Characterization of Auxin Transporter Genes in Sweet Potato
Various Bioinformatics tools were used to exhaustively search the I. batatas proteome for the presence of PIN, PILS, AUX/LAX, and ABCB gene families. A total of 5 AUX/LAX, 16 PIN, 12 PILS, and 34 ABCB genes were found, and their physicochemical properties are described in Table 1. The 5 IbLAX sequences were located on five different chromosomes, had 6–8 exons (Fig. 1), and the encoded proteins were 419–486 amino acids (a.a.) long, with MW ranging from 47.03–54.87 kDa, and pIs ranging from 7.28–9.28. Except for IbLAX5 (9 TM domains), the other IbLAX sequences had 11 TM domains.
Table 1
Summary of the properties of I. batatas auxin transport sequences
Gene | Gene Identifier | Chr. | Chr. Location | Strand | CDS Length (b.p.) | No. of exons | Protein | Subcellular Localization | No. of TMM domains |
Length (a.a.) | MW (kDa) | pI |
IbLAX1 | g25526 | LG7 | 1550143–1554700 | - | 1338 | 7 | 445 | 50.48 | 8.67 | plasma membrane | 11 |
IbLAX2 | g18076 | LG5 | 10169542–10174899 | - | 1404 | 8 | 467 | 52.62 | 9.28 | plasma membrane | 11 |
IbLAX3 | g14264 | LG4 | 10773653–10778112 | - | 1260 | 7 | 419 | 47.03 | 8.47 | plasma membrane | 11 |
IbLAX4 | g58883 | LG14 | 25245748–25250410 | - | 1371 | 6 | 456 | 51.12 | 7.28 | plasma membrane | 11 |
IbLAX5 | g34013 | LG9 | 358138–361567 | + | 1461 | 8 | 486 | 54.87 | 8.86 | plasma membrane | 9 |
IbPIN1 | g31622 | LG8 | 8347173–8352042 | + | 1842 | 6 | 613 | 66.91 | 8.56 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN2 | g26722 | LG7 | 10572868–10577209 | + | 1953 | 6 | 650 | 70.23 | 9.34 | plasma membrane | 9 |
IbPIN3 | g50203 | LG12 | 24863450–24866705 | + | 1845 | 6 | 614 | 66.81 | 9.36 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN4 | g12633 | LG3 | 23886640–23890762 | - | 1809 | 8 | 602 | 65.43 | 7.20 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN5 | g33395 | LG8 | 22354325–22359773 | + | 1098 | 6 | 365 | 39.88 | 8.13 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN6 | g61458 | LG15 | 10634836–10644514 | + | 1899 | 8 | 632 | 68.89 | 8.87 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPIN7 | g24730 | LG6 | 28353079–28356723 | + | 1683 | 7 | 560 | 60.85 | 9.17 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN8 | g30109 | LG7 | 34842340–34849521 | + | 2073 | 11 | 690 | 74.87 | 8.99 | plasma membrane | 9 |
IbPIN9 | g8864 | LG2 | 34201096–34203215 | - | 1113 | 5 | 370 | 40.35 | 7.67 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN10 | g8865 | LG2 | 34206652–34208767 | - | 1011 | 6 | 336 | 35.80 | 6.19 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPIN11 | g30543 | LG8 | 1654916–1657682 | + | 1116 | 5 | 371 | 40.32 | 6.04 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN12 | g30544 | LG8 | 1660826–1669740 | + | 2583 | 13 | 860 | 94.75 | 8.55 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPIN13 | g42952 | LG11 | 10698597–10702015 | + | 1695 | 8 | 564 | 61.15 | 8.93 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPIN14 | g52608 | LG13 | 10412343–10415279 | + | 1653 | 4 | 550 | 60.58 | 9.23 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPIN15 | g60777 | LG15 | 5657665–5659045 | - | 792 | 4 | 263 | 28.40 | 8.97 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPIN16 | g60784 | LG15 | 5724120–5726035 | - | 1047 | 5 | 348 | 37.38 | 8.68 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS1 | g24041 | LG6 | 23670714–23676338 | + | 1224 | 10 | 407 | 44.11 | 8.87 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS2 | g29170 | LG7 | 28534633–28537128 | + | 1137 | 1 | 378 | 41.71 | 5.31 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPILS3 | g24004 | LG6 | 23358265–23363104 | + | 1182 | 11 | 393 | 42.52 | 9.10 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS4 | g24023 | LG6 | 23516313–23521518 | + | 1452 | 11 | 483 | 52.37 | 8.61 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS5 | g626 | LG1 | 3553017–3559887 | - | 1242 | 8 | 413 | 44.61 | 5.64 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS6 | g24617 | LG6 | 27610422–27614637 | - | 1377 | 11 | 458 | 50.46 | 9.05 | plasma membrane | 11 |
IbPILS7 | g639 | LG1 | 3727031–3732733 | + | 1188 | 8 | 395 | 42.80 | 5.64 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS8 | g492 | LG1 | 2712412–2715413 | + | 1131 | 9 | 376 | 40.70 | 9.31 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbPILS9 | g17090 | LG5 | 2952926–2955127 | - | 1227 | 2 | 408 | 44.82 | 5.19 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS10 | g29577 | LG7 | 31267731–31272875 | + | 1215 | 10 | 404 | 44.12 | 6.32 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS11 | g29578 | LG7 | 31275671–31282780 | + | 1272 | 11 | 423 | 45.45 | 8.60 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbPILS12 | g29861 | LG7 | 33340199–33346258 | + | 1146 | 10 | 381 | 41.50 | 9.12 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbABCB1 | g58077 | LG14 | 19643150–19649479 | + | 4086 | 9 | 1361 | 149.20 | 7.85 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB2 | g41706 | LG11 | 2236150–2240985 | - | 3657 | 11 | 1218 | 132.40 | 8.30 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB3 | g46730 | LG11 | 39340040–39349688 | - | 4362 | 17 | 1453 | 158.98 | 8.75 | plasma membrane | 13 |
IbABCB4 | g5572 | LG2 | 8997084–9003307 | + | 3828 | 12 | 1275 | 136.98 | 6.84 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB5 | g34715 | LG9 | 4480216–4489179 | - | 3816 | 12 | 1271 | 137.95 | 6.80 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB6 | g25655 | LG7 | 2364737–2375555 | - | 3861 | 14 | 1286 | 142.46 | 5.84 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB7 | g45972 | LG11 | 34038568–34046429 | - | 3534 | 14 | 1177 | 128.24 | 8.08 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB8 | g19793 | LG5 | 23636660–23642900 | - | 3618 | 10 | 1205 | 131.52 | 8.80 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB9 | g1318 | LG1 | 7918997–7926418 | + | 3672 | 14 | 1223 | 133.60 | 9.08 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbABCB10 | g17513 | LG5 | 5919612–5932282 | + | 3714 | 38 | 1237 | 140.63 | 6.54 | plasma membrane | 2 |
IbABCB11 | g19792 | LG5 | 23622142–23628260 | - | 3465 | 11 | 1154 | 125.60 | 8.60 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB12 | g20718 | LG5 | 29670942–29677045 | - | 3753 | 9 | 1250 | 137.80 | 6.49 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB13 | g32017 | LG8 | 11601756–11607059 | + | 2115 | 19 | 704 | 76.22 | 6.14 | plasma membrane | 6 |
IbABCB14 | g25228 | LG6 | 31386847–31394948 | + | 3963 | 11 | 1320 | 143.81 | 7.60 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB15 | g30121 | LG7 | 34905790–34917058 | + | 3669 | 11 | 1222 | 132.55 | 8.95 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbABCB16 | g40423 | LG10 | 16539099–16545820 | - | 3522 | 8 | 1173 | 128.35 | 8.31 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB17 | g32021 | LG8 | 11623228–11628502 | - | 2055 | 18 | 684 | 73.67 | 7.32 | plasma membrane | 6 |
IbABCB18 | g23634 | LG6 | 20413802–20420526 | - | 3693 | 8 | 1230 | 134.34 | 8.55 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB19 | g30093 | LG7 | 34747721–34755526 | + | 3777 | 11 | 1258 | 136.78 | 8.09 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB20 | g20247 | LG5 | 26720114–26729268 | + | 3849 | 14 | 1282 | 142.58 | 5.72 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB21 | g37468 | LG9 | 26036136–26043381 | + | 3699 | 12 | 1232 | 134.49 | 7.09 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB22 | g34716 | LG9 | 4489923–4496439 | - | 3825 | 14 | 1274 | 140.65 | 6.60 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB23 | g14668 | LG4 | 14021708–14031551 | + | 4017 | 13 | 1338 | 147.13 | 8.80 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB24 | g46727 | LG11 | 39314943–39321198 | - | 3687 | 14 | 1228 | 134.64 | 8.47 | plasma membrane | 13 |
IbABCB25 | g49067 | LG12 | 16286698–16299323 | + | 2802 | 22 | 933 | 102.89 | 8.91 | plasma membrane | 8 |
IbABCB26 | g40744 | LG10 | 18874918–18890246 | + | 2550 | 20 | 849 | 95.11 | 8.84 | plasma membrane | 6 |
Table 1
Gene | Gene Identifier | Chr. | Chr. Location | Strand | CDS Length (b.p.) | No. of exons | Protein | Subcellular Localization | No. of TMM domains |
Length (a.a.) | MW (kDa) | pI |
IbABCB27 | g17337 | LG5 | 4785229–4791980 | + | 1893 | 17 | 630 | 67.85 | 8.25 | plasma membrane | 6 |
IbABCB28 | g25319 | LG7 | 329534–335099 | + | 2169 | 17 | 722 | 78.52 | 8.71 | plasma membrane | 6 |
IbABCB29 | g25107 | LG6 | 30683900–30687230 | + | 1488 | 12 | 495 | 54.77 | 8.41 | plasma membrane | 5 |
IbABCB30 | g46728 | LG11 | 39323514–39334578 | - | 3738 | 15 | 1245 | 135.57 | 8.11 | plasma membrane | 12 |
IbABCB31 | g54072 | LG13 | 21475466–21488883 | - | 8715 | 13 | 2904 | 323.37 | 7.09 | plasma membrane; nuclear | 12 |
IbABCB32 | g55161 | LG13 | 28321952–28333090 | + | 7194 | 23 | 2397 | 264.48 | 7.15 | plasma membrane; nuclear | 12 |
IbABCB33 | g60954 | LG15 | 6855944–6862171 | + | 4131 | 10 | 1376 | 151.26 | 8.03 | plasma membrane | 10 |
IbABCB34 | g62855 | LG15 | 21717081–21721653 | - | 1941 | 10 | 646 | 71.25 | 9.49 | plasma membrane | 2 |
The 16 IbPIN genes had 4–11 exons (Fig. 1) and were unevenly distributed across eight chromosomes: 4 on Chromosome 8; 3 on Chromosome 15; 2 on Chromosomes 2 and 7; and one on Chromosomes 3, 6, 11, 12, and 13. The encoded IbPIN proteins were 263–860 a.a. long, had MW ranging from 28.40-74.87 kDa, pIs ranging from 6.04–9.36, and 8–10 TM helices.
The 12 IbPILS genes had 1–11 exons (Fig. 1) and were unevenly distributed along four chromosomes: 3 on Chromosome 1, 1 on Chromosome 5, 4 on Chromosome 6, and 4 on Chromosome 7. The encoded protein sequences were similar in length (ranging from 376–483 a.a.), had MWs ranging from 40.70-52.37 kDa, and had pIs ranging from 5.19–9.31. Most of the IbPILS sequences had the canonical 10 TM helices, while 3 had 8 TM helices and 1 had 11 helices.
The 34 IbABCB genes had 8–38 exons (Fig. 1) and were unevenly distributed along 14 chromosomes (none on Chromosome 3). The IbABCB proteins had a wide range of: lengths (495–2904 a.a.), MWs (54.77-323.37 kDa), and pIs (5.72–9.49). The sequences had 2–13 TM helices, but 20 sequences had the canonical 12 TM helices.
All the sequences analyzed in this study were predicted to localize to the plasma membrane, with IbABCB31 and IbABCB32 predicted to localize in the nucleus.
Motif Analysis of Sweet Potato Auxin Transporter Genes
Ten motifs were identified in the IbLAX sequences (Fig. 2). Motif 1 was present in all the IbLAX sequences, and this motif corresponded to the ‘auxin transporter-like 1’ domain (PTHR48017:SF29). Motifs 2, 5, and 6 were also present in 5, 4, and 4 sequences, respectively, and they corresponded to the IPR013057 transporter domain found in LAX sequences. Several of the motifs corresponded to transmembrane and hydrophobic domains which corroborated the presence of several TM helices.
Fifteen motifs were detected in the IbPIN sequences (Fig. 2b). All the sequences had a combination of motifs (Motifs 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9) that corresponded with the auxin efflux carrier domain (PTHR31752) and/or the membrane transport domain (IPR004776). Thirteen sequences had Motif 5, which had the specific PIN2 domain, IPR033526. PIN proteins can be designated into 2 groups: canonical or ‘long’ PINs and noncanonical or ‘short’ PINs (Mohanta et al. 2018). Canonical PINs have a long hydrophilic loop with domains H1, H2, H3, and H4 in between their TM helices (Mohanta et al. 2018). Motifs 8, 9, 12, and 13 corresponding to domains H1, H2, H3, and H4 were found in 8, 8, 7, and 7 IbPINs, respectively. There were 7 IbPINs (IbPIN-1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 13, and 14) with all four domains H1-H4. IbPIN6 had H1 and H2 only, while the remainder of the IbPINS did not have the H1-H4 domains. Motifs 1, 2, 4, 10, and 11 are conserved N-terminal motifs, while Motifs 3, 5, 6, and 14 are conserved C-terminus motifs that were previously described (Wang et al. 2022).
Fifteen motifs were found in the IbPILS sequences. All the sequences had at least one of Motifs 1, 2, and 5, representing the PILS Interpro domain, IPR045033. The presence of this domain further confirmed that these were PILS proteins. Motif 8 was present in all 12 IbPILs sequences, and this motif had cytoplasmic and TM regions. There were 15 motifs present in the IbABCB sequences. All the sequences had one or more motifs (Motifs 1, 3, 6, 7, 10, and 13) that corresponded to the ABCB domain (PTHR24221, PTHR24222). The ABC transporter transmembrane domain (IPR011527; IPR036640) was also present in the sequences (Motifs 4, 8, 11, and 15). Motifs 2 and 5 represented the P-loop NTPase domain (IPR027417) and one or both of these motifs were present in each sequence. Motif 1 represented the conserved Walker B motif, while Motif 2 represented the conserved Walker A motif found in ABCB proteins (Wang et al. 2022).
Phylogenetic Analysis of Sweet Potato Auxin Transporter Genes
Neighbour-joining (NJ) phylogenetic trees were constructed to investigate the relationships between the I. batatas auxin transporter sequences and those from other crops, including the highly characterized A. thaliana sequences. Figure 3a shows the phylogenetic tree for the LAX sequences. The LAX sequences formed two main phylogenetic groups, I and II.
The IbPILS sequences were grouped into three subfamilies: I, II, and III (Fig. 3b). Subfamily I has IbPILS-1, -3, -4, -8, -10, and − 11 sequences homologous to AtPILS-1, -3, and − 4, which have more than fifteen phosphorylation sites (Wang et al. 2022). IbPILS-5, -7, and − 12 belong to Subfamily II, which also has the homologous AtPILS-5/7 proteins with less than ten phosphorylation sites (Wang et al. 2022). Subfamily III has IbPILS-2, -6, and − 9, and these proteins are homologous to AtPILS-2/6, which have 10–15 phosphorylation sites (Wang et al. 2022).
The IbPIN sequences were grouped into five main subfamilies (Fig. 3c). Group I contains all the long or canonical IbPINS that were detected by MEME, and they were homologous to all five long AtPIN sequences. Groups II-V had noncanonical PIN sequences. IbPIN8 was found in Group II, which represents the AtPIN8 subgroup, while IbPIN-5/15/16 were found in Group IV, which represents the AtPIN5 subgroup. IbPIN6 formed a subgroup with AtPIN6, and both sequences have a truncated middle hydrophilic loop, so they are sometimes not classed as a long or short PIN. IbPIN-9/10/11/12 were found in Group V, which did not contain any A. thaliana sequences, but had homologous sequences from S. tuberosum, I. triloba and I. trifida.
The IbABCB protein family was clustered into four major subfamilies: I, II, III, and IV (Fig. 3d). The auxin-signaling AtABCB-1/4/6/14/15/19/20/21 sequences and their homologous IbABCB sequences were present across all four subfamilies.
Bioinformatics prediction of auxin-transporting ABCB proteins
The ABCB proteins in A. thaliana that transport auxin have a conserved D/E-P motif at P1008 in AtABCB1 (Hao et al. 2020). The results of the MEME analysis of the IbABCB sequences are shown in Supplementary Table 2. The 11 IbABCB proteins with the D/E-P motif are listed in Table 2.
Table 2
List of IbABCB proteins that are predicted to transport auxin and their A. thaliana and O. sativa homologs from the phylogenetic tree in Fig. 3d
IbABCB protein with D/E-P motif | A. Thaliana/ O. sativa homolog |
IbABCB1 | AtABCB1 |
IbABCB2 | AtABCB14 |
IbABCB4 | AtABCB4, AtABCB21 |
IbABCB6 | AtABCB6, AtABCB20 |
IbABCB12 | AtABCB6, AtABCB20 |
IbABCB14 | AtABCB1 |
IbABCB15 | AtABCB15 |
IbABCB16 | AtABCB15 |
IbABCB18 | AtABCB15 |
IbABCB19 | AtABCB19, OsABCB14 |
IbABCB34 | AtABCB6, AtABCB20 |
In silico and qRT-PCR Expression Analysis of Auxin Transporter Genes
The expression of the auxin signaling genes in various sweet potato tissues are shown in the heatmaps (Figs. 4 and 5). Some genes (IbLAX1, IbLAX4, IbPILS2, IbPILS6, IbPIN8, and IbABCB27) showed moderate to high expression in all the tissues studied. Genes such as IbPILS1, IbPILS4, IbPIN2, IbPIN16, IbABCB12, and IbABCB16 showed little to no expression in the various tissues. The expression levels in the same tissue from different cultivars were generally similar. Some genes had tissue-specific expression patterns. For example, IbLAX5, IbPILS10, IbPIN13, IbABCB9, IbABCB14, and IbABCB19 showed the highest expression in shoots and leaves. Conversely, IbABCB1 and IbABCB8 showed the highest expression in root tissue (FR, ITR, ETR, and MTR). There were no genes that showed expression in one specific tissue only.
The expression of auxin signaling genes in SRs vs. FRs at three different time points (30 days after transplanting [DAT], 40 DAT, and 50 DAT) that was conducted by Wu et al. (2018) was plotted on the heatmaps shown in Fig. 6 and Fig. 7. For the cultivar used in their study, tuber initiation occurs around 30 DAT. Figure 6 indicates that IbLAX1, IbPILS3, IbPILS7, IbPIN-5, -9, -10, and − 13 were up-regulated in SRs vs. FRs at tuber initiation (30 DAT), while there are no IbABCB genes that are up-regulated at the same stage (Fig. 7). There were more up-regulated IbPIN, IbPILS, and IbLAX genes than down-regulated genes, and only one strongly down-regulated gene (IbPIN11) expressed across all three comparisons. IbLAX1 and IbPIN11 were significantly up-regulated across all three developmental stages, while other genes, such as IbLAX5 and IbPILS10, were significantly up-regulated during SR expansion (40 DAT and 50 DAT) (Fig. 6).
Most of the IbABCB genes were not differentially expressed, and the remaining IbABCB genes were differentially expressed at 40 DAT and 50 DAT (Fig. 7). Two of the three up-regulated IbABCB genes (IbABCB1 and IbABCB14) were predicted to be auxin transporters while all the down-regulated IbABCB genes were not predicted to be involved in auxin signaling.
Time series data were also analyzed to further investigate the auxin transporter genes involved in SR initiation. The results of the DEGs obtained at different stage comparisons are shown in Fig. 8. IbLAX1 and IbLAX5 auxin influx transporters were upregulated in ITRs at S16 and S14 compared to FRs and S4 or S8 (Fig. 8), similar to Fig. 6. Additionally, IbPIN13 was upregulated in ITRs vs. FRs in both Fig. 6 and Fig. 8. However, not all the genes showed similar expression patterns in the different datasets. For example, IbPIN-1, -4, -6, and − 7 were upregulated in ITRs vs FRs in Fig. 8, but they were not differentially expressed at 30 DAT in Fig. 6. Additionally, IbPIN-10, -11, and − 12 were downregulated in ITRs vs. FRs in Fig. 8, but this was observed in Fig. 6 for IbPIN11 only.
IbPILS2 was upregulated in almost all the time point comparisons (Fig. 8), but it was not differentially expressed (Fig. 6). IbPILS-3, -5, -7, and − 10 were upregulated in at least one comparison in both Fig. 6 and Fig. 8. IbABCB-1, -9, -14, -31, and − 32 were upregulated in ITRs vs. FRs (Fig. 8), but this was the same only for IbABCB1 and IbABCB14 (Fig. 6).
Since there were differences in gene expression between the datasets from different cultivars, qRT-PCR was used to measure the gene expression of some of these genes in a different cultivar at 49 DAT (Fig. 9). The expression levels of the auxin transporter genes were generally the highest in the leaf (Fig. 9). IbPIN11 was significantly downregulated in SRs, and IbPIN13 was significantly upregulated (Figs. 6 and 8). There was no significant difference between their expressions in the qRT-PCR dataset (Fig. 9). The significant upregulation of IbPIN14 and IbLAX1 at 50 DAT (Fig. 6) is corroborated by the qRT-PCR results. While IbLAX5, IbPILS7, IbPILS10, IbABCB1, and IbABCB14 were differentially expressed at 50 DAT (Fig. 6), they were not differentially expressed at 49 DAT in the qRT-PCR data.
Analysis of CREs in Auxin Transporter Gene Promoter Sequences
Supplementary Table 3 shows the different types of CREs predicted to be found in the promoter regions of the auxin signalling genes. Except for IbABCB6 and IbLAX2, all the other auxin signalling genes had at least one light-responsive CRE, and most had more than one light-responsive CRE. Additionally, all the auxin signalling genes except IbPILS8, IbABCB11, IbLAX3, and IbPIN1 had at least one CRE involved in hormone responsiveness. CREs involved in abscisic acid responsiveness (ABRE) and methyl jasmonate (MeJA) responsiveness were the most commonly occurring hormone-responsive CREs. Some auxin signalling genes had CREs for auxin, gibberellin, salicylic acid, and/or ethylene responsiveness.
Additionally, a few genes had CREs involved in various aspects of plant development and stress responses. For example, there were CREs involved in wound responsiveness (WUN-motif, W box, WRE), circadian responses, anaerobic induction (ARE), drought responses (MBS), defense and stress responses (TC-rich repeats), and meristem expression (CAT-box).