Chemical inhibition of PKG, proteases and calcium release all impair egress
To identify the molecular processes required for B. divergens egress, we used the flow cytometry-based egress assay to screen for compounds that inhibit 8-Br-cGMP-induced egress. The compounds were selected based on known egress inhibition in P. falciparum or T. gondii. BAPTA-AM, which chelates intracellular calcium, and Compound 1 (C1), an inhibitor of apicomplexan PKG, both inhibited 8-Br-cGMP induced egress (Fig. 1F). Inhibitors of serine proteases, including TPCK, TLCK and PMSF, reduced induced egress at similar concentrations to those that inhibit P. falciparum gametocyte egress, whereas inhibitors of other protease classes exhibit modest inhibition (< 20%) (Figure S1H)34–36. The short incubation time (15 min) may not identify inhibitors of certain proteases such as PfPMX/TgASP3 which act several hours prior to egress. Inhibitors of the lipid signaling pathway that inhibit egress in T. gondii and/or P. falciparum, including U73122 and propranolol which target PI-PLC and phosphatidic acid phosphatase, respectively, did not influence egress by B. divergens, whereas the diacylglycerol kinase inhibitor R59022 instead enhanced induced egress (Figure S1H)27,29,37,38. In line with our flow cytometry assay, E64d treated parasites showed no obvious defect in egress, motility or invasion by video microscopy (Figure S1J). Taken together, these data demonstrate a requirement for cGMP signaling, calcium signaling (both intracellular and extracellular), serine proteases and gliding motility for efficient egress by B. divergens. Unlike in T. gondii, release of calcium with the ionophore A23187 does not induce egress or motility in B. divergens, suggesting calcium release is required, but not sufficient for egress. We note that a previous study found that A23187 could induce egress in B. bovis which could be due to differences between species, host cells, or technical such as the extracellular concentration of calcium39.
Motility is required for B. divergens merozoites to egress from permeabilized RBCs but not for permeabilization
The initial deformation of the RBC in egress appears to be caused by direct contact with the parasite indicating the parasites actinomyosin motor may be used to physically disrupt the host membrane (Fig. 1B)16. To test if motility is required during egress, egress was induced with 8-Br-cGMP in the presence of phalloidin-Alexa Fluor 488, which selectively stains the cytoskeletons of permeabilized RBCs, and cytochalasin D, which inhibits actin polymerization and gliding motility. Cytochalasin D-treated parasites can be induced to lyse the host cell, but do not escape the permeabilized cell (Fig. 1G-H, Video S2). Immediately preceding egress, the host cell becomes ruffled, but no localized deformation is observed, followed by the RBC rapidly showing a reduced diameter, becoming round and being infiltrated by phalloidin, demonstrating the RBC membrane has been permeabilized (Fig. 1H, Video S2). T. gondii secreted lytic factors (e.g. PLP1) and host calpains damage the host cell, allowing the motile parasite to escape the permeabilized cell27,40,41. The mechanisms of RBC lysis in asexual Plasmodium spp. remain unclear42,43. B. bovis PLP1 is not strictly required for egress, however, its absence does lead to continued intracellular replication (4 parasites per cell instead of 2 which is typical of B. bovis), suggestive of a partial egress defect44. In contrast to P. falciparum which fractures the RBC cytoskeleton during egress (Figure S1I)45, the permeabilized RBC remains relatively intact throughout egress in B. divergens (Figs. 1B-C, 1G-H)16. P. falciparum secretes proteases (SERA6) which degrade the RBC cytoskeleton, leading to the to rupture of the RBC to release free merozoites, thus bypassing the requirement for gliding motility in egress17,46,47. Consistent with this difference, Babesia spp. do not have an ortholog of any SERA protease nor an ortholog of the phospholipase TgLCAT/PbPL. Taken together, these data argue for a mechanism of host cell lysis in B. divergens relying centrally on secretion of lytic factors (e.g PLPs). While, we do not observe a requirement for parasite motility for host cell lysis, we cannot rule out that motility contributes towards cell lysis as has been observed in T. gondii40.
Identification of putative egress, motility and invasion genes through transcriptomic analyses
The lytic cycle of B. divergens has been morphologically defined but remains poorly characterized at the molecular level in any Babesia spp.5 There are several Babesia spp. transcriptomes at different stages of the life cycle, however, there are no synchronous intraerythrocytic stage time course transcriptomes48–52. We generated a synchronous bulk transcriptome of one replication cycle (0–12 hrs) for B. divergens. As a parallel strategy, we utilized a recent asynchronous single-cell transcriptome where expression profiles of individual genes were generated using a pseudo-time analysis with the start of gene expression identified by cross-correlation analysis between the bulk and single-cell expression curves53. Genes that showed expression changes over time display a transcriptional cascade associated with “just-in-time” gene expression that has been observed in Plasmodium spp. and T. gondii (Figs. 2A and S2A)54,55. The number of genes detected and that display significant changes over time for each method can be found in Fig. 2B. The timing of peak expression between the bulk and single-cell transcriptomes was well correlated for the majority of genes, supporting the use of the pseudo-time data for downstream analysis (Fig. 2D).
93 B. divergens genes were identified as orthologs or family members of known egress, motility or invasion genes we have collated for apicomplexan parasites. 91 of these genes are expressed in in vitro culture and 67 showed expression changes over time (Table S1). Genes that are expected to co-localize within the same subcellular compartment (e.g. micronemes) based on orthology display similar expression profiles as has been observed in Plasmodium spp. and T. gondii (Figs. 2C and S2B)54,56,57. Secondary messenger-responsive proteins, including PKG, PKAc1, PKAr, and CDPK4 (PfCDPK4/TgCDPK3) peak ~ 8–10 hours post invasion (hpi) and remain high until 12 hpi when parasites naturally egress (Figs. 2C). Other putative members of the egress signaling pathway did not display stage-specific expression indicative of a role in egress or invasion (Table S1). The cysteine and aspartyl proteases, DPAP1 (no direct ortholog) and ASP3 (ortholog of PfPMX/TgASP3), respectively, display expression profiles matching that of microneme proteins (Figs. 2C). The aspartyl protease ASP2 (closely related to BdASP3) displays an expression profile matching rhoptry proteins (Figs. 2C). All nine B. divergens PLP genes are expressed (Data not shown). We found that only PLP1 (TgPLP1/PfPLP3) and PLP4 (no direct ortholog) display an expression profile matching other microneme and rhoptry proteins, respectively, suggestive of a role in egress and invasion or post-invasion PV breakdown, respectively (Figs. 2C).
Multiple invasion ligands were identified by orthology to known apicomplexan ligands and display expression profiles matching that of rhoptry or microneme proteins (Figs. 2E). These included TRAP2/P18, RAP1 and AMA1, which all have a demonstrated role in Babesia spp. invasion (Fig. 2C)58–60. The B. divergens orthologs of the Plasmodium spp. or T. gondii rhoptry protein, SRA, and microneme proteins, CLAMP, GAMA, MAEBL and CelTOS represent novel vaccine targets that have not been investigated in Babesia spp.61–65 Inner membrane complex (IMC) proteins, which are involved in cell structure and motility, are transcribed in three groups (Figure S2B), suggesting that IMC assembly with distinct profiles warrants future study.
A comparative transcriptomic approach using data from P. falciparum and T. gondii was used to identify novel proteins putatively involved in egress, motility or invasion (methods outlined in Figure S2C). 104 genes were identified, 31 of which were identified by multiple methods and whose orthologs have no known function (Figs. 2E; Table S1). Of the 8 genes found in all three species, 5 have a growth phenotype in the T. gondii CRISPR screen and the P. falciparum piggyBac screen (Table S1).
A genetic screen of high priority candidates reveals the essentiality of PKG, CDPK4, ASP2 and ASP3 for parasite proliferation
We focused on 11 high priority candidates based on transcriptomics as well as orthology to apicomplexan egress genes, including the kinases, PKG, PKAc1, PKAc2, CDPK4, CDPK5 and CDPK7, the perforin-like proteins, PLP1 and PLP4, and the proteases, ASP2, ASP3 and DPAP1. PKG is conserved between B. divergens, P. falciparum and T. gondii and has a well-characterized role in egress and invasion in these latter species66,67. PKAc1 suppresses egress in T. gondii but is instead required for invasion by P. falciparum10,12,68−71. The CDPK family of proteins are also required for P. falciparum and T. gondii egress and invasion, although the direct orthologs (defined by reciprocal blast) do not always have the same function between species (Reviewed in72,73). PLPs are involved in host cell permeabilization and egress in T. gondii, Plasmodium spp. sexual stages and B. bovis40,44,74−76. PfDPAP family members and BdASP2/ASP3 orthologs (PfPMX, PfPMIX and TgASP3) are required for egress and/or invasion in P. falciparum or T. gondii77–82.
To develop a stable transfection system for B. divergens, multiple transfection methods and selection drugs with established resistance markers were tested for stable transfection of a GFP reporter plasmid (Figure S3A and C) (summarized in Table S2). Nucleofection of isolated merozoites and blasticidin-S selection was the most efficient method and was used for all further transfections. A CRISPR/Cas9 system was generated to introduce a HA tag, as well as the glmS riboswitch with and without a destabilization domain (DD) inducible knockdown system in series to the 3’ end of each gene (Figs. 3A and S3B)83,84. Parasites containing the correct integration reached > 1% parasitemia 12–16 days after transfection for all constructs, except PKAc1, PLP1 and PLP4 which we were unable to tag (Figure S3F and H). PKG-HA-DD-glmS parasites were initially used to determine the effectiveness of the knockdown systems. Induction of the DD system, which induces protein degradation, generated a more rapid (~ 6 hrs) and stronger reduction of protein levels than the glmS system (Fig. 3B). The glmS system, which destabilizes mRNA, resulted in slower knockdown that was first observable by 24 hrs, but generated strong knockdown by 48 hrs (Fig. 3B). Combining both systems resulted in a stronger knockdown than either alone (Fig. 3B). This pattern was reflected in the effect of these knockdown systems on parasite growth when targeting PKG, CDPK4, ASP2 or ASP3, with the double knockdown producing the strongest defect in all lines, whereas the DD or glmS alone were not sufficient for all genes (Fig. 3D). DPAP1, PKAc2, CDPK5 and CDPK7 knockdown did not affect proliferation (Fig. 3D, data not shown).
PKG and CDPK4 are essential for egress and their depletion results in continued intracellular replication
We analyzed knockdowns of PKG and CDPK4 following synchronized invasion to understand when the block in proliferation occurs. PKG or CDPK4 knockdown parasites continued to replicate within a single iRBC, to form up to 16 parasites per RBC by 40 hpi (Figs. 3C-E and S3I). The fraction of parasites that replicate to > 4 per iRBC is dependent on the degree of knockdown (Fig. 3E). Knockdown of PKG prevented induced egress by 8-Br-cGMP, further supporting that 8-Br-cGMP induces egress through activation of PKG (Figure S3D). The reduced susceptibility to 8-Br-cGMP mediated induced egress in PKG-HA-DD-glmS parasites without inducing knockdown compared to WT parasites is likely due to a partial knockdown in the absence of induction, due to tagging as observed in other parasite recombinants (Figure S3D)85,86. A model of the molecular pathways involved in B. divergens egress can be found in Fig. 3F.
The proteases ASP2 and ASP3 are required for egress and invasion
The orthologs of B. divergens ASP2 and ASP3 in P. falciparum (PfPMIX/PMX) and T. gondii (ASP3) are the most upstream proteases known to date in the protease cascade that matures many proteins in the micronemes and rhoptries that are required for egress and invasion80,81. ASP2 and ASP3 knockdown resulted in an increased number of free merozoites in culture (Fig. 3D). In the ASP3 knockdown culture, clusters of parasites were also observed in lightly stained RBCs (Fig. 3C, ASP3 left panel). To further define these phenotypes, induced egress in knockdown parasites was observed by video microscopy. The time to egress and rate of escape from the lysed cells was the same between ASP2 knockdown and WT parasites (Fig. 4A, B and E). After egress, ASP2 parasites typically bound to a single RBC and were able to strongly deform it (pre-invasion) similar to WT, however, were unable to complete invasion and eventually detached from the cell (Figs. 4C-E; Video S5). The time from initial deformation of the RBC by the intracellular ASP3 knockdown parasite to the time of lysis of the RBC was significantly longer than in WT parasites and fewer parasites were able to escape the lysed RBC (Figs. 4A-B, F-G). Fewer ASP3 knockdown parasites were able to escape the lysed cell, and parasites that successfully egressed were able to bind to and deform the RBC, however, unlike WT or ASP2 knockdown parasites that typically bind strongly to a single host cell, ASP3 parasites maintained gliding motility over the surface of the cell, often contacting multiple host cells, but were rarely able to complete invasion (Fig. 4B-D, 4F-G; Video S6). Together, these results are consistent with the transcriptomic data suggesting ASP2 functions in the rhoptries and knockdown parasites are able to reorient but are not able to undergo the final step of invasion which requires rhoptry proteins87–89. The ASP3 phenotype suggests that it is required for maturation of microneme proteins that are required for RBC lysis and reorientation and/or anchoring of the apical end of the parasite to the RBC prior to rhoptry release21,23. In comparison to T. gondii, which requires only TgASP3 to process proteins in the rhoptries and micronemes, our data suggest that BdASP2 and BdASP3 are functionally orthologous to PfPMIX and PfPMX, respectively, and likely responsible for processing proteins required for invasion in the rhoptries, and egress and invasion in the micronemes, respectively.
PKG, ASP2 and ASP3 are druggable targets required for egress and/or invasion
Significant effort has been invested to develop specific inhibitors of apicomplexan PKG, CDPKs and aspartyl proteases (PfPMIX, PfPMX and TgASP3) (reviewed in90–94). To demonstrate that PKG is a druggable target in B. divergens we used the apicomplexan PKG inhibitors compound 1 (C1), and ML10 a potent and highly specific P. falciparum PKG inhibitor with in vivo activity95,96. To determine the specificity of C1 and ML10 for BdPKG, CRISPR/Cas9 was used to introduce a putative resistance mutation (T651Q) equivalent to the gatekeeper mutations that confer resistance in P. falciparum and T. gondii (Fig. 5A)67,97. A 500 bp region within a plasmid was used as a repair template, achieving ~ 50% editing, with decreasing efficiency further from the cut site (Figure S3E and F). We utilized the ability to perform sequential transfection with the same resistance marker to generate double mutants, containing the T651Q mutation and the glmS knockdown system. Treatment of WT parasites with C1 or ML10 resulted in the same continued intracellular replication as was observed with PKG knockdown (Fig. 5B). The potency of C1 and ML10 against B. divergens is ~ 25-fold and 281-fold less than against P. falciparum, and 4.4- and 8.4-fold less than against B. bovis 66,96,98,99. A 3- and 10-fold for C1, and 15- and 8-fold for ML10, reduction in the IC50 was observed between WT compared to PKG-glmS parasites with or without knockdown, respectively (Figs. 5C-D). A trending, but not statistically significant shift in the IC50 was observed between WT and the PKG-T651Q parasites (10.5 vs 14.1 µM for C1, and 591 nM vs 1209 nM for ML10), whereas the same mutation in knockdown parasites restores susceptibility to near WT levels (Figs. 5C-D). Together these results support a model in which C1 and ML10 are able to target PKG, however, at concentrations required for killing B. divergens there are secondary targets contributing to growth inhibition, which is likely to be CDPK4 that is the only other CDPK to share the same small gatekeeper residue as PKG (Figure S3G). The ability to rapidly and specifically inhibit PKG with C1 when combined with partial knockdown was used to investigate the role of PKG during RBC invasion. PKG knockdown increased the sensitivity to C1 invasion inhibition by 20-fold (Fig. 5E), suggesting PKG signaling is also required for host cell invasion.
To determine the druggability of ASP2 and ASP3, we screened 22 aspartyl protease inhibitors, including compounds known to be active against P. falciparum PfPMIX and PfPMX as well as clinical inhibitors of human beta-secretase, against WT and knockdown parasite lines (Figure S4)81,100−103. 14 compounds displayed an IC50 < 25 µM, with the most potent compound (TCMDC-134675) having an IC50 of 891 nM against WT parasites (Fig. 5G and Table 1)81,103. We observe a 2.7-fold and 3.6-fold increase in sensitivity to TCMDC-134675 in ASP2 and ASP3 knockdown parasites, respectively. CWHM-0000166 was less active against WT parasites (8.8 µM), but displayed the largest increase in sensitivity of 7.7-fold and 26-fold against ASP2 and ASP3 knockdown parasites, respectively (Fig. 5F). In P. falciparum, incomplete PMX inhibition results in parasites lysing the PVM, whereas complete inhibition blocked PVM rupture80,104. To determine if the phenotype observed in ASP3 knockdown parasites was incomplete, we combined knockdown with CWHM-0000166 treatment. Under these conditions we observed that parasites continued to replicate intracellularly, as was observed with inhibition of PKG and CDPK4, further supporting a role of ASP3 in egress (Fig. 5B). We also observed clusters of parasites within a lysed RBC, in line with the live microscopy results that parasites that do lyse the host cell escape at a reduced rate. The similar phenotype seen following inhibition of ASP3 to the protein kinases CDPK4 and PKG, suggests that failure to egress by multiple mechanisms results in a default for continuation of the intracellular lytic cycle. No synergy was observed between ASP2 or ASP3 knockdown and ML10, suggesting the kinase and protease egress pathways act independently. Together these data demonstrate that PKG, ASP2 and ASP3 are essential and druggable proteins in B. divergens that are required for egress and/or invasion.
Table 1
IC50 values of Aspartyl protease inhibitors against B. divergens. IC50 (± S.D.)
| Wild-type | ASP2 (High Shld1) | ASP2 (Low Shld1 = Knockdown) | ASP3 (High Shld1) | ASP3- (Low Shld1 = knockdown) |
TCMDC-134675 | 0.891 (± 0.307) | 0.320 (± 0.212) | 0.478 (± 0.288) | 0.362 (± 0.129) | 0.246 (± 0.095) |
TCMDC-136879 | 4.03 (± 1.90) | 1.57 (± 0.17) | 1.63 (± 0.94) | 1.39 (± 0.26) | 0.539 (± 0.358) |
CWHM-0000099 | > 25 | 11.8 (± 0.8) | 3.99 (± 3.15) | 16.3 (± 3.7) | 2.85 (± 1.52) |
CWHM-0000117 | 6.81 (± 3.08) | 2.66 (± 0.55) | 2.56 (± 1.32) | 3.17 (± 0.61) | 1.13 (± 0.50) |
CWHM-0000166 | 8.80 (± 3.18) | 2.89 (± 1.27) | 1.15 (± 0.70) | 2.76 (± 0.96) | 0.337 (± 0.157) |
CWHM-0000047 | 19.5 (± 5.3) | 18.5 (± 12.9) | 6.32 (± 5.84) | 16.9 (± 9.0) | 8.47 (± 5.35) |
CWHM-0000579 | 12.6 (± 6.6) | 7.49 (± 4.73) | 11.1 (± 6.5) | 9.12 (± 6.12) | 7.32 (± 6.48) |
CWHM-0000162 | 13.3 (± 9.4) | 7.15 (± 6.45) | 6.47 (± 5.35) | 8.00 (± 5.06) | 6.41 (± 6.74) |
lanabecestat | 19.8 (± 5.3) | 10.1 (± 3.4) | 4.67 (± 3.06) | 14.1 (± 2.6) | 10.0 (± 5.4) |
verubecestat | 10.9 (± 3.3) | 6.38 (± 3.27) | 1.89 (± 2.78) | 8.04 (± 3.36) | 5.49 (± 4.29) |
CWHM-0000068 | 16.6 (± 7.6) | 15.7 (± 12.6) | 8.02 (± 0.89) | 13.3 (± 2.9) | 9.88 (± 4.84) |
CWHM-0000116 | > 25 | > 25 | 18.8 (± 8.2) | 20.3 (± 11.3) | 21.4 (± 10.2) |
CWHM-0000123 | 9.46 (± 3.66) | 8.39 (± 4.39) | 10.8 (± 2.8) | 11.2 (± 8.7) | 9.22 (± 1.76) |
CWHM-0000293 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 |
CWHM-0000299 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 |
CWHM-0000460 | > 25 | 12.3 (± 10.2) | 12.2 (± 1.5) | 12.4 (± 5.6) | 12.6 (± 4.0) |
CWHM-0000580 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 | > 25 |
CWHM-0000583 | > 25 | 14.2 (± 9.5) | 14.5 (± 8.9) | 13.8 (± 5.1) | 14.1 (± 6.9) |
CWHM-0000658 | 16.2 (± 9.8) | 12.6 (± 11.9) | 6.47 (± 3.82) | 9.35 (± 3.77) | 7.82 (± 5.45) |
AZD3839 | 25.7 (± 12.3) | 15.8 (± 9.6) | 8.64 (± 4.98) | 15.8 (± 3.6) | 18.6 (± 13.4) |
LY2811376 | 24.2 (± 10.7) | 6.37 (± 3.46) | 2.57 (± 2.67) | 13.4 (± 7.2) | 12.1 (± 8.2) |
LY2886721 | 18.5 (± 5.7) | 6.38 (± 3.72) | 5.76 (± 6.77) | 9.62 (± 4.22) | 9.30 (± 6.24) |
ML10 | 0.864 (± 0.319) | 0.794 (± 0.072) | 1.56 (± 1.24) | 0.682 (± 0.256) | 0.628 (± 0.219) |
Atovaquone | 0.021 (± 0.007) | 0.020 (± 0.005) | 0.020 (± 0.008) | 0.021 (± 0.006) | 0.025 (± 0.011) |