Two-phase kinetics of PQ-pool oxidation after illumination have been observed in previous studies using isolated thylakoids (McCauley and Melis 1986; Ivanov et al. 2007) with oxygen acting as the sole terminal electron acceptor from PETC. In the present research, we used electron acceptors, Fd + NADP+, and varied light conditions, while evaluating the redox state of the PQ-pool at broad range of intervals after illumination ranging from 0.1 seconds to 10 minutes. This approach permitted to elucidate the mechanisms conditioning the "fast" and "slow" phases of PQ-pool oxidation in the dark, and allowed to propose their potential contribution to PQ-pool oxidation in isolated intact chloroplasts and leaves.
The rapid increase in Afl that is observed under certain conditions within a timescale from 0.5 to 7 seconds corresponds to the "fast" phase of PQ-pool oxidation in the dark after illumination of isolated thylakoids. As seen in the insets of Figs. 3a and 3b, in the presence of effective electron acceptors, the rapid change in Afl is restricted to the initial 1 second of darkness. Conversely, in the absence of effective acceptors, with oxygen as the sole acceptor (Figs. 3a, 3b, 4a, 5a-5c), the initial increase in Afl in the dark proceeds more gradually over 7 seconds. It is established that the reduction of P700+ after turning off the light takes approximately 100 to 200 ms (Schreiber 2017). These observed variations in the rate of Afl changes in the dark, depending on the conditions suggest the possible contribution of residual electron flow from the PQ-pool to downstream acceptors to the "fast" phase of PQ-pool oxidation in the initial moments of darkness, the magnitude of which is influenced by the status of PETC established during thylakoid illumination.
As Table 2 demonstrates, the inclusion of Fd and Fd + NADP+ in the thylakoid suspension results in a decrease in τ1, the half-time of the "fast" phase, compared to conditions where oxygen serves as the only acceptor, and this decline in τ1 closely correlated with an increase in the P700+ level as the efficiency of PS I acceptors increased (Fig. S1a). This figure shows increase in P700+ level during 800 ms flash applied to dark-adapted thylakoids in the presence of Fd + NADP+ which apparently reflects light-depended FNR activation. The absence of such increase in P700+ level when such flash was applied after pre-illumination of thylakoids with light of 650 µmol photons m− 2 s− 1 indicated that the FNR was already activated (Fig. S1b). The lower value of τ1 after pre-illumination as compared with that in dark-adapted thylakoids (0.06 sec vs. 0.13 sec) could be attributed to such full activation of FNR. This activation of FNR can determine the significant electron flow from the PQ-pool to downstream acceptors in the initial period of darkness in the presence of Fd + NADP+ after pre-illumination.
Thus, the "fast" phase of PQ-pool oxidation in the dark can be partially attributed to the electron flow from the PQ-pool to downstream acceptors. However, when its contribution is weakly expressed, such as in the presence of only O2 as an acceptor, the "fast" phase of Afl increase may be facilitated also by another mechanism.
It was shown that higher light intensity led to an increase in the amplitude of the "fast" phase (Ivanov et al. 2007). The authors interpreted this result as a consequence of the increased accumulation of superoxide radicals, O2•−, in the membrane under high light intensity. These radicals are capable of oxidizing PQH2 molecules in the dark in thermodynamically advantageous reaction. They were generated inside the membrane upon the reduction of O2 molecules by PETC components (Shuvalov, V. A. and Krasnovskii, A. A. 1975; Kozuleva et al. 2011, 2015). Similarly, in our experiments, we noticed an increase in the fraction of the "fast" phase as light intensity increased in the absence of an effective electron acceptors from PS I (Fig. 4a). Additional evidence of increased oxidation of the PQ-pool by O2•− could be inferred from a larger fraction of the "fast" phase of Afl changes in the absence of acceptors compared to the presence of Fd, despite similar P700+ levels in both scenarios (Fig. S1). Furthermore, the existence of the "fast" phase under anaerobic conditions could potentially be linked to the production of superoxide radicals from the oxygen released during illumination in the water-oxidizing complex (Fig. 4b). These results can be considered indirect evidence supporting the hypothesis of the role of the O2•− in the "fast" phase of PQ-pool oxidation in the dark.
The "fast" phase of PQ-pool oxidation after its reduction in the light appears to be a combination of electron flow to downstream acceptors of PETC and potential oxidation of PQH2 molecules by O2•− produced by PETC components during illumination and preserved in the membrane. The contribution of the electron flow to downstream acceptors is heavily dependent on the presence of an effective electron acceptor from PS I.
The "slow" phase of PQ-pool oxidation is attributed to the autocatalytic reaction of PQ-pool components with molecular oxygen. The comproportionation reaction between plastoquinone and plastohydroquinone molecules leads to the formation of plastosemiquinone, PQ•−:
PQ + PQH2 → 2PQ•− + 2H+ (Reaction 1)
Plastosemiquinone, having a low enough redox potential, can interact with molecular oxygen, leading to the formation of a superoxide anion-radical. This radical can oxidize plastohydroquinone, forming a new plastosemiquinone and hydrogen peroxide:
O2 + PQ− → PQ + O2•− (Reaction 2)
O2− + PQH2 → PQ•− + H2O2 (Reaction 3)
This slow, autocatalytic process of redox transformations involving PQ-pool components, oxygen, and ROS in the thylakoid membrane enables the gradual oxidation of the PQ-pool in the dark.
Our findings suggest that hydrogen peroxide could modulate the "slow" phase of PQ-pool oxidation in the dark. Long-term illumination of thylakoids in the absence of an effective electron acceptor from PS I significantly accelerated the "slow" phase. This effect was neutralized by addition of catalase into the thylakoid suspension (Fig. 5a, 5b).
Potential oxidation of the thylakoid PQ-pool by hydrogen peroxide in biological systems has not been thoroughly explored to date. However, studies exist on the mechanism of oxidation of reduced quinones in solutions containing H2O2. In the study by Sanchez-Cruz et al. (2014), a mechanism of such oxidation was described. According to this, H2O2 molecules react with semiquinones, forming a hydroxyl radical and a hydroxide ion, a process the authors termed the metal-independent Fenton reaction:
Q●− + H2O2 → Q + OH● + OH− (Reaction 4)
The study (Khorobrykh and Tyystjärvi 2018) conducted the reaction of PQH2 with H2O2 in methanol, proposing a sequential deprotonation process for PQH2 oxidation by hydrogen peroxide:
PQH2 + H2O2 → PQH− + H3O2+ (Reaction 5)
PQH− + H2O2 → PQ2− + H3O2+ (Reaction 6)
The authors proposed that the resulting deprotonated products could react with oxygen to form plastosemiquinone, which could subsequently be oxidized by oxygen as per Reaction 2:
PQH− + O2 → PQ●− + HO2● (Reaction 7)
PQ2− + O2 → PQ●− + O2●− (Reaction 8)
However, the interactions of PQ-pool components with H2O2 within thylakoids cannot be entirely explained by one of these mechanisms. It's important to consider that, according to (Sanchez-Cruz et al. 2014), the rate constant for the reaction of semiquinones with hydrogen peroxide (reaction 4) is approximately 104 M− 1s− 1, significantly lower than the rate constant for semiquinones reacting with oxygen, given redox potential (Em) values close to the Em for the PQ/PQ●− pair, which is around 108 M− 1s− 1 (Wardman 1990). Secondly, in experiments by (Khorobrykh and Tyystjärvi 2018), incubating 75 µM PQH2 with 5 mM H2O2 did not result in the complete oxidation of PQH2, irrespective of incubation time, suggesting the absence of direct redox reactions of plastoquinone forms with H2O2 and a more complex process. We propose that a small accumulation of H2O2 in the thylakoid suspension during illumination, which could only react with PQ-pool components at the phase boundary, might catalyze the oxidation of the PQ-pool by molecular oxygen (reactions 1–3) through the deprotonation of PQH2 molecules.
Thus, the "slow" phase of PQ-pool oxidation, which is observable in isolated thylakoids, appears to reflect only its oxygen-dependent oxidation. The rate of this process increases in the presence of hydrogen peroxide, which is formed in the PETC during illumination.
The experiments with isolated thylakoids in the presence of Fd + NADP+ (Figs. 3a and 3b) indicate that after pre-illumination the steady-state Afl level established after 100 sec in the dark with Fd + NADP+ was substantially lower than in the absence of effective acceptors. In contrast, after flash illumination this effect was less pronounced. It was concluded (see above) that a more complete activation of FNR was established under pre-illumination conditions due to longer illumination time. These conditions could result in a larger accumulation of NADPH in the suspension compared to flash illumination. Therefore, the lower steady-state Afl level and smaller τ2 value (23 sec vs. 60 sec, Table 2) imply that a larger concentration of NADPH in the reaction medium facilitates more active NADPH-dependent reduction of the PQ-pool, maybe through NDH complex. This reduction occurring concurrently with oxidation by oxygen led to a decrease in the steady-state Afl level in the dark.
Such situation in intact chloroplasts and its absence in thylakoids, in the latter case both with and without Fd + NADP+, after exposure to only a 1.5-sec flash, may explain the difference in the kinetics of PQ-pool oxidation in these objects (Fig. 2b vs. Figure 3a). Even when Fd + NADP+ are present in the thylakoid suspension, a sufficient concentration of NADPH may not be generated during the flash. However, in chloroplasts, such a flash can provide the reduction of almost all NADP+ in the limited volume of stroma. The similar τ2 values for intact chloroplasts after flash illumination (31 s) and thylakoids with Fd and NADP+ after pre-illumination (23 s) (Table 1, 2), as well as the similar pattern of Afl changes in the dark (Fig. 2b and Fig. 3b) point out the role of the NAPDH in the oxidation of PQ-pool in chloroplasts after illumination.
In chloroplasts, due to substrate scarcity, the pathways consuming NADPH are significantly suppressed. This makes the post 1.5-second flash illumination state in chloroplasts similar to the situation after continuous illumination of thylakoids with added Fd + NADP+, where NADPH is not consumed at all. However, when considering whole leaves, the nature of PQ-pool oxidation after a 1.5-second flash closely resembles that in isolated thylakoids without additions, rather than in chloroplasts, yet with a larger "fast" phase amplitude (Fig. 2a and 2c). The half-times of the "slow" phase, τ2, for whole leaves and thylakoids without additions are both within the 80–90 s range (Table 1). At that, as shown in Fig. 2d, the pattern of Vj' changes in the leaves in the dark markedly differs from that in intact chloroplasts and thylakoids. This pattern can be well explained by the decrease in NADPH content accumulated in the stroma when its oxidation pathways are functioning under conditions of metabolite exchange between the stroma and cytoplasm, and regeneration of NADP+. Specifically, the absence of notable NADPH accumulation during flash illumination impedes PQ-pool reduction. Conversely, when NADPH accumulates, it leads to the observed slowdown of its oxidation, as is the case in intact chloroplasts. Therefore, the acquired data suggest a link between the redox state of the PQ-pool in vivo in the dark after illumination and the capacity of stromal metabolism to utilize NADPH.
The demonstrated in this study interaction of the PQ-pool components with H2O2 serves as an additional aspect of the pool's antioxidant function, leading to the neutralization of H2O2. It is well-known that stress conditions amplify ROS production (Allan and Fluhr 1997; Apel and Hirt 2004; (Borisova-Mubarakshina et al. 2012). During the initial stages of stress conditions, the utilization of NADPH may slow down, resulting in an accumulation of reduced Fd. This leads to the reduction of molecular oxygen and the production of H2O2 in the chloroplast’s stroma (Kozuleva and Ivanov 2010). Furthermore, the production of hydrogen peroxide in the thylakoid membrane significantly increases as well (see review Borisova-Mubarakshina et al. 2019). Thus, H2O2 considerably accumulates during the initial stages of stress conditions when the photosynthetic apparatus is yet to acclimate to the new conditions (Borisova-Mubarakshina et al. 2014). Simultaneously, the activity of ascorbate peroxidases (APX) decreases during the first stages of stress conditions, primarily due to ascorbate being exhausted as a result of its oxidation to dehydroascorbic acid (Zechmann 2011). An increase in ascorbate content, along with a rise in the content and activity of APX in chloroplasts, is only observed after a certain period of stress exposure (Caverzan et al. 2012; Zechmann 2018). Therefore, managing an excessive amount of hydrogen peroxide, beyond what is needed for its signaling role, can be critical for plant sustainability at the onset of stress factors. The neutralization of H2O2 by the PQ-pool components during this period prevents not only the inactivation of Calvin-Benson cycle enzymes by H2O2 (Kaiser 1976, 1979), but also the generation of the hydroxyl radical, an extremely effective oxidant that damages the functionality of the photosynthetic machinery.