Gamma spectroscopic analysis was carried on cassava crop samples collected within the Enugu old coal mining area—popularly known as Iva-valley. The results obtained from the three areas-Camp 1, Camp 2 and Pottery are presented below.
Activity concentrations in Camp 1
The result for the activity concentration of radionuclides in the cassava samples obtained from the Iva-valley area, classified as camp 1 is presented in table 1. The activity concentrations range from 39.34 - 442.45 Bq/kg, 11.7 to 89.22 Bq/kg and 70.46 to 182.23 Bq/kg for 40K, 226Ra and 232Th respectively.
Table 1: Activity concentration of radionuclides in cassava samples of camp 1 (Bq/kg)
Sample code
|
40K
|
226Ra
|
232Th
|
A1
|
109.64±9.33
|
39.39±3.82
|
118.47±4.10
|
A2
|
185.56±6.75
|
42.70±3.56
|
114.45±3.80
|
A3
|
39.34±5.59
|
89.22±5.09
|
70.46±1.59
|
A4
|
179.47±2.02
|
18.42±5.44
|
169.89±2.50
|
A5
|
193.07±3.20
|
34.12±5.87
|
119.10±2.46
|
A6
|
262.02±4.20
|
57.91±6.03
|
182.23±3.82
|
A7
|
442.45±6.99
|
20.97±1.85
|
118.92±6.84
|
A8
|
319.87±5.98
|
36.62±8.27
|
140.29±3.10
|
A9
|
234.28±5.32
|
24.28±5.73
|
116.38±5.38
|
A10
|
162.83±1.86
|
49.13±2.54
|
173.77±2.50
|
A11
|
186.38±4.29
|
22.43±3.29
|
131.48±3.43
|
A12
|
274.65±9.02
|
11.70±1.50
|
168.52±1.40
|
Mean
|
215.79±5.37
|
37.24±4.41
|
135.33±3.41
|
Activity concentrations in Camp 2
The activity concentration of radionuclides in the cassava samples collected from around the camp 2 site is shown in table 2. The values range from 113.99—253.96 Bq /kg, 16.10—54.32 Bq/kg and 85.29—212.77 Bq/kg for 40K, 226Ra and 232Th respectively.
Table 2: Activity concentration of radionuclides in cassava samples of camp 2 (Bq/kg)
Sample code
|
40K
|
226Ra
|
232Th
|
A13
|
246.03±5.13
|
19.11±7.18
|
173.77±2.39
|
A14
|
242.44±7.34
|
31.28±7.23
|
187.28±4.23
|
A15
|
253.96±1.39
|
38.81±3.70
|
164.08±1.36
|
A16
|
184.99±6.12
|
43.83±5.21
|
212.77±3.29
|
A17
|
178.32±3.94
|
25.32±4.39
|
132.47±2.39
|
A18
|
113.99±7.30
|
16.10±1.15
|
157.58±3.19
|
A19
|
137.23±4.30
|
54.32±3.23
|
85.29±1.20
|
A20
|
192.53±5.92
|
46.29±7.32
|
154.23±2.43
|
Mean
|
193.68±5.18
|
34.38±4.92
|
158.43±2.56
|
Activity concentration in pottery
The results for the gamma spectroscopic analysis carried out on cassava samples collected from around the pottery area is shown in table 3. The activity concentrations in cassava samples range from 180.87—423.42, 12.38—46.92 and 59.40—203.48 Bq/kg for 40K, 226Ra and 232Th respectively.
Table 3: Activity concentration of radionuclides in cassava samples of Pottery (Bq/kg)
Sample code
|
40K
|
226Ra
|
232Th
|
PT1
|
246.03±1.08
|
19.11±7.18
|
173.54±3.42
|
PT2
|
411.50±4.66
|
33.25±4.63
|
59.40±4.90
|
PT3
|
327.32±3.29
|
19.39±3.20
|
93.20±1.29
|
PT4
|
298.09±5.20
|
16.39±3.20
|
189.32±0.93
|
PT5
|
180.87±1.55
|
14.02±5.21
|
144.81±1.48
|
PT6
|
221.38±6.26
|
19.28±5.29
|
154.38±3.11
|
PT7
|
231.10±3.11
|
46.92±5.79
|
68.87±2.62
|
PT8
|
302.95±8.08
|
30.47±4.86
|
154.88±2.16
|
PT9
|
423.42±4.29
|
22.38±4.20
|
203.48±1.56
|
PT10
|
276.83±7.29
|
24.43±6.29
|
166.29±1.89
|
PT11
|
276.31±5.32
|
12.38±4.01
|
154.28±1.39
|
PT12
|
415.32±6.20
|
18.43±5.39
|
192.42±3.10
|
Mean
|
300.92±4.69
|
23.03±4.93
|
146.23±2.32
|
The concentration values of the radionuclides were higher than what Jwanbot et al (2012) and Jibiri and Abiodun (2012) observed for cassava and other root tuber crops like yam and cocoyam at Jos-Plateau and Abeokuta, all noted as high radiation areas in Nigeria respectively. Also, when compared the result with that obtained by Tchokosa et al. (2013), the activity concentrations in the Iva-valley area were higher. A similar study carried out by Addo et al. (2013) on activity concentration around a cement factory in Ghana show a lower result than those of this study. Table 4 shows some comparisons of the results obtain from this study and others.
Table 4: Comparison between radionuclides concentrations (Bq kg−1) of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K in Cassava
Sample category
|
40K (Bq/kg)
|
226Ra (Bq/kg)
|
232Th (Bq/kg)
|
source
|
location
|
cassava
|
223.79±33.85
|
13.07±2.88
|
19.11±2.09
|
Rilwan et al 2022
|
Jos, Nigeria
|
cassava
|
479.87± 42.42
|
2.97 ±1.02
|
0.67 ±0.08
|
Jibiri & Abiodun, 2012
|
Ogun State, Nigeria
|
cassava
|
17.97 ± 1.24
|
2.25 ± 0.40
|
2.62 ± 0.16
|
Jwanbot et al 2012
|
Jos, Nigeria
|
cassava
|
67.27 ± 4.55
|
77.51±4.99
|
28.86±5.79
|
Avwiri et al 2021
|
Niger-Delta, Nigeria
|
cassava
|
746.08 ± 0.48
|
24.83 ± 10.87
|
859.41 ± 2.47
|
Ononugbo et al 2019
|
Delta state, Nigeria
|
cassava
|
27.2 ± 3.61
|
0.64 ± 0.21
|
0.57 ± 0.18
|
Doyi et al 2018
|
Ghana
|
cassava flour
|
91.78 ± 5.02
|
|
1.09 ± 0.17
|
Lopes et al 2018
|
Brazil
|
cassava
|
242.19±5.07
|
31.20±4.73
|
145.19±2.78
|
This study
|
Enugu, Nigeria
|
Statistical Analysis
Due to the wide variations of the radionuclide concentrations within the areas under study, a statistical analysis was performed on the activity concentration values. The statistical tool used to ascertain if there is a significant difference between the activity concentrations in the cassava samples obtained in the various areas was the ‘Analysis of Variance’ (ANOVA). In using this statistical tool, two hypotheses were propounded: the null and alternative hypothesis.
- The null hypothesis (H0)—implies that there is no significant difference in the mean values of the activity concentrations within the area.
- The alternative hypothesis (H1)—implies that there is a significant difference in the mean values of the activity concentrations within the area.
The statistics was performed using Microsoft EXCEL statistical package at 95% confidence level.
Table 5 shows the ANOVA result, for 40K in the cassava samples, the calculated F-value was higher than the F-critical, thereby making us reject H0 and accept H1. This implies that there is a statistically significant difference in the mean activity concentrations of 40K in the cassava samples within the three areas under investigation. Whereas 226Ra and 232Th shows no significant difference in the activity concentrations and HO was accepted. The difference in the mean activity concentration of 40K could be as a result of the different amount fertilizer applications by various farmers.
Table 5: ANOVA Results for the area under study
Groups
|
F-value
|
F-critical
|
Decision
|
40K
|
4.81
|
3.32
|
REJECT H0
|
226Ra
|
2.61
|
3.32
|
ACCEPT H0
|
232Th
|
0.79
|
3.32
|
ACCEPT H0
|
Daily Intake of Radionuclide
The estimated daily intakes of radionuclides through the consumption of studied cassava are shown in table 6. The mean daily intakes of the radionuclides 40K, 226Ra and 232Th for the three areas under study varied from 61.87-96.12 Bq; 7.35-11.89 Bq and 43.23-50.61 Bq respectively. 40K constituted the highest daily intake of the natural radionuclides followed by 232Th. Potassium-40 is usually of limited interest because, as an isotope of an essential element, it is homeostatically controlled in the human cells (Jibiri and Abiodun, 2012). The daily intake of 232Th in the cassava samples were higher than those of 226Ra.
Table 6: Daily intake of radionuclides and Annual effective Dose from the three areas under study
Sample code
|
Dint 40K (Bq)
|
Dint 226Ra (Bq)
|
Dint 232Th (Bq)
|
Total AED (mSv/yr)
|
A1
|
35.02
|
12.58
|
37.85
|
0.92
|
A2
|
59.28
|
13.64
|
36.56
|
1.56
|
A3
|
12.57
|
28.50
|
22.51
|
0.33
|
A4
|
57.33
|
5.88
|
54.27
|
1.51
|
A5
|
61.68
|
10.90
|
38.05
|
1.62
|
A6
|
83.70
|
18.50
|
58.21
|
2.20
|
A7
|
141.34
|
6.70
|
37.99
|
3.72
|
A8
|
102.18
|
11.70
|
44.82
|
2.69
|
A9
|
74.84
|
7.76
|
37.18
|
1.97
|
A10
|
52.02
|
15.69
|
55.51
|
1.37
|
A11
|
59.54
|
7.17
|
42.00
|
1.57
|
A12
|
87.74
|
3.74
|
53.83
|
2.31
|
A13
|
78.59
|
6.10
|
55.51
|
2.07
|
A14
|
77.45
|
9.99
|
59.83
|
2.04
|
A15
|
81.13
|
12.40
|
52.42
|
2.13
|
A16
|
59.10
|
14.00
|
67.97
|
1.55
|
A17
|
56.96
|
8.09
|
42.32
|
1.50
|
A18
|
36.41
|
5.14
|
50.34
|
0.96
|
A19
|
43.84
|
17.35
|
27.25
|
1.15
|
A20
|
61.50
|
14.79
|
49.27
|
1.62
|
PT1
|
78.59
|
6.10
|
55.44
|
2.07
|
PT2
|
131.45
|
10.62
|
18.98
|
3.46
|
PT3
|
104.56
|
6.19
|
29.77
|
2.75
|
PT4
|
95.23
|
5.24
|
60.48
|
2.50
|
PT5
|
57.78
|
4.48
|
46.26
|
1.52
|
PT6
|
70.72
|
6.16
|
49.32
|
1.86
|
PT7
|
73.83
|
14.99
|
22.00
|
1.94
|
PT8
|
96.78
|
9.73
|
49.48
|
2.54
|
PT9
|
135.26
|
7.15
|
65.00
|
3.56
|
PT10
|
88.43
|
7.80
|
53.12
|
2.33
|
PT11
|
88.27
|
3.95
|
49.29
|
2.32
|
PT12
|
132.67
|
5.89
|
61.47
|
3.49
|
mean
|
77.37
|
9.97
|
46.38
|
2.03
|
Annual effective dose
The total annual effective dose for the three radionuclides (40K, 226Ra and 232Th) in the area under study is presented in table 6, the values ranged from 0.33-3.72 mSv/yr, with a mean value of 2.03 mSv/yr. The annual effective dose for this study were higher than what Jibiri and Abiodun (2012), Hassan etal., (2021) obtained in their study, and also lower to what Jayasinghe et al., (2020) obtained for food crops from a high background area of Sri Lanka. The values obtained for this study were mostly higher than the world average values (120 μSv y−1 for uranium and thorium series radionuclides and 170 μSv y−1 for non-series 40K) reported by UNSCEAR (2000). From this study, it can be observed that the average radiation dose from the cassava samples in the study area exceeds the 1 mSv/yr as recommended by UNSCEAR (2000). Individuals consuming cassava from the study area stands the risks of receiving twice the recommended value of internal radiation ingestion of the food samples.