The most important finding of this study was the confirmation on cadaveric specimens that the PCL and its tibial insertion were always located medial to the posterior septum and that it was possible to create an effective tibial tunnel in the anatomical footprint of the PCL while preserving the posterior septum. In addition, the anatomical morphology of the PCL tibial insertion was found to be right-angle trapezoidal-like, and the length of the four lateral sides of the PCL tibial insertion and the area of the insertion were measured on twelve human cadaveric knee.
To date, there is no consensus on the description of the anatomical morphology of the PCL tibial insertion[18]. Sheps et al. performed anatomical experiments on 10 knee specimens from 12 cadavers and found that the PCL tibial insertion showed a trapezoid-like structure, located in the depression between the tibial plateau and extending below the articular surface, with the superior lateral and superior medial angles of the insertion located in an oblique walking shape between the anterior angles of the medial and lateral menisci, with palpable ship side sample structure represents the inferior boundary[19]. Ramos et al. found a right-angle trapezoidal-like structure in the center of the PCL tibial insertion after dissecting 30 knees, with the superior and inferior lateral edges of the insertion parallel and perpendicular to the medial side, the lateral oblique walk of the insertion, and the posterior lateral edge at a distance of 1.7 mm from the posterior capsule[17]. Our results about the morphology of the insertion are similar to those of Sheps and Ramos et al. The PCL tibial insertion region has a right-angle trapezoidal-like structure with a narrow superior and a wide inferior border. In addition, for the description of the inferior border of the insertion, our findings were similar to those of Winkler et al, which found that the tibial footprint is bounded posteriorly by the champagne-glass drop-of, a bony landmark at the transitional zone to the popliteus muscle, just was the posterior capsule tibial retroflexion[20]. Therefore, we believe that the PCL tibial footprint is always located above the shipboard-like structure and does not extend further down.
The current literature on the anatomical location of the PCL and its tibial insertion and posterior septum is infrequent. Ahn et al. found that within the posterior articular cavity, the posterior septum separates the medial and lateral compartments of the knee, while the PCL is always located medial to the posterior septum[21]. Luo et al. described the alignment of the posterior septum in relation to the PCL tibial insertion after dissecting 22 knees, with the posterior septum wrapping around the lateral border of the PCL in 8 specimens and anterior to the PCL in another 14 specimens, the posterior septum wrapped around the PCL after bifurcation, and both alignments ended at the posterior capsule[22]. Unfortunately, neither Ahn et al. nor Luo et al. simultaneously explored the anatomical relationship of the PCL and its tibial insertion with the posterior septum. First, within the articular cavity, we are in agreement with Ahn et al. that the PCL is always located medial to the posterior septum, however, at the PCL tibial insertion, we found only 1 alignment relationship where the posterior septum was bypassed from the lateral side of the PCL in all 12 specimens compared to the 2 alignment relationships described by Luo et al. We believe that this difference in alignment may be due to the fact that Luo et al. first cleaned the posterior septum before determining the positioning of the tibial insertion and posterior septum, rather than directly observing the anatomic relationship from the medial and lateral views of the knee, thus confusing the tissue distribution of the lateral border of the insertion and the posterior septum and eventually appearing as two alignments.
In addition, the area of the footprint of the PCL tibial insertion was measured to be approximately (123.3 ± 31.4) mm², and the horizontal and vertical distances of the point S from the posterior septum were approximately (6.7 ± 2.9) and (5.7 ± 2.3) mm, respectively, which is similar to the findings of Greiner et al, who measured the surface area of the tibial insertion to be approximately 155 mm² after dissecting 10 knee specimens[23]. The 8 mm diameter tibial tunnel outlet selected for this study accounted for approximately 30.0–52.2% of the tibial insertion area, whereas when a 9 mm diameter tunnel was selected, it accounted for approximately 38.0–66.1% of the insertion area, and even when a 10.0 mm diameter tunnel was selected, it accounted for only 46.9–81.56%. Therefore, we believe that it is perfectly feasible to create an 8 to 10 mm diameter tibial tunnel within the PCL tibial footprint while preserving the integrity of the posterior septum, although it is worth noting that when the graft diameter is 11 mm, there is a risk of damaging the posterior septum by creating a tunnel centered on point C.
The preservation of the posterior septum during PCLR can help in the recovery of the physiological function of the knee after ligament surgery. Ramos et al. found that the vascular network formed by the middle genicular artery entering the posterior septum after division of the popliteal artery is mainly concentrated in the superior region of the septum, and therefore the intraoperative preservation of this region can prevent the recovery of blood flow after PCLR[16]. Our findings are similar to those of Ramos, in that the dissection revealed that the middle genicular artery branches from the popliteal artery above the popliteal fossa and penetrates deep into the posterior septum to supply blood, and HE staining of the posterior septum and capsule tissues revealed that not only the upper and middle regions of the posterior septum, but also the tissue at the base of the posterior septum is still rich in blood vessel tissue, suggesting that preserving the integrity of the base of posterior septum also has the potential to promote the recovery of blood vessel after PCLR, compared to the trans-septum approach[24]. In addition, the posterior septum contains a large number of type II and type IV mechanoreceptors, and the neurosensory deficits associated with the loss of proprioceptors can be effectively reduced by preserving the posterior septum during PCLR[25]. Konrads et al. followed up 21 patients with intraoperative preservation of the posterior septum from 6 to 12 months, and at the last follow-up, all patients had no joint effusion, 90.5% of patients had a complete return to preoperative level of joint motion, and the mean difference in tibial posterior displacement on stress radiographs was 4.1 mm on the healthy and affected side[26]. This suggests that the posterior septum contains rich hemodynamic tissues that can help accelerate the rehabilitation process and efficiency of PCLR.
There are several limitations on the anatomy study. First, PCLR tibial tunnel creation was performed on a cadaveric anatomical basis, which is somewhat different from the actual clinical arthroscopic observation, but the specimens included were freshly frozen with intact intra-articular structures, and the experimental data measured were close to those of general clinical patients, and therefore have reference significance for clinical arthroscopic PCLR. Second, the number of specimens included in the study was only 12, but the average age of the included specimens was (49.75 ± 3.54) years, which was mainly in middle age, and no significant degeneration of intra-articular ligaments and other structures was observed after opening the capsule, which is generally representative. Third, we found the area of PCL tibial insertion measured in the study was (123.3 ± 31.4) mm², which is smaller than the area of the insertion reported in other literature, which may be related to the Asian ethnicity to which the specimens belong.