a systematic review and meta-analysis by Salah et al., SGLT2 inhibitors usage also strongly reduced the risk of hospitalization for heart failure by 48% [46].
At present, there are many clinical trials discussing the protective effect of SGLT2i on the cardiovascular system. However, the underlying mechanism is not completely clear. In the future, we warrant additional trials to elucidate the potential mechanism of SGLT2i on the cardiovascular system.
Limitations
This systematic review and meta-analysis has several limitations. First, although the glomerular filtration rate of all participants met the conditions of renal insufficiency, the baseline was different, which may have impacted the results. Second, part of the trial was short, and no long-term clinical follow-up was conducted Third, we did not consider the underlying cardiovascular diseases of the included patients, and perform subgroup analysis as appropriate.