TEM and HRTEM images of Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies are shown in Fig. 1, and it can be seen that these CeO2 particles exhibit clear but various features. In Fig. 1a1 and b1, CeO2 is nearly spherical, while CeO2 in Fig. 1c1 and d1 has a cubic and irregular polyhedral shape (although a few particles present a rhombic hexahedron shape), respectively. This shape difference mainly stems from the difference in the raw materials of the synthesis process. Furthermore, it is obvious that the CeO2 particle sizes in Fig. 1a1 and c1 are markedly larger than those in Fig. 1b1 and d1. Specifically, the diameters of CeO2 spheres in Fig. 1a1 and b1 are 225 ± 25 nm and 30 ~ 60 nm, respectively. Similarly, the edge lengths of CeO2 cubes and irregular polyhedrons in Fig. 1c1 and d1 are approximately 200 nm and 80 ~ 180 nm, respectively. Under the same raw materials and thus the similar shape, the differences of particle sizes result from different synthesis media. The large and small particles were synthesized in the deionized water and water-ethanol binary mixtures, respectively. In other words, with the increase of ethanol, the particle size of CeO2 becomes smaller. It is inferred that when the volume ratio of ethanol-water rises, the solubility of the reactants decreases, resulting in a higher supersaturation. This elevated supersaturation affects the nucleus growth period, namely, causing it to be shortened. As a result, the size of CeO2 becomes smaller [32]. For the convenience of the statement, these catalysts in Fig. 1a1, b1, c1 and d1 are denoted as Pt/C-CeO2(s1), Pt/C-CeO2(s2), Pt/C-CeO2(c) and Pt/C-CeO2(p), respectively.
As reported previously [30, 32] and revealed by the HRTEM images (Fig. 1 a2-d2), the (111) crystal plane is exposed by the spherical CeO2 selectively, and the (200) crystal plane is exposed by the cubic CeO2 selectively. However, Pt/C-CeO2(p) has different exposed crystal planes, such as (200) and (220) planes (Fig. 1-d2), which may be due to various shapes of CeO2 in this sample. The decoration of Pt nanoparticles can be observed on carbon black and/or CeO2 surfaces with a typical interplanar spacing of 0.23 nm, which is attributed to the (111) plane of Pt.
The XRD patterns in Fig. 2 demonstrate the successful synthesis of Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies. According to our previous work [33], the Pt/C catalyst was also prepared for comparison and its XRD pattern is displayed in Fig. 2, too. The peaks at 25° in all the XRD patterns are ascribed to the (002) plane of carbon black support. The diffraction peaks located at 28.5°, 33.1°, 47.5°, 56.3°, 59.1°, 69.4°, 76.7° and 79.1°correspond to (111), (200), (220), (311), (222), (331), (420) and (422) planes of CeO2 (JCPDF#81–0792), respectively. The diffraction peaks located at 39.9°, 46.4°, 67.7° and 81.6° are assigned to the (111), (200), (220), and (311) planes of Pt (JCPDF#87–0640), respectively. The particle sizes of Pt in Pt/C-CeO2(s1), Pt/C-CeO2(s2), Pt/C-CeO2(c), Pt/C-CeO2(p) and Pt/C are calculated to be 3.36, 2.98, 4.27, 5.22, 5.48 nm using the Scherrer’s equation d = 0.89λ/βcosθ, respectively. Notably, Pt nanoparticles in the four catalysts containing CeO2 are smaller than those in Pt/C. Moreover, the Pt diffraction peaks of Pt/C-CeO2 (s1) are narrower as compared to those of Pt/C-CeO2(s2), which is consistent with the result that Pt/C–CeO2(s1) has a larger particle size of Pt. A similar trend is observed for Pt/C-CeO2(p) and Pt/C-CeO2(c).
The dispersion degree and the particle size distribution of Pt in the four catalysts containing CeO2 can be clearly observed in Fig. 3. Specifically, Pt/C-CeO2(s1), Pt/C-CeO2(s2) and Pt/C-CeO2(c) exhibit more uniform dispersions, which are superior than Pt/C compared to our previous work [33], while Pt/C-CeO2(p) shows more severe agglomeration. It is well-known that the dispersion of catalytic active sites plays a crucial role in improving the electrochemical active surface area and catalyst utilization. In addition, it is evident that the particle size distribution of Pt in these four catalysts (Fig. 3a2-d2) almost corresponds to the Pt particle sizes calculated from Scherrer’s equation in the XRD patterns (Fig. 2).
Figure 4 displays the high-resolution XPS spectra of Pt 4f for Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies and Pt/C. Taking the Pt/C-CeO2(s2) as an example (Fig. 4a), on the fitting curves, the most intense peaks (70.60 and 73.87 eV) are the characteristics of Pt0, and the second and weaker doublet (71.25 and 74.68 eV) can be assigned to Pt2+ [34–37]. Furthermore, the Pt binding energy of all four catalysts containing CeO2 demonstrates a negative shift compared to the Pt/C catalyst in Fig. 4a and b, suggesting an increase in the content of low-valence Pt species. The binding energy (B.E.) and relative intensity of Pt species in the five catalysts are exhibited in Table 1 by fitting calculation, which shows that the order of Pt0 content is Pt/C-CeO2(s2)> Pt/C-CeO2(s1)> Pt/C-CeO2(c)> Pt/C-CeO2(p)> Pt/C. Figure 4c reveals the high-resolution XPS spectra of Ce 3d for Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies. The Ce 3d spectra are divided into eight peaks [38]. Among them, the peaks u and u' located at 906.64 eV and 885.86 eV are attributed to Ce3+, and the other peaks are assigned to Ce4+. CeO2 has a fluorite structure, where the cation valence state can be switched between Ce3+ and Ce4+ [39, 40]. Additionally, the relative intensity of Ce species in the four catalysts is listed in Table 2, which displays that the order of Ce4+ content is Pt/C-CeO2(s2)> Pt/C-CeO2(s1)> Pt/C-CeO2(c)> Pt/C-CeO2(p). It is interestingly found that the order of Ce4+ content is exactly the same as that of Pt0 content. In other words, the more Ce4+, the more Pt0. For Pt/C, the content of Pt0 is the lowest since it does not contain CeO2. This indicates the “metallization” effect of CeO2 on Pt, which may be ascribed to the electrostatic interaction between CeO2 and Pt. It is well known that Pt has a valence electron configuration of 4f145d96s1, which contains unoccupied orbits, but the valence electron configuration of Ce3+ is 4f1, namely betatopic configuration. Thus, the electrons of Ce3+ may have a trend to transfer to Pt, leading to an increase of Pt0 and Ce4+. This reveals the reason for the consistent order of Pt0 and Ce4+ content in these four catalysts containing CeO2. In addition, it has been reported that the (111) crystal plane is more likely to lose electrons than the (200) and (220) crystal planes in CeO2 owing to different O-vacancy concentrations in different crystal planes [41]. Therefore, Pt/C-CeO2(s1) and Pt/C-CeO2(s2) contain more Pt0 than Pt/C-CeO2(c) and Pt/C-CeO2(p) because the CeO2 in the former two is nearly spherical, mainly exposing the (111) crystal plane, according to TEM and HRTEM images (Fig. 1). Furthermore, the large discrepancy of CeO2 particle size between Pt/C-CeO2(s1) and Pt/C-CeO2(s2) (Fig. 1a1 and 1b1) results in significant differences in the Pt0 content between them. For Pt/C-CeO2(s2), a much smaller particle size of CeO2 inevitably leads to a significant increase in the contact surface between Pt and CeO2, thereby strengthening their interaction and increasing the Pt0 content. However, this phenomenon does not exist between Pt/C-CeO2(c) and Pt/C-CeO2(p) despite a smaller particle size of CeO2 in the latter one because CeO2(200) plane is easier to lose electrons than CeO2(220) plane [41], and thus Pt/C-CeO2(c) (exposing (200) planes) contains a higher Pt0 content than Pt/C-CeO2(p) (mainly exposing (220) planes, with few (200) planes).
Table 1
Binding energy (B.E.) and relative intensity of Pt species in four Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies as well as Pt/C.
Catalysts | Species | B.E. of Pt 4f7/2 (eV) | B.E. of Pt 4f5/2 (eV) | Relative intensity (%) |
Pt/C-CeO2(s1) | Pt0 | 71.39 | 74.77 | 51.28% |
| Pt2+ | 71.88 | 75.98 | 48.72% |
Pt/C-CeO2(s2) | Pt0 | 70.60 | 73.87 | 70.36% |
| Pt2+ | 71.25 | 74.68 | 29.64% |
Pt/C-CeO2(c) | Pt0 | 71.11 | 74.44 | 48.80% |
| Pt2+ | 71.69 | 75.26 | 51.20% |
Pt/C-CeO2(p) | Pt0 | 71.42 | 74.83 | 39.41% |
| Pt2+ | 71.91 | 75.36 | 60.59% |
Pt/C | Pt0 | 71.79 | 74.93 | 36.42% |
| Pt2+ | 72.64 | 75.55 | 63.58% |
Table 2
Relative intensity of Ce species in four Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies.
Catalysts | Relative intensity of Ce3+ | Relative intensity of Ce4+ |
Pt/C-CeO2(s1) | 20.09% | 79.91% |
Pt/C-CeO2(s2) | 9.60% | 90.40% |
Pt/C-CeO2(c) | 32.51% | 67.49% |
Pt/C-CeO2(p) | 33.22% | 66.78% |
The electrocatalytic activity of Pt/C-CeO2 with different morphologies and Pt/C for HER was tested by the LSV in 0.5 M H2SO4 solution, and the results are shown in Fig. 5a, which declares that all the catalysts containing CeO2 have lower over-potential than Pt/C. When the cathode current density is 10 mA cm− 2, the over-potential of Pt/C-CeO2(s2) is approximately 258 mV, which is lower than that of Pt/C-CeO2(s1) (265 mV), Pt/C-CeO2(c) (267 mV), Pt/C-CeO2(p) (270 mV) and Pt/C (273 mV). The Tafel slopes of Pt/C-CeO2(s1), Pt/C-CeO2(s2), Pt/C-CeO2(c), Pt/C-CeO2(p) and Pt/C are calculated, and the values are 52.9, 42.0, 59.5, 70.7 and 83.3 mV dec− 1, respectively (Fig. 5b). Undoubtedly, these four catalysts containing CeO2 all demonstrate remarkable catalytic activity and intrinsic kinetics superior to Pt/C. Moreover, the number of active sites on the catalyst was evaluated through Cdl, which is illustrated in Fig. 5c. Based on the fitting results, Pt/C-CeO2(s2) has the highest Cdl value, which is 5.03 mF cm− 2, indicating that this catalyst possesses the highest number of active sites and the largest electrochemical active surface area. However, the most serious agglomeration of Pt particles in Pt/C-CeO2(p) (Fig. 3d4) may be the reason why it has the lowest Cdl value.
Under the same Pt loadings of these catalysts, it is reasonable to attribute the differences in electrocatalytic activity to various CeO2 morphologies. The excellent catalytic activity of Pt/C-CeO2(s2) is mainly ascribed to the following two reasons. Firstly, according to the results of TEM, XRD and the Pt particle size distribution characterization, Pt/C-CeO2(s2) possesses the smallest particle size and the better dispersion degree of Pt, which can provide more active sites and electrochemical active surface area. Moreover, the smaller particle size of CeO2 also has more surfaces to contact with Pt. Secondly, the catalytic activity of Pt for HER is related to the content of Pt0. It has been proven that the catalyst with a higher content of the metallic state exhibits superior catalytic performance [42]. Metallic Pt contributes to the high catalytic activity for HER because the 5d orbital of Pt0 appears to hybridize with the H 1s orbital to form weak Pt-H valence bonds, leading to a DG (relative free energy) value of approximately zero eV for H* absorption based on the results of density functional theory calculations [43]. As mentioned by XPS analyses, the interaction between Pt and CeO2 in Pt/C-CeO2(s2) is the strongest because the (111) crystal plane is exposed on the surface of small spherical CeO2 particles, which results in a highest content of Pt0. In summary, the catalytic activity order of the four catalysts containing CeO2 is Pt/C-CeO2(s2)> Pt/C-CeO2(s1)> Pt/C-CeO2(c)> Pt/C-CeO2(p), which is almost positively correlated with the dispersion degree and particle size distribution of Pt and the Pt0 content mentioned above.
In addition to catalytic activity, stability is another crucial indicator of the catalyst performance. Figure 6 illustrates the LSV curves of Pt/C-CeO2(s2), Pt/C-CeO2(p) and Pt/C before and after 1000 CV cycles. It is evident that the two LSV curves of Pt/C-CeO2(s2) show minimal difference, indicating that this catalyst not only exhibits excellent catalytic activity but also possesses good long-term stability. However, the over-potential of Pt/C-CeO2(p) changes from 270 mV to 280 mV after 1000 CV cycles when the cathode current density is 10 mA cm− 2, which suggests a decline in stability. It is worth noting that the stability of both catalysts (Pt/C-CeO2(s2) and Pt/C-CeO2(p)) is superior to that of Pt/C. This finding further emphasizes that the addition of CeO2 also contributes to the improvement of the catalyst stability to some extent.