3.1. The conserved nature of rLdRab1
This study utilizes molecular biology methods to express and purify the protein after cloning the LdRab1 sequence from the NCBI Ld database. The recombinant protein rLdRab1 has 222 amino acid residues, 55 of which are charged, and 6 of the histidines are at the N-terminus. Rab subfamily-specific structural components have been identified as conserved in all eukaryotic isoforms. [5]. Multiple sequence alignment of rLdRab1 performed using BLAST identified the small GTP and P-loop NTPase superfamily domain, the Rab1 family (RabF1-F5), Rab subfamily (RabSF2-SF4), GDI and GEF interaction elements, as defined for Rab proteins (Fig. S1) [5, 10].
The secondary structure prediction tools JPRED (https://www.compbio.dundee.ac.uk/jpred/), PredictProtein (https://predictprotein.org/), Phyre2 (http://www.sbg.bio.ic.ac.uk/~phyre2/html/page.cgi?id=index) estimate residue stretches 13-20, 48-58, 61-68, 89-95, 122-127, 153-157 to be participating in β strand formation; and 27-34, 73-84, 100-115, 140-149, 165-183 to compose helices (Fig. S2A). Homology alignments determined up to 90% similarity in the orientation and organization of beta and alpha stretches and an alpha-beta 3-layer (aba) sandwich at C end of rLdRab1 with lower protozoa like Cryptosporidium parvum (Fig. S2B) and up to 70 % with Rab 8A (2fu5) from Mus musculus (Fig. S2C) and YPT1 (1yzn) from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Fig. S2D). A study elucidating the molecular functions of a Rab1 homologue from L. donovani reported up to ~80% similarity of the homologue with protozoan parasites, yeast and mice [8]. The sequence identity with rLdRab1 is low but there exists considerable structural similarity. Such homology between Rab isoforms has been previously reported. However, Rab1 isoforms in Leishmania genus is not previously discussed. This protein is implicated to function as a molecular switch to regulate vesicle trafficking pathways [7, 27].
The 3-D structure was modelled and analysed using SWISS Model (https://swissmodel.expasy.org/) and PHYRE2 (Fig. S3). The ribbon diagram generated depicts acidic residues in red and the basic residues in blue. The hydrophobic β strands occupy the buried core protein, whereas the helix and loop region are relatively solvent interactive. Such models of Rab1 have been elucidated and described. Globe predictions suggest rLdRab1 to be loose globular, lacking the typical compactness of a globular domain (table S2). A possible disulfide bonding is predicted between Cys 215, 216 (table S3).
3.2. pH induced unfolding is a non-two-state process
The solution behaviour of rLdRab1 isoform was predicted using sequence-based in silco analysis and biophysical techniques. Various in silico physico-chemical characteristics of rLdRab1 computed by ExPASy ProtParam (https://web.expasy.org/protparam/) are listed in table S1. The protein is slightly basic with a pI of 8.52. The aliphatic index which defines the relative volume occupied by the aliphatic side chain was computed to be 65.6. For thermostable proteins, the reported aliphatic index is garter than 90. This suggests rLdRab1 to be partially unstable or short-lived. As an index for protein hydrophobicity, Grand average of hydropathicity (GRAVY) was computed to be – 0.544. Proteins with a GRAVY score above 0 are more likely to be hydrophobic. This states the mild hydrophilic and polar nature of rLdRab1 isoform.
To understand the biophysical nature of rLdRab1 unfolding, the tertiary alterations induced on lowering the solution pH were monitored by intrinsic fluorescence at 340 nm and ANS fluorescence at 480 nm (Fig. 1A, B). IF and ANS assay effectively monitor the alterations in 3-D conformations on denaturation. Intrinsic fluorescence spectrum reflects the perturbation around the local interactions of Tyr and Trp residues. The fluorescence obtained by exciting the protein at 280 nm is due to tryptophan residues and energy transfer from the tyrosine residues, whereas the fluorescence obtained by the excitation at 297 nm is mainly due to tryptophan. Trp fluorescence is sensitive to the polarity of its micro-environment. Spectral properties such as λmax and intensity convey valuable information about the local solvent environment [28, 29]. rLdRab1 possess three tryptophanyl residues at position 146, 108 and 68 and two of the tyrosinyl residues at 13, 84 are predicted to have up to 25 % of solvent accessibility, whereas tyrosinyl placed at 40, 43 and 58 are relatively solvent interactive (Fig. S4).
The pH dependence of tryptophanyl fluorescence has been described earlier [30]. Signals of the fluorescence probes in the pH range 6 – 8 suggest stable native like conformations. A gradual decrease IF intensities accompanied by increase in ANS fluorescence is observed as pH is reduced from 5.5 to 3.0 (Fig. 1A-C). This corresponds to the unfolding transitions from native structures as ANS fluorescence is a direct estimate of surface exposed hydrophobic elements. Further decrease in pH saturates the lowest IF intensities and maximum ANS fluorescence (Fig. 1A-C). This illustrates accumulation of an unfolded intermediate below pH 3. The midpoint of transition from all three probes was calculated around pH 4 (Fig. 1D). However, differences in the slopes of unfolding (Fig. 2D) resulted in non-superimposable transitions (Fig. 1C, D). Hence there exists more than one transition intermediates during the acidic unfolding of rLdRab1. This intermediate which accumulates in the low pH range 1.5-3 demonstrates typical characteristics described for protein folding intermediates: an exposed hydrophobic core and loose structural arrangements [31, 32]. Similar observations have been described for a rLdRab5 and its mutants wherein urea induced unfolding accumulated at least three intermediate states [10].
3.3. The partially unfolded intermediate at pH 2
The rLdRab1 isoform purified at pH 6.5 was physically denatured at pH 2 and chemically in 6 M GuHCl. The content of secondary structure and tertiary conformations in different solution conditions were elucidated by far UV CD and fluorescence probes respectively (Fig. 2). The far UV CD spectrum of rLdRab1 isoform converted to MRE measured negative peaks at 209 nm and 222 nm at pH 6.5 (Fig. 2A). The negative ellipticity at 209 is dominant than that at 222 nm, which corresponds to the α+β structural class of proteins. The CD spectrum is significantly resembles to lysozyme, a model α+β protein [24]. The helical content of native rLdRab1 isoform was determined to be 38 % which is close to the estimated values of secondary structure prediction tools (32.41 %, 23.61 % and 43.98 %, respectively of helix, extended beta and loop structures and belonging to the α+β class). The isoform is almost unfolded in 6 M GuHCl, with only ~10 % of secondary structure (Fig. 2A). At pH 2, the negative ellipticity at 208 nm and 222 nm were observed to be similar in magnitude with a net 25 % loss in secondary structure (Fig. 2A). The tendency to adopt helix or beta transitions were estimated by ellipticity ratios (table 1). θ205/θ222 was calculated for disorder changes, θ216/θ222 for beta structures and θ222/θ208 for helical nature [33]. θ222/θ208 at each pH was calculated to be < 1 which demonstrates a predominantly helical nature of the rLdRAb1 isoform at both pH (table 1). The marginal 4% increase in θ215/θ222 at pH 2 along with more than half the decrease in θ204/θ222 corelates to a mild beta tendency following decreased in unstructured or disorder and helicity upon unfolding at pH 2 (table 1).
Table 1: Biophysical characterization of conformational states formed in pH 2, pH 6.5 and 6 M GuHCl.
Variables
|
pH 2
|
pH 6.5
|
6 M GuHCl
|
[θ]222 (deg.cm2.dmol-1)
|
-8725.65
|
-11890.40
|
-1853.15
|
% helix
|
29.00 ± 0.14
|
37.96 ± 0.18
|
12.44 ± 0.05
|
[θ]222/[θ]208
|
1.09 ± 0.06
|
0.82 ± 0.01
|
-
|
[θ]215/[θ]222
|
1.11 ± 0.01
|
1.06 ± 0.06
|
2.16 ± 0.18
|
[θ]204/[θ]222
|
0.25 ± 0.05
|
0.98 ± 0.08
|
|
λmax (nm) (IF)
|
340 ± 1.4
|
337 ± 1.3
|
352 ± 1.0
|
I360/I330 (IF)
|
0.91
|
0.78
|
1.07
|
I340 (IF)
|
601.72
|
1392.51
|
94.39
|
λmax (nm) (TRP F)
|
339 ± 0.64
|
337 ± 0.52
|
|
I360/I330 (TRP F)
|
0.92
|
0.79
|
|
I340 (TRP F)
|
252.56
|
581.82
|
|
ANS FI 480 nm
|
1708.061
|
39.872
|
50.406
|
The IF spectra of rLDRab1 at pH 6.5 pH 2and exhibits λmax in the 336-338 and 336-340 nm range (Fig. 2B). The pH 2 unfolded isoform records marginally broader λmax with ~2 nm red shift and ~55 % quenched fluorescence (Fig.2B, table 1). Solvent interacting Trp residues have reported λmax of ~345-350 nm [29]. The isoform is almost fully denatured in 6 M GuHCl. ANS dye strongly interacts with exposed hydrophobic clusters, which significantly enhances fluorescence of the bound dye. ANS fluorescence directly corelates with exposed hydrophobic surfaces and efficiently monitors solvent exposure of hydrophobic clusters upon unfolding [34, 35]. ANS fluorescence of rLdRab1 at pH 6.5 and 6 M GuHCl overlap (Fig 2C), whereas there is ~12-fold increase at pH 2. This corresponds to perturbation of the core hydrophobic clusters, making their surface accessible for ANS binding. The results demonstrate the passage of acid-mediated denaturation of rLdRab1 through exposure of core hydrophobic clusters, retaining partial proportions of secondary and tertiary structure.
3.4. Aggregation kinetics
The phenomenon of protein aggregation describes the passage of soluble conformers generally partial or wrongly folded through a nucleation dependent mechanism to defined fibrillar aggregates [36]. Aggregation can proceed from either of the conformations that exist during protein folding, function, or degradations [37]. Since a partially unfolded intermediate accumulates at pH 2, its tendency to form amyloid aggregates was studied. The sequence of LdRab1 was studied for its amyloid behaviour in silico using AMYLPRED [38], which predicted stretches 14-23, 46-51, 70-83, 90-94 of LdRab1 sequence as aggregation prone. In vitro amyloid fibril formation of various model and diseased proteins have been described at pH 2 at various temperatures. [39, 40]. Time course of amyloid formation of 2 mg/ml rLdRab1 (~72 µM) at pH 2.0 and pH 6.5 at 310 K was followed by ThT fluorescence at 485 nm (Fig. 3). A sigmoidal increase in ThT fluorescence was observed at pH 2, which saturated after 5 days of incubation. To calculate parameters of aggregation kinetics, the data points was fitted with non-linear regression conveying a nucleation dependent model (Fig. 3). Lag time of ~ 68 h and half time of ~87 h was calculated. On the other hand, rLdRab1 at pH 6.5 did not record any significant ThT binding. After 72 h, precipitate like particles resulting in a turbid reaction mixture suggested amorphous aggregation (Fig. 3). The aggregation products present in the reaction mixtures after a period of 7 days were characterised by its tinctorial properties, secondary structure, and morphology.
3.5. Characterization of final aggregates
The morphology of the final aggregation products formed at pH 2.0 and pH 6.5 was examined up on negative staining using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) at a magnification of 60000X (Fig. 4). At pH 2, dense needle-like formations between 200 and 400 nm in length were observed (Fig. 4A). These structures resemble the protofibrils reported for various proteins in similar conditions [41–43]. At pH 6.5, the protein is converted into amorphous aggregates (Fig. 4B).
The secondary structures of aggregation products were determined by far-UV CD (Fig. 5). The protofibril formed at pH 2 (pH 2a) showed a single broad negative peak spanning 212 – 219 nm, typically described for extended β structures (Fig. 5A) [25]. The aggregates at pH 6.5 (pH 6.5a) record negative peaks at 209 nm and 222nm (Fig. 5A). There is a significant loss of CD signals as compared to native state at pH 6.5 (pH 6.5n). The structural transitions from native to the aggregated state is estimated from ellipticity ratios (Fig. 5B). Ellipticity ratio of θ222/θ208 of pH 6.5 aggregates (pH 6.5a) was calculated to be 1.1, suggesting dominance of helical nature in the aggregates. A decrease in disorder as well as beta content was observed. In protofibrils at pH 2, the decrease in disorder and increase in beta content is observed. The aggregates appear to retain helical nature of the recombinant protein.
Amyloid fibrils exhibit tinctorial (dye binding) properties which result in change in the spectral characteristics of the dyes [35]. The tinctorial characteristics of aggregates at pH 2 and pH 6.5 are described in Fig. 6 using ThT assay, CR difference spectra, ANS assay, and right-angle scattering (RLS). Fluorescence and difference spectroscopy of the dyes ThT and CR respectively, provide information of the content of β sheets as they specifically bind to cross β grooves [35, 44]. The protofibril-like aggregation products formed at pH 2 illustrate strong binding with ThT resulting in ~60% increase in ThT fluorescence (Fig. 6A) and a positive CR differential absorption (Fig. 6B). This demonstrates the presence and dominance of amyloid-like cross β sheet structures in the protofibrils. ~12-fold enhanced fluorescence ANS is observed in pH 2 formed aggregates (Fig. 6C) illustrating the significantly exposed hydrophobic clusters. Aggregation products of pH 6.5 do not present any tinctorial binding illustrating non amyloid, amorphous products. Light scattering (Fig. 6D) on the other hand provides information on particulate material present in the solution. Aggregates at pH 6.5 record ~50% higher RLS which determines its amorphous nature.