The latest ESC guidelines on cardio-oncology propose biomarker- and echocardiography-based screening strategies for the early diagnosis of CTRCD. This single-center prospective cohort study, which followed the ESC guidelines for patients with breast cancer receiving anthracycline-based chemotherapy, offers several insights. First, hsTnT levels peaked 3 months after the first initiation of anthracycline agents (i.e., completing 4-cycle of anthracyclines). Second, LV systolic function deteriorated over time, but it only became prominent enough to be diagnosed with CTRCD within 6 months. Finally, the increase in hsTnT, but not BNP, was significantly associated with the subsequent development of CTRCD, particularly when the absolute value exceeded 0.018 ng/ml or the increase from baseline exceeded 0.009 ng/ml.
Recently, the Strain Surveillance of Chemotherapy for Improving Cardiovascular Outcomes (SUCCOUR) trial reported the efficacy of treating early detected cardiotoxicity with cardioprotective agents, and the use of TTE with strain analysis has gained widespread acceptance as a convenient, less invasive, and sensitive modality for detecting CTRCD.10 Cardinale et al. previously demonstrated that the most significant deterioration of LVEF occurs within 6 months,14 while most studies have shown that the onset of GLS decline occurs mostly 3 months after the first initiation of anthracyclines.17–21 A similar trend was observed in our study for both LVEF and GLS. The incidence of CTRCD was found to be 20% by the GLS-based definition and 2.2% by the LVEF-based definition, which is also consistent with previous studies.17,22, 23 However, our study reached different conclusions from past similar studies involving patients with relatively preserved EF, insignificant baseline hsTnT values, and a significant increase in hsTnT.18,24
Few studies have addressed both biomarkers and echocardiographic parameters simultaneously for a longer period.18 However, the results are conflicting with regard to the timing of the decline in cardiac function and the association between the decline in cardiac function and the increase in cardiac troponins. Elevated cardiac troponin is a matter of debate in predicting the deterioration of LV function, as findings have been inconsistent across studies, including multiple foci on malignancies.25,26 Data on the difference in cardiac troponin levels between patients with or without CTRCD are limited, but several studies reporting an increase in cardiac troponin after initiating anthracyclines were usually detected after three or four cycles of administration, regardless of the type of malignancy, dose, regimen, and protocol.17– 21
Currently, the benefit of early detection of the rise in cardiac troponins remains inconclusive, as demonstrated by the Prevention of Cardiac Dysfunction During Adjuvant Breast Cancer Therapy (PRADA) trial,27 which showed that cardioprotective agents can treat the rise in troponins but failed to demonstrate an association with cardiac function parameters. In contrast, a small-scale study suggested the feasibility of repeated measurement of cardiac troponin and early drug treatment in preventing CTRCD.8 The lack of consistency between the results of these trials may be due, in part, to the unclear cutoff for cardiac troponin, which is used to define myocardial damage that is strongly associated with future cardiac dysfunction and clinical outcomes. The cutoffs for hsTnT presented in our study indicate good discrimination but require further validation in larger studies. The current Cardiac CARE study28 addressed this point and clarified the future role of measuring cardiac troponins.
The ability of cardiac troponin levels to predict CTRCD may also be influenced by ethnicity. Some studies have reported a higher susceptibility to CTRCD in patients of African ancestry,29 but to our knowledge, no previous studies have examined the difference in the increase in cardiac troponins among different ethnicities. In the present study, both the absolute value and/or the change in hsTnT values and the incidence of CTRCD were similar to those of a previous study with different ethnicities.24 Even though certain genetic variants have been identified as high or low risk,15 our study suggests that hsTnT levels and the incidence of CTRCD after initiating anthracyclines in patients with breast cancer are not significantly different in the monoracial Japanese population compared with Western populations.
The differences in chemotherapy protocols may explain the variation in conclusions related to the increase in hsTnT levels. Taxane and cyclophosphamide are also known to cause myocardial dysfunction, with varying incidences depending on the agent and dose. For instance, docetaxel has been reported to affect 2.3–13% of the population, whereas the incidence of paclitaxel is less than 1%.30 For cyclophosphamide, the incidence varies from 7–28% depending on its dose.30,31 However, few studies have addressed the difference in protocols with the same chemotherapeutic agents. In addition, no comparative studies have evaluated the cardiotoxicity of different agents in the same class. Previous studies have implied that epirubicin may be less likely than doxorubicin to cause myocardial dysfunction.9 In our study, most patients received epirubicin, but the cumulative dose exceeded 250 mg/m2 doxorubicin equivalent, which is considered as a large amount; thus, recommended to follow up hsTnT as Class IIa in the ESC guidelines.15 Our result may well support the recommendation to measure the hsTnT of patients who are to receive the amount of anthracycline, and they may be considered to start monthly follow-ups of echocardiography for the subsequent 3 months in order to start cardioprotective agents and even SGLT2 inhibitor, which is suggested to be effective in preventing the decline of LV function by emerging results.32
In facilities, acquiring reliable GLS is difficult; hence, hsTnT is undoubtedly a reliable biomarker to detect patients, especially those categorized as low-risk, who need to be referred for close cardiac surveillance. Highly-sensitive cardiac troponin can also contribute to populations for whom obtaining echocardiographic images of sufficient quality for analysis is challenging. A prospective study reported that approximately 10% of cases failed to measure the GLS due to insufficient image quality (e.g., left mastectomy and left breast prosthesis),33 which is comparable to the results of our study. As long as the quality of echocardiographic images is reported to influence the evaluation of CTRCD,33 further efforts should be made to identify the true cutoffs of hsTnT and to identify the ideal use for early detection of CTRCD to address the weakness of echocardiographic evaluation.
Our study has several limitations. First, the results were derived from a single university hospital with a single ethnic group. Second, most of our study population had a low to moderate risk of a cardiovascular event; hence, the results should be interpreted accordingly. Third, our study population incorporated a minor variance in chemotherapeutic agents, such as a small number of patients receiving doxorubicin and/or paclitaxel, whereas most patients received epirubicin and docetaxel, which might have affected the results. Fourth, a certain number of patients (10%) were excluded from the present analysis because of the low quality of echocardiographic images due to left-sided surgery or radiotherapy.