Recruitment
The ARIQUELI study was conducted between July 2012 and June 2020 at the mood disorders outpatient clinic of the Hospital das Clínicas of the University of São Paulo. Patients were enrolled until December 2019, when the planned sample size was reached, and followed up until June 2020. 130 screening candidates were evaluated, of which 105 were actually included. [Figure 1]
Characteristics of the sample
Patients were divided according to the stage of the illness, with the mania/hypomania group comprising 19 (18.3%) participants, the depressive episodes group comprising 59 participants (56.7%), and the mixed states group comprising 26 (25%). No differences were observed between episode types [Table1].
Table 1: Characteristics of the sample
|
General
|
Mania
|
Depression
|
Mixed
|
p
|
Age, years, (IQR)
|
31 (18 - 39)
|
31 (20 – 39)
|
30 (20 – 39)
|
31 (18 – 39)
|
.411 a
|
Womens, n (%)
|
73 (69.5)
|
12 (63.2)
|
39 (66.1)
|
12 (81.5)
|
.285 b
|
Age of onset BD I, years
|
16 (4 – 33)
|
14.5 (5 – 24)
|
16 (4 – 33)
|
15 (6 – 33)
|
.253 a
|
Illness duration, years (SD)
|
13.79 ± 7.64
|
16.14 (5.82)
|
13.42 (8.12)
|
12.57 (7.66)
|
.417 a
|
CGI-BP-M-Mania (IQR)
|
4 (1 – 5)
|
4 (1 – 5)
|
2 (1 – 5)
|
4 (1 – 5)
|
<.001 a
|
CGI-BP-M-Depression (IQR)
|
3 (1 – 6)
|
2 (1 – 5)
|
4 (1 – 6)
|
4 (1 – 5)
|
.008 a
|
CGI-BP-M-Overall (IQR)
|
4 (1.13)
|
4 (1 – 6)
|
4 (2 – 6)
|
4 (1 – 5)
|
.449 a
|
Depressed patients had lower scores for mania than manic or mixed patients (p < .001), and manic patients had lower scores for depression than depressed and mixed patients (p=.008).
76 patients (78.4%) had at least one psychiatric comorbidity, with alcohol abuse or dependence (33%), specific phobia (32%), obsessive-compulsive disorder (32%), social phobia (29.9%), and panic disorder (27.8%) being the most common. Specific phobia (p=0.026), Post-traumatic stress disorder (p=.045) and Body dysmorphic disorder (p=0.039), were more common in the mixed episode group.
Efficacy
With respect to the primary endpoint, we found a response rate of 38.5%, and a remission rate of 33.3%. There was no difference between groups with different episodes (Table 2).
Table 2: Response and Remission rates
|
General
|
Mania
|
Depression
|
Mixed
|
p
|
Response, n (%)
|
40 (38.5)
|
5 (27.8)
|
27 (45.8)
|
8 (19.2)
|
.214
|
Remission, n (%)
|
35 (33.3)
|
7 (36.8)
|
23 (39.0)
|
8 (21.0)
|
.164
|
We examined whether rapid cycle was associated with response or remission. We found no significance but we observed a trend (p=.062) in depressed patients with rapid cycling to not respond and a trend in depressed patients with rapid cycling to discontinue therapy (p=.074).
Study participants experienced a significant decrease in CGI-BP-M scores between the baseline and week eight, with the median score decreasing to two points for the mania and depression scores and to three points for the total illness CGI-BP-M scores. There was also a significant decrease in scores between the first visit and the last observed visit (LOCF), with a decrease of 7.49 (9.2 SD) for the HAMD (p < 0.001) and a decrease of 4.60 (8.5 SD) for the YMRS (< 0.001).
The reduction in scores between groups from baseline to week eight was evaluated. No differences were found in the YMRS scale (p=.102), but there was a difference between groups in HAMD (p=.010). Patients with depression showed a mean decrease of 9.76 (5.79 SD), while patients with mania showed a decrease of 3.70 (5.76 SD) and in the mixed state of 4.65 (9.24). Bonferroni's analysis showed a greater decrease in the group of patients with depression compared to patients with mania (p=.044) and patients in the mixed state (p=.046). Something similar was also observed in the CGI score.
No differences were observed between the groups in the CGI-BP-M total or CGI-BP-M mania assessment, but differences were observed between the groups in the CGI-BP-M assessment depression: the group of patients in depression showed a greater decrease than the group of patients in mania (p=.007) and although not significant, it showed a tendency to decrease compared to the group in mixed state (p=.075).
Dosage
The median quetiapine dosage was 300 mg at weeks one and two, 400 mg at week three, and 500 mg at weeks four, six, and eight.
No differences were noted between episode groups with regard to quetiapine dose at the last visit in the acute phase. However, a difference (p=0.29) was observed between groups at the second week, where the depressed group had a greater number of patients on doses below the median than the mania or mixed state groups.
Safety and Tolerability
During this follow-up period, the sample “as a whole” evolved with no significant differences (p=.090) in weight between baseline weight (median 72 kg) and end of the acute phase (median 74 kg). No differences were observed between the episode groups either.
Regarding dropout rates, a total of 26 participants (24.8%) left the study during the acute phase, with no statistical differences between episode groups. In terms of reasons, 40% of the sample discontinued treatment due to adverse effects, 28% due to worsening condition or failure to respond, 24% due to treatment abandonment or failure to follow up, and 8% due to withdrawal of consent. No differences were observed between reasons or between groups of episodes.
Differences between group effects of episode type were observed for the adverse effect asthenia, fatigue or tiredness (p=.042) and for the adverse effect memory difficulties (p=.041), which were observed more frequently in patients in a mixed state compared to depressed or manic patients and less frequently in patients with a manic episode compared to depressed and mixed patients; a difference was also observed for the adverse effects migraine (p=.002), tension headache (p=.047) and weight gain (p=.006), which occurred less frequently in the manic patients than in the mixed and depressed patients; and finally in the effects menorrhagia (p=.014) and urticarial erythema (p=.012), which occurred more frequently in the mixed group than in the depressed and manic patients.
Maintenance of monotherapy
The median sustained response was five months, with only three patients completing 22 months of maintenance therapy without loss of response or dropout and no difference was seen between groups (p=.616).
The dropout rate in the maintenance phase was 58.3% in a total of 14 patients. Loss of response requiring treatment improvement was observed in seven patients (29.2%) of the sample.
Although no change in weight was observed in the acute phase, a significant increase was observed between baseline study weight (median 72 kg) and the last observation in the maintenance phase (median 80 kg) (p=.014).