3.1. Patent analysis:
Using selected keywords and after applying suitable filters one hundred forty four patents had been shortlisted. The applications were further analysed to classify them into three categories namely diagnostics, therapeutics, and both. The diagnostic and therapeutic patent applications were further sub-classified into various sub-categories based on their usage and mode of action (Figure: 2 a,b).
In general, there is an upward trend in number of patent applications being filed which seems to slow down in recent years (Fig. 3a). Abbvie INC7 is the most active applicant in this field (Fig. 3b). Most of the patent applications belong to A61K and A61P category as per IPC. In the subsequent subsections, the patents have been discussed under various sub-categories based on their applications.
3.2. Diagnostic agents
Twenty six patent applications which describe inventions of diagnostic utility for endometriosis have been classified into various sub-categories on the basis of their detection using different methods/techniques. These techniques include use of biomarkers (genetic markers, serum markers, and other biological markers); physical examination of both endometrial tissue and out-growth using different hysteroscopic techniques like laparoscopy, MRI, Ultra-sonography and biopsy, and myomectomy.
3.2.1. Biomarkers for the diagnosis of Endometriosis
I. Genetic markers
Genetic markers play a crucial role in the diagnosis of endometriosis. Nine patent applications describes usage of genetic marker for the prediction of endometriosis. The patent application numbers WO2020234280 and WO2019106034 claim for high expression of ESR, CXCL12, and CXCR4 genes that indicates the presence of endometriosis [17][18]. CN113736875 patent claims that expression of some miRNAs such as miR-22-3p, miR-182-5p, and miR-103a-3p is associated with endometriosis [19]. Detection of GPR30 mRNA in a sample of a suspected patient is described in patent application KR1020180083178 [20]. RU0002730952, and CN113186311 are the patent application which are claiming for the detection of CA125 as a biomarker for the diagnosis in unsuspected patient [21]. Also, the RU0002677866 patent describes that usage of Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) rs2241423, rs7766109, rs4953655, and rs9939609, for evaluation as genetic risk-associated variations for endometriosis [22]. RU0002766750 patent application describes PAI1-675 5G/4G, MTHFR C677T, MTRR A66G, NOS3 C-786T associated genetic polymorphisms. Alongwith these around 40 nucleotide sequence has been claimed under patent application WO2018049946 for disease prediction.
II. Serum markers
Serum markers can play an excellent role in the prediction of diseases. For examples include description of serum ezrin, phospho-ezrin, and their combination in the sample protein given in the patent number KR1020170068169. The RU0002676035 patent application has claimed that the level of serum interleukin-6 (IL-6) and alpha-2-glycoprotein (ABG) are being associated with endometriosis [23][24]. Also, RU0002676050 patent application has considered that increase in the level of IL-6 can be helpful in the detection of endometriosis.
III. Other Biological markers
Some biological sample reveals that few micro-organisms are found at the site of infection, which might be suspected to be associated with endometriosis. As given in the patent application number CN113186311, the biological biomarkers “Clostridium disporicum” and “Lactobacillus reuteri” are micro-organisms found in the endometrial tissues of affected women [25].
3.2.2. Devices or Methods of Physical examination of Endometriosis
The physical examination is an easiest method for the detection of endometriosis. Several methods come under the physical examination; such as Laparoscopy, MRI, Biopsy, hysterectomy and myectomy. In physical examination the clinician figures out the abnormality of the pelvic-peritoneal region using given techniques as per the type of infection.
3.2.3. Laparoscopy
Currently laparoscopy is a gold-stranded method for the diagnosis of endometriosis. This is a preferred approach for observing endometriosis lesions under magnification both inside and outside the pelvis [26]. The condition may have multiple appearance, and the red, black and white lesions on the various region of pelvis which may turn out to be non-endometriotic lesions in certain cases, thus making the confirmatory tests essential to avoid unnecessary medication [27]. Patent applications CN212679168 and RU0002775664 describes a laparoscopic instrument/technique for accurate result.
3.2.4. MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) and Ultra-sonography
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and Ultra-sonography are another methods being used for the detection of endometriosis [28]. Patent application RU0002618923 and RU0002757755 describes a modification of MRI method in which the maximum thickness of the connective zone between the endometrium, myometrium and Endometriosis can be identified by measuring blood flow characteristics in uterine tissue in uterine myomas. RU0002764106, RU0002437615 and IN201741019461 are the patent applications which are dealing with the use of A-focused (HIFU) high intensity focused ultrasound instrumentation, for detection of destruction, loss of villi, shed down mucus membrane, Homogeneity and echogenicity using 2D and 3D mode examination using the ultra-sonographic technique [29]. In hysteroscopy the uterine cavity is examined [30], and suspicious adenomyosis sections of the mucosa are marked. Oxytocin is introduced into the cervix in the presence of adenomas, dark colour blood begins to flow from endometriosis suspicious area as a better inspect for endometriosis as mentioned under the application SU01398871.
3.2.5. Biopsy
The technique of taking tissue samples from the suspected endometrial region is also give excellent output as a results for diagnosis. CN111397943, CN111317564, CN212281620, and US20210321993 are mentioned with a microwave ablation needle used to ablate endometrial tissue to take the samples for the site of infection. Also, there is another method use to take samples from the endometrial lesions using a specific mounting rod highly focused device claim in patent application CN109700546.
3.2.6. Myomectomy
A patent application RU0002711297 has claimed for the S.N.A.L.T.A. uterotomy score scale that has been designed for the detection of nodule size tissue sample in case of endometriosis gives an accurate result of presence of endometriosis in suspected women.
3.4. Traditional medicines
The most reliable sources for the development of novel pharmaceuticals are believed to be traditional medicines for Several reproductive disorders, especially endometriosis, which have been treated with a variety of therapeutic herbs and metabolites derived from plants. Many gynaecologic disorders’ symptoms now are frequently remedied using medicinal herbs and traditional medicines [57]. As we have seen natural products are less side-effective but more curative. Anti-proliferative, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory properties have been found in medicinal plants products and their active ingredients. These qualities may assist in the treatment of endometriosis [58] [59]. In this patent analysis, we have retrieved forty three patent applications for traditional herbal products. All these patent applications are belonging to a specific country, the majority of the traditional medicine and herbal products in the field of therapeutic approaches for endometriosis has owned by China and these applications are increasing every-year. All the herbal products and medicines prepared from the plant extracts have been patented by the Chinese assignees in the traditional Chinese medicine category. These traditional plant medicine applications have been patented mainly under two major IPC (International Patent Classification) A61B and C12Q. All these patent applications has no patent family, as we can see in our observed data that each patent has been considered as a single patent application under a standard IPC classification.
These traditional Chinese medicines are required to take a certain amount for effective results. Several pharmaceutical compounds have been mentioned as traditional therapeutics that contain some raw material such as peach kernel, rhizoma sparganii, rhizoma curcumae, rhizoma corydalis, curcuma zedoaria, cortex moutan, thallus laminariae, poria cocos and prunella vulgaris in patent applications CN104740536, CN101011563 and CN109045205 for the preparation of these unique medicines. Anorectal medication administration, also known as Chinese herbal hydrotherapy, which is a way of treating certain disorders that entails seeping Chinese natural herbs into the vagina and having left it for a few hours to permit the Chinese herbal medications to swallow into the intestinal mucosa. Patent application CN105920260 deals with the Lotus pod, rodgersflower rhizome, ramie leaf, hang rock wind, Artemisia anomala, excrementum pteropi, three Blue or green leaf, wilson passionflower herb, Auricularia on Weigelae, Euonymus euscaphis Hand Mazz and thunder slender acanthopanax used as a raw material for treatment of endometriosis. Also, there are some specific composition of a traditional medicine using transferrin, iron oxide black and beta-cyclodextrin meant for treatment of the endometriosis (CN113559221). Patent applications CN101020030 and CN109674903, deal with snow lotus, cnidium fruit, broom cypress, flavescent sophora root, tuckahoe, herba boschniakia rossica, lucid ganoderma, alumen, wild ginseng, semen persicae, and saffron for treatment of endometriosis. Earthworm, dried ginger, dried fennel, fructus aurantii, corydalis tuber, radix paeoniae rufa, astragalus membranaceus, flos carthami, fructus aurantii, fennel, dried radix paeoniae rufa, trogopterus dung, cortex moutan, lindera aggregata, rhizome cyperi, Szechwan chinaberry fruit, pollen typhae, scorpion, rhizome sparganii, Cinnamomum cassia\ curcuma zedoary, cassia twig, resina draconis, pangolin and spina gleditsiae as the raw medicines are claims under CN1712047, CN105456974, CN111568989, CN112870325, CN101104007 and CN108567931 for the treatment of endometriosis. Traditional chinese medicine composite as Chinese angelica, herba leonuri, fried cattail pollen, rhizoma chuanxiong, trogopterus dung, radix paeoniae rubra, cassia twig, bighead atractylodes rhizome, poria cocos, peach kernels, and flos cartham; Used for treatment of endometriosis has given under CN106902193, patent applications. Medicine enema is prepared with raw materials herba patriniae, herba epimedii, rhizoma sparganic, flos carthami, honeysuckle stem, angelica sinensis, herba leonuri, soapberry, folium artemisiae argyi, rhizoma corydalis, caulis sargentodoxae, red peony root, dragon's blood, notoginseng, tangerine seed, campsis grandiflora, rhizoma cyperi, ligusticum wallichii, caulis spatholobi, peach kernels, dipsacus asperoids, salviae miltiorrhizae achyranthes bidentata and loranthus parasiticus each required 10–20 parts as a stranded quantity for treatment claims in CN104667074, CN112957447 and CN1133734 patent application. Similarly, Traditional medicine composition of “cassia twigs, herb of Tuberculate speranskia, Rhizoma sparganii, Rhizoma curcumae, Folium artemisiae argyi, Dahurian angelica roots, Sappan wood, fennel, clove, fructus aurantii, leech and Myrrh” has used for the preaparation of therapeutic medicine (CN105497705, CN105456909). Also, “Chinese angelica, motherwort herbs, fried cattail pollen, Sichuan lovage rhizome, flying squirrels droppings, red peony roots, cassia twigs, large head atractylodes rhizome, Indian bread, peach kernels and red flowers” water has suspected as medicinal role in CN1927359, and CN102861185. Patent application CN101015504 deals with the administration of oxirane, pingyangmycin with saline using aspetic gelatin sponge and syringe in the uterus give suppository source to the women. In patent applications CN1911422, and CN104208227, Semen cuscutae, dried human placenta, Radix Angelicae Sinensis, Ligusticum wallichii, corydalis tuber, placenta hominis, ligusticum wallichii, Chinese herbaceous peony, salvia miltiorrhiza, turmeric, Ramulus euonymi used for the preparation of medicine. Patent applications CN112826914, CN112755136, CN109925495, CN108671125, and CN108567838 claims for peach kernels, safflower, galangal, angelica Sinensis, cinnamon, fennel, dried ginger, astragalus mongholicus, citron, fingered citron, purple perilla, and orange peel raw material used as therapeutic agents as a raw material used in the treatment of endometriosis [14]. Cassia twig and Poria cocos pills are used for pill preparation patented in CN111624269. Soybean and lotus stamen are used as raw materials in CN101569662 for the preparation of endometriosis. The active component in the treatment of endometriosis is andrographolide as mentioned in CN103520152 patent application. CN105816762, CN106975065 and CN112957422 are the patent application which claims for the radix ginseng rubra, trogopterus dung, radix notoginseng, tubers of scirpus planiculmis, rhizoma polygoni paleacei, Cantonese speranskia herba houttuyniae, root of red-rooted salvia and rhizoma smilacis glabrae, which are used for the preparation of an effective medicine for endometriosis. Patent application CN106138372 and CN108888647 has mentioned some specific plants extract such as fiber crops, owe quintessence oil, endothelium corneum gigeriae galli, kelp, deerblood, gynura procumbens, and ginseng play effective role in the treatment of endometriosis. Rhizoma Pinelliaes as main supplement claims under CN103893449 and CN107335009 deal with Rhizoma polygonati with yellow rice wine and Rhizoma curcumae rhizoma cyperi for endometriosis treatment. Also, CN114452368, CN107496826, CN103536843 and CN105944033 are patent application which is dealing with the few radix aconiti lateralis preparata, fructus evodiae, rhizoma zingiberis, cortex cinnamomi, flos carthami, rhizoma curcumae processed with vinegar, rhizoma sparganii processed with vinegar, banksia rose, Ramulus euonymi, salvia flava, red stalk grass, rhizoma corydalis processed with vinegar, radix angelicae sinensis, radix paeoniae alba, radix rehmanniae preparata, radix astragali preparata, poria cocos, rhizoma atractylodis macrocephalae, semen coicis, semen plantaginis, fried pollen typhae, charred pollen typhae and radix glycyrrhizae preparata for the preaparation of a traditional medicine. Nature provides a tremendous resource for the identification of novel therapeutic chemicals for the treatment of severely debilitating disorders with the least side-effects because of the enormous structural and biological variability of natural products. Combining therapies is the best course of action for endometriosis. In terms of downstaging and symptom reduction (disease-free duration), combination therapy appears to have a better advantage when these therapeutic approaches are compared.
3.5. Combined Patent applications for Diagnostic and therapeutic Patent applications
There are certain inventions which can be utilized both for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. In the current patent analysis, two patent application fall under this category. WO2001032920 patent application disclose the invention relates to the discovery of genes and their products that are associated with the disease endometriosis. It has been discovered that cathepsin D, AEBP-1, stromelysin-3, cystatin B, protease inhibitor 1, sFRP4, gelsolin, IGFBP-3, dual specificity phosphatase 1, PAEP, immunoglobulin chain, ferritin, complement component 3, pro-alpha-1 type III collagen, proline 4-hydroxylase, alpha-2 type I collagen, claudin-4, melanoma adhesion protein, procollagen C-endopeptidase enhancer, nascent-polypeptide-associated complex alpha polypeptide, elongation factor 1 alpha, vitamin D3 25 hydroxylase, CSRP-1, steroidogenic acute regulatory protein, apolipoprotein E, transcobalamin II, prosaposin, early growth response 1 (EGR1), ribosomal protein S6, adenosine deaminase RNA-specific protein, RAD21, guanine nucleotide binding protein beta polypeptide 2-like 1 (RACK1) and podocalyxin are all implicated in this disease. Also, EP1767632 patent applications deals with the nucleic acid molecules, including dsRNA, siRNA, antisense, 2,5-A chimeras, aptamers, and enzymatic nucleic acid molecules, such as hammerhead ribozymes, DNAzymes, and allozymes for the diagnosis and treatment of endometriosis.