CD4+ and CD8+ T cells have long been considered the subjects of the cellular immune response to eliminate infected cells. Hodgson et al. reported that disturbance of immunoregulatory T lymphocyte numbers or functions might be a primary pathogenetic determinant in ongoing liver cell injury in CHB patients 8. In the present study, we investigated the characteristics of T lymphocytes, including the absolute counts and mitochondrial mass, in different CHB statuses. We determined that the CHB patients had lower absolute T cell counts than the controls, but had higher T cell mitochondrial damage frequencies, which agreed with the studies of Bhargava et al. 4 and Jiang et al. 9. Further analysis indicated that the T cell mitochondrial damage frequencies were significantly elevated in the decompensated cirrhosis phase. Furthermore, the T cell mitochondrial damage frequencies increased with disease progression. In contrast, the absolute T cell counts were significantly decreased in the decompensated cirrhosis phase, where the absolute T cell counts decreased with disease progression. The absolute CD8+ T cell counts were negatively correlated with the mitochondrial damage indexes. The absolute CD4+ and CD8+ T cells counts had a weakly positive correlation with AST levels, while the absolute CD4+ T cell counts had a weakly positive correlation with HBsAg and HBeAg levels. However, the T lymphocyte mitochondrial damage indexes were not correlated with serum ALT and AST levels, and there were no correlations between the T cells and other indicators.
The immune mechanism of HBV infection has been widely studied in recent years. Hepatitis B patients have disordered cellular immunity, with imbalanced T cell subsets and decreased T cell numbers 10, which might be caused by virus-specific T cells overexpressing co-inhibitory molecules. The constant overexpression of such molecules leads to T cell apoptosis, such as PD-1 overexpression, which obstructs T cell receptor-mediated signaling and induces functional exhaustion in T cells 11–13. Additionally, virus-specific T cells also express higher levels of the apoptosis gene BIM, which induces apoptosis and contributes to CD8+ T cell exhaustion 14. Furthermore, targeted mitochondrial oxidation in T cells causes mitochondrial dysfunction, and this injury accelerates and promotes T cell senescence, dysfunction, and apoptosis 15. Briefly, as a complex mechanism of energetic and metabolic impairment, mitochondrial dysfunction can lead to cell injury 16. However, it remains unclear whether the characteristics of lymphocyte subsets and mitochondrial mass differ between the CHB disease stages, and few studies have reported whether decreased T cell numbers are associated with mitochondrial mass functional defects. Accordingly, we detected the mitochondrial damage indexes in patients with different stages of CHB and demonstrated that the patients, particularly patients in the decompensated cirrhosis phase, had decreased absolute total T cell counts as compared with the controls and that the T cell counts decreased with disease progression. However, the patients had higher mitochondrial damage indexes and T cell frequencies, which were comparable to previous results 17,18. We also determined that there was a correlation between the mitochondrial damage indexes and the absolute T cell counts, and the CD8+ T cells were negatively correlated with mitochondrial damage indexes, which agreed with the results of Fisicaro et al. 19.
The mitochondria are the main source of intracellular ROS and are the regulatory center of apoptosis 20. Some studies reported that depleted HBV-specific CD8+ T cells with high ROS levels demonstrated extensive downregulation of mitochondrial function 19. Furthermore, previous studies demonstrated that hepatitis B pathogenesis involved mitochondrial dysfunction in immune cells, and hepatitis B patients typically have increased ROS levels 21,22. Therefore, we hypothesized that mitochondrial dysfunction might trigger the decrease in immune cells as a mechanism of chronic liver disease development, which consequently leads to immunosuppression and the persistent existence of viruses. In the present study, the absolute T cell counts were not correlated with HBV DNA levels, which was inconsistent with the results of Ferrari 23 and might be related to the control of the virus after the use of antiviral drugs. However, the absolute T cell counts were correlated with the mitochondrial damage indexes. These results indicated that the reduction of T cells in CHB might be associated with mitochondrial dysfunction severity rather than the viral load. Nevertheless, determining which of these hypotheses is correct clearly requires further studies. Regardless, the causal relationship between mitochondrial dysfunction and decreased T cells counts remains unclear. Although mitochondrial dysfunction is considered the significant cause of T lymphocyte depletion, various other causes, such chronic antigen stimulation, might also lead to T cell dysfunction 24. Therefore, the association between mitochondrial and T cell dysfunction in CHB and whether mitochondrial damage leads to cell reduction requires further investigation in vivo and in vitro.
Some studies demonstrated that the considerable ROS reactivity can disrupt the integrity of hepatic cell functions and structures 25,26. However, few studies discussed the relation between the T cell mitochondrial damage index and liver injury indicators such as AST and ALT. Most studies focused on the relationship between hepatitis B markers and AST and ALT, possibly because of the known relationship with hepatitis B severity 27. Our results suggested that the mitochondrial damage index and liver injury markers are not related, which contradicted the results of some studies 28. We speculated that this might be related to the fact that we detected the T cell mitochondrial damage index rather than that of liver cells.
In summary, there is strong evidence that patients with HBV infection, especially patients with decompensated cirrhosis, have higher CD4+ and CD8+ T cell mitochondrial damage frequencies and indexes than healthy controls, and have lower absolute CD4+ and CD8+ T cell counts, which might be caused by mitochondrial damage and which may contribute to viral persistence. However, there is no relationship between the mitochondrial damage index and liver injury markers. It was not possible to state that CD4+ and CD8+ T cell mitochondrial damage was the proximate cause of hepatic cell injury in the CHB patients, and the decreased CD4+ and CD8+ T cells caused by mitochondrial damage could represent an important arm in disease progression in this group of patients.
More detailed knowledge about the exact interplay of T cell mitochondrial damage and the immune response in HBV infection is needed. Future studies should focus on the longitudinal changes of T cells during anti-HBV treatment of CHB. Moreover, only CD4+ and CD8+ cells were evaluated in this study. Mitochondrial damage in other cells, such as B cells and natural killer cells, should also be evaluated in CHB patients. Finally, the relation between T cell mitochondrial damage and absolute T cell counts requires confirmation by larger-scale studies with different patient profiles.