Investigation of high-speed circulation flow reactors for heterogeneous photocatalysis. Compared to homogeneous photocatalysis, heterogeneous photocatalysis is an underexplored field in organic synthesis, especially with respect to scaling up30. Polymeric carbon nitrides (PCNs) are among the most appealing heterogeneous catalysts for photocatalysis and have undergone significant development during the past decade due to their metal-free and inexpensive characteristics, tunable bandgaps, and excellent chemical and photostabilitities31,32. In this study, we investigated the feasibility of heterogeneous photocatalysis in a flow process using nickel/mesoporous graphitic carbon nitride (mpg-CN) photo-mediated C−N coupling reported by König33,34, which is an industrially significant dual catalytic reaction for achieving ligand-free Buchwald-Hartwig type C−N coupling under ambient conditions35. However, initial attempts to perform the reaction in a capillary packed with mpg-CN (with particle diameters ranging from 1–3 µm, Supplementary Fig. 2), yielded a very low product yield, with significant Ni-black contamination after just an hour of flow operation, thus blocking light penetration (Supplementary Fig. 8a). Furthermore, introducing argon gas to flow a gas‒liquid−solid suspension to mimic a serial microbatch reactor proved to be ineffective, with less than 5% conversion achieved due to the short residence time. Reducing the flow rate to increase the residence time to 5 h only gave small improvement to 12% conversion and 7% yield (Supplementary Fig. 8b). We then focused our efforts on utilizing the circulation flow reactor.
A custom-designed circulation flow system was assembled as a proof-of-concept for a study, comprising a reagent reservoir, peristaltic pump, perfluoroalkoxyalkane (PFA) tubing coil, and multiple sets of 64 W light-emitting diode (LED) (Supplementary Fig. 9). The study aimed to investigate the impact of different flow rates to overcome the challenge of solid deposition. At a 10-gram scale, the substrates were first mixed with 5% w/w mpg-CN and 5 mol% NiCl2⋅glyme in 100 mL of DMA to create a slurry. The slurry was continuously pumped at variable flow rates using a peristaltic pump and directed to the PFA tubing reactor (outer diameter (O.D.) = 6.4 mm, inner diameter (I.D.) = 4.8 mm, volume (V) = 90 mL). The reactor was irradiated by 9 sets of 64 W LEDs (Supplementary Fig. 9c). The reaction mixture was recirculated to the original reservoir until the reaction was completed.
To ensure optimal irradiation of most of the solution in the tubing coil, the tubing reactor volume was kept constant at 90 mL. The results indicated that at a flow rate of 20 mL/min, the flow was interrupted after 2 hours of reaction due to clogging, resulting in only 35% conversion (refer to Fig. 2a). However, when the flow rate was raised to 30 mL/min, full conversion was achieved in 12 hours, despite partial aggregation of the mpg-CN in the tubing reactor. At a flow rate of 40 mL/min, complete conversion was accomplished in just 8 hours, and aggregation was entirely prevented. Higher flow rates (80 and 120 mL/min) resulted in smooth flow processes, but no further acceleration of the reaction rate was observed. Therefore, circulation with a high flow rate proved effective in overcoming solid sedimentation and preventing clogging.
The I.D. of the tubing utilized in the circulation flow reactor was identified as a crucial parameter affecting several important factors such as production capacity, mixing efficiency, and light penetration and uniformity. To assess the effect of tubing size on the reaction, the experiment was repeated in the circulation flow reactor at a flow rate of 80 mL/min using three different tubing sizes with I.D. values of 1.6 mm, 3.2 mm, and 4.8 mm, as depicted in Fig. 2b. The results revealed that comparable conversions and yields were attained with the different tubing sizes, provided no clogging occurred.
Subsequently, the concentration and catalyst loading were explored (Fig. 2c and Supplementary Fig. 9c). It was found that a lower catalyst loading of 2.5% w/w mpg-CN and 2.5 mol% NiCl2⋅glyme at a concentration of 10 g/100 mL yielded satisfactory results in the circulation flow reactor. Moreover, it was observed that the number of 64 W LED lamps could be reduced from 9 to 5 without compromising the reactivity (Fig. 2d). However, a decrease in the number of lamps to 3 or 4 was observed to lead to a noticeable decline in the reaction efficiency.
Scaling up of heterogeneous photocatalytic C−N, C−S, and C−C couplings. After demonstrating the viability of heterogeneous photocatalysis in high-speed circulation flow syntheses, we scaled up the C−N coupling model to 100 g to showcase its practical synthetic applications. This was achieved using a circulation flow rate of 400 mL/min in a microtubing reactor with a volume of 850 mL (Supplementary Fig. 10). Full conversion was attained in 8 h (Fig. 3a, left), with yields comparable to that of the 10-g scale reaction. Remarkably, conducting the same-scale reaction in a conventional batch reactor (Supplementary Fig. 13) only yielded 30% conversion after 12 h, underscoring the circulation flow reactor's tenfold greater efficiency than the batch reactor. Moreover, the heterogeneous mpg-CN photocatalyst was recovered via simple filtration and washing and sustained its catalytic capacity for at least ten cycles of the C−N coupling reaction (Supplementary Figs. 11 and 12), enabling kilogram-scale synthesis with the same batch of photocatalyst (Fig. 3a, right).
To demonstrate the broad utility of the high-speed circulation flow reactor, the same reactor was used in a 100-g scale heterogeneous photocatalytic C−S coupling31 to produce a precursor for the drug molecule bipenamol (Fig. 3b). As expected, the high-speed circulation flow exhibited significantly higher reaction rates compared to conventional batch synthesis due to enhanced light irradiation and excellent mixing efficiency. Furthermore, the circulation flow reactor was easily reconfigured for gas/liquid/solid triphasic photocatalytic oxidative trifluoromethylation33 by introducing another peristaltic pump for the delivery of air. This modification led to the production of 57.3 grams of the isolated drug trifluridine (Fig. 3c and Supplementary Fig. 14). Notably, the reactions run in the circulation flow reactor consistently showed significantly improved efficiencies compared to those of the conventional batch reactor.
Enabling kilogram-scale semi-continuous production in an automated fashion. The transition from manual to automated chemical synthesis offers numerous benefits, such as enhanced efficiency, cost-effectiveness, on-demand production36–39, and improved reproducibility in processes adhering to good manufacturing practice (GMP)40,41. However, the adoption of conventional batch reactors for automation necessitates the use of sophisticated control systems and significant investments in specialized infrastructure42–44. Continuous flow processing offers a promising and easy alternative for automation due to its continuous nature and ease of automating unit operations45–47. Nonetheless, the incompatibility of solids limits the range of viable reaction patterns.
We envisioned that the high-speed circulation flow system would serve as an excellent platform for automated syntheses, inheriting the merits of continuous microflow reactors while addressing challenges related to solid clogging. Although the reactions occur in batch mode, semi-continuous production can be simply achieved through automated feeding and collection, controlled by pumps and valves. To demonstrate its feasibility, the 100-g Minisci-type trifluoromethylation circulation flow system was further equipped with a reagent feeding container, a solvent feeding container, a product collecting bottle, a waste collection bottle, a jacket-condenser and an additional set of valves and pumps. Automation was implemented through the use of Python programming, which enabled the precise control of pumps and valves to specify the paths of air, solvent, and slurry (Figs. 4b and 4c). Automated production for 210 h using irradiation with 425 nm LED light and 1 kg of starting materials afforded the product trifluridine in an overall 43.2% yield (Fig. 4a). Consistent results were obtained across ten batches of circulation flow synthesis (Section 7.4 in the Supplementary Information). Moreover, the absence of clogging throughout the entire reaction process demonstrated the robustness of the system. The catalyst could be recovered and reused. These results clearly indicate the potential for scalable on-demand production of value-added compounds using this simple yet highly efficient platform.