Based on ICA, we found FC changes in multiple regions of three RSNs. Significant correlations were found between the FC values of multiple brain regions (i.e. the right SMG, the left ANG and left MOG) and the neurocognitive scale scores in patients with ESRD. Additionally, the FC values of the right MCC were significantly correlated with the serum calcium level. These results provide both empirical and complementary evidence indicating that the underlying clinical symptoms of patients with ESHD are associated with changes in the FC of several different RSNs.
We found that the ESHD group exhibited abnormal FC regions in the DMN involving the bilateral PCUN and inferior parietal lobule (IPL, including the bilateral ANG and right SMG). The dysfunctional connection of the DMN may lead to learning/memory retrieval and self-reference processing disorders, behavior defects of external orientation consciousness, and loss and weakening of emotion, leading to possible abnormalities of the VN, the AN and/or the SMN [23]. Furthermore, the PCUN plays a central role in a range of integrated self-awareness tasks, including self-processing operations, visual–spatial processing and episodic memory retrieval [24, 25]. The ANG integrates visual, auditory and somatosensory inputs; thus, it is involved in visual–spatial abilities, language and reading comprehension, self-awareness and memory retrieval functions [26, 27]. The SMG is associated with episodic memory encoding, short-term auditory memory, memory processing [28–30]. Our results agree with many previous studies [13, 31–35]. For example, Huijuan Chen et al. identified the abnormal spontaneous activity of the DMN in the PCUN and IPL/ANG using the amplitude of low-frequency fluctuations (ALFFs)[33] and regional homogeneity [35] analysis, respectively, in patients undergoing HD. Using degree centrality (DC) and seed-based FC analyses, Peina Chen et al. [36] found that patients with ESRD and cognitive impairment exhibited increased DC values in the left SMG. Using diffusion-tensor imaging technology, Longjiang Zhang et al. [31] found many changes in the fibre bundles connecting the posterior cingulate cortex and the PCUN to the bilateral IPL in patients with ESRD following renal transplantation as well as positive correlations between these changes and NCT-A scores. In summary, previous studies and our study indicate that the abnormal PCUN and IPL (including the ANG and SMG) may be the characteristics of brain spontaneous activities in patients with ESHD. Furthermore, our results revealed that negative correlations existed between the increased FC values of the right SMG and the NCT-A score, and the decreased FC value of the left ANG and NCT-B score. This result provides further evidence to support the notion that the increased FC of the SMG may reflect a compensatory mechanism that helps maintain cognitive function, and the decreased FC of the ANG may be a critical signature associated with the progression of cognitive decline of patients with ESHD.
We also observed abnormal FC regions in the right MFG. Peina Chen et al.[36] found a positive correlation between the DC values of the right superior frontal gyrus and neurocognitive scores in ESRD with cognitive impairment. TingYu Chang et al. [32] used graph theory analysis to evaluate patients with ESRD without cognitive decline that were receiving peritoneal dialysis, finding many abnormal FC regions of the frontal gyrus and cingulate gyrus. We confirmed that the FC values of the MFG in the ESHD group are abnormal, which is inconsistent with the superior frontal gyrus reported in most previous studies. According to previous studies [37, 38], We speculate that the observed difference may be related to different treatments (i.e. conventional treatment, HD and peritoneal dialysis) or the severity of the disease. Melissa et al.[39] found that patients undergoing HD are more vulnerable to damage to their visual–spatial processing, deductive reasoning, executing, and verbal skills than their short-term memory, and these findings support our speculation; however, a study with a larger sample size will be required to validate our findings. Nevertheless, our discovery of FC regions in the right MFG may provide additional brain imaging markers for cognitive impairment in patients with ESHD.
We also found decreased FC in the left MOG, which has rarely been reported in previous studies. Indeed, we found only one related study, conducted by Waverly Harrell et al.[40] where functional MRI was performed during a visual–spatial working memory task in 21 children with CKD in which several brain regions in the frontal cortex, occipital cortex, temporal cortex, insula and cingulate cortex were activated, and these regions were important elements of visual working memory and visual–spatial processing in these children. The abnormal MOG of the ESHD group could have various explanations. First, previous studies [41, 42] have shown that patients with ESRD/CKD are more vulnerable to visual impairment and eye disease; therefore, we speculate that the abnormal FC of the occipital lobe may be related to the visual impairment of patients with ESHD. Second, the dysfunctional DMN connection may cause abnormalities in the VN, AN and SMN [43], which may be related to the feedback mechanism of neural impulses in the frontoparietal and occipital cortex of the DMN. Third, the MOG belong to the occipital cortex, which is mainly associated with vision, language, executive function and visual–spatial processing [44]. The functions of these regions are consistent with the vulnerable aspects of cognitive impairment during HD. Therefore, we speculate that the intrinsic FC changes of the MOG may be related to the cognitive decline of patients with ESHD. Moreover, our speculation is supported by the positive correlations between the MOCA scores and the decreased FC values of the left MOG. These positive correlations suggest that the FC changes of the MOG might be critical signatures associated with the progression of cognitive decline. In summary, the FC changes of the MOG may provide additional sensitive brain imaging markers for the cognitive impairment of patients with ESHD.
We also found a negative correlation between the increased FC value of the right MCC and the serum calcium level. A previous study [14] found that changes to the white matter structure of the left anterior thalamic radiation were positively correlated with the serum calcium level. Hypocalcaemia is common in patients with ESRD [45] and may lead to neurotoxicity and neurotransmitter imbalance as well excessive parathyroid hormone stimulation and neuron 1,25(OH)2D3 deficiency[46]. Moreover, 1,25(OH)2D3 deficiency leads to neurotoxicity acting on the cingulate cortex and prefrontal cortex. Several other studies [47–50] have indicated that the MCC is an important transit station connecting the anterior and posterior cingulate cortex in the limbic system, which play important roles in working memory, attention and execution, emotional perception, reward and punishment. Therefore, based on previous findings and our study, we suggested that hypocalcaemia may directly or indirectly affect abnormal changes in the spontaneous activity of the MCC in patients with ESHD and may affect cognitive function through changes in the FC of the MCC.
Our research has several limitations. First, this is a cross-sectional study. We did not determine whether the relationship between HD and cognitive impairment changes with dialysis time; longitudinal research may help solve this problem. Second, the size of our research sample may limit the generalisability of our results. In addition, our results do not exclude the effects of the ultrafiltration rate and other dialysis parameters during dialysis or complications in patients with ESRD (including hypertension, hypotension, transient ischemic attack, diabetes, the level of parathyroid gland or thyroid hormone, depression and anxiety). Finally, in patients with ESRD, the types and measurement time (dialysis day and nondialysis day) of neurocognitive scales used in our study may have affected the sensitivity of different brain regions to cognitive function evaluation.