Most studies have demonstrated an improvement in sperm quality following second ejaculation [1, 2, 4, 6, 7]. However, only a few studies have focused on whether a second ejaculation can offer enough spermatozoa with progressive motility for IVF [13]. Therefore, we comprehensively compared and analyzed the sperm quality and bioinformatics analysis of DEPs between two ejaculates as well as the pregnancy outcomes of second ejaculation IVF, ICSI, and conventional IVF. We showed that the second ejaculation could produce good quality sperm and lower the rate of application of unexpected ICSI without affecting pregnancy outcomes.
In the present study, we performed semen analysis between the first and second ejaculations. There was higher concentration, progressive motility, total progressive motility sperm count after swim-up and lower SDF in the second ejaculation. Similar to our study, studies have indicated that an increase in motility and decrease in SDF are associated with second ejaculation [6, 7]. It is not clear why the second ejaculation with a short abstinence period was associated with higher-quality sperm. Human spermatozoa are produced in the seminiferous tubules and are stored in the epididymis. During epididymal transit, a series of elaborate interactions between spermatozoa and epididymal secretions occurs [14], which may influence flagellar beating and sperm motility [15]. This is consistent with our bioinformatics analysis, which showed that downregulated proteins were mainly enriched in flagellated sperm motility, sperm binding to the zona pellucida, and spermatogenesis. However, further bioinformatics analysis showed that the significant module of the PPI network was mainly enriched in cellular oxidant detoxification, cell redox homeostasis, glutathione metabolic processes, hydrogen peroxide catabolic processes, and negative regulation of apoptotic processes, which are involved in oxidative stress and infertility [16–21]. These may be explained that although the downregulation protein from second ejaculation with short storage time in the epididymis will reduce the sperm motility, glutathione metabolism may play a major role in this process to improve the overall sperm quality of the second ejaculation. Another reasonable explanation might be that second ejaculation is associated with shorter storage time in the epididymis and lower oxidative stress. Shorten exposure to reactive oxygen species arising from dead spermatozoa and leukocytes in the epididymis [22, 23] will also be the reason for the association between increases in sperm quality and a decrease in SDF with second ejaculation.
We detected a lower fertilization rate in the second ejaculation IVF groups. However, our study found a similar rate of rescue ICSI between couples with second ejaculation IVF and those with conventional IVF. Though with the variety of semen quality and fertilization modes, fertilization ability will differ. Previous research has demonstrated that sperm from the proximal cauda shows higher fertilizing potential than those from the distal cauda in animals [24]. Second ejaculation could decrease the storage and transfer time of spermatozoa in the epididymis, indirectly influencing a series of physiological and biochemical changes, which may consequently decrease fertilizing capacity. Furthermore, the downregulated DEPs were enriched in flagellated sperm motility and binding of sperm to the zona pellucida, which may also decrease the fertilizing capacity.
In this study, there was an increase in the rate of good-quality embryos on day 3 and good-quality blastocyst in the second ejaculation IVF group. The significant increase in good embryos obtained in the second ejaculation IVF group highlighted by our study could be explained by lower exposure to higher oxidative stress in the epididymis than elsewhere in the reproductive tract. Many studies have shown that oxidative stress results in increased SDF and poor embryonic development [18, 25]; therefore, shorter storage time in the epididymis might lead to lower SDF and higher good-quality embryo rates. As confirmed in our study, the significant module of the PPI network was mainly enriched in cellular oxidant detoxification, cell redox homeostasis, glutathione metabolism, hydrogen peroxide catabolism and the negative regulation of apoptosis, which also involved glutathione metabolism related to sperm DNA damage, apoptosis and embryogenesis [16, 26–28]. Furthermore, only good-quality sperm can fertilize oocytes with good quality using natural processes.
Nevertheless, no significant differences in oocytes utilization rate and the pregnancy outcomes were observed. Although the fertilization rate of second ejaculation IVF groups was decreased, the overall egg utilization rate remained unchanged may due to the increasing of high-quality embryo rate on day 3 and high-quality blastocyst rate, so as the pregnancy outcomes. Similarly, owing to higher fertilization rate but higher immaturity eggs not used for ICSI compared to IVF, the percentage of embryos formed or stored from 2PN were equal [29]. Originally, ICSI was applied to overcome the risk of low or total failed fertilization and increase the number of embryos [30]. However, no difference in the rescue ICSI rate between the second ejaculation IVF group and the conventional IVF group, nor did the oocyte utilization rate between the second ejaculation IVF group and the ICSI group was found in our study. Considering the high cost and additional required laboratory experience, a second ejaculation IVF could be used to decrease the application of unexpected ICSI in selected male infertile couples.