Population census of Mellegue catchment
The following figures (Figs. 2, 3 and 4) shows the evolution of the demographic population of the Mellegue catchment area which was calculated on the basis of Worldpop data program. Referring to these figures, we notice that there is an urban growth at the level of large cities such as Tebessa (Algeria) and Kef (Tunisia). The most condensed urban agglomeration is concentrated in Tebessa with more than 10 000 inhabitants/km (Fig. 4). We obviously observe a demographic increase on the Tunisian-Algerian border marked by the birth of new urban agglomerations near the region of Tajerouine (the governorate of Kef) with a demographic density lower than 1000 inhabitants/km. In addition, we observe a reduction in demographic occupancy rates in almost all urban areas that are part of Tunisian territory. The only exception lies in the city of Kef where we note that there is a demographic increase in the centre of the city resulting in 4,000 and up to 10000 inhabitants/km locally in 2020 against 2,000 inhabitants/km in 2002, which requires development and urban extension to retain this population growth. In addition, the Tunisian part was obviously marked by the installation of new urban areas manifested by low populations limited to 1000 inhabitants/km. The installation of these new agglomerations automatically implies a probable urban extension.
On the other hand, the Algerian part of the watershed shows a considerable increase in population density observed in several regions such as the city of Ouenza, Meskiana and Khenchela. The regions of Tebessa and M'Daourouch are the most affected by population growth where the demographic occupancy rate exceeds 10,000 inhabitants/km (Fig. 4). This shows that the Algerian part of the basin has experienced a more advanced demographic development compared to the Tunisian territory which seems to have a low growth rate.
A previous research study (Weslati et al. 2022) proofs an extension of more than 3000 hectares of urbanized areas on the study area during 2002–2021. The general census of the population of the Mellegue watershed (Figs. 2 and 3, Table 1) shows an estimated population increase of 241837 in 2020 compared to 2002 with an average annual growth rate of 1.19%. The population census by country within the basin confirms the previous conclusions where we observe demographic stability in Tunisia throughout this period. Again, the region shows in some years a considerable reduction in population (2018/-1875). On the other hand, the same graphs show a significant increase of the Algerian population where it annually exceeds 10 000 inhabitants/year. It should be noted that the Tunisian regions of the watershed (Governorate of Jendouba, Kef and Kasserine) are considered among the poorest governorates of the country. School drop-out and unemployment rates are the highest (Dhraief et al. 2020). The economic crisis and the absence of stable employment opportunities promotes the development of informal trades. All these factors have imposed a migration from these regions to the eastern coast because of the economic and social potentialities. The rate of migration was intensified considerably from 2011 (revolution) following socio-political crises of the state.
Table 1 Population Census in Mellegue Watershed from 2002 to 2020
Year
|
Total population in the Mellegue catchment
|
Rate of population growth (inhabitant)
|
Rate of population growth (%)
|
Tunisian population in the bassin
|
Rate of population growth (inhabitant)
|
Rate of population growth (%)
|
Algerian population in the bassin
|
Rate of population growth (inhabitant)
|
Rate of population growth (%)
|
2002
|
1 124 852
|
0
|
0,00%
|
331 869
|
0
|
0,00%
|
792 984
|
0
|
0,00%
|
2003
|
1 130 945
|
6093
|
0,54%
|
328 231
|
-3638
|
-1,10%
|
802 714
|
9731
|
1,23%
|
2004
|
1 142 782
|
11 837
|
1,05%
|
326 659
|
-1572
|
-0,48%
|
816 123
|
13 409
|
1,67%
|
2005
|
1 147 153
|
4370
|
0,38%
|
322 851
|
-3808
|
-1,17%
|
824 301
|
8178
|
1,00%
|
2006
|
1 159 648
|
12 495
|
1,09%
|
325 131
|
2279
|
0,71%
|
834 517
|
10 216
|
1,24%
|
2007
|
1 167 464
|
7816
|
0,67%
|
322 936
|
-2194
|
-0,67%
|
844 528
|
10 010
|
1,20%
|
2008
|
1 180 646
|
13 182
|
1,13%
|
321 788
|
-1148
|
-0,36%
|
858 858
|
14 330
|
1,70%
|
2009
|
1 209 711
|
29 064
|
2,46%
|
326 672
|
4883
|
1,52%
|
883 039
|
24 181
|
2,82%
|
2010
|
1 215 051
|
5340
|
0,44%
|
323 838
|
-2834
|
-0,87%
|
891 213
|
8174
|
0,93%
|
2011
|
1 235 205
|
20 154
|
1,66%
|
321 430
|
-2408
|
-0,74%
|
913 774
|
22 562
|
2,53%
|
2012
|
1 246 557
|
11 352
|
0,92%
|
321 472
|
41
|
0,01%
|
925 085
|
11 310
|
1,24%
|
2013
|
1 263 801
|
17 244
|
1,38%
|
322 442
|
970
|
0,30%
|
941 358
|
16 274
|
1,76%
|
2014
|
1 280 222
|
16 422
|
1,30%
|
321 964
|
-478
|
-0,15%
|
958 259
|
16 900
|
1,80%
|
2015
|
1 293 120
|
12 898
|
1,01%
|
321 036
|
-928
|
-0,29%
|
972 084
|
13 825
|
1,44%
|
2016
|
1 312 370
|
19 250
|
1,49%
|
323 685
|
2648
|
0,82%
|
988 685
|
16 601
|
1,71%
|
2017
|
1 326 584
|
14 214
|
1,08%
|
323 323
|
-362
|
-0,11%
|
1 003 261
|
14 576
|
1,47%
|
2018
|
1 339 768
|
13 184
|
0,99%
|
321 448
|
-1875
|
-0,58%
|
1 018 320
|
15 059
|
1,50%
|
2019
|
1 355 466
|
15 698
|
1,17%
|
324 229
|
2781
|
0,87%
|
1 031 237
|
12 917
|
1,27%
|
2020
|
1 366 689
|
11 223
|
0,83%
|
324 373
|
144
|
0,04%
|
1 042 316
|
11 079
|
1,07%
|
Total
|
1 366 689
|
241 837
|
21,50%
|
324 373
|
-7495
|
-2,26%
|
1 042 316
|
249 332
|
31,44%
|
Forest investigation
Forests are the concern of the whole world; they are threatened by irresponsible deforestation and fires. Figure 5 shows NDVI interpreted map based on Landsat images for 2002, 2012, 2018 and 2022. It clearly shows a net degradation of the forests especially in the downstream part of the watershed. Other additional studies (Weslati et al. 2022) have reported the loss of more 15 000 hectares of forests in the catchment of Mellegue during the period 2002–2021. This is explained by several effects; in Tunisia, the socio-political status of the country since 2011 (revolution) has seriously affected the forestry sector. Consequently, the deforestation index has increased, but it was not calculated in the latest FAO statistics due to these socio-economic problems. Still, more than 400,000 m3 of wood has been produced from Tunisian forests (Chriha and Sghari 2013). In return, deforestation in Algerian regions has also intensified, registering an increase from 11,000 ha/year in 2005 to more than 18,000 ha/year in 2018 (FAO 2015a; FAO 2015b).
Always coveted by the population, forest areas constitute a means of subsistence where various local daily activities are organized around them such as the production of charcoal, the collection of firewood or even artisanal wood and cork activities. Unfortunately, forests are still over-exploited causing considerable environmental and ecological degradation. In Tunisia, the exploitation of forest products is controlled and regulated through a specialized dedicated department of the Ministry of Agriculture. Figure 6 and Table 2 summarize a statistic of the number of forest offenses legally proceeded for twenty years (between 2001 and 2021) and which took place in the Tunisian part of the Mellegue watershed. They reveal that the number of fines in 2018 was multiplied five times compared to 2002 (51 in 2002 against 251 in 2018). It is also noted that the number of offenses during the first decade (from 2001 to 2010) is almost stable. The turning point was 2011 following the socio-political unrest that lasted throughout the year. At that time, the state lost much of its authority where only 25 offenses were written and which required a serious intervention of the army to struggle against these acts of ecological degradation. Since then, even if the state has restored its control, the number of reported offenses has continued to increase, exceeding 350 fines in 2021 compared to only 63 in 2001.
Secondly, fires remain by far the primary threat due to their ability to quickly ravage large areas. According to the results of the historical fires from the MODIS and VIIRS sensors (Fig. 7 and Table 2), the impact of the fires seriously affected the vegetation in the Mellegue catchment. The number of fires increased tragically during the second decade (2011–2021) compared to the first (2002–2011). For example, the number of annual fires in 2013 is almost equal to the sum of all the fires recorded during the first decade (2002–2011) with a total of 144 fires.
Table 2
Statistics of fires number occurring in the catchment of Mellegue forests during the period 2002–2021
Year
|
Algeria
|
Tunisia
|
Total
|
2002
|
1
|
0
|
1
|
2003
|
6
|
3
|
9
|
2004
|
10
|
2
|
12
|
2005
|
14
|
3
|
17
|
2006
|
6
|
3
|
9
|
2007
|
6
|
6
|
12
|
2008
|
31
|
1
|
32
|
2009
|
23
|
3
|
26
|
2010
|
10
|
1
|
11
|
2011
|
13
|
2
|
15
|
2012
|
33
|
57
|
90
|
2013
|
27
|
29
|
56
|
2014
|
50
|
165
|
215
|
2015
|
13
|
65
|
78
|
2016
|
47
|
86
|
133
|
2017
|
29
|
109
|
138
|
2018
|
19
|
18
|
37
|
2019
|
49
|
63
|
112
|
2020
|
24
|
69
|
93
|
2021
|
64
|
57
|
121
|
However, the thorough evaluation of this figure allowed to classify the number of fires by country. The socio-political instability of Tunisia since 2011 has impacted the vegetative spaces. From 2012, the number of fires begins to increase intensely compared to the antecedent years. The record took place in 2014 with 215 fires in the entire basin where 80% of them (169 fires) are started in Tunisia. During this year, a record was reached in terms of burned areas, indicating more than 6000 ha of land that were invaded by these fires (Fig. 8). According to these results, it can be seen that the period between 2012 and 2014 led to an unprecedented resurgence of forest fires where Tunisia was punctuated by multiple political, terrorist and social crises. Although the state has regained its power where a certain stability has been felt, leading to a drop in the number of fires, especially in 2018 (37 in total with 18 in Tunisia), the values remain high compared to the first period (2002–2011). Over the entire basin, the sum of the fires accumulated in the second decade (2012–2021) is equal to 1073 where 718 of these fires are initiated in Tunisia against 355 in Algeria. The number is multiplied 10 times compared to the period 2002–2011 with only 144 fires (24 fires in Tunisia and 120 in Algeria) reported in the entire basin.
The Algerian territory recorded rhythmic fires with a slight increase compared to the first decade. The political instability of Tunisia may have affected the neighbouring forest areas of Algeria. Some fires were deliberately started in Tunisia and invaded the Algerian forests (or vice versa.). Forest areas are always exposed to climate change, especially during years of drought, but significantly to anthropogenic actions. In conclusion, the forests of the Mellegue watershed have been the victim of large-scale degradation. For example, since 2011, more than 1 000 ha of the forests of the Djebel Ouergha mountain under the delegation of Sakiet Sidi Youssef have been devastated by fires following anthropogenic, climatic and terrorist actions (Fig. 9).
Deep water analysis and quantification
In-depth analysis prove that water resources of the basin are seriously threatened. To begin with, the area witnessed an expansion of agricultural land and has thus led to an increase in water requirements for irrigation. In Algeria, more than 500 000 ha were added to agricultural land in 2014 compared to 1994 (Harbouze et al. 2019). Consequently, the consumption of surface or deep water has reached a very high threshold. To compensate this excessive demand for water, the number of dams has increased from 44 with a storage capacity of 3.3 billion m3 in 1994 to 100 dams in 2016 with a mobile water storage of 12 billion m3. Half of this water is dedicated to agricultural irrigation (6 billion m3). As a result, the area of irrigated land increased from 350 000 ha in 2000 to 1.3 million ha in 2017 (Harbouze et al. 2019). On the other hand, it should be noted that Tunisia suffers from a shortage of water due to the reduction in lakes and surface reservoirs following the intensification of the arid climate. The area of irrigated land has increased from 380 000 ha in 2001 to 460 000 ha in 2010, which has resulted to an increase in the need for water resources for irrigation (Chebbi et al. 2019). In addition, Tunisian regions of the basin are mainly based on agriculture and associated activities. For example, 25% of the population of the governorate of Kef is absorbed by the agronomic sector where the agricultural area occupies almost 70% of the region total area. Cereal farming is the main activity with 43% of the occupation rate compared to the total surface of the governorate. The installation of several irrigated areas and wells has enabled the development of the cereal sector and plant nurseries. In 2017, the governorate of Kef disposed already 43 000 hectares of irrigated areas compared to 10 000 hectares in 2005 (Samaali and Mjejra 2020). In addition, the Tunisian ministry of agriculture announces the installation of a new irrigated areas with an estimated surface area of 2000 hectares which will be supplied with water from the new Mellegue 2 dam. As for Jendouba (outlet of the catchment), it participates in the national production of various products, particularly in cereal production and market gardening where it also has more than 40 000 hectares of irrigated areas (Chebbi et al. 2019). The Algerian territory of the catchment also invests in the agricultural sector. The region of Tebessa is largely based on agriculture, it has nearly 20 000 hectares of irrigated perimeters. The governorate announced in 2014 a deduction of a new irrigated area exceeding 30 000 hectares. The new area will be fed by the Ouldjet Mellegue dam and two small dams planned at Ferkane and Ouenza (Azzeddine 2011). These facts have led to an excessive use of shallow and deep waters, which has modified the natural characteristics of water cycles and resulted in a significant degradation of the quality of these waters mainly by salinization (Chebbi et al. 2019; Laajimi 2011).
The geographical location, as well as the climatic characteristics, classify Tunisia and Algeria under high-water stressed areas (500 m3/inhabitant/year) (Hofste et al. 2019). It can also be expected that the demand for the supply of water resources will be intensified in proportion to the current population growth. Mellegue dam in situated in the downhill of the catchment, in El-kef near the outlet. The location of the dam made it possible to supply the approximate towns with drinking water and be used for irrigation. However, in recent years, the dam has suffered a sharp decrease in its waters. Figure 10 shows an NDWI-based comparison of the dam’s water between 2002, 2012 and 2022. A serious quantitative drop in the water resources of the dam can be clearly be notified. Figure 11, followed by Table 3 illustrates the difference in the contour of the water retention of the dam in 2002 compared to 2022 which clearly proves the decrease in the water reserves of the dam. Indeed, the area of the dam changed from 600 ha in 2002 to 320 ha in 2012 until reaching 242 ha in 2022, while the perimeter of water retention decreased from 55.5 km in 2002 to 19.8 km and 16.6 km for 2012 and 2022 respectively.
The natural muddy flows of the main river have caused the siltation of more than half of the dam storage. Some study claimed that the dam would be completely silted up by 2025 (Cherni et al. 2010). The water become too salty reaching 10 g/l. Another ancillary study reported that the dam's water storage is actually around 5 million m3 where they recorded more than 68 million m3 in 2002 (Weslati et al. 2020). In fact, this decrease was partially due to squandering of the dam's water resources for the irrigation and drinking water, dropping from 292 million m3 in 2002 to less than 6 million m3 actually.
Table 3
Water storage contrast in the Mellegue dam for 2002, 2012 and 2022
Date of observation
|
December-2002
|
December-2012
|
December-2022
|
Instrument
|
Landsat ETM+
|
Landsat ETM+
|
Landsat
OLI
|
Surface of water dam (hectare)
|
600
|
320
|
242
|
Perimeter of water dam (kilometre)
|
55.5
|
19.8
|
16.6
|
The approximate regions of the Mellegue dam are increasingly suffering from a shortage of water manifested by a disruption and a daily cut in the distribution of drinking water. Considerable efforts have been made to manage the surface waters of the basin; in 2016, the Tunisian state started construction work on the upper Mellegue dam. The reservoir of the dam has a surface of 1320 ha with a maximum reservoir capacity estimated at 195 million m3. The average annual supply is estimated at 170 million m3, of which 87 million m3 of water will be transported to the Sidi Salem dam while the rest (76 million m3) will be mobilized for the existing perimeters (drinking water and irrigation) with 8.7 million m3/year dedicated to the creation of a new irrigated perimeter estimated with an area of 2000 ha. Works were also been carried out to fight against floods which frequently occur near the outlet of the Mellegue catchment (in the plain of Jendouba) as well as to produce electricity (Fehri 2014; Sahar et al. 2019; Université de Tokyo 2013). In return, the Algerian state completed the execution of the Ouldjet Mellegue dam in 2019. It is located upstream of the basin, 15 km from the city of Ouenza and 75 km from Tebessa. The maximum capacity of the reservoir is estimated at 156 million m3. The development of the dam is intended for the mobilization of water from the main river where approximately 130,000 inhabitants of neighbouring municipalities will be supplied with reservoir water. Part of the dam’s water is also planned to meet the needs of the phosphate complex installed in the town of Oued Kerbrit. Similarly, the objective of the development of the dam is envisioned to meet the irrigation water needs of agricultural land in the region of Ouenza.
The geographical location of Tunisia classifies it as a country with an arid to semi-arid climate over almost all of its surface with low to medium rainfall. Indeed, Tunisia has a low volume of available water estimated at 500 m3/inhabitant. A rate that ranks the country among the regions with high water stress (Solanke et al. 2005). Again, these water resources are poorly distributed where northern of Tunisia is responsible for generating 80% of water surface and 60% of the overall water contribution to the country (Cherif 2003). The arid to semi-arid climate has aggravated the situation due to the inter-annual variability of rainfall which generally brings low precipitation rates.
Secondly, the average water consumption for Tunisia is estimated at 70 litres per resident per day in urban areas compared to 50 litres per resident per day in rural areas (WMC and TAP 2019). The forecast of future water consumption for Tunisia tends to double around the 2050 horizon, estimated at 140 litres per inhabitant per day in urban areas against 100 litres per resident per day in rural areas (WMC and TAP 2019). The expansion of urban areas in the watershed of the Mellegue will necessarily cause an increase in water consumption, amplifying the pressure on water resources which requires recovery and management actions integrating not only this basin but all the watersheds of Tunisia.
Despite a narrow surface area and rigid climatic factors, Tunisia claims a considerable potential in thermo-mineral water. The bottled water market in Tunisia is growing steadily. In one decade, consumption has increased from 290 million litres in 2000 to 900 million litres in 2009, reaching 2.7 billion litres in 2020. These statistics rank Tunisians among the biggest consumers of mineral water in the world (4th rank according to (research and markets 2022) To meet daily needs, there has been an increase in the number of production units. Currently, 29 units are installed in 12 governorates producing more than 364 000 bottles per hour. The number of units was expanded 4 times compared to 1994 with only 7 packing plants (Oueslati 2021).
In this context, the packaging of bottles of mineral water is done in and near the watershed of the Mellegue thanks to an aquifer located on its NW edge. In this part, there are three mineral water conditioning plants (figure). Two factories belonging to the same company group (SOSTEM) dating from 1968 (Safia Aïn Mizeb) and 1989 (Safia Aïn Ksiba) for the packaging of mineral water from a limestone aquifer of Ypresian age (brand “Safia”). The group's statistics confirm an increase in production resulting in 130 million bottles in 2021 compared to 68 million bottles in 2006 from the Aïn Mizeb source (Fig. 13). The second unit (Aïn Ksiba) confirms an annual production of 223 million bottles in 2021 compared to 147 million bottles in 2013 (Fig. 13). This will most likely lead to a depletion of deep-water resources in the region. The parent company has been carrying out exploration work on other wells for years. Currently, it has several boreholes to supply their production units. The depletion of the aquifer's water resources intensifies when a third unit based in the city of Tajerouine was installed to exploit the waters of a sand-gravel aquifer of Mio-Pliocene age, dedicated for conditioning brand bottled mineral water (brand “Dima”). The factory was installed in 2009 with a production capacity rate of 40 000 bottles per hour.
The results of the variation of the surface and subsurface waters of the basin were interpreted by GRACE and GRACE-FO satellite data. According to these results illustrated in Fig. 14, we notice the existence of two methods from the JPL (red) and CSR (orange) labs to which is associated a curve representing the arithmetic mean of the two methods (blue). However, there is a slight difference between the two applied methods (JPL and CSR). The results of the JPL lab show a weak to stable variation in the period 2002–2010. From 2011, the decline increases continuously until reaching in 2021 a reduction of -20 cm in equivalent water depth.
CSR's research centre results follow almost the same pattern of JPL during the first period (2002–2010) with a slight variation. The difference stands out in the second period (2011–2021) where the decrease is less pronounced. The general trend of the curve indicates a reduction in resources intercepted by a few recharge periods. The general balance of the CSR curve shows a reduction of about − 10 cm in water equivalent thickness during the period of 2002–2021.
From the average of these two results (blue), it can be seen that the behaviour of the equivalent water thickness was influenced by two different periods. The first period (2002–2010) was marked by a certain stability manifested by repetitive recharge periods where peaks exceeding + 5 cm in equivalent water thickness are often observed. From 2011, these peaks are no longer observed throughout the following period. There is a continuing and deeper decline. The recharge periods are not very spread out and of very short duration. With the exception of the event that took place in March 2012, all recharge periods observed barely crossed the bar of + 0 cm of equivalent water thickness.
It can be seen that the resources of the basin are overexploited in the second decade (2011–2021) where the trend curve (black) shows a decreasing with continuous pace, which can be linked to the socio-political events in Tunisia dating from 2011 so far. If we take the results of the trend curve interpreted annually on the average of the results of the two research centres (JPL and CSR), we deduce a reduction of about − 16 cm in equivalent thickness water where it has been intensely declined during the period 2011–2021. Total estimates claim an overall exploitation of approximately 1.7 billion m3 of the water resources of the basin (surface and deep).
Based on all these points, it is clear that the state of water resources in the Mellegue watershed is alarming mainly due to the excessive and anarchic consumption of water resources for the different sectors (irrigation, industry, sanitation, drinking water) and which intensified especially in Tunisia from 2011.
In order to monitor the groundwater reserves of the Mellegue watershed, GLDAS data provided by NASA made it possible to quantify the volume of groundwater throughout the entire basin. The data available is from 2003 to the present. The general situation shows a decrease in the available volume (Figs. 15 and 16) starting from an initial volume estimated at 11.7 billion m3 in 2003 to 9.5 billion m3 by the end of 2021. On the basis of these estimates, we deduce an approximate consumption of two billion m3 of water resources throughout the period, which coincides with the previous results confirmed by the GRACE data. Consequently, the annual balance sheet shows an average consumption of 120 million m3 per year. This work also shows that the Tunisian water reserves constitute about 50% of the total volume found in the basin. This implies that there has been an overexploitation of these waters, linked to strong demographic pressure and agricultural activities, which has caused a drop in the amount of available basin water.
The uncertainties associated with the input variables have repercussions, in terms of indeterminacy, on the results, whose conclusions stated above remain significant. However, it is necessary to implement deeper studies within the basin for a detailed assessment of water resources (deep and surface) for sustainable management. This requires a study of the mechanisms responsible for the quantitative and qualitative degradation of water. Knowing that good management requires a detailed understanding of the basin, requested in particular for similar regions characterized by an arid climate where the rainfall deficit weighs on the recharge of the aquifers.