Trial design
This is a prospective, single-center, three-blind, randomized controlled clinical trial.Table 1 shows the overview of the trial methods and design.
Table 1 Chinese clinical Trial Registry data set
Data category
|
Information
|
Primary registry and trial identifying number
Date of registration in primary registry
Date of Last Refreshed on
Registration Status
Source(s) of funding
Primary sponsor and Secondary sponsor
Contact for scientific queries
Public title
Scientific title
Countries of recruitment
Target disease
Study type
Objectives of Study
Intervention(s)
Key inclusion and exclusion criteria
Target sample size
Recruitment status
Primary outcome(s)
Key secondary outcomes
|
Chinese Clinical Trial Registry number:ChiCTR2200057591
15/03/2022
14/11/2022
1008001 Prospective registration
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine,General Hospital of Western Theater Command
N/A
CC,[email protected]
Comparative study of different doses of platelet-rich plasma in the treatment of meniscus injury of grade I and II knee joint in young people
Comparative study of different doses of platelet-rich plasma in the treatment of meniscus injury of grade I and II knee joint in young people
China
Knee meniscus injury
Observational study
To explore the clinical appropriate dose of PRP in the treatment of meniscus injury of knee joint in young people
PRP treated low(2ml), medium(5ml) and high(8ml) dose intervention groups
The placebo group was plasma
Ages eligible for study: 18-44yr
Sexes eligible for study: both
Inclusion criteria:1. Patients in line with clinical diagnosis and MRI shows meniscus injury of degree Ⅰ and Ⅱ;2. Young people aged 18 to 44 with full capacity for civil conduct should be selected;3. Hb > 120g/L, PLT > 120*10^9/L;4. The coagulation function and transmission of nine normal;5. Subjects do not take glucosamine hydrochloride and other drugs to protect articular cartilage or received injection of sodium hyaluronate within 3 months before the test;6. Subjects and their families are informed of the research content and voluntarily sign relevant agreements. (1) Exclusion criteria:1. Those who do not cooperate with the study;2. Patients with serious articular cartilage injury and cruciate ligament injury without repair or reconstruction;3. Injection site infection;4. Sepsis;5. Patients with dysfunction of important organs such as heart, liver and kidney;6.Patients with complicated immunodeficiency or severe infection; 7.Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory and analgesic drugs have not been stopped for more than 48 hours;8. Hematopoietic system or skeletal system tumors;9.Systemic corticosteroid treatment is not stopped for more than 2 weeks.
84
Recruiting
Lysholm scale,MRI(including T2mapping technology)
VAS,SF-36,infrared thermal imaging,musculoskeletal ultrasound
|
Trial setting
General Hospital of Western Theater Command is used as the test base in this experiment, which is a large comprehensive Grade-A hospital integrating medical treatment, teaching, scientific research and health management.The rehabilitation medicine discipline the researchers work in is the key discipline of the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the Paraplegia Diagnosis and Rehabilitation Center of the whole Army, the Clinical Medical Research Center of Orthopedics and Sports Rehabilitation of Traditional Chinese Medicine of Sichuan Province and the quality specialty of Lianqin Medicine, which has a good research foundation.The relevant medical staff involved have carried out PRP treatment for more than 4 years, accepted at least nearly 1,000 patients, and have mastered the key technology of PRP treatment. Training on standardized registration, randomization, rehabilitation intervention, evaluation and data collection is also conducted.
Eligibility criteria
The target population for this study are those who met the consolidated inclusion criteria:
- According to the 2018 edition of "BASK National Consensus" [13] diagnostic criteria, and MRI diagnosis of meniscus injury Ⅰ, Ⅱ degree injury;
- According to WHO "Age Division Criteria", young people aged 18 to 44 with full capacity for civil conduct should be selected;
- Hb>120g/L,PLT>120×10 9 /L[14] ;
- The coagulation function and transmission of nine normal;
- Subjects do not take glucosamine hydrochloride and other drugs to protect articular cartilage or received injection of sodium hyaluronate within 3 months before the test;
- Subjects and their families are informed of the study content and voluntarily sign the relevant agreement.
The exclusion criteria are as follows[15] :
- Those who do not cooperate with this study;
- Patients with serious articular cartilage injury and cruciate ligament injury without repair or reconstruction;
- Patients with degree III meniscus injury undergoing surgery or (and) without surgery;
- Abnormal coagulation function: platelet dysfunction syndrome, thrombocytopenia, hemorrhagic disease, etc.
- Injection site infection;
- Sepsis;
- Patients with heart, liver, kidney and other important organ dysfunction;
- Patients with complicated immunodeficiency or severe infection;
- Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory and analgesic drugs have not been stopped for more than 48 hours;
- Hematopoietic or skeletal system tumors;
- Hb<100g/L,PLT<105×109/L;
- Systemic corticosteroid therapy is discontinued for less than 2 weeks.
Recruitment, randomization and allocation
The patients who may be qualified are initially screened by rehabilitation doctors through consultation, physical examination and check. The commissioner guides the patient to prepare according to the trial procedure.
The SPSS software is used for random grouping.Because patients tend to be enrolled one after another,therefore, before the start of the experiment, patients will be randomly assigned to different groups according to the enrollment order of patients and the corresponding random number, and the grouping is hidden.Once the trial is initiated, patients who meet the inclusion criteria can be directly enrolled into the corresponding group according to the pre-determined protocol.Eligible patients are provided with informed consent that explained in detail the significance of the trial, the process of randomization, inconsistent rehabilitation protocols, treatment procedures, and possible adverse effects.Those who agree will sign consent forms as required by the Ethics Committee and in accordance with the "Declaration of Helsinki".Figure 1 shows an overview of recruitment, random allocation, and allocation based on the CONSORT principle.
Blinding
The plasma placebo group has the same color and appearance as the PRP group, except for the absence of platelet therapy components.Neither the patient nor the operator can identify the specific component,All the blood components on the blood bag shall be covered with black after examination by therapists, nurses and blood transfusion medical personnel, who will not participate in PRP operation.Researchers randomly grouped patients by SPSS software. PRP operators only checked and operated with patients' general information and recorded the injection volume without knowing the blood composition and grouping.The efficacy is evaluated by a third person who do not know the grouping status;In the data summary stage, all data are analyzed by a third party to separate researchers and statisticians.
Interventions
Control group
The control group is plasma placebo group, and patients can receive a set of knee meniscus rehabilitation treatment plan in the 2018 edition of the American Physical Therapy Association's "Joint Pain and Movement Disorders due to meniscus and knee cartilage Injury" clinical practice guidelines [16],and appropriate rehabilitation guidance.At the same time, different doses of subgroups of knee joint cavity puncture plasma injection operation.
Experimental group
The experimental group is PRP treatment group. In addition to the above rehabilitation treatment plan and guidance, knee joint puncture injection PRP treatment is performed for subgroups with different doses [3].
Withdrawal from trial
Patients will be withdrawn for either of the following:
- Those cases that do not meet the inclusion criteria and are mistakenly included should be eliminated;
- Those who do not affect data collection and safety evaluation according to the requirements should be excluded;
- Subjects with poor compliance and self-withdrawal;
- Cases that are discontinued due to serious adverse events that make continuation of the trial unsuitable.
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
Lysholm score scale is used to evaluate the changes of knee function.At the same time, magnetic resonance imaging (including T2mapping technology) is used for quantitative analysis. T2 relaxation time is measured by magnetic resonance T2mapping imaging technology. The water content, composition and anisotropy changes of collagen fibers in meniscus are noninvasive detected at the molecular level to evaluate the physiological and pathological status of meniscus. Quantitative analysis of meniscus damage and repair healing state in early stage.
The scale is assessed by an unwitting third person,and the MRI is diagnosed by a radiologist.
Secondary outcome
Visual analogue scale (VAS) and infrared thermal imaging [17] are used to evaluate the changes of patients' pain, and quality of life score (36-item Short Form Health Survey) is used to evaluate patients' quality of life. The musculoskeletal ultrasonography is used for semi-quantitative evaluation of meniscus injury morphology and signal.
In the meantime,the incidence of adverse events and compliance evaluation indexes are set for safety evaluation.
Data collection
Lysholm scale and VAS score are followed up before treatment, 1 week, 3 weeks, 5 weeks and 1 month, 3 months, 6 months after treatment. SF-36, musculoskeletal ultrasound, MRI (including T2mapping), and infrared thermal imaging are followed up before and 3 and 6 months after treatment.Table 2 lists the planned data collection at each point in time.
Table 2 Scheduled events and timeline of trial
stage
|
Be selected
|
Treatment period & Follow-up period
|
Point in time
|
pre-treatment
|
First week of treatment
|
Third week of treatment
|
Fifth week of treatment
|
The first month after treatment
|
Three months after treatment
|
Six months after treatment
|
Basic medical history
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sign informed consent
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Determine inclusion and exclusion criteria
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fill in the basic information
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Compliance record
|
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
Observation outcomes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
VAS
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
Lysholm score scale
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
SF-36
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
√
|
√
|
Musculoskeletal ultrasound
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
√
|
√
|
MRI(including T2mapping technology)
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
√
|
√
|
Infrared thermal imaging
|
√
|
|
|
|
|
√
|
√
|
Safety observation
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Record adverse events
|
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
Other work
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Compliance evaluation
|
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
√
|
In addition, it is also necessary to collect the patient's general condition, past history, personal history, family history and other relevant information. Include name, sex, age, height (cm), weight (kg), phone number, previous trauma history, smoking and drinking history, drug and food allergy history, and medication history for other diseases.
Sample size calculation
This study is a randomized controlled trial, using the multi-group differential analysis method, according to the literature review, the treatment rate is expected to be 70% in the low-dose group, 80% in the medium-dose group, 90% in the high-dose group, and no treatment effect in the control group.Bilateral α=0.05 was set with 90% certainty. Take the following formula to calculate each group of 18 people, a total of 72 people.
After fully considering the possible culling and shedding in this research, the loss of follow-up rate is considered to be about 10%.Therefore, 84 patients are studied.
Data management
Ensure data collection, input, summary and update through a wide range of applications, etc. The research data of the scale will be collected by online APP and updated by spreadsheet summary. The integrity, consistency and rationality of the data will be reviewed regularly. Objective examination can be recorded truthfully in the case report form.
Quality control
- In order to facilitate the smooth progress of this project, the relevant operating procedures of clinical trials and implementation process shall be scientifically, rigorously and standardizing;
- Unified training should be conducted for researchers to be familiar with the implementation plan of diagnosis and treatment measures, so as to improve the consistency of internal observation and inter-observer consistency of researchers and ensure the reliability of clinical trial conclusions;
- Strictly record the relevant evaluation indexes of the corresponding treatment nodes of patients, eliminate the reasons for shedding and the reasons for the termination of the experiment, etc;
- Set up a quality monitor to conduct quality control and supervision over the whole process of the study, check and confirm the correctness and completeness of all the records and reports of the study data as well as the filling of the case report form, and ensure the consistency with the original data;
- To ensure the smooth progress of the research, a detailed research plan, progress arrangement and assessment indicators should be formulated, and specific provisions should be made on the division of labor and organization and coordination of each group;
- In order to ensure patient compliance, techniques and drugs associated with the study therapy cannot be used during the trial period.
Statistical method
SPSS23.0 statistical software (SPSS, USA) is used for processing. For the clinical data of the experimental group and the control group, independent T test is used for the comparison of continuous variables between the two groups, analysis of variance is used for the three groups and above, and Chi-square test or Fisher exact test is used for counting data. P≤0.05 indicated statistical significance.