Taxonomic description of the identified species:
Phylum : Chordata
Class : Actinopterygii
Order : Cypriniformes
Family : Nemacheilidae
Genus : Schistura
Species : S. scaturigina
Morphometric analysis
A species of S. scaturigina that stand out for having 10–12 dark brown transverse bars present across lateral line interspaced narrowing down at sides, not extending to ventral sides. Scales that do not overlap cover the body. Complete lateral line; 9 branching rays on the dorsal fin; moderately caudal extension of the dorsal adipose crest. Up to half of the space between the pectoral and pelvic fin is covered by the pectoral fin. caudal fin slightly emarginate. Nostril is situated nearer to the eyes’ frontal edges. Mouth slightly arched; upper and lower lips both straight and median dip in the lower lip (Fig. 3). Three pairs of barbells were present among these 2 pairs of barbells. The anterior edge of the orbit is reached by the maxillary barbs. Observed morphological features of S. scaturigina are provided in Table 1.
Table 1
Morphometric characteristic of Schistura scaturigina collected from river Tons, a tributary of river Yamuna in Uttarakhand
Parameters | Range (mm) | Value (mean ± SD, n = 15) |
TW (g) | 1.92–4.13 | 3.14 ± 0.77 |
TL (cm) | 55.00–78.00 | 65.50 + 7.20 |
SL (cm) | 46.10–68.00 | 55.10 + 6.50 |
FL (cm) | 53.50–770 | 65.90 + 7.50 |
HL (mm) | 10.13–12.54 | 11.59 + 0.85 |
Sn. L (mm) | 4.19–5.62 | 4.91 + 0.42 |
IOD (mm) | 3.27–5.34 | 4.14 + 0.61 |
ED (mm) | 1.84–2.70 | 2.17 + 0.29 |
PDL (mm) | 22.98–30.81 | 27.19 + 3.34 |
DFBL(mm) | 5.95–9.91 | 7.81 + 1.33 |
CPBL(mm) | 4.01–6.25 | 5.08 + 0.69 |
AFBL(mm) | 2.84–4.95 | 3.96 + 0.72 |
GM(mm) | 3.27–5.58 | 4.44 + 0.84 |
BD(mm) | 6.37–9.67 | 8.02 + 1.12 |
BGL(cm) | 22.50–46.00 | 32.00 + 7.20 |
CPH(mm) | 4.33–6.81 | 5.56 + 0.77 |
DFH (mm) | 8.60-13.62 | 10.97 + 1.75 |
CFH(mm) | 9.14–12.41 | 10.69 + 0.98 |
AFH (mm) | 6.82–8.93 | 7.73 + 0.70 |
TW = Total Weight; TL = Total Length; SL = Standard Length; FL = Fork Length; HL = Head Length; Sn. L = Snout Length; IOD = Inter Orbital Depth; ED = Eye Diameter; PDL = Pre-Dorsal Length; DFBL = Dorsal Fin Base Length; CPBL = Caudal Peduncle Base Length, AFBL = Anal Fin Base Length; GM = Gape of Mouth; BD = Body Depth; BGL = Body Girth Length; CPH = Caudal Peduncle Height; DFH = Dorsal Fin Height; CFH = Caudal Fin Height; AFH = Anal Fin Height. |
Colour
Olive yellow or matt golden body colour on the background with 10–12 dark brown vertical bands (Fig. 4). The pre-dorsal has 3–4 bands, the dorsal has 3, and the post-dorsal has 5–6 bands. Pre-dorsal bands are wider than post-dorsal bands. The dorsal fin and caudal fin both have noticeable black patches.
Habitat
locally, the species is known as ‘Garia’ and the common name is ‘stone loach’. This species was benthos pelagic in their nature and lives in the hill streams found attached with small pebbles.
Distribution
The species is globally distributed in Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, and Nepal [38, 39]
Sequence analysis
To achieve accurate species identification, the nucleotide sequences of the COI and 16S fragments were acquired. Both the COI (493 bp) and 16S (1066 bp) gene sequences showed significant matches with the sequence of S. scaturigina. The COI sequences were uploaded to GenBank with the accession number ON745188 and scaturigina from GenBank with 95% and 98% similarity, respectively (Table 2). The sequence showed that the average nucleotide frequencies for COI were T = 27.61, C = 28.77, A = 24.47, and G = 19.14, with a GC percentage of 47.9%, while those for 16S were T = 21.76, C = 25.42, A = 30.39, and G = 22.42, with a GC content of 47.8%. the outcome of the COI and 16s gene pairwise genetic distance analysis for species identification.
Table 2
Sequence match with NCBI nucleotide database
Species Name | Accession no. | % of similarity | % of query coverage |
Schistura scaturigina | MK993534 | 95.33 | 97 |
Schistura rupecula | MK480347 | 91.06 | 93 |
Schistura rupecula | MK480346 | 91.06 | 93 |
Schistura rupecula | MN172328 | 90.45 | 57 |
Schistura fasciata | KX951823 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | MG736498 | 90.47 | 57 |
Schistura mizoramensis | MF098658 | 90.45 | 95 |
Schistura sp. | KT896738 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura sp. | KT896735 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | KJ909378 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | KJ909377 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | KJ909376 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | KJ909375 | 90.47 | 96 |
Schistura sp. | KF598791 | 90.45 | 95 |
Schistura cf. | JN815297 | 90.49 | 57 |
Schistura fasciata | KX399157 | 90.24 | 96 |
Schistura fasciata | KY810453 | 90.24 | 95 |
Schistura sp. | KT896737 | 90.26 | 96 |
Schistura nebeshwari | KJ909450 | 90.6 | 96 |
Schistura khugae | KJ909379 | 90.26 | 96 |
Schistura fasciata | KJ936799 | 90.24 | 99 |
Schistura cf. | KF598790 | 90.24 | 95 |
Schistura scaturigina | MG238197 | 90.26 | 97 |
Schistura cf. l | KF318336 | 90.24 | 95 |
Schistura fasciata | KY810454 | 90.04 | 95 |
Schistura nebeshwari | KY810441 | 90.06 | 95 |
Schistura nebeshwari | KY810440 | 90.06 | 57 |
Phylogenetic analysis
The software seqscape v.2.1 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) was used to align and modify the sequence. In the National Centre for Biotechnology Information's GenBank (BLASTN) database, the resulting consensus sequences were compared with the already-existing public datasets [40]. The COI gene and 16S grouped our specimens with S. scaturigina sequences during phylogenetic reconstruction. Other genomes from the family Schistura place scaturigina in a distinct group (Fig. 5). The MEGA 6 software was used to calculate genetic distance among similar species. The Neighbour-joining (NJ) algorithm [41], which was created with the support analysis of bootstrap pseudo replicates, was used to create a dendrogram from the genetic distance matrix.
The Neighbor-Joining approach was used to infer the evolutionary history [41]. The ideal tree is displayed with a branch length sum of 2.71410544. The evolutionary distances, which are measured in base substitutions per site, were calculated using the Maximum Composite Likelihood technique [42]. There were 28 nucleotide sequences in the analysis. Codon positions 1st + 2nd + 3rd + Noncoding were included. Positions with holes and incomplete data were all removed. The final dataset contained 496 locations altogether. MEGA6 was used to undertake evolutionary analysis [43].
Fish morphometric characters are the evaluable characters that apply to all fishes. The individual fish shape can be examined using some markers that have been randomly chosen on a fish's body. A landmark is an object's point of correspondence that can be used to compare populations both inside and outside of it [44]. A comparative morphometric study has been carried out in a 15-nos sample of S. scaturigina. The measurement study revealed that no significant intra-species variations have been found. A brief description and meristic study in comparison with various workers along with the present work also support that no significant variations and changes have been found (Table 3).
Table 3
Meristic characteristics of Schistura scaturigina collected from river Tons and compared with other published literature
Meristic characters | Present study | Day, 1839 | Talwar and Jhingran, 1991a | Rahman, 2005 | Sethy et al., 2009 |
Dorsal fin rays | iii 9 | iii 9 | iii 8 | 9 (1/8) | iii 8 |
Anal fin rays | i 5 | 7–8 (2/5–6) | ii 5 | 6 (1/5) | i 5 |
Pelvic fin rays | i 7 | 8 | i 7 | 7 (1/6) | i 7 |
Pectoral fin rays | i 9 | 11 | i 9 | 11–12 (1/10–11) | i 9 |
Caudal fin rays | 18 | 17 | - | - | 18 |
Barbels | 3 pairs, well developed | Present | 2–4 pairs | - | - |
Nos of bands | 10–12 prominent brown vertical bands with border dorsally | About 15 brown bands | 9–12 dark vertical bands broader dorsally | - | 10–12 prominent brown vertical bands |
The body of the species was found elongated and its depth was observed as 5.45–7.95 times in standard length (SL), against the value of 4.9–7.7 times as reported by Talwar and Jhingran [27], and 6.5 by Sethy et al. [45]. While the head length was observed as 3.92–5.48 times SL, against 4.0 times as reported by Sethy et al. [45] In our study, we could find the eye diameter 5.5–5.81 times of head length, while Day [22] reported it as one-fifth of the length of the head. The maximum length of the species was reported as 100 mm TL by Shrestha [46] from Nepal, 5 cm SL by Talwar and Jhingran [27] from Indian waters, and 5.9 cm TL by Rahman (2005) from Bangladesh waters. In our observation, we could find the maximum length of the species as 78 mm.
In the current investigation, we found a link based on the COI gene that is comparable to the molecular analysis of Ng and Jiang's [47] work. On the other hand, the morphological analysis revealed a link between the COI gene and the study by Ng [48] in (S. scaturigina). The complexity of the evolutionary reconstruction of the Schistura genus is well known. In this work, the molecular analysis successfully confirmed the identification of the species as S. scaturigina and supported the findings provided by Kovacic et al. [49]. S. scaturigina.
There have been no comprehensive reports on fish diversity and distribution records in river Tons. Whatever study conducted in the river Tons has been restricted to limited selected stretches of the river with variable altitudes. Negi and Mamgain [50] reported 19 fish species from the lower stretches of river Tons. Nautiyal [51] described only 3 species from Naitwar-Mori. In the present study, we could report a total of 10 species from river Tons during 2019–2021 with the new report of S. scaturigina. So far the species is reported in the Indian states of Assam, Bihar, Jharkhand, Mizoram, Odisha, Sikkim, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal [45, 52], but not from river Yamuna in Uttarakhand. The present finding confirms its extension of distribution ranges in river Yumana of the state Uttarakhand and kept wide open assemblages of such extension of biodiversity distribution in the studied environment.
Comparative study of identifying keys of closely related species of Schistura scaturigina
Key to species of the genera Schistura
1. Complete lateral line………………………………………………………………2
Incomplete lateral line…………………………………………………………….2
2. 11-13 dark brown transverse bars on the body, frequently united on middorsal………….3
body with 10-12 dark brown transverse stripes and small, slender bands coming from above…………3
Body with 15-16 irregular, dark bands that are barely discernible. …… Schistura khugae
3. The dorsal fin has eight and a half branching rays and the base has three distinct black spots ………4
8-9 branching rays on the dorsal fin have noticeable dark patches at the base………4
10-11 soft rays on the dorsal fin…….… Schistura mizoramensis
4. On the ventral and dorsal sides of the caudal peduncle, there is a moderately high adipose crest ……. Schistura fasciata
On the ventral and dorsal sides of the caudal peduncle, there is a somewhat adipose crest ……. Schistura scaturigina