This was the first study to analyze the trends of EoL care aggressiveness in patients with stage IV cancer using national data. Over the study period, we found an overall decrease in the aggressiveness of EoL care in patients with stage IV cancer. This may be related to the increase in the number of hospice institutions and beds in Korea and the increase in public awareness of hospice and EoL care between 2012 and 2018. According to a recent report by the MoHW and the National Hospice Center (NHC), the number of hospice institutions in Korea increased from 56 in 2012 to 158 in 2018, and the number of hospice beds increased steadily from 893 to 1,542. In addition, the hospice use rate of cancer patients also showed a steady increase from 11.9% in 2012 to 22.9% in 2018, which is consistent with the increase in inpatient hospice use found in this study [10]. According to another report by the MoHW and NHC, public awareness of hospice or palliative care increased from 71.6% in 2012 to 92.4% in 2018 [21, 22].
Over the years during the study period, the rates of receiving chemotherapy, ICU admission, and CPR decreased, inpatient hospice use increased, and late hospice admission decreased. Similar patterns of aggressive EoL care were observed in studies with Korean pediatric patients [15] and Qatari patients who died between 2009 and 2013 [23]. These results are contrary to studies showing an increase in aggressive care provided in the United States [16], Canada [17], and Taiwan [24] between the mid-1990s and early 2000s.
Among the indicators, the proportion of ER visits more than twice in the last month of life did not show any significant change. Differences in predisposition may occur because ER visits are not always caused by cancer itself or by cancer-related complications but are influenced by comorbid conditions. As such, we found it to be less useful as an indicator of aggressive EoL care, similar to observations by Earle et al. [25].
In previous studies on the trend of aggressive care at the end of life, the related causes of increased aggressiveness in care included low hospice access and patients’ and families’ attitudes toward hospice care and chemotherapy [16]. In contrast, the Qatar study found that the opening of the palliative care unit and implementation of a do not attempt resuscitation (DNAR) policy were related to a decrease in aggressive care [23]. Similarly, a Korean study with children [15] described a decrease in aggressive care due to changes in attitude toward EoL. Another study also suggested that the Hospice-Palliative Care Act may be associated with an increased use of hospice services and a decrease in CPR in EoL [24]. Other studies [12, 15] suggested that changes in patients’ financial burden caused by changes in chemotherapy-related medical insurance policies led to changes in the aggressiveness of EoL care. In Korea, as health insurance was applied to hospice-palliative care in 2015, the financial burden of hospice use decreased, and the number of hospice institutions increased. This development in Korea’s hospice infrastructure and the change in attitude toward hospice and EoL care are thought to be related to the decrease in aggressive care found in this study.
We also found that patient factors such as age, sex, and institution of death, as well as disease characteristics such as cancer type were significant independent predictors of aggressive EoL care. Younger age was a significant independent predictor of aggressive EoL care, consistent with other studies [16, 17, 25]. This is thought to be because the younger the age, the higher the physical tolerability of the treatment, and the higher the expectations of patients, families, and physicians for a full recovery.
Our study also found female patients to receive more aggressive treatment such as chemotherapy, CPR, ER visits, and ICU admissions, while having a lower rate of hospice use, which was inconsistent with most other studies [16, 17, 25]. One study, however, reported higher rates of late-stage chemotherapy in female patients than in male patients [26].
Depending on the cancer type, hematologic malignancies are strongly associated with highly aggressive EoL care and low and late use of hospice care [25, 27]. This was also observed in our study, which is thought to be due to the characteristics of hematologic malignancy, such as a high frequency of hematologic complications and therapeutic optimism based on a plethora of treatment options, which is different from solid cancer [28].
Our findings indicated that receiving care at a tertiary referral hospital at the EoL results in more aggressive care than general hospitals or local clinics. This is consistent with what has been reported in other studies [16, 25]probably because tertiary hospitals are in an environment where active treatment is possible compared with other hospitals.
We performed a subgroup analysis to determine the status and trend of aggressive treatment according to the cancer type. All the five major cancer types showed a tendency toward decreasing EoL care aggressiveness. The proportion of patients receiving chemotherapy showed a steady decrease in all five major cancer types; however, in 2018, the rate of lung cancer patients receiving chemotherapy was higher than that of other cancers, which is related to the emergence of many new treatment options, such as targeted therapy and immunotherapy for lung cancer [29, 30]. However, for colorectal and gastric cancers, the rate of chemotherapy at the end of life was relatively low. This seems to be related to the limited treatment options because traditional cytotoxic chemotherapy is the mainstay of colorectal or gastric cancer treatment despite the development of targeted therapies [13, 31].
A limitation of our study is that several significant factors related to the use of aggressive care at EoL were not included. These factors include the patient’s performance status, comorbidities, awareness of disease status, patient preference for EoL care, and communication on EoL.
In conclusion, the EoL care aggressiveness of patients with stage IV cancer showed an overall tendency to decrease during the study period from 2012 to 2018 in Korea, among all five major cancer types. Further studies are needed to identify other factors related to EoL care aggressiveness, and to find out ways to effectively manage these factors to improve quality of life for advanced cancer patients.