SpO2 was significantly decreased during HH from 60 to 135 min, while HR was increased from 75 to 150 min. These responses represent typical hemodynamic responses to HH in lowlanders. Moreover, SpO2 and HR showed negative correlations during HH, indicating that individuals with lower SpO2 experienced increased HR to enhance cardiac output and maintain blood oxygen levels. This suggested individual differences in adaptability to HH. These results were consistent with previous studies of lowlanders 9,10,33 and even highlanders 4,5. Although individual variations were seen in hemodynamic responses to HH, subjects were certainly exposed to HH and physiological changes were evoked.
On the other hand, no significant differences in SBP or DBP were seen. Under conditions of hypoxia, peripheral vascular resistance is decreased by nitric oxide released from vascular endothelial cells 34, which seems to decrease blood pressure, but some studies have reported that blood pressure does not change or is even slightly increased during long and/or severe hypoxic exposure (equivalent to over 4000 m) due to chemoreflex activation of the sympathetic nervous system 35–37. Responses of blood pressure to HH remain controversial. In this study, the level of HH was not severe and the exposure was relatively short, so blood pressures were unchanged.
All subjects showed decreases in aldosterone after HH, indicating natriuresis and diuresis completely consistent with previous studies 16,17,38. In addition, cortisol was significantly decreased after HH. In a field study, Wood et al. 21 reported cortisol at rest was increased over 5150 m, but was unchanged at 3400 m and 4270 m. In addition, cortisol was subdued at 4270 m and increased at 5150 m after exercise. They suggested a threshold of HH effects for cortisol response. Cortisol secretion is stimulated by adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH). Mclean 38 reported decreased levels of salivary cortisol and aldosterone at 4500 m, and assumed that high altitude impaired ACTH stimulation of cortisol and aldosterone secretion. Similarly, Bouissou et al. 39 reported that the rise in ACTH in response to 60 min of exercise was unchanged in a climatic chamber at 3000 m compared to 0 m, but that cortisol response was subdued. They found that post-exercise ACTH and cortisol levels correlated strongly at 0 m, but not at all during HH, suggesting ACTH-driven steroidogenesis at 0 m, but some disconnect at HH with an apparent reduction in cortisol sensitivity to ACTH. Cortisol is thus increased by stress under severe HH conditions 19,20,22, whereas mild HH conditions (up to 4000 m) might suppress cortisol secretion due to changes in steroidogenesis or sensitivity to ACTH.
Noradrenaline tended to increase during HH in this study. Many previous studies have found no changes in noradrenaline during acute HH 23,24, but increases with chronic HH (> 1 week) 24,40. Interestingly Rostrup et al. 24 reported that noradrenaline was decreased with 2 days at 4200 m and showed a significant positive correlation between noradrenaline and SpO2, suggesting individual variations in acclimatization to HH due to oxygen sensitivity of tyrosine hydroxylase. In the present study, a non-significant tendency toward a positive correlation was seen between noradrenaline and SpO2. Furthermore, noradrenaline correlated strongly with HR and SpO2 correlated negatively with HR (Table 4). These findings suggest that individuals who maintain a higher SpO2 have higher noradrenaline levels with lower HR due to the effects of noradrenaline on α1-adrenoreceptors 41. Although the causal direction of the relationship was unclear, our results suggest that individuals with good adaptability to HH (i.e., maintenance of higher SpO2) maintain a lower HR via the effects of noradrenaline.
IL-6, IL-8 and WBC count were increased after HH in this study (Table 3). First, we provided evidence that inflammatory and immune responses were evoked by acute HH even with 75 min of exposure. These results are consistent with previous studies 8,29,30. IL-6 has various functions 42, one of which is stimulation of WBC production and immune responses 43. Similarly, IL-8 is known as a neutrophil chemoattractant 44 and evokes angiogenesis 45. IL-6 and IL-8 are thus treated as mediators of inflammation 43,45,46; as a result, WBC count increased as an immune response in this study. On the other hand, previous studies have reported increases in other cytokines such as IL-1β and TNF-α with longer HH exposures 29,30. No such changes were seen in this study. Our results thus might suggest that changes in IL-6 and IL-8 represent first responses to acute HH.
Interestingly, individual variations were seen in relationships between cytokines, cortisol and SpO2. The relationship between IL-6 and WBC appears reasonable, with higher IL-6 inducing higher WBC count and immune responses to inflammation. The underlying mechanisms might be explained by variations in SpO2. Lower SpO2 was significantly associated with higher IL-6 and marginally associated with higher WBC count, suggesting that individuals with lower blood oxygen levels (low adaptability to HH) show increased inflammatory and immune responses to HH. In addition, higher IL-8 was significantly associated with higher cortisol. Cortisol levels mostly decreased after HH, and this relationship is difficult to explain. However, cortisol has anti-inflammatory effects and increases under IL-6 stimulation 47, and cortisol exposure is known to increase IL-6 and IL-8 levels in lymphomonocytes 48. Crosstalk interactions probably exist between cortisol and cytokines, and higher levels of IL-8 might induce secretion of cortisol to mitigate inflammation. IL-6 also showed a similar, non-significant relationship to cortisol.
With these physiological responses, the starting point seems to be lower blood oxygen levels. Individuals with lower SpO2 evoke greater inflammatory and immune responses than those with higher SpO2. Malacrida et al. 8 reported that HIF-1α, HIF-2α and NRF2 mRNA levels in WBC increased with HH (3830 m) and increased IL-6 levels and oxidative stress. They also reported negative associations between SpO2 and IL-6, HIF-1α, HIF-2α and NRF2 mRNA levels, and suggested temporal regulation of transcription factors, inflammatory state, and oxidative stress homeostasis in humans during HH. Although we did not measure oxidative stress or levels of HIF-1α or HIF-2α, similar responses seem likely to have occurred in our study, especially among individuals with lower SpO2. In addition, the factors underlying individual variations in SpO2 remain unclear, although some genetic components are likely involved 9,49. In particular, genetic variations in HIF-2α (EPAS1) are known to represent a key factor in the low hemoglobin adaptation among Tibetan highlanders 6,50. HIF-1α and HIF-2α are also known as mediator of inflammatory and immune responses 25,51. Some genetic variations in HIF-2α are seen in the Japanese population and might contribute to SpO2 levels and responses to HH.
Taken together, lower SpO2 appears to evoke various physiological responses, not only in hemodynamics, but also in hormonal, inflammatory and immune responses even with short HH exposures. While none of our subjects experienced AMS symptoms (LLS score > 3), these responses may precede AMS symptoms. A previous study also reported no associations between cytokine levels and AMS 52. More interestingly, complex physiological interactions and individual variations in hormonal, inflammatory and immune responses seem to be evoked by low oxygen levels in the body. Controversial results in previous studies might thus have been due to wide individual variations in such responses to HH. Cytokine storm in coronavirus disease 2019 has been speculated to involve the secretion of various cytokines, particularly IL-6 53, and our results suggest that individuals with lower SpO2 under HH stress might be at higher risk of cytokine storm, since they may secrete more cytokines in response to hypoxia during lung inflammation. Although we examined some parameters related to lower SpO2, further genetic and transcriptome analyses are needed to clarify the detailed physiological mechanisms and individual differences involved in responses to HH in humans.
This study showed a number of limitations. First, the small sample size limited the ability to analyze individual variations, and more data need to be accumulated. Second, blood was only sampled before and after HH for safety reasons in this study. Some hormone or cytokine levels may thus have rapidly normalized during changes in pressurization. More time points and longer HH exposures are needed for better temporal analyses of physiological responses.
In conclusion, cortisol and aldosterone were decreased and HR, IL-6, IL-8 and WBC count were increased by acute HH. Lower SpO2 was associated with higher HR, IL-6 and WBC count, and higher IL-8 was associated with higher cortisol. These results suggest that inflammatory and immune responses are evoked even with short (75-min) HH and higher responses are evoked in individuals with lower SpO2 (poor adaptability to HH).