To the best of our knowledge, this is the first clinical trial to estimate the safety and efficacy of RT plus TACE and LEN in HCC with PVTT. Our study demonstrated that RT-TACE-LEN favored significantly longer PFS and OS over TACE-LEN, and the therapeutic modality was an independent prognostic factor for both PFS and OS. Besides, treatment-related toxicities of RT-TACE-LEN were acceptable and manageable.
PVTT was an important prognostic factor for poor survival outcomes among patients with HCC. It not only promotes intrahepatic tumor spread but also rapidly decreases blood supply to the liver, causing rapid deterioration of liver function and increased risk of portal hypertensive complications[25], which greatly limits the application of TACE in the treatment of PVTT. So far, there have been no worldwide consensuses or guidelines on the treatment of HCC with PVTT. Western guidelines regard PVTT as an advanced stage of HCC with little hope for a cure, and thus only recommend sorafenib or LEN monotherapy as standard of care[9, 26], resulting in a median OS of no more than 13 months. While in the eastern countries, anticancer treatments are more aggressive: surgical resection, RT and TACE are recommended for selected HCC patients with PVTT by Chinese, Japanese, South Korean, and Asia-Pacific clinical practice guidelines because of their promising survival outcomes in the clinical practice[27, 28]. Although, combination of TACE and LEN has been demonstrated clinical benefit in the treatment of advanced HCC by our previous study, its efficacy against PVTT is limited and the prognosis of HCC patients with PVTT is still dismal[15]. Therefore, novel therapy modality including efficient local approach against PVTT should attach great importance.
The potential benefits of applying RT to the treatment of PVTT has been reported by previous studies[20, 21, 29, 30], and one of the primary indications for RT is the macrovascular invasion. Yoon et al reported in a randomized clinical trial that patients with HCC showing macroscopic vascular invasion in the TACE-RT group had a significantly higher radiologic response rate than the sorafenib group at 24 weeks (33.3% vs. 2.2%, p < 0.001), a significantly longer median time to progression (31.0 vs. 11.7 weeks, p < 0.001), and significantly longer OS (55.0 vs. 43.0 weeks, p = 0.040) [21]. As in the current study, consistent results have been described that adding RT to TACE and LEN could further prolong the median OS and PFS to 22.8 and 12.8 months, respectively. The possible rationale for this triple combination therapy might be attributed to the quick reduction in tumor thrombus volume through radiation, which may relieve portal blood flow, allowing the maintenance of liver function, limiting intrahepatic tumor spread, and thereby allowing additional TACE[31, 32].Conversely, failure outside the radiation field could be complement by combining TACE and LEN treatment.
In terms of safety, most adverse events in our study were mild to moderate and could be manageable, which was similar to previous studies that combined therapy was used to treat advanced HCC[20, 21]. More than 90% of patients receiving TACE-RT treatment experienced any-grade adverse events and 12% were reported with serious adverse events reported by Yoon et al. And the most common toxicities ≥ grade 3 included AST/ALT increase (13.3%), diarrhea (2.2%), abdominal pain (2.2%), and bilirubin increase (2.2%)[21]. As in our study, hepatic toxicity was the most common adverse event in TACE-LEN group, announcing approximately 20% of ALT/AST increase. Toxicity profile was similar in the RT-TACE-LEN group to that of TACE-LEN, and adding RT did not significantly increase the incidences of serious adverse events. Given these findings, toxicities caused by RT-TACE-LEN seemed to be acceptable and tolerable.
Several limitations should be considered in the current study. First, it was a nonrandomized controlled trial involving only three medical centers in China. Second, the number of included patients was relatively small. Thus, larger-sample sized, more medical centers and randomized-designed clinical trials are warranted to confirm the clinical benefit of this triple combination therapy.
In conclusion, our study demonstrated that, for patients with HCC showing PVTT, the combination therapy of RT-TACE-LEN was well tolerated and provided significantly improved PFS and OS compared with TACE-LEN. This novel triple combination therapy may be a promising treatment for patients with advanced HCC showing PVTT. Further studies are needed to confirm our findings.