Antisense oligonucleotide (ASO) may directly or indirectly be delivered into the cell. Direct insertion involves the use of a gene gun while the indirect method may be through Agrobacterium tumefaciens, viral-mediated asRNA transfer or by infiltration of ASO into a cell. The indirect method through Agrobacterium is effective in downregulating the quantity of a specific protein (Gelvin 2003; Aregawi et al. 2022). Among the earliest studies involving the indirect approach in plants aimed to compare the effectiveness of sense, antisense, or dsRNA in generating RNA-mediated virus resistance through post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) (Waterhouse et al. 1998). Particle bombardment through the gene gun is an effective method of genetically transforming crops such as cereals (Hamada et al. 2018). It is particularly useful for introducing multiple genes and for transforming plants that are difficult to transform through agro-infection. In a recent study, sorghum was transformed using shoot meristem explants and tungsten particles coated with the CYP79A1 antisense RNA construct, which were delivered using helium gas. After bombardment, the explants were cultured on an induction medium and then selected for further study (Pandey et al. 2019).
Applications of antisense RNA technology in crop improvement
Antisense RNA technology is applied in crop improvement in the following areas: Fruit ripening, enhanced shelf-life, reduction of lignin content, enhancement of nutritional qualities, bacterial and virus resistance, altered flower colour, etc. (Le and Wang 2011; Tiwari et al. 2014). Although other forms of antisense technologies such as RNAi, siRNA and miRNA have been widely applied in modifying and improving crops for various purposes, the use of asRNA is gaining more acceptance (Xu et al. 2018; Tilahun et al. 2021; Sinha et al. 2023). Consequently, crops of high economic and cultural significance have been improved using antisense-RNA technology (Table 1), and many more in the nearest decade, as more attention and research interest are geared towards the applications of the antisense-RNA for crop improvement. Furthermore, small non-coding RNA has been employed as a biological tool to investigate gene function in vitro and in vivo and in regulating genes in crop plants in a specific manner without affecting the expression of other genes, consequently increasing their productivity (Kumar et al. 2012). Meanwhile, some of the areas where the techniques have been successfully applied are elucidated below.
Table 1
Some of the crops improved using antisense RNA technology.
SN | Crop | Purpose | Improved traits | Targeted gene(s) | References |
1 | Tobacco | Biotic resistance | Tobacco mosaic virus resistance | CP | Powell et al., 1989 |
2 | Tomato | Enhanced shelf life Biotic resistance | Delay fruit ripening Virus resistance | 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) oxidase Polygalacturonase (PG) gene AL1-coding gene of tomato golden mosaic virus TGMV | Oeller et al. 1991 Day et al., 1991 |
3 | Potato | Biotic resistance Quality improvement Quality improvement | Potato virus resistance Reduced discoloration of tuber after bruising Amylose-free starch | PVX Granule-bound starch synthase (GBSS). | Bachem et al., 1994. Salehuzzaman et al., 1993. |
4 | Wheat | Quality improvement | Amylose enhancement | Sbe2a | Sestil et al., 2010 |
5 | Grass pea | Quality improvement | Low neurotoxin (β-ODAP) | CoA Synthase | Kumar et al., 2011 |
6 | Cassava | Quality improvement | Hydrogen cyanide (HC) reduction | CYPTGA1 | Pandey et al. (2019), Siritungam and Sayre, 2003 |
| | Biotic resistance | Resistance to cassava mosaic virus | AC1, AC2, AC3 | Zhang et al., 2005 |
7 | Petunia | Quality improvement | Change in flower colors. | dihydroflavonol-4- reductase | Van der Krol et al., 1988 |
8 | Torenia | Quality improvement | Change in flower colors. | dihydroflavonol-4- reductase | Aida et al., 2000 |
9 | Peanut | Quality improvement | Removal of substances that causes allergy. | Ara h 2 protein-coding gene | Dodo et al., 2008. |
10 | Mustard | Quality improvement | Oil quality | FAD2 | Sivaraman et al., 2004 |
11 | Soybean | Quality improvement | Oil quality | FAD2-1 | Zhang et al., 2014 |
12 | Rice | Quality improvement | Increase grain storability | Lipooxygenase (LOX3) | Xu et al., 2014 |
13 | Cotton | Biotic resistance | Resistance to cotton leaf curl virus (CLCuV) | βC1 gene | Sohrab et al., 2016 |
14 | Sorghum | Quality improvement | Reduction of cyanogenic glycoside | CYP79A1 | Pandey et al., 2019 |
15 | Maize | Quality improvement | Protein enrichment | 22-KD | Frizzi et al., 2010 |
List of Figures and Legends |
Delay ripening and enhancement of shelf life in fruits.
Due to their natural properties and composition, fruits and vegetables are more susceptible to spoiling than cereals. As a result, a huge amount of fruits and vegetables produced are wasted due to spoilage, resulting in inedible waste. Therefore, it is necessary to increase the shelf life of fruits and vegetables to reduce deterioration and spoilage, which would help to minimize horticultural losses. This is an important agronomic trait that should be prioritized. Polygalacturonase (PG) is a crucial tomato cell wall enzyme that is responsible for fruit softening (Rajput et al. 2021) and it plays a significant role in modifying the pectin fraction of the cell wall during ripening. By expressing antisense RNA, plants with lower levels of PG activity have been used to better understand the enzyme's function (Tuck et al. 2016). Polygalacturonase antisense genes were employed, coupled with CAMV 35S promoter to enhance the shelf life of tomatoes via agrobacterium-mediated transformation (Saurabh et al. 2014; Rajput et al. 2021). Ethylene regulates the timing of maturation and extends the preservation of fruits by regulating the expression of genes involved in metabolic processes (Kim et al. 2015). To delay the ripening of the fruit, the expression of the rate-limiting enzymes in the ethylene biosynthetic pathways can be inhibited by using antisense RNA of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) oxidase from tomato (Oeller et al. 1991; Gupta et al. 2013). Xiong et al. (2005) utilized antisense technology to subdue the expression of the ACC oxidase gene in tomatoes which is associated with ethylene synthesis. The approach led to the extension of the shelf life of the tomatoes, as demonstrated by a reduced ethylene production rate in the ripened fruits of the transgenic plants. Specifically, the introduction of an antisense RNA unit blocked the expression of the gene, resulting in significant inhibition of ethylene production and consequently a longer shelf life for the tomatoes. The use of the antisense technique is promising in suppressing various pathways in plant species. In the case of tomatoes, transgenic varieties were created by introducing an antisense RNA segment of the TOMSSF gene under the regulation of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter. This resulted in decreased activity of sucrose synthase (SuSy) in the fruits of the transgenic tomatoes (Saurabh et al. 2014; Rajput et al. 2021) and caused a delay in fruit ripening and this approach may be extended to other economical fruits like peas, mangos, banana, apples, and grapes where uncontrolled ripening may cause deterioration and high economic loss.
Virus resistance
Plant viruses are a major factor in reducing crop productivity and yield, as they can affect the quality of crops (Luckanagul et al. 2014). Antisense RNA is effective in creating resistance to plant viruses, as the antisense sequence impedes RNA biosynthesis. Day et al. (1991) reported that antisense RNA can prevent DNA viruses, the antisense DNA of the AL1-coding gene from the geminivirus tomato golden mosaic virus (TGMV) was effective in suppressing TGMV replication. Pathogen-derived resistance (PDR) is a powerful approach to combat virus infections in plants and has been successfully used to engineer virus-resistant plants (Simón-Mateo and García, 2011). Inverted repeats of antisense oligonucleotide of the coat protein (CP) gene of the Tobacco Streak Virus (TSV) have been introduced as an effective and reliable strategy for developing economically important crops that are resistant to TSV (Pradeep et al. 2012). Tomato varieties that are resistant to Potato Spindle Tuber Viroid (PSTVd) were produced through antisense RNA technology (Schwind et al. 2009). Furthermore, in 1989, Powell et al. reported the development of a tobacco variety that is resistant to tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) by using the asRNA technology to modify the CP gene which conferred resistance to TMV.
Developing bacterial-resistant crops
Bacterial diseases pose a significant challenge to field crops, such as tomatoes, soybeans, bananas, etc. due to their fast spread and difficult control. Therefore, it is essential to develop bacterial-resistant varieties of food crops to minimize infections, reduce yield loss, and lower production costs. One promising approach is the use of asRNA to enhance bacterial resistance. In a study by Escobar et al. (2001), silencing two bacterial genes (iaaM and ipt) effectively reduced the production of crown gall tumours caused by Agrobacterium tumefaciens in Arabidopsis to nearly zero. This finding suggests that it may be possible to engineer resistance to crown gall disease in trees, ornamental plants, and even food crops (Saurabh et al. 2014).
Pest resistance
Insect pests are responsible for significant losses in crop yield and the cost of insecticides, with an estimated 20–40% reduction in yield. Despite the use of insecticides, pests have developed resistance, which is exacerbated by the high amount of synthetic pesticides used annually (Ferry et al. 2006; Gordon and Waterhouse 2007; Cagliari et al. 2019). The global expenditure on pesticides is nearly $56 billion, with almost 6 billion pounds of chemicals used in attempts to reduce pest damage (Atwood and Paisley-Jones 2017). However, recent research has shown that unmodified antisense DNA oligonucleotides derived from the RING domain of the LdMNPV IAP-3 gene can cause high mortality rates among gipsy moth larvae, both infected and uninfected with LdMNPV (Oberemok et al. 2019). These oligonucleotides, known as oligoRINGs, function as an antisense RNase H-dependent oligonucleotide, causing degradation of the target mRNA for the host IAP-Z gene. This results in downregulated expression of the target protein, prompting cell apoptosis and larval senescence. The insecticidal effect of oligoRING on LdMNPV-free gipsy moth larvae is believed to be due to interference with the expression of the host IAP-Z gene.
Reduction of linamarin in cassava
Linamarin is a cyanogenic glycoside that is naturally present in many crops, including cassava and lima beans. It can release toxic hydrogen cyanide upon hydrolysis, which poses a health risk to humans and animals that consume these crops. Antisense RNA technology has been employed to reduce linamarin in cassava by downregulating the expression of the cytochrome P450 genes (CYP79D1 and CYP79D2), which catalyzes the first step in linamarin synthesis. The linamarin content in the transgenic crop was reduced by 99% (Siritungam and Sayre 2003).
Reduction of cyanogenic glycoside in sorghum
A major hindrance to the utilization of sorghum forage is the production of cyanogenic glycoside in its leaves and stem, which can be fatal for cattle feeding on it during the pre-flowering stage. To address this, Pandey et al. (2019), isolated and cloned CYP79A1 cDNA in an antisense orientation, driven by the rice Act1 promoter. The resulting construct led to a significant reduction in hydrogen cyanide (HCN) levels in transgenic plants, thus confirming the efficacy of this approach in reducing HCN levels in forage sorghum and making it safer for cattle consumption.
Reduction of lignin content in jute
Flax and jute are important economic crops to the textile and paper industries. However, the linen (textile) and paper industries are currently experiencing a shortage of high-quality flax fibers and bast fibers from jute species due to high lignin content which reduces the qualities of the products made from these plants. Excessive levels of lignin make the fibers rigid and brittle, affecting their textile properties. Moreover, the process of removing lignin produces wastewater that causes severe environmental pollution. Additionally, the high quantity of lignin in commercial jute and flax varieties increases the cost of pulp and fiber production for high-quality textiles and paper. Therefore, there is a need for the development of varieties of jute and flax with low lignin content using asRNA technology or any other molecular tool to address the problem at its root (Xie et al. 2020).
Antisense RNA technology can be utilized to reduce the amount of a crucial enzyme involved in the biosynthesis of lignin in Corchorus species, specifically C. capsularis and C. olitorius, as well as in flax. The enzyme 4-coumarate: CoA ligase (4-Cl) is a vital enzyme involved in the preliminary stages of lignin biosynthesis, along with other enzymes such as phenylalanine ammonialyase (PAL) and cinnamate 4-hydroxylase (C4H). Given the availability of the 4-Cl gene sequence, transgenic varieties of jute and flax can be developed to express the antisense RNA (asRNA) construct that downregulates the 4-Cl mRNA level, which in turn reduces lignin production. Therefore, asRNA technology has the potential to become a potent molecular tool that can generate jute and flax varieties with low lignin content. This would make it easier, more environmentally friendly, and cost-effective to process the fiber for producing various valuable commodities like high-quality paper and cloth (Tanmoy et al. 2014).
Altered colour/scent of flowers.
The demand for economically important flowers like lotus, rose, tulip, petunia, orchids, and poppies with different colors and scents has increased for decoration and fragrance purposes. To improve the quality of these flowers, a gene-silencing approach may be considered. Studies by Seitz et al. (2007) and Nakatsuka et al. (2010) suggest that modification of flower color can be achieved by reducing the accumulation of polyacrylate anthocyanins through asRNA. In a similar vein, Nishihara et al. (2005) found that gene silencing of chalcone isomerase (CHI) in tobacco resulted in reduced pigmentation and altered flavonoid components in flower petals. The study also revealed that CHI plays a significant role in the cyclization reaction from chalcone to flavanone, as evidenced by the accumulation of elevated levels of chalcone in yellow-colored pollen (Saurabh et al. 2014).
Enhancement of nutritional value and quality
One of the goals of plant breeding is to improve the nutritional quality of crops. Antisense RNA technology can be utilized to achieve this objective, as demonstrated in a study by Tilahun et al. (2021). Specifically, antisense RNA technology has been used to enhance the protein quality of maize by targeting seed storage proteins (SSPs), such as Zein proteins which are endosperm-specific proteins in maize, a major staple food worldwide (Zhang et al. 2015). Zein proteins account for 60% of corn proteins, but they lack essential amino acids such as lysine and tryptophan (Frizzi et al. 2010). To produce high-lysine maize variants, RNA silencing has been successfully employed in maize to reduce the expression of 22-KD (α-zeins subfamily) maize zein proteins (Esen 1987; Coleman and Larkins 1999). Decreasing the content of zein proteins through antisense RNA technology leads to the production of maize with higher levels of lysine and tryptophan (Frizzi et al. 2010).
Inducement or restoration of male sterility
In hybridization and plant breeding, male sterility is a crucial factor for purity. Application of antisense RNA in inducing male sterility in self-pollinated crops or restoring the reproductive capacity of the male plant is an important adventure for a successful breeding programme of bisexual plants. Suppression of the mutator S gene (MutS) homolog also known as the Msh1 by preventing its expression in tobacco resulted in cytoplasmic male sterility due to the remarkable mutation of the mitochondria DNA (Sandhu et al., 2007). Some reports demonstrated the use of antisense RNA to produce transgenic plants with induced male sterility or the restoration of the productive ability of once-sterile male plants (Nizampatnam and Kumar 2011). Also, about three decades ago, while working on transgenic petunia plants, van der Meer et al. (1992) declared that antisense RNA of chalcone synthase (CHS) prevents the biosynthesis of flavonoids and covertly caused male sterility of the plant. They summarily remarked that antisense RNA could be utilised by breeders to either induced or restore male sterility in plants and this will give a wider horizon in the genetic manipulation of such plants.
Challenges
One of the key drawbacks of antisense RNA technology is the challenge of effective intracellular delivery of the ASO. The ASO could bind to a non-targeted mRNA, thus the site selection in the mRNA is of great concern (Gupta et al. 2011). Therefore, antisense RMA is yet to be perfected, although the utility of small RNAs as mediators in gene silencing is of immense potential, some of the issues and controversies surrounding its use still need to be addressed with a more convincing approach (Tilahun et al. 2021). There is a need for more comprehensive research to improve the technology and develop an efficient delivery system that will enable the asRNA to bind its targeted mRNA sequence and site without any escape or off-target (Singh et al. 2020). The off-target effect could lead to false experimental inferences and interpretations, and negatively impact or alter the phenotypical expressions of the modified plants which may result in undesirable pleiotropic changes in plant morphology and development. In addition, there is a concern that the asRNA-mediated gene silencing requires specific homology between the asRNA and the targeted mRNA. Thus, long antisense oligonucleotides that could specify a unique mRNA may equally direct the RNase-H, causing it to cleave a non-target mRNA at a complementarity site (Tidd 1996). This, of course, could be counterproductive and may be used as an argument against the use of technology for crop improvement. Nevertheless, to ally the fear of off-target cleavages, the specificity of antisense action for gene silencing can be improved through some analogue modification of the backbone molecules (Fisher et al. 2002).
Outlook
There are achievements and progress recorded with the use of antisense RNA technology in crop improvement. Although, the implicit understanding of the mechanisms of antisense RNA technology is still in progress. Therefore, more antisense molecules would be subjected to scientific investigations in the future to discover the effective intercellular delivery method (s) of the ASO into the cell for the specificity of hybridization with the target mRNA. A clearer understanding of the fate of dsRNA molecules within the cytosol will enhance the utility of small RNA molecules in gene silencing. This will include a more vivid understanding of the mechanism guiding the endonucleolytic cleavage of hairpin and the precursor transcripts by RNase III-like Dicer ribonuclease and direct the cleavage of target transcripts by Argonaute RNase H-like proteins and RISC in a sequence-specific manner. In this case, more work and intensive studies are still required if the potential of the technology should be fully utilized in crop improvement to generate crop cultivars with improved agronomic traits leading to increasing yield and nutritional value towards sustainable agriculture and global food security.