Machine components are desirable to be operated under oil lubricated condition to prevent damage due to direct contact between the two opposing sliding surfaces. Many studies of mechanical sliding surfaces under lubricated condition have been conducted in the field of tribology. Friction behaviours of sliding surfaces under lubricated condition can be divided into three states: boundary lubrication, mixed lubrication, and fluid lubrication. Under fluid lubrication, the shear resistance of the oil in the gap is the dominant factor in friction force because the two surfaces are completely separated by the oil film. Friction loss can be suppressed by using a low-viscosity oil to reduce fluid resistance. However, since low-viscosity oils make the oil film thinner and reduce the gap between two sliding surfaces, the risk of seizure is increased as well as friction and wear of sliding surfaces. The trend toward friction loss reduction using low-viscosity oil has made the role of lubricating additives in protecting surfaces particularly important. It is thus essential to evaluate the characteristics of the adsorbed layer formed in narrow gaps by additives in fluid lubricated condition.
Many studies of the friction characteristics of lubricant additives between two surfaces separated by the oil film have generally been performed under elastohydrodynamic lubricated condition using a glass disk and a steel ball. The entrainment speed dependence of the friction coefficient and the oil film thickness of lubricants containing various additives such as fatty acid and polymer additives have been investigated in several studies 1–5. In contrast, few studies have investigated the effect of the adsorbed layer formed on metal surfaces by lubricant additives under fluid lubricated conditions 6,7 and the influence of the shear on the adsorbed additive layer structure remains unclear.
In this study, neutron reflectometry was used to investigate the structure of adsorbed additive layers under fluid lubricated conditions. Neutron reflectometry is becoming widely used in the field of tribology, but it is mainly used to evaluate the thickness and density of adsorbed additive layers in a static state 8–10. For example, fatty acids such as palmitic and oleic acids were found to form a nanoscale adsorbed layer on Fe, Cu, and diamond-like carbon, with thicknesses roughly equivalent to their molecular chain lengths 11–14. Regarding for polymer additives, the temperature dependence of the thickness and density of the adsorbed layer formed under static states has been evaluated 1. In contrast, few operando analyses have been conducted in the shear field 15, and the change in the structure of the adsorbed layer formed by additives at the sliding surfaces has not been clarified.
To obtain a clear neutron reflectivity profile, it is essential to use a substrate coated with a smooth thin metal film. It is thus common to deposit a metal film with a thickness of 30–50 nm on a mirror-polished silicon block using a metal deposition system 16,17. However, damage to the metal film due to friction during neutron reflectometry causes operando analysis to fail. Therefore, when Armstrong et al. analyzed the structure of an adsorbed layer of glycerol monooleate (GMO) under shear conditions, they set the gap between the roller and flat disk to as much as 200 µm 15. Reflectometry experiment have also been performed with a commercially available rheometer installed in a reflectometer, but the minimum gap between the cone and plate is typically on the order of 100 µm, which does not correspond to the typical oil film thickness in tribological conditions, and the shear rate was only around 103 s− 1 15,18–21.
The objective of this study was to establish an operando analysis method for evaluating the interfacial structure of an adsorbed layer formed by an additive on a metal surface under fluid lubrication conditions in which a non-contact condition was maintained with a few micrometers gap. To achieve this, an analytical method was developed that combines the use of a neutron reflectometer with that of a previously developed parallel-disk viscometer with a narrow gap that can measure the shear force of oil film between two parallel faces. Its use demonstrated that interfacial slip occurs on the adsorbed layer formed by fatty acids. It was shown that there was no direct contact between the two sliding surfaces and that the adsorbed layer reduces shear force even under fluid lubrication conditions when the gap is less than several µm 6.
In this study, the feasibility of interfacial analysis was verified by installing the narrow gap viscometer in a neutron reflectometer. A high shear force was applied while maintaining a narrow gap between the two parallel faces sandwiching lubricant between them and irradiating a neutron beam onto the interface. First, an experiment using base oil without any additive was conducted to confirm that using the viscometer and neutron reflectometer combination results in correct measurement. Next, the structure of the adsorbed layer of a polymer additive formed on Cu layer under a high shear field in the narrow gap was evaluated.