The main aim of this clinical study was to explore the attachment profiles by the ASQ of adolescent patients with ED diagnosis and their parents before and after treatment with a family and relational focus at an intensive outpatient ward. After treatment the Adolescent ED-patients had a significant decrease (p <0.01) in ASQ4 as shown in Table 1 and Fig. 2. They moved towardsSecure style. Our hypothesis is that this could be an effect of the treatment’s relational focus, indicating new positive experiences.
Remarkable and illustrative in our findings was the difference in ASQ4 between the scores of the adolescents (high) and of the parents (low) (Fig. 1). With both parents distant, as our study proposes, a family climate is created where the child is left alone without transforming moments of meeting [39], when the individual is seen just as is without preconceived ideas and fully acknowledged. The adolescents are left with a sense of not making an impact on others. A gap arises, which the adolescents try to bridge by being overly attentive to parents and others to get into contact. When this is not obtained, they anxiously increase their efforts, obsessively interpreting other’s minds, although not accurately, so-called hypermentalizing [40]. Disordered eating allows for momentary relief in stressful times by acting towards oneself, but leading to a vicious/dysfunctional cycle, which interferes with the development of more adaptive emotion regulation strategies.
Fathers in this study were high on ASQ2, the Attachment Avoidance scale, which may affect the marital as well as the father-child relationship. In our previous study on the same population [22], fathers scored low on self-protection according to SASB, which signifies problems with nurturing and protecting oneself as well as others. The father has an important role in helping a child during adolescence to separate from the mother and to individuate during normal psychological development, even more so if the mother wants to hold back. This task is more difficult to accomplish if the father is not sufficiently present in the life of the adolescent.
Another aim was to relate the ASQ -factors of the patients to the outcome measures of BMI and CGAS before and after treatment. In this study the rise of the BMI was directly and inversely related to the diminution of the ASQ4, implying a direct effect on the restrictive symptoms by establishing a new Internal Working Model[30], another way of relating to self and others. Insecure attachment, personality disorders, and most psychiatric disorders can be seen as manifestations of communicative strategies to ensure appropriate accommodation to changing situations [11]. Eating Disorders could be states of goal-directed behavior to regulate unbearable and unmentalized self-states, after successful treatment no longer needed. The increase in CGAS had no relation to the decrease in ASQ4 or any other rate on the ASQ-scale.
The foundation of the treatment at the ward was to be a holding environment for the patients, their parents, and the staff and to create self-consciousness in a mentalizing climate [7]. Validating emotions and putting them into words and connecting them to the cause, was a central part of therapy, during meals at the unit, in other daily situations and during therapy. The forms completed initially were valuable guiding tools. The staff engaged the patients by sharing meals and activities, served as experts as well as role models and initiated new ways of relating and reflecting to break the patients’ isolation. The family sessions were held by the family’s team, the therapist, and a staff member, who contributed experience of the patient in daily life at the ward, and a reflecting position. ED-focused family therapy is found to be the strongest evidence-based treatment for adolescent AN [41].
The ward became “asafe place” for the patients and the parents, who were seen as important actors in the recovery of their children. They took, with growing confidence, more and more responsibility in handling the hard feeding situations and incommunicating with their adolescents. The patients got new relational experiences, ASQ4 was lowered, and they moved towards Secure. Their mentalizing capacity was growing, giving themthepossibility to relate to themselves and to others in a new way. Starvation as an emotion regulation strategy was losing its importance allowing a breakfrom the vicious cycle. Recovery of the patient´s and the family´s social functions became possible leading to salutogenic cycles [11]. The adolescent developmental crisis [42] gotpotential to be solved for future life by new experiences.
Strengths and limits
Treatment with a relational and family focus impacts attachment insecurity in patients as well as outcome in terms of BMI among the adolescent ED-patients. The change in ASQ4 is significantly correlated to change in BMI. Attachment-styles of all the family members put light on the possible dynamics of interplay in families with adolescent ED-patients.
The main limitation concerns the rather small sample size, which also was the reason why the patients were not stratified into different groups according to gender or diagnosis. The difference in weight cut-off between anorexia and atypical anorexia is questioned by Monteleone and colleagues [43] when found that adolescents with atypical AN diagnosis do not differ from those with full AN diagnosis. They may even show greater psychopathology. The patients in our study received the same treatment irrespective of diagnoses. The fall-off was examined and found with small differences, both in distribution of diagnoses and patterns of attachment.
The long-time-standing result is not at hand, and a follow-up study is eligible. Further studies are necessary to explore more deeply the connection between attachment and self-image.