This is a single center, large-sample retrospective study that focused on analgesic effects and early outcomes of PNB.
The most important finding of this study was that resting VAS score 6 hours and 48 hours postoperatively were significantly lower in the PNB + PCA group than the PCA group. Although resting VAS score at rest after 24 hours showed no significant difference, the average resting VAS score was lower at all time points in the PNB + PCA group (Fig. 1), indicating that peripheral nerve block affects pain in postoperative patients. Additionally, by adding PNB after surgery, postoperative complications such as pneumonia and delirium were significantly reduced because pain-relieved postoperative patients at rest could get willingness to begin ambulation and eating sooner, leading to fewer complications. Furthermore, PNB might make early rehabilitation possible.
However, active VAS score was not significantly different between the groups, indicating that movement after surgery is still painful for most patients even if they received PNB. This might cause patients to require more opioids, so there was no significant difference in total morphine use between the groups.
Poor postoperative outcomes, including longer hospital stay and more complications are associated with postoperative pain.[4, 24] Thus, less postoperative pain at rest can offer advantages including early ambulation and fewer complications.[25] Many studies focused on periarticular injection after total hip arthroplasty,[26–28] but few studies have focused on bipolar hemiarthroplasty. Because we assume fracture can cause pain, pain management after hip-fracture surgery is usually underestimated. This study focused on PNB effectiveness for geriatric femoral-neck fracture patients and demonstrate that less pain at rest was achieved, which could give geriatric patients greater will to move and eat. Although we did not analyze the effect of periarticular injection in this study, other studies have demonstrated its effectiveness.[29–31] We also performed periarticular injection in all patients, so further studies can focus on periarticular injection with PNB.
In geriatric femoral-neck fracture patients, pneumonia (especially aspiration pneumonia) is the major mortality-causing complication after surgical treatment.[32] The main reason for aspiration pneumonia is a non-ambulatory state due to postoperative pain. After complications from aspiration pneumonia occur, IV antibiotic treatment is necessary, which leads to other morbidities. This study showed that PNB after femoral-neck fracture surgery significantly lowered the risk of aspiration pneumonia. One retrospective study suggested that longer duration of surgery, delayed surgery, age, low body-mass index, and malnutrition were risk factors for aspiration pneumonia.[33] In patients with high risk of aspiration pneumonia, post-surgical PNB should be administered.
Another mortality-causing complication after hip-fracture surgery is delirium, and development of postoperative delirium is associated with longer hospital stay, increased medical complications, and poorer short-term functional outcome.[34–36] If delirium after geriatric hip-fracture surgery is well controlled, complications can be alleviated. One retrospective cohort study showed that PNB and general anesthesia were associated with a small reduction in postoperative delirium.[37] This study showed the PNB + PCA group had a significantly lower risk of delirium, which can lead to earlier ambulation and rehabilitation. Postoperative delirium with severe pain and distress occurred most on postoperative day 1 and day 2, thus, PNB should be considered to control postoperative pain.
Subgroup analysis according to anesthesia type (general and spinal) was done for evaluating the effectiveness on early postoperative pain score difference. Although spinal anesthesia can influence on pain in postoperative 6 hours, the result showed no significant difference in both subgroups in both PNB + PCA and PCA groups. And also, inter group of subgroup analysis was same results in both groups. In both general anesthesia patients and spinal anesthesia patients, resting postoperative 6 hours VAS was significantly lower in PNB + PCA group.
The analgesic effect of ropivacaine is 11 hours in average, the effect of PNB would be less in postoperative day 1 and 2.[38] However, Desmet et al [39] have demonstrated that, compared with no block, supra-inguinal FICB results in lower pain scores and decreased morphine consumption (at 24 and 48 hours) after THA. As the FICB is a field block, the high volumes of local anesthesia combined with epinephrine injected during FICB could contribute to the duration of analgesic effect. So, early postoperative pain reduction can influence on patients’ pain perception, which can influence on pain reduction until 48 hours after surgery.
There are some limitations in this study. First, PNB was given as a single shot after the surgery. If we use continuous PNB for femoral-neck fracture patients, postoperative pain and active VAS score might both be much lower.[40] And PNB can be devided into two groups (femoral nerve block and fascia iliaca compartment block), which can be a bias. Future studies can focus on block type. Second, this was a single-center retrospective study but it included a large patient sample and statistical correction for age, BMI, sex, and ASA score. Finally, we did not analyze long-term follow-up data including functional scores because geriatric femoral-neck fracture patients are often lost during follow-up and can be difficult to survey. Further studies are required for long-term follow-up.