Our study confirmed that older patients with pneumothorax, with or without underlying lung disease, who had concomitant pneumonia on admission should be treated with caution because of the high mortality rate. Although COPD and ILD are considered mortality risks for pneumothorax, this study suggests that concomitant pneumonia on admission may also be a mortality risk factor.
Our study is the second on pneumothorax in the older population in Japan, and we included 239 older patients, a more significant number than that in the previous study. Few studies have examined the mortality rate of spontaneous pneumothorax in the older population. The Japan Geriatrics Society and the Japan Gerontological Society have recently published a proposal to define older adults as ≥ 75 years9; however, internationally, older adults are defined as those aged ≥ 65 years. In this study, the definition of older patients was based on the World Health Organisation and United Nations classifications (patients aged ≥ 65 years).10 Since many patients have multiple rather than a single underlying pulmonary disease, we classified the patients more finely for investigation. In this study, 11.7% of patients had no underlying lung disease, indicating that primary pneumothorax can be recognised even in older patients. Emphysema was the most common underlying lung disease. The number of cases was small owing to the detailed classification; therefore, no significant differences were likely to be found. In this study, 22.6% of the patients had concomitant pneumonia on admission. A comparison of the survival and in-hospital death groups showed a significant difference (p < 0.01), suggesting that concomitant pneumonia on admission is a prognostic factor for in-hospital death.
The mortality rate among older spontaneous pneumothorax patients in our hospital was 15%, higher than that in the previous study. One reason is that our hospital has an emergency centre with 42 departments that handle tertiary care (where more severe illnesses are concentrated); hence, there are many severe cases with underlying diseases.
Few deaths were directly attributable to pneumothorax. In previous reports, the direct causes of death were COPD, pneumonia, heart disease, empyema, and sepsis.4,11 Most of these were due to the progression of comorbidities. Our research suggests that patients with pneumothorax often die of comorbidities rather than pneumothorax itself.
In previous reports, the proportion of patients with pneumothorax and concomitant pneumonia on admission was as high as 11%,4,12−14, but it reached 22.6% (54 cases) in our hospital. A total of 11% of the patients (28 cases) with PSP had only pneumothorax without an underlying pulmonary disease. On admission, the mortality rate was 33% (18/54) in patients with concomitant pneumonia. Only patients with pneumothorax without underlying lung disease were included among those with concomitant pneumonia on admission, and the mortality rate was as high as 29% (2/7 cases). Unlike in previous reports, patients with concomitant pneumonia on admission were more frequent with higher mortality rates, suggesting that concomitant pneumonia on admission may be a risk factor for mortality. The development of pneumonia in older patients is most likely due to their poor general health. Pneumonia in older patients is often caused by aspiration pneumonia due to poor swallowing function; however, bacterial pneumonia has also been recognised. Therefore, it is suggested that, even without any other underlying disease, older patients are likely to be in poor general condition and have fewer treatment choices for pneumothorax.
CCI was used to assess the severity of complications. Nineteen diseases were listed in the CCI, and higher scores were assigned to diseases with higher severity. A score was assigned to each disease, and each score was used to evaluate the severity of the complications.15 When the CCI was used to assess systemic comorbidities, mortality was higher in the group with higher scores. Systemic conditions likely affected the mortality in patients with pneumothorax; however, the log-rank test did not reveal a significant difference.
Pneumonia is more likely to occur in patients with systemic comorbidities, which may increase mortality rates.
As this study was a retrospective analysis at a single centre, it is necessary to confirm the results by a prospective study at multiple centres. The present study included patients aged ≥ 65 years with underlying diseases, limiting the possible confounding control of age and comorbidities. Further studies are needed to analyse the role of these potential confounders. In addition, pneumothorax is a recurrent disease. It is desirable to keep the patients under observation even after discharge from the hospital and observe them for the period until recurrence and death; however, the patients were observed only during hospitalisation. Unlike other countries, Japan does not have a unified medical record system, and without a visit to our hospital, physicians do not know how the patient turned out after discharge. Japan's medical and insurance systems are unique, and similar studies should be conducted in other countries.