The National Children's Hospital in San Jose, Costa Rica treats every single live born patient with a NTD within the country’s territory and the public universal healthcare system guarantees that all children will benefit from free medical care throughout their childhood. The spina bifida clinic opened its doors in 1993 and has closely followed this population from the pre folate to the full four component fortification policy to this day. All these circumstances provide a very accurate depiction of the incidence, clinical characteristics, and management of this group of patients.
Additionally, in Costa Rica there is no legal termination of affected pregnancies and even if this is a possibility, it is often not a choice for pregnant women due to cultural and religious beliefs[23]. This adds validity to our findings, as we consider that the studied population reflects most patients born with spina bifida under current folate fortification policies.
Fetal structural abnormalities have been described in up to 3% of all pregnancies and prenatal ultrasound remains one of the most reliable screening methods[23, 24][24]During the first trimester detection rates have been quoted close to 51% and this rate may increase to 90% in the second trimester[25–29] The identification of the lemon & banana signs along with ventriculomegaly are suggestive of MMC, however detection may be challenging during the first trimester[26–28]. In our cohort, 52% of cases OF MMC were detected during the second semester and 53% during the third semester respectively which underlines that early detection is still challenging within our healthcare system, however it opens the possibility of reaching early second semester evaluation that could allow prenatal MMC repair.
Literature has cited a hypothetical benefit of a cesarean delivery in reducing infant morbidity and mortality among MMC patients, quoting decreased trauma to the spinal defect, less probability of infection due to exposure of vaginal flora and improved access to surgical closure following the cesarean section[30–33]. In our series, despite having a 36% of the patients delivered vaginally, there were no recorded incidents of wound infection and as the cohort shows, 85% of the patient underwent prompt surgical closure within 24 hours after vaginal or cesarean delivery.
Several authors have described a positive impact of folate fortification on the functional level of patients with MMC, which indirectly improves morbidity and mortality[16, 34, 35]. Our results are consistent with previous studies as 77% of our patients have lesions at or below L3 which allows them to walk with the use of orthoses (independent ambulation)[36]
Given this tendency, there is also an increased frequency matching severity, as 67% of the MMC lesions were lesser than 5 cm of diameter, therefore allowing a feasible closure without the use of flaps or releasing incisions. This potentially shows a significant impact of folic acid in the decrease of anatomical level (caudalization of MMC) and reduction of diameter which along with almost nonexistent kyphosis (only 3 patients − 1.4%), facilitates not only the closure of the defect, but can also prevent the occurrence of this orthopedic problem that has been reported in 12 to 20%[37, 38]
The presence of symptomatic Chiari II malformation at birth in only 6 patients (2.7%), two of whom had lesions above L3 and which were larger than 5 cm of diameter could also be attributable to the protective effect of folate in the rest of this cohort, as Pollack, Protzenko and McDowell have reported 4.5, 12 and 21% rates of symptomatic Chiari II at birth requiring surgical management respectively[39–42]
It is to note that all three of our patients that underwent perinatal VP shunting followed by suboccipital decompression due to symptomatic Chiari II malformation (apnea, stridor and swallowing abnormalities), had a poor outcome, requiring tracheostomy and PEG, however they remain alive at follow up. This bad outcome has also been reported in other series[39, 40, 43] probably due to intrinsic brainstem anomalies as described by McLone[44].
In contrast to other studies, where there has been a reduction in the number of cases which require VP shunting[45, 46], our cohort shows that 78% of the patients underwent a shunt insertion which is also consistent with traditional series[29, 47, 48]. Of patients requiring a CSF shunt, 12% underwent the procedure at the time of spine repair due to the presence of overt hydrocephalus and a surgical timing less than 8 hours after delivery.
It is to note that the very low incidence of symptomatic Chiari II malformation at birth plus the significant percentage of ambulatory patients and the near absence of kyphosis in our cohort could suggest a protective effect from folic acid in live born MMC patients, which overlaps with the potential therapeutic objectives of prenatal MMC repair, warranting further studies and analysis of[49–54].
A major strength of our study is the analysis of representative data obtained from the only spina bifida clinic that manages every single case of live born myelomeningocele in Costa Rica, where there is a free universal healthcare system, and mandatory food fortification policy with four different staple foods are fortified with adequate folic acid dosage.
Limitations of this study are the lack of control data from the same population before the staple food folate fortification policy was introduced to conduct as pre- and post-fortification effectiveness analysis for severity.
In conclusion, mandatory four staple food fortification effectively and safely decreases the prevalence of NTD. A universal healthcare system that enforces a good prenatal care provides an early possibility of detection of NTD cases which optimizes their obstetric care. Additionally, a centralized spina bifida care institution provides a uniform approach to multidisciplinary evaluation and treatment with prompt clinical and surgical management of patients with MMC and associated hydrocephalus.
This preventive and curative approach not only prevents the saturation of health services with cases that otherwise can be prevented through folate fortification, but also optimizes the use of resources and personnel to other healthcare needs.