DED is a multifactorial disorder caused by various factors, and it is classified into two main mechanisms: a decrease in tear quantity and an increase in evaporation of the ocular surface11. In the 2017 report of the Tear Film and Ocular Surface Society International Dry Eye Workshop II (TFOS DEWS II), it is recommended to diagnose DED by evaluating scores through surveys targeting individuals with symptoms and assessing tear film homeostasis through the following parameters: NITBUT, osmolarity, ocular surface staining1. We focused on NITBUT as one of these parameters in our study. We observed a significant decrease in NITBUT one month after surgery, both in repeated measurements within the operative eyes and in comparisons with the non-operative fellow eyes. This indicates that there was an increased instability of the ocular surface, not only compared to the preoperative but also the fellow eye. Furthermore, the eyes undergoing vitrectomy exhibited changes that closely resembled the diagnostic criteria for DES as proposed by TFOS DEWS II1.
Ghasemi et al have reported a significant decrease in Schirmer's test values at 1 month and 3 months after 23-gauge PPV12. Additionally, Sato et al have reported a significant increase in corneal and conjunctival fluorescein staining score and TMH one week after performing 25-gauge PPV13. We also observed a significant decrease in NITBUT after 1 month of vitrectomy, compared to baseline in operative eyes and non-operative fellow eyes. This was consistent with previous studies. However, the measured parameters such as LLT, TMH, and MG loss showed similar trends but did not reach statistical significance in elucidating the underlying cause.
In previous studies focusing on cataract surgery, most cases of dry eye disease (DED) were found to be transient, lasting approximately 3 months after surgery, with subsequent recovery observed through tear break-up time (TBUT)14–16. Lee et al have reported a significant increase in OSDI score at 3 months after vitrectomy17. To confirm this, we also conducted a follow-up at 3 months after surgery to investigate the recovery of DED. Although Recovery of LLT, TMH, and MG losses at 3 months compared to 1 month after surgery was observed, but it was not statistically significant.
Since the reported occurrence of DED after vitrectomy, several studies have investigated the risk factors associated with this condition. Yang et al have identified age as a prominent risk factor18, while another study reported scleral depression as a risk factor19. In this study, similar to previous findings, increasing age was found to be a risk factor that could affect the NITBUT value at one month after surgery. Mathers et al. suggested that age-related dry eye may be associated with factors such as tear quantity, evaporation rate, and intraocular pressure20. Damato et al. proposed decreased tear secretion due to fibrotic changes in the lacrimal glands as a contributing factor21. These age-related factors contributing to dry eye in the general population are believed to potentially influence the development of DED after surgery as well.
The tear film is composed of the lipid layer, aqueous layer, and mucin layer, which nourish the conjunctival epithelium and cornea, facilitate smooth eyelid movement, and provide the cornea with a high refractive index for optimal optical surface quality. The pathogenesis of DED involves inflammation, cellular apoptosis of lacrimal and conjunctival epithelial cells, and androgen imbalance22,23. Following vitrectomy, potential causes of DED include direct damage to the corneal epithelium and conjunctiva due to surgery, as well as tear film instability and distribution caused by scleral sutures, conjunctival sutures, incisions, and conjunctival edema after surgery24. Using a 20-gauge vitrectomy probe can cause surgical-induced astigmatism, and using a 23-gauge vitrectomy probe has been reported to cause changes in corneal topography after surgery, although less than with a 20-gauge probe25,26. Both scleral incision and closure also contribute to the development of DED. Furthermore, the blood flow and edema of corneal tissue associated with vitrectomy can influence the adhesion of the mucin layer on the ocular surface, potentially allowing the infiltration of inflammatory factors. This process can lead to tear gland damage, exacerbating corneal injury27. Additionally, the postoperative medications prescribed for the management after vitrectomy often contain preservatives, which are known to impact the integrity of the corneal epithelium28. Finally, molecular changes following PPV also contribute to the development of DED. Previous studies have demonstrated a reduction in conjunctival goblet cells and mucin protein levels in tears, accompanied by increased cytokine levels after PPV29. These changes can explain the decrease in non-invasive tear breakup time observed in this study following PPV. These factors can contribute to the occurrence of DED after vitrectomy and potentially impact the instability of the tear film. In this study, we targeted surgeries performed using a 25-gauge vitrectomy probe. It is expected that the relative minimal damage to the conjunctiva through sutureless surgery was achieved. However, despite these factors, it is important to note that there was a significant decrease in NITBUT at one month after surgery compared to before surgery and when compared to the non-surgical group. This finding is significant and highlights the impact of surgery on the ocular surface, even with the use of a 25-gauge vitrectomy probe and minimal conjunctival damage.
There are several limitations in this study. Since the patient's subjective symptom score was excluded, it is not known whether the patient actually complained of discomfort due to the decrease in NITBUT. In addition, the sample size is small, and the observation period for all subjects is not the same, so there is a lack of repeated measurements for the same time points. Furthermore, there was a lack of control over conditions other than vitrectomy and cataract surgery. This is considered a challenge that needs to be overcome through large-scale in serial studies.
Nevertheless, this study is the first to investigate the ocular surface index after 25-gauge PPV using an ocular surface analyzer, and it is meaningful that a significant decrease in the NITBUT was observed after surgery. This can be used as objective evidence that 25-gauge PPV can cause DED. Furthermore, It will help clinicians predict the possibility of developing dry eye syndrome after vitrectomy and reduce patients' postoperative discomfort.