This study of patients operated for stage I-III CC showed an increase in abdominal VAT after 3 years in left-sided colonic resected patients. Moreover, V/S ratio decreased after 3 years in right-sided resected patients. When stratifying by sex VAT increased only significantly after 3 years in men after left-sided resection, but the same tendency was observed in women. The VAT increase in women may have been significant if more patients were included. For both sexes no changes in VAT within the groups was observed after right-sided resection. No subjects in the present study developed T2D during the 3 years of follow-up.
Due to the prognostic significance of increased VAT left-sided resected CC survivors may constitute a population at risk of developing metabolic disturbances and having an inferior cancer prognosis. The overall increase in VAT after surgical cancer treatment is in line with our prior findings (26). In that study it was speculated whether the type of resection per se has the potential to alter metabolism.
Our data indicate that left-sided colonic resected CC survivors may constitute a risk population. This is in line with two recent epidemiological studies. In 2018 Jensen and coworkers showed that left-sided colonic resection compared with right-sided colonic resection was associated with an increased risk of T2D in CC patients and non-cancer patients suffering from inflammatory bowel disease etc. (27). Later, a study from Taiwan explored the association between resection type and metabolic disturbances in patients without CC and found a higher CVD risk after left-sided resection, and a reduction in T2D after right-sided resection when compared with non-colectomy subjects (35). However, the most recent epidemiological study found an increased T2D risk after colectomy compared with small bowel resection, but when stratifying by resection type, they found no difference in T2D risk (36).
One explanation of the changes in fat depots in this study and the metabolic disturbances in the first two abovementioned epidemiological studies may be an altered gut hormone secretion after left-side colonic resection. The hormones Glucagon Like Peptide 1 (GLP-1) and Peptide YY (PYY) are produced by intestinal L-cells located in the small intestine, but also in the colon. The density of L-cells increases from the proximal to the distal colon, thus from right to left colon (37). GLP-1 is an important regulator of glucose homeostasis and both GLP-1 and PYY have strong appetite suppressing effects (38). Thus, in theory removal of a tumor and surrounding tissue in the left side of the colon may result in removal of several glucose regulatory and appetite suppressing hormone-producing cells. This may eventually result in increased appetite and fat accumulation including VAT in addition to glycemia.
It is well known that excess VAT is accompanied by low-grade inflammatory changes within the fat depot. This contributes to chronic systemic inflammation with enhanced concentrations of circulating cytokines such as CRP and IL-6 and adipokines (39), which is associated with cancer progression and poor survival in patients with CC (40). In the present study CRP and IL-6 levels were only available preoperatively and values were within the normal range in both resection groups and in men and women respectively.
Our data revealed that SAT was increased independent of resection type and in both sexes after 3 years. In contrast to VAT, the role of abdominal SAT in development of diabetes, CVD and cancer recurrence and death after cancer resection is not fully understood (41, 42). Nonetheless, an increase in VAT is highly correlated with an increase in SAT (41, 42).
Until recently the impact of adiposity on CC prognosis has been confusing (43). The divergent results may be due to the various ways to measure adiposity in former studies (eg BMI, waist-circumference, bioelectrical impedance, quantitative CT-scans etc.) (44). However, since excess adipose tissue is believed to be involved in the underlying pathogenesis of CC (45), it seems plausible that adiposity is associated with more aggressive cancers with increased rates of recurrence. This was confirmed in a recent and the largest metanalysis including 45 studies and 607,266 patients with stage I to IV colorectal cancer as they reported a significant increase in colorectal cancer (OR = 1.27; 95% CI 1.11–1.45) and overall (OR = 1.20; 95% CI 1.06–1.36) mortality in patients with obesity compared with normal-weight patients (43). Moreover, increased waist circumference, which is strongly correlated to VAT (46), was associated with increased colorectal cancer mortality (43).
Increased VAT expressed as an increased V/S ratio is sometimes used as a negative prognostic marker. Thus, in a prior study by Hyeong-Gon Moon et al they included 161 CRC resected patients (both men and women) with an average preoperative V/S ratio of 0.83 which is comparable to our data (average V/S-ratio preoperatively was 0.83 in our study) and showed that patients with V/S ratio > 50% percentiles had significantly lower cumulative disease-free survival rate compared to patients with low V/S ratio during the 8 years of post-operative follow up (21). Based on this study CC survivors who had undergone left-sided colonic resection in the present study may have a worse prognosis. However, in a prospective observational study, overall survival was reduced in right-sided compared with left-sided CRC (47), and similar studies suggest that tumor location have no impact on overall survival (48).
Due to the strong association between excess VAT and morbidity and mortality in CC survivors, identifying CC survivors with increased amounts of VAT may be of great clinical relevance. Our study revealed a moderately increased VAT after left-sided CC resection. This is in line with two prior epidemiological studies showing that left-sided colonic resected patients may constitute a risk population. The underlying mechanisms remain unclear, but changes in gut hormone secretion after left-sided resection could be at play.
A strength of the present work is that the method used as quantitative computed tomography (CT) to determine VAT, SAT and TAT in CC is well established. CT scans were consistently performed before surgery in relation to cancer staging and later until 3 years postoperatively to detect disease recurrence. Furthermore, all analyses were performed blinded to type of surgery (right or left-sided resection) and were performed by two independent investigators. Another strength of this study is the prospective nature of the study allowing us to detect changes in abdominal fat depots over time. Moreover, the two groups were comparable preoperatively. On the other hand, a limitation of the present study included lack of all other variables except for CT-scan results after 3 years.