In this study, single cell transcription maps of bone and bone marrow tissue samples from patients with fresh and old fractures were systematically identified. Based on the gene expression characteristics of single cells, 18 different cell subgroups were identified, indicating the diversity of cell groups in bone tissue at different periods of fracture. In our analysis, 18 cell subsets were identified, and cluster10 (macrophages) and cluster5 (fibroblasts) were main newly discovered cell types compared with 13 cell subsets in the original article. By analyzing the changes of genes in different cell subpopulations in fresh and old fracture tissues, we found that in fibroblasts, the expression altered significantly by differential expressed genes identification.
Fibroblasts play an important role in fracture healing. Fibroblasts are regulated by inflammatory cytokines and secrete inflammatory cytokines that regulate immune processes. IL-1β and TNF-α promote fibroblast proliferation and also promote prostaglandin E2 expression, which in turn inhibits fibroblast proliferation [9]. Fibroblasts express a variety of TLR receptors and therefore secrete a large number of cytokines in response to pathogens and injuries [10]. Poly(I:C), LPS, bacterial lipoprotein, and flagellin stimulate fibroblasts to secrete IL-6 [11]. Cytokines secreted by fibroblasts regulate T cells, B cells and macrophages. These immune cells secrete a large amount of cytokines to promote the absorption of necrotic tissue and the formation of new blood vessels. At the same time, they can also regulate the balance of osteoblasts and osteoclasts [12, 13]. In addition, different cell subsets of fibroblasts have different functions, with some promoting inflammation and others inhibiting it [14].
In our study, the most prominent one is that the expression of TXNIP gene is significantly increased in fibroblasts of old fracture samples. This gene encodes a thioredoxin-binding protein that is a member of the alpha arrestin protein family. Thioredoxin is a thiol-oxidoreductase that is a major regulator of cellular redox signaling which protects cells from oxidative stress. This protein inhibits the antioxidative function of thioredoxin resulting in the accumulation of reactive oxygen species and cellular stress. This protein also functions as a regulator of cellular metabolism and of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress. Knocking down TXNIP in osteoblasts promoted osteogenic differentiation, and culture osteoclasts with TXNIP silenced osteoblast supernatant increased the activity of osteoclasts [15]. Recent study found that tanshinol activated TXNIP pathway to inhibit microcirculation disturbance, then improved bone quality [16]. We speculate that TXNIP elevation in old fracture samples inhibit osteoblast differentiation and promote osteoclast absorption. In addition, (cluster10) macrophages, as a versatile cell type, has also attracted attention in recent years for its role in the process of fracture repair.
Mcarophages take participate in inflammatory stage and play an important role in fracture healing [17]. In animal modal, depletion of macrophages reduced expression of oncostatin M, collagen type 1 and decreased bone mineralization thorugh reducing the production of oncostatin M. Osteogenic differentiation of MSCs obviously reduced due to lack of macropahges induction, resulted in reduced callus formation and bone deposition [18, 19].
Macrophages produced a series of cytokines promote angiogenesis and formation of primary cartilaginous calluses [20], such as IL-1, IL-6, TNF-α, CCL2. Rencet study have shown that macrophages also play an important role in late fracture. Proinflammatory cytokines produced by macrophages affect osteoblast and osteoclast differentiation. Bone morphogenetic protein 2, bone morphogenetic protein 4, and TGF-b1 secreted by macrophages promote osteogenesis [19]. Recent study have shown that macrophages promote osteogenic differentiation of BMSCs through secreting macrophage scavenger receptor 1 to activate PI3K pathway [21].Recent studies have shown that M1, M2 and DC cells are recruited to the fracture site in the early stage of fracture repair, which may synergically regulate inflammation and participate in osteoblast recruitment in the later stage of fracture repair. The number of M1 cells at the fracture site was correlated with the expression of IL-1α, IL-1ß, IL-2, IL-17, Eotaxin, and MCP-1, and the number of DCs was correlated with the expression of IL-6, G-CSF, LIF, KC, and VEGF-A [22, 23]. Reducing the number of macrophages has no effect on the early stage of fracture healing, but will affect the formation of endochondral ossification in the later stage, leading to slower fracture healing. M2-type macrophages increased significantly in ossification stage [23].
Our results show that AREG expression is elevated in old fracture samples. AREG secreted by macrophages drived fibroblast proliferation [24]. AREG is related to epidermal growth factor EGF and TGF-α, which promote the growth of epithelial cells [25]. Expression of AREG influence bone development which was stimulated by Parathyroid hormone and bone growth promoting hormone in osteoblasts and bone tissue. Importantly, the tibial trabecular bones of AREG-deficient mice were significantly smaller than those of wild-type mice [26]. We speculated that the proliferation of macrophages in old bone tissue may influence the number of fibroblasts through the secretion of AREG, then hinder bone healing.
It was observed that macrophages and other cell subsets exhibited the most extensive and intensive connections when the interaction links between various cell groups were examined. Especially in the old fracture samples, Macrophages possess a broad array of ligands and engage in many cellular interactions. The most significant important of these is the ANXA1-FRP1 signaling pathway. Previous studies have shown that ANXA1-FRP1 signaling pathway plays an important role in inflammatory response, and their interaction enhance anti-inflammatory effects [27]. Old fracture samples are mainly at the stage of callus formation and bone remodeling. Macrophages at this stage mainly play an anti-inflammatory role, release tissue repair factors, and recruit stem cells to promote osteoblastic differentiation [28].
To sum up, we speculate that macrophages in fracture tissue affect the function of cluster0 (neutrophils), cluster5 (fibroblasts), ISG cells) and cluster14 (mDC cells) through ANXA1-FRP1 signal pathway. At present, the function of macrophages in fracture repair is unclear. This study further demonstrated that macrophages influence the function of other immune cells in bone through ANXA-FRP1 signaling pathways in the late stage of fracture repair, thus affecting osteogenic differentiation.