3.1 Mean and variability in Wet Days and Dry Spells
Figure 2 shows the average number of wet days and dry spells during MAM, JJA, SON and OND seasons based on an average of 30 years mean (1981–2010) over the IGAD region of Eastern Africa. Generally, the results show the areas with the highest number of wet days vary from season to season and within countries. On seasonal timescale, the MAM season (Fig. 2a), the highest number of wet days (55-65days) are recorded over southwestern parts of the region, mainly over southwestern South Sudan, southern and south-Eastern parts of Uganda, Lake Victoria basin and the highland of western and Nyanza region of Kenyan, while everywhere in Sudan, Eritrea, Djibouti, northern Somalia, Upper Nile state in South Sudan, southeastern, northern and northeastern Ethiopia, northeastern Kenya recorded lowest number of wet days, which is less than 15 days per three months. Similarly, the JJA season (Fig. 2b), the highest number of wet days (65–75) were recorded over western South Sudan, highlands of central and western Ethiopia, whereas northern Sudan, southeastern Ethiopia zones, majority of counties in Kenya, most parts of districts in Somalia and coastal Djibouti recorded lowest number of wet days. In SON season, the highest number of wet days were recorded over most parts of Uganda, south-western South Sudan and Ethiopia, while most parts of Sudan, eastern and Southeastern Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Djibouti, Eritrea recorded the lowest number of wet days ranged between 45–60 dry days (Fig. 2c). During the DJF season, except southern and central Uganda, Lake Victoria basin, the rest of IGAD regions recorded lowest wet days ranging between 0–10 dry days (Fig. 2d). The wet days patterns proved the potential of the highland of western Kenya, most parts of Uganda, southwestern Ethiopia during MAM, JJA and SON, most parts of South Sudan during MAM and JJA for sustainable food crops production and food security. The south-northwards and north-southward movement of ITCZ around the Equator suggests the highest (lowest) number of wet and dry days over the region. Across all four seasons, out of 92 possible wet days, the sub-regions in Northern and Red Sea states in extreme northern Sudan, northeastern consistently recorded less than 5 wet days. Generally, the highest number of wet days (lowest wet days) are recorded in areas where the MAM, JJA, SON and DJF season are considered as the main rainfall season (dry climatology). The highest number of wet days explained the importance of JJA for South Sudan, Ethiopia, while MAM and OND for Kenya, MAM, JJA, SON for the Uganda agriculture sector.
Figure 3 presents the mean dry spells(climatology) patterns during four seasons. Conversely, the shortest and longest continued dry-spells recorded over areas with highest and lowest wet days as described in Fig. 2. Most parts of Kenya, Somalia and Ethiopia recorded 3–5 consecutives dry spells (21–35 consecutive dry days) during MAM (Fig. 3a), whereas southwestern and northern parts of South Sudan, western Ethiopia, rain belts in southern parts of Sudan recorded the less than 1 spells as the shortest spells in IGAD region during JJA season (Fig. 3b). Nevertheless, the OND shows 3–5 spells (21–35 consecutive dry days) recorded over most parts of Kenya, Somalia and southeastern Ethiopia, while southwestern Uganda recorded 1 spell as longest (Fig. 3c). Similarly, central and northern Uganda, most parts of southern, central and northern Kenya, northeastern, central and southwestern Ethiopia have the longest spells during DJF season(Fig. 3d). Lake Victoria basin consistently observed lowest spells across all four seasons. In addition, these results show, the majority of lands in the IGAD region are dry and susceptible to agriculture failure due to 2–4 consecutive dry spells, therefore, the prolonged number of dry spells over most parts of ASALs in the IGAD region explained why they experienced chronic food insecurity. The mean wet days and dry spells patterns explained south-north timing of rainfall onset progression and retreat(cessation) from March to November.
Figure 4 presents the seasonal mean state of the variability of the wet days (first raw) and dry spells (second raw) at the 1mm threshold for the 1981–2010 reference period. The results show areas and seasons with the highest amount of total rainfall as noted in previous study by Cattani et al., (2018), wet days and less dry spells recorded less variability compared to dry regions. Thus, most parts of southwestern South Sudan, most parts of Uganda, highlands of western Kenya and Ethiopia have lowest variability (less 10%), whereas ASALs in southern parts of Sudan, northeastern Kenya, eastern and southeastern Ethiopia especially Eastern Hararghe and northern Somalia recorded highest variability in wet days (Fig. 4a), because these areas experience low mean rainfall through the year(Schreck & Semazzi, 2004). According to Muluneh Sorecha & Bayissa, (2017), the CV values of, 41, 34 and 31% recorded Babile, Haramaya and Kersa districts in Eastern Hararghe, Ethiopia. Most parts of South Sudan, central and western Ethiopia observed lowest variability during JJA (Fig. 4b), and the same patterns of low variability continued to SON seasons, however, the highest variability was observed over northeastern Kenya, southeastern Ethiopia and northern Somalia (Fig. 4c). Due to widespread dry conditions during DJF season over the IGAD region, the highest variability (more than 100%) is observed everywhere in Sudan, northern parts of South Sudan, south-eastern Ethiopia, most parts of Somalia and northeastern Kenya (Fig. 4d). On the contrary, the dry spell patterns (Fig. 4e-h) or second row shows highest variability of dry spells over the same regions and areas with lowest variability on wet days. Therefore, most parts of Uganda during MAM and SON (Fig. 4e and 6g), most parts of South Sudan during JJA season (Fig. 4a) observed highest variability of wet days (more than 100%) compared to other countries in the IGAD region. The patterns of variability in wet and dry spells revealed that areas with lowest variability in wet days (highest variability of dry spells) are most conducive environments for rain-fed food crops production and provided food basket and food security for the IGAD region.
Furthermore, the study analyses the means values at the countries or national level (Djibout, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan and Uganda) and region levels (average of all pixels over IGAD region) for wet days and dry spells during 1980s, 1990s,2000s, 20, 30- and 41-years average presented in Fig. 5. Generally, Uganda had the highest number of wet days (lowest consecutive dry spells) in both MAM SON seasons, while South Sudan recorded the highest during JJA. On the other hand, Somalia and Djibouti recorded the highest number of dry spells over the season of MAM and OND. In rankings countries based on number of wet days(dry spells), Uganda recorded the highest number of wet days (lowest dry spells), followed by South Sudan, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Eritrea, Djibouti and Sudan during MAM season(Fig. 5a,b), while South Sudan on top of countries based on number of wet days(dry spells), followed by Uganda, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sudan, Djibouti, Kenya and Somalia (Fig. 5c,d). for OND, again Uganda ranked on top, followed by South Sudan, Ethiopia, Kenya, Eritrea, Somalia, Sudan and Djibouti (Fig. 5e, f). Due to a big portion of ASALs in northern Sudan, northeastern Kenya, southeastern Ethiopia, and most parts of central Somalia, the IGAD region recorded less than 10 wet days (more than 8 consecutive dry spells) during MAM. The recent years (2011–2020) recorded the highest mean wet days in South Sudan, Uganda, Ethiopia, Kenya and average of the entire IGAD region.
Figure 6 below shows the average number of wet days(first column) and dry spells(second column) during 1980s, 1990s, 2000s,2010s (1981–1990, 1991–2000, 2001–2010,2011–2020), 30 years average (1981–2010), 41 years average (1981–2021) and 20 years average (1981–2000,2001–2020) in Arua, AlQadarif, Upper Nile, Arsi, and Trans Nzoia as the most five agricultural districts, state, zone and county in Uganda, Sudan, South Sudan and Ethiopia. The results revealed that the mean values for four decades (1980s, 1990s, 2000s,2010s) and 41 years average (1981–2021) for MAM, JJA and SON Seasons recorded very close mean values across all five regions. The different timescale means values for MAM season showed that Arua followed by Trans Nzoia recorded the highest mean of wet days (lowest mean consecutive dry spells), and AlQadarif recorded the lowest mean (highest mean dry spells) during the season (Fig. 6a, b). The highest wet days (lowest dry spells) during JJA were recorded over Arua and Upper Nile (Fig. 6c, d). The patterns of JJA continued, where the Arua recorded the highest mean of wet days (lowest mean consecutive dry spells) during up to SON (Fig. 6e, f). in Addition, the Arsi zone in Ethiopia recorded the lowest mean values (highest mean value of consecutive dry spells) of wet days during OND.
3.2 Probability of Wet Days and Dry Spells exceeding defined thresholds
Figure 7 and 8 shows the probability of wet days and dry spells exceeds 7, 14,21,28 consecutive wet days and 1,2,3,4 consecutive dry spells during MAM, JJA, SON and DJF season reference to 1981–2010 climatology. The results for MAM season (Fig. 7a-d) show everywhere in Uganda, South Sudan and Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Djibouti and most parts of Eritrea observed more than 90% probability of wet days to exceed 7 consecutive wet days (Fig. 7a). However, these areas started shrinking continuously with an increase in probability of consecutive wet days from 7 days to 14,21 and 28 days. Under probability of 14 consecutive wet days (Fig. 7b), the highest probability recorded in the whole country of Uganda, most parts of South Sudan, central and southwestern Ethiopia, highlands of western and Nyanza in Kenya with probability more than 80% southern, while the lowest probability was recorded in the central and northern part of Sudan, northwestern Eritrea with probability less than 1%. The same patterns observed under probability of exceeding 21 and 28 consecutive wet days (Fig. 7c, d), where the whole country of Uganda, southwestern South Sudan and Ethiopia recorded highest probability (80–100%) and lowest probability (1–5%) extended to northeastern Kenya, northeastern and southeastern Ethiopia, northern Somalia, everywhere in Eritrea and Djibouti. For JJA, more than 90% probability of exceeding 7 and 14 consecutive wet days which cover whole parts of Uganda, South Sudan, western, central and northern parts Ethiopia, western and costal Kenya (Fig. 7e) has continuously shrink to cover lake Victoria basin, central and northern Uganda, and southwestern Ethiopia for probability of exceeding 21 and 21 consecutive wet days, whereas lowest probability extended to northern Sudan, most parts of Kenya, everywhere in Somalia, southeastern South Sudan and Ethiopia(Fig. 7g,h). The highest probability(more than 80%) during SON observed over whole Uganda and South Sudan, most parts of Ethiopia, western and coastal counties in Kenya(Fig. 7i), most parts of Uganda and South Sudan, western and northwestern Ethiopia, western and Nyanza in Kenya (Fig. 7j,k) and patterns reduced to cover most parts of Uganda, western South Sudan and Ethiopia, western and Nyanza in Kenya(Fig. 7l) for probability of exceeding 7,14,21 and 28 consecutive wet days respectively. The patterns of probability for DJF (figure m-q), show the highest probability was recorded over southern Uganda, western and southern parts of Kenya for probability of exceeding 7days (Fig. 7m), which reduced to southern Uganda only under for probability of exceeding 21 and 28 days (Fig. 7o, q). In the IGAD region, Uganda and South Sudan, western and Nyanza counties in Kenya continuously recorded more than 80% probability of exceeding 7–28 days during MAM, JJA and SON season. No any changes in pattern of probability of exceeding 7–28 days over Sudan across all four seasons (MAM, JJA, SON and DJF) because these areas are dry climatology.
On other hand, the areas with lowest probability (less than 1%) under consecutive wet days recorded the highest probability (100%) exceeding 1,2,3 and 4 consecutive dry spells during MAM, JJA, SON and DJF seasons. Sudan, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Kenya, Djibouti and Somalia recorded 100% probability of exceeding 1 consecutive dry spell during MAM, SON and DJF seasons (Fig. 8a, I, m), whereas Western South Sudan, southern parts of Sudan, highlands of western Ethiopia are only areas recovered lowest probability (less than 5%) of probability of exceeding1 consecutive dry spell during JJA season(Fig. 8e). No any changes in pattern of 1% probability of exceeding 2,3 and 4 consecutive dry spells over northern parts of Sudan during MAM season (Fig. 8b, c,d) because these areas are dry climatology and ICTZ never crossed Sudan border this time of year. Most parts of Kenya and Ethiopia during SON and DJF recoded 60–100% probability of exceeding 2,3 and 4 consecutive dry spells because it is not possible for 7–28 days to pass without 1mm rainfall thresholds. Since JJA is main season over South Sudan, northern Uganda, highlands of western Ethiopia, this explain why the probability of exceeding 2,3 and 4 consecutive dry spells are less than 1% (Fig. 8f, g,h). Similarly, the patterns of 1% of 1% probability of exceeding 2,3 and 4 consecutive dry spells covered all Sudan during DJF season (Fig. 8n, o, q).
3.3 Change in Mean of Wet Days and Dry Spells
Figure 9 present the spatial patterns of changes in Seasonal mean state of Number of wet days at 1 mm thresholds for the four decades 1980s,1990s,2000s and 2010s (1981–1990,1991–2000,2001–2010 and 2011–2020), average of 40 years (1981–2020) and differences between current (2001–2020) and previous 20 years (1981–2000) relative to 1981–2010 reference period. This result shows high decadal (10 years) variability of wet days over IGAD region. The wet days have deceased over South Sudan, western Ethiopia in1980s (Fig. 8a), southeaster Ethiopia and everywhere in Uganda, Kenya and Somalia in 1990s (Fig. 9b), costal and northeastern Kenya, southern and central Somalia and most parts of Ethiopia in 2000s, while increase in wet days was observed over Kenya, central and southeastern Ethiopia in 1980s, southern parts of Sudan, western Ethiopia in 1990s, most parts of South Sudan and Uganda in 2000s(figure c) and a large portion of IGAD regions in recent years 2011–2020 (Fig. 9d). The extra-ordinary increase in wet days signals in recent years (2011–2020) maintained the increase signals over Uganda, South Sudan and highlands of western and Nyanza counties in Kenya when current 20 years (2001–2020) compared to previous 20 years (1981–2000) during MAM season (Fig. 9e). For JJA, the decreased wet days over Sudan, South Sudan and Uganda and increased over highlands of western Ethiopia, western and Nyanza in Kenya in 1980s (Fig. 9f) has recovered in 1990s (Fig. 9g, h), while increase continued in 2010s (Fig. 9i) and clearly increased wet days were captured when recent 20 years compared with the previous (Fig. 9j).The decreased wet days in 1998s during MAM and JJA continued in OND season over Uganda, South Sudan and Sudan (Fig. 9k). The decreased wet days signals have recovered over western Ethiopia, Sudan and northern parts of South Sudan in 1990s (Fig. 9l), while most parts of Ethiopia observed decrease again in 2000s (Fig. 9m) and northern parts of South Sudan, northwestern Ethiopia and almost everywhere in Sudan in 2010s (Fig. 9n). The decreased wet days over Sudan and northern parts of South Sudan and incresed patterns over lake victoria basin, eastern Uganda, most parts of Kenya, central and southeastern Ethiopia, everwhere in Soamila during OND decade of 2011–2020 is the most higest incresed(increase) in wet days patterns in the record of last 40 years. The patterns of DJF season(Fig. 9q-u) revelead the decresed wet days signals over Uganda in 1998s and 1990s(Fig. 9s,t) recovered in 2000s and decresed again in 2010s(Fig. 9u).The increase in wet days over most parts of the region in current 20 year (2001–2020) compared to previous 20years (1981–2000) contributed largely by extra-ordinary wet days in 2018, 2019 and 2020.
Figure 10 present the spatial patterns of changes in Seasonal mean state of number of dry spells at 1 mm thresholds for the four decades 1980s,1990s,2000s and 2010s (1981–1990,1991–2000,2001–2010 and 2011–2020), average of 40 years (1981–2020) and differences between current (2001–2020) and previous 20 years (1981–2000) relative to 1981–2010 reference period. This result shows high decadal (10 years) variability of dry spells over the IGAD region as observed in wet days analysis already discussed in Fig. 9. The dry spells has increased over South Sudan, western Ethiopia in1980s (Fig. 8a), southeastern Ethiopia and everywhere in Uganda, Kenya and Somalia in 1990s (Fig. 10b), coastal and northeastern Kenya, southern and central Somalia and most parts of Ethiopia in 2000s, while decrease observed over Kenya, central and southeastern Ethiopia in 1980, southern parts of Sudan, western Ethiopia in 1990s, most parts of South Sudan and Uganda in 2000s(figure c) and most parts of region in recent years 2011–2020(Fig. 10d). The strong of decrease (increase) in dry spells signals in 2010s (1990s and 2000s) maintained the decrease (increase)signals over Uganda, South Sudan and highlands of western and Nyanza counties in Kenya when current 20 years (2001–2020) compared to previous 20 years (1981–2000) during MAM season (Fig. 9e). for JJA, the increased dry spells over Sudan, South Sudan and Uganda and increased over highlands of western Ethiopia, western and Nyanza in Kenya in 1980s (Fig. 10f) has recovered in 1990s (Fig. 10g, h), while decrease continued in 2010s (Fig. 10i) and decreased dry spells capture well when recent 20 years compared with the previous (Fig. 10j).The increased dry spells in 1998s during MAM and JJA also continued in OND season over Uganda, South Sudan and Sudan (Fig. 10k). The increased dry spells signals have recovered over western Ethiopia, Sudan and northern parts of South Sudan in 1990s (Fig. 10l), while most parts of Ethiopia exhibit significant increase again in 2000s (Fig. 10m) and northern parts of South Sudan, northwestern Ethiopia and almost everywhere in Sudan in 2010s (Fig. 10n). The increased dry spells patterns over Sudan and northern parts of South Sudan and increased patterns over lake victoria basin, eastern Uganda, most parts of Kenya, central and southeastern Ethiopia, everywhere in Somalia during OND decade of 2011–2020 is the highest increase in dry spells patterns in the last 40 years due to extraordinary reduction of dry spells due heavy rain observed in last 6 years in the region. The patterns of DJF season (Fig. 10q-u) revealed the decreased dry spell signals over Uganda in 1998s and 1990s (Fig. 9s,t) recovered in 2000s and decreased again in 2010s(Fig. 10u). Increases in dry season rainfall over East Africa is also found by Wainwright et al., (2021).
The raw figures of changes in wet days and dry spells illustrated in table 2. The comparison for means in last 41 years (1981–2020), four decades of 1980s,1990,2000s and 2010s (1981–1990,1991–2000,2001–2010 and 2011–2020 respectively), current 20 year (2001–2020) and previous 20 years (1981–2000) from climatology(1981–2010 )over five potential agricultural production areas (El Gadaref in Sudan, Upper Nile in South Sudan, Arsi in Ethiopia, Tranz Nzoia in Kenya, Arua in Uganda. The MAM season results revealed that Tranz Nzoia in western Kenya recorded 5 wet days increase during 2011s, followed by 3 wet days over Trans Nzoia and Arsi in Ethiopia during 1981s, while 3 wet days decreased over Trans Nzoia during 1990s. During the last decade (2011–2020), the wet days over Trans Nzoia have increased by 8 and 11 days during JJA and OND respectively. As evidence of a slight increased MAM rainfall trend in the last decade 2011s, the Arsi zone, Upper Nile state, Trans Nzoia county and Arua district observed decrease in dry spells. In addition, the JJA observed − 0.8 decrease in dry spells over Trans Nzoia as the highest changes in dry spells across all MAM, JJA and SON seasons.
Table 2:illustrated the changes in wet days and dry spells over five potential agricultural production areas (El Gadaref in Sudan, Upper Nile in South Sudan, Arsi in Ethiopia, Tranz Nzoia in Kenya, Arua in Uganda
3.4 Inter-annual variability in Wet Days and Dry Spells
The standardized Anomaly Index (SAI) for wet days and dry spells over entire pixels over the IGAD region presented in 11. The results show an increase in the trend of wet days over the IGAD region during MAM, JJA and SON (Fig. 10a). This increase is attributed to the increase in intensity and frequency of wet days during the last decade (2011–2020) across all three main rainy seasons in the region. This finding is not consistence with studies by Nicholson, (2017), who reported decline in rainfall over East during MAM season in recent decades. In the last 40 years, 2018, 2019 and 2019 are the years with the highest increase in wet days. The MAM 2018, JJA 2020 and OND 2019 are the wettest seasons in the last 41 years with the highest increase in number of wet days anomalies. The MAM 1981, JJA 2018 and OND 1997 are the second wettest years in the ranking. On other hand, the dry spell anomalies show decreasing in trend across all three seasons (Fig. 11b). The MAM 1992, JJA 1982 and OND 1994 are the most years observed increase in number of dry spells anomalies in the last 41 years, while MAM 1987 and 1990, MAM2001,2008 and 2012, OND2019 are the most years with decrease in dry spells anomalies over IGAD region.
Figure 12 presents the Inter-annual variability of wet days anomaly over countries member states and entire pixels over the IGAD region. Generally, the results show, the IGAD region observed less than 10 days increase/decrease in wet days. Uganda and South Sudan as counties with the highest amount of total rainfall observed the highest number of wet days and highest(lowest) changes in wet days compared to other countries. MAM 2018 recorded extra-ordinary increased number of wet days over Kenya, Uganda, Somalia and South Sudan (Fig. 12a). MAM 1981 is the wettest (highest increased number of wet days) in the last 40 years over Kenya. In recent years (2011–2020), the JJA over Uganda recorded yearly variation in wet days patterns with 2021 recorded the highest decrease in wet days. the decreased rainfall patterns in 1980 and 1990s over Uganda, South Sudan, Ethiopia, Eritrea and Somalia due to decreased JJA wet days (Fig. 12b). The OND 1997 and 2019 are the most recorded extra-ordinary increased wet days in the last 40 years over Somalia, Ethiopia, Kenya and Eritrea (Fig. 12c). The year 1993 over Uganda recorded the highest decrease in wet days in the records of the last 40 years. The wet days patterns played a significant role in increased/decreased total rainfall and changes in rainfall trends.