Auxins and cytokinins are the most commonly used PGRs in plant tissue culture (George et al. 2008); therefore, regeneration is usually limited when PGRs are removed from the medium. In this experiment, only some shoots were regenerated in PGR-free media, but most of them showed albino symptoms, which is consistent with the results of Farhadi et al. (2017) and Hailekidan et al. (2013).
Our results showed that the combination of auxins with cytokinins increased the number of regenerates. The type and number of organs regenerated from explants directly depended on the type and concentration of PGRs and also on the plant species. In contrast to other studies, we found that IBA has a better effect on the proliferation rate, especially through bulblet production. Ren et al. (2018) emphasized that bulblet production in Lycoris sprengeri was enhanced when 1 mg/l of NAA was used. In addition, it is reported that the simultaneous use of NAA and BAP was the best hormone combination for bulblet proliferation in Lilium Hybrid Cv. 'Ravenna' (Rafiq et al. 2021) and Narcissus tazzeta L. (Rahimi Khonakdari et al. 2020). Although IBA is basically used for root induction in propagated regenerates (George et al. 2008), in our experiment, the number of roots, shoots and bulblets increased significantly with the addition of IBA.
No callus was obtained in either experiment, indicating that regenerates were produced by direct organogenesis. The absence of callus in the basal parts of the regenerants is very fruitful in adaptation because the vascular system of the root and the vascular system of the plantlet are better connected. Although the effect of different basal media on the regenerative ability of in vitro cultured plants has been investigated in numerous studies (Kairuz et al. 2021; Tahiri et al. 2022; Pullaiah et al. 2022), there have been no reports on the effectiveness of basal media in bulbous plants under in vitro conditions. The use of five different media in this study showed that some media, including N6, B5, and WPM, limited the regenerative ability of explants. On the other hand, the CLC and MS media showed the highest regeneration potential for all types of regenerations under light conditions. The CLC medium was specifically developed by Chée et al. (1992) to enhance somatic embryogenesis of Ipomoea batatas. Considering composition of the different incorporated media, we find that CLC and MS media have similar compositions, except for NH4NO3 and MgSo4.7H2O, which are present in about half the concentration in the CLC medium than in the MS medium. In order to clearly compare the studied media, the concentration of macroelements in each medium was calculated (Table 4). A principal component analysis was then performed to reduce the dimensionality of the obtained data and to increase interpretability. A biplot was then generated based on the first two components (Fig. 1), which explained more than 98 percent of the variability. The distribution of media and elements on the biplot diagram shows that there is a close relationship between the media CLC and MS; moreover, the element N is located near these two media, suggesting a high effectiveness of the element N on the mentioned media composition. The total concentration of N and the ratio of nitrate (NH4+) to ammonium (NO3−) ions are two important factors to consider when formulating a media for different plant species is in demand (George et al., 2008). The amount of NH4+ and also total nitrogen is high in MS and CLC medium compared to other media. Reduced nitrogen (NH4+) is generally available in lower amounts than nitrate in various media compositions, but organogenesis is highly dependent on its presence (Drew 2015). Luciani et al. (2001) demonstrated that proliferation rates of garlic clones can be improved by using higher amounts of nitrogen. (Kumar et al. 2007) concluded that nitrogen-containing compounds have a crucial effect on bulblet initiation and enlargement in in vitro culture of Oriental lilies.
Table 4
The concentration of the different elements (mM) in five basal media used in this experiment
Element | | Media |
| MS | N6 | CLC | B5 | WPM |
Ca | | 2.99 | 1.13 | 2.99 | 1.02 | 3 |
Cl | | 5.98 | 2.26 | 5.98 | 2.04 | 1.3 |
K | | 20.04 | 30.93 | 20.04 | 24.73 | 12.61 |
P | | 1.25 | 2.94 | 1.25 | 1.09 | 1.25 |
N | | 60.01 | 34.99 | 38.79 | 26.75 | 14.7 |
MG | | 1.5 | 0.75 | 1.5 | 1.01 | 1.5 |
Plant species respond specifically to light regime and intensity, so it is important to evaluate light efficacy in each plant in vitro. Our results showed that in darkness, root production was reduced, shoot multiplication was moderately affected, but bulblet production was completely reduced. According to George et al. (2008), adventitious shoots can regenerate in the dark, but they are basically stronger in the light.
Root production can be stimulated or inhibited in light (Li et al. 2021). Regeneration of adventitious roots on explants appears to be affected by light energy. However, in some plants, root induction is enhanced in darkness, possibly due to natural auxin enhancement under these conditions.
The effect of light on bulblet regeneration has been emphasized in numerous reports. Rahimi Khonakdari et al. (2020) reported that the average bulblet production ratio under light conditions was twice that under dark conditions. Cheesman et al. (2010) showed that bulblet formation was completely suppressed in Eucomis zambesiaca in total darkness, which is consistent with our results. In contrast, bulblet regeneration was increased in Lilium longiflorum (Kumar et al. 2006) in continuous darkness.