3.2.1 Occurrence forms of heavy metal in RECC
Tessier sequential extraction method was used to analyze the occurrence forms changes and the solidification effect of heavy metals in RECC at different ages was studied. Exchangeable fraction and carbonate-bound fraction are sensitive to environmental changes, which is considered as available state. However, Fe-Mn oxide-bound fraction, organic-bound fraction and residual fraction tend to be stable and difficult to leach, which is considered to be stable. Therefore, available state is the main form of heavy metal pollution to the surrounding environment. The formula for calculating the solidification rate of heavy metal is as follows:
$${S_{hm}}=(1 - \frac{{{c_{ex}}+{c_{cb}}}}{{{c_{hm}}}}) \times 100\%$$
4
where \({S_{hm}}\) is solidification rate of heavy metals, \({c_{ex}}\) is the exchangeable fraction content, \({c_{cb}}\) is the carbonate-bound fraction content, \({c_{hm}}\) is total content of heavy metal.
The occurrence forms of heavy metals in RECC at different curing ages are shown in Fig. 2. The solidification rates of Cr, Pb, Cu, Ni, Cd and As in the red mud are 66.66%, 82.73%, 92.96%, 95.84%, 92.41% and 87.98% respectively. Among them, the solidification rate of Cr is the lowest, followed by Pb. When the curing age increases from 60 d to 120 d, the solidification rate of heavy metals tends to be stable, among which the solidification rate of As is higher than 99.90%, that of Cu, Ni, Cd, Cr, Pb is 97.62%, 97.02%, 96.83%, 95.91% and 91.11%, respectively.
3.2.2 Solidification mechanism analysis of self-cementation of hydration products
The content of available state of Cr exceeds the limit of Identification standards for hazardous wastes—Identification for extraction toxicity (GB 5085.3—2007). Although Pb does not exceed the limit, its solidification rate is low, and the content of available state exceeds 1.00 mg/kg. In practical engineering, the extensive application of RECC produces cumulative occurrence effect, which leads to the decrease of safety, and may cause the pollution of groundwater and soil under extreme conditions. Other heavy metals are far lower than the limit. Therefore, considering the content of available state and solidification rate of heavy metals in RECC comprehensively, analyzing the occurrence forms and solidification rate of Cr and Pb in RECC is necessary.
The occurrence forms of heavy metals in red mud and RECC at different curing ages are shown in Fig. 3. Compared with the red mud, the solidification rate of Cr and Pb in the RECC is significantly improved. With the increase of curing age, the heavy metals in RECC gradually change from available state to stable state.
In order to analyze the solidification mode mechanism of heavy metals by hydration products of RECC, 0.6 wt.% PbCrO4 was added into RECC, and the solidification mode of Pb and Cr was analyzed by means of XRD, XPS and MAS NMR.
The binding energy of Pb and Cr was analyzed by XPS, and the results are shown in Fig. 4. According to the XPS spectrum of PbCrO4 (Liu et al. 2020), the Cr 2p spectrum is at 588.1 eV and 578.9 eV, and the Pb 4f spectrum is at 142.9 eV and 138.2 eV, respectively. As can be seen from Fig. 4, the binding energy peaks of Pb and Cr shift to the direction of high binding energy peaks in the hydration process, indicating that Pb and Cr participated in the hydration reaction to form stable geopolymers in the RECC, changing their valence state and coordination environment (Ye et al. 2017, Zhang et al. 2018).
The change of coordination environment of Si and Al in RECC was further analyzed by XPS spectrum, and the results are shown in Fig. 5. Due to the existence of Pb and Cr, the binding energy of Si and Al has changed, among which the binding energy of Al is highly sensitive to coordination environment. The peak of Al 2p has shifted from 74.02 eV to 73.76 eV after the addition of lead chromate, which indicates that the coordination number of Al has changed from octahedron to tetrahedron during geopolymerization, resulting in the lower binding energy of Al. It shows that the addition of Pb and Cr changes the coordination environment of elements, besides Pb and Cr participate in the hydration process of RECC. It also proves that heavy metals are solidified in the hydration products of RECC by chemical bonding and physical adsorption.
SEM-EDS was used to analyze the micro-morphology and the distribution law of Pb and Cr of RECC with PbCrO4, and the results are shown in Fig. 6. According to the energy spectrum analysis, both Pb and Cr participate in the geopolymerization reaction of RECC, and N(C)-S-A-H amorphous gel are generated, which can effectively solidify Pb and Cr. This is because heavy metals have a charge balance reaction with Al(OH)4−, and can replace metal cations such as Al3+ and Ca2+ to participate in the hydration reaction, thus being fixed in the stable hydration products.
The mineral phases of Pb and Cr in the RECC were analyzed by XRD, and the results are shown in Fig. 7. Compared with the XRD spectrum of the control group, the diffraction peak of hydration products of RECC with PbCrO4 shifted and produced a new diffraction peak, which changed the type of hydration products of RECC. Pb participated in the hydration reaction and reacted with Si, Al and Fe in the system to produce PbSiO3, PbFe12O19 and Pb2Al3(SiO4)(Si2O7)(O, OH)2, realizing the transformation from available state to stable state. Cr reacts with elements such as Na, Si, Al and Fe to produce NaCr + 3Si2O6 and Fe(Cr, Al)2O4, which realizes the transformation of Cr(Ⅵ) to low toxicity Cr(Ⅲ), and reduces the leaching and migration of heavy metals in RECC.
According to the above analysis, compared with the red mud, the reason for the change of occurrence forms of heavy metals in RECC is that the hydration products of RECC solidify heavy metals by self-cementation. Al3+ combines with four oxygen to form [Al(OH)4]−, which can react with heavy metals in RECC in charge balance (Li et al. 2019). The available state of heavy metals combine with Si (Al) oxygen tetrahedron or iron oxygen polyhedron to form stable three-dimensional network-like compact structure, which fixes the heavy metals in stable hydration products, realizes the transformation of heavy metals from available state to stable state.
3.3 Synergistic effect of solidification agent on heavy metals solidification in RECC
3.3.1 Effect of solidification agent on solidification rate of heavy metals
In order to further improve the solidification rate of heavy metals in RECC, the effects of solidification agents on the solidification rate and occurrence forms of heavy metals was studied. Attapulgite, fly ash and 5A zeolite were added to improve the solidification rate in RECC, and the solidification mechanism was analyzed by mechanical properties, FT-IR and XRD.
The solidification rate of Cr and Pb in RECC with solidification agent is shown in Fig. 8. It is clear that fly ash, attapulgite and 5A zeolite can all improve the solidification rate of heavy metals in RECC, and the order of solidification effect is 5A zeolite < fly ash < attapulgite. The best solidification agent for heavy metals is attapulgite with 6 wt.%. When curing time is 28 d, the solidification rates of Pb and Cr are increased by 8.86% and 4.28% respectively. The solidification rate of Cr and Pb in the RECC increased significantly, and the heavy metals tended to be stable, which weakened the leaching and migration of heavy metals in the RECC.
3.3.2 Compressive strength
The 28 d compressive strength of RECC with 2%, 4% and 6% solidification agent was tested, and the result was shown in Fig. 9. As can be seen, with the increase of the dosage of fly ash, the compressive strength first increases and then decreases. When the dosage of fly ash is 2 wt.%, the optimum compressive strength reaches 19.62 MPa. With the increase of the dosage of attapulgite, the compressive strength gradually increases. When the dosage of attapulgite increases to 6%, the maximum compressive strength reaches 24.15 MPa. With the increase of the dosage of 5A zeolite, the compressive strength first increases and then decreases. When the dosage of 5A zeolite increases to 4%, the compressive strength reaches the optimal value of 18.30 MPa.
3.3.3 Analysis of microstructure
The FT-IR analysis of hydration products of RECC with solidification agent is shown in Fig. 10. The absorption peak of CO32− is at 1380 cm− 1, and the unreacted Na-O and Ca-O in the stone react with CO2 to form carbonate. The absorption peak of Si-O-T(T = Si, Al, Fe, Ca, etc.) is at 1070 cm− 1 to 988 cm− 1, and the Na-O bond is at 770 cm− 1. With the increase of dosage of solidification agent, the absorption peaks of Si-O-T and Na-O increase, which indicates that the solidification agent promotes the geopolymerization of RECC.
The XRD analysis of hydration products of RECC with solidification agent is shown in Fig. 11. Compared with the control group, with the addition of attapulgite, 5A zeolite and fly ash, there is no new diffraction peak in the XRD spectrum, which indicates that there is no new type of hydration product. However, the diffraction peaks of the hydration products including ettringite, anorthite and calcite are enhanced, and the camel peak strength of N(C)-S-A-H amorphous gels is enhanced, which indicates that more gels are produced by the addition of solidification agent. This is because the addition of solidification agent increases the alkalinity, enhances the dissolution of silicon and aluminum components and promotes geopolymerization, thus improving the compressive strength and heavy metal solidification rate of RECC.