The participant sample consisted of 15 CDOA over the age of 65 who volunteered to participate after reading the study description and consent form. CDOA were initially recruited through our community partner, a senior-serving non-profit organisation in the DTWE. Seven of the 15 older adults recruited identified themselves as members of the Lebian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ+) community and the majority (10 out of 15 participants) are ethnic minority older adults. The characteristics of the study participants are presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Demographic table of participants
Demographic Variable
|
Category
|
Frequency
|
Percent
|
Age
|
65-70
|
7
|
46.6
|
|
71-75
|
5
|
33.3
|
|
76-80
|
2
|
13.3
|
|
80+
|
1
|
6.6
|
Gender
|
Male
|
5
|
33.3
|
|
Female
|
10
|
66.6
|
Household Status
|
Living alone
|
14
|
93.3
|
|
Living with other family members
|
1
|
6.6
|
Highest Education Attainment
|
Grade School
|
1
|
6.6
|
|
High School
|
4
|
26.6
|
|
College diploma
|
4
|
26.6
|
|
Undergraduate
|
3
|
20
|
|
Master's
|
2
|
13.3
|
|
Doctorate
|
1
|
6.6
|
Identify as low-income*
|
Yes
|
12
|
80
|
|
No
|
3
|
20
|
Ethnicity
|
Caucasian
|
5
|
33.3
|
|
South Asian
|
3
|
20
|
|
East/Southeast Asian
|
4
|
26.6
|
|
Persian
|
3
|
20
|
Identify as LGBTQ+
|
Yes
|
7
|
46.6
|
|
No
|
8
|
53.3
|
* LICO cutoff <$26,620/year Based on poverty line in urban areas of Canada, with a population of 500,000 or more
|
Based on our thematic analysis, four themes were derived from the interview data demonstrating the factors that most significantly impact the mental wellbeing of CDOA in the Downtown West End of Vancouver. These include:
- Sense of stability over personal circumstances
- Having the ability to do
- Creating a positive impact on other peoples’ lives
- Feeling a sense of belonging
Sense of stability
All participants expressed that, as they age, their mental health has been affected because they feel that they are losing control over their life at an old age, an age where they are supposed to feel the most stable. Thai includes control over their bodies, their judgements, their time, and their independence. One participant (F, 78) referred to “stability” as being “in control, even when everything is spiraling down”. The two senses of stability that participants mentioned most often were financial and relationship stability.
Financial stability was mentioned by majority of the participants as an important factor that impacts their mental wellbeing. Many of the participants who reside in the DTWE are low-income older adults. A lack of financial security was identified as a factor that participants felt contributed to having a good quality of life, including having access to healthy diets, proper housing, transportation, and adequate health services (i.e., dental, vision, and mental health services). One participant (M, 67) said:
“Every now and then, I can certainly feel that I should be saving [money] and that I should have saved. I certainly worry about money more than most seniors, and this really gives me anxiety. I'd like to see some counseling services provided for free or for low cost to those seniors who can't afford it. Because mental health is just as important as physical health, and seniors have made an enormous contribution to our society. They deserve the respect and consideration and help if they need it.”
Participants identified that factors impacting one’s sense of stability also included relationship stability (the ability to rely on others). Many older adults find comfort and unwavering support in a good network of family or friends as they age, as well as the routine that they have built, such as one participant (F, 74) who said:
“I have very good friends who are around my age and who live near me. So, and we've all – I wouldn't call it a family relationship, but we're very good friends, and we're there to support and help each other and just to [have] social action, just to get together for a drink every week. It makes me look forward to it.”
On the contrary, social isolation — especially during and after the COVID-19 pandemic, where social restrictions have prevented people from communicating face-to-face — had a detrimental effect on the mental health of CDOA. One participant (F, 72) mentioned the fear and anxiety that they experience living in isolation:
“I fear of something happening to me and having no one around. Like, my husband was sick for several years and then I took care of him until he passed. And… but now, there's nobody for me.”
Additionally, when the COVID-19 pandemic occurred, many older adults found difficulties with maintaining their interpersonal relationships. This is especially true with those who had limited access to technology. One participant (M, 82) explained the difficulties with activity continuation using technology:
“I used to go down to [a community center] for a physical meeting with my choir. It’s sort of a seniors’ choir and songwriting class. Since the pandemic, it's all virtual and online, so we're doing zoom meetings, but there's always some kind of technical issues with some people or me not being able to join or start the video… And I had troubles, because I had a really old computer and then I had to buy a new computer”.
Having the ability to “do”
Many participants mentioned that dealing with their ongoing health issues and experiencing physical decline has been the most significant barrier to performing hobbies and activities that they used to do, which in turn negatively impacts their mental wellbeing. One participant (F, 70) explained:
“When you're aging, you’re dealing with more health issues. For example, I suffer from high blood pressure, so I take high blood pressure pills. I also suffer from osteoporosis, so I take medication for that. You know, you're finding that you can't really do some of the things that you used to do in your youth. You can't walk as far without feeling some pain. You know, your mental facilities, although I try to keep myself as engaged as possible, your mental facilities sort of declined.”
“Doing” is more than just participating in current activities, it is also about the loss of one’s ability to do an activity and finding joy in compensating. With declining physical health, some have taken an interest in less physically involved activities. Many older adults have gained newfound enjoyment in art-based activities such as music or painting, hobbies that were not in their repertoire in their younger days. One older adult (F, 73) took up a new activity and reported:
“When I retired when I was 71, I took up singing lessons. I had never sung in choirs, but I decided – I’d never done singing lessons, so now I'm taking singing lessons, and they bring me huge joy, I have to say, I get to sing whatever I want! So, right now, I'm singing Bach, who could believe that? I can do whatever.”
However, for participants who feel that they are still physically able and active, often their biggest barrier to pursuing activities is their safety. As racially-motivated crimes in the DTWE have increased after the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly towards the Asian/Pacific Islander population in Canada, some older adults found that their daily walks around the neighbourhood, which once brought them joy, have become burdensome. Two Asian-Canadian participants (F, 68; F, 68) said:
“I was attacked by a white man, about a month ago. I was taking a photo of a tree and then I turned to take a selfie, and I heard a man's voice saying, “hey, I want to ask you a question!”. And I knew, with the tone and the loudness of where it was coming from, behind me, I knew that something bad was going to happen, but I had to look to see who it was. I turned around and that's when he just, boom! Pushed me to the ground.”
“Someone said to me: “you know, it's Kung flu!” and blaming [COVID-19] on China, you know, and those people think that way. a lot of times, like a LOT of times, I even forgot that I was Asian, until I got attacked. Then I [remember] oh yeah! I have to be careful now, you know, because I look Asian to people. But in my mind, I'm Canadian. I love going for a walk, I walk around the Seawall, walk around Stanley Park, and usually, I would go by myself. But now, after the attack, it’s… different.”
Creating a positive impact on other peoples’ lives
Helping others has allowed older adults in the community to feel empowered. For older adults with the skills and capacity to volunteer, it was said that it is “one of the greatest gifts that I can leave behind for the community.” The idea of changing other peoples’ lives for the better has been reported by one participant as a major contributor to their mental health:
“I work as a volunteer peer support person. So, I have four clients right now and I talk to them once a week or more than once a week. One of them I'm going to start with Zoom next week. So, it keeps me in contact with other people, how are they doing. I'd like to think I contribute somewhat to their mental health, their good mental health, so that in turn helps with mine.”
Teaching is one of the many ways that older adults can positively contribute to the community. One participant mentioned that teaching gave them a “sense of purpose” and positively impacted their mental wellbeing.
“I still contribute to my community in whatever way I can. I teach yoga because that gives me a great deal of pleasure. I also have education, which is not a professional degree but a diploma. At some point, when I got more out of my shell, I found that I really liked to teach. I like to help people turn their light bulbs on and partially that was because I learned so much, I learned more than my students ever learned.”
Feeling a sense of belonging
As many of the older adult residents of the DTWE belong to under-represented groups, the feeling of belonging to and acceptance within their community has been a life-long objective. LGBTQ+ participants specifically spoke about breaking away from social labels, which allowed them to live authentically, start thinking of their own goals in life, and do what makes them happy. One participant (M, 67) stated:
“Part about mental health, I think, was the fact that we were encouraged to be who you are. One can be a doctor, the other can be a cashier in a grocery store, and both can be happy, and neither is elevated, and I think having the opportunity to challenge that within yourself is part of the ongoing condition of mental health.”
Breaking away from stereotypes can feel uncomfortable, but it begins the path to self-acceptance. Part of feeling a sense of belonging is accepting oneself and creating a sense of purpose. As one participant (M, 70) described:
“Satisfaction with yourself, and I don't mean a self-satisfied image, I mean a true acceptance of who you are and what you've done is everything. And I suppose there's also a component there that you still have a place in the world. A very big one, that what you can do could still matter in the world.”
Aside from self-acceptance and individuality, most participants mentioned that feeling a sense of belonging ultimately stems from being part of a community. Whether it is a spiritual or religious community, communities based on identity (e.g. queer communities, communities based on ethnic backgrounds), or geographical-based community such as the DTWE, they ultimately allow people to feel like they belong. One participant (F, 74) stated:
“I'm on the board of a community of an organization that’s just reinventing itself. And I've been part of it for five years, it's trying to have an impact on the condition of LGBT seniors in Vancouver. I feel like it’s where I’m supposed to be, considering my own identity and what I have been through.”
To further this point, another participant (F, 68) explained that belonging to an online community allowed them to gain support and initiate conversations around the hate crimes, which helps them cope and not feel alone in dealing with a traumatic experience:
“I've joined an Asian-Canadian Writers [Facebook] Group and I started to post things about Asian hate crime rising, because I've seen things on the news. And so, no sooner after I posted something like that, other people were talking about it in the group. So, it had so many responses from people I don't even know, and all supporting me! So, it does help.”