Generation of the animal model C57BL/6J-Prph2em1Sal
The c.584 G>T knock-in mouse model was generated by homologous recombination using CRISPR/Cas9 system in mouse zygotes (Fig. 1A). Pure Prph2WT/KI animals were crossed to obtain Prph2KI/KI mice. At this point, all animals were genotyped and then cross-bred to obtain the needed animals for the study. The genotyping showed the insertion of the point mutation in c.584 (Fig. 1B). This mutation resulted in the change of a single amino acid. Arginine in position 195, with a positively charged side chain, was exchanged by the hydrophobic leucine. This mutation was localized in the helix D, which is localized in the peripherical area of the interface crevice, the domain involved in PRPH2 oligomerization (Fig. 1C). Retinal degeneration of both Prph2WT/KI and Prph2KI/KI mice was characterized at 1, 3, 6, 9, 12, and 20 months of age.
Visual function decreases with age in peripherin mutant mice
To assess the effect of the peripherin gene mutation on visual function, the VA of Prph2WT/WT, Prph2WT/KI, and Prph2KI/KI mice was analyzed by optomotor test (Figure 2A). As shown in Figure 2B, VA of both Prph2KI/KI and Prph2WT/KI peripherin mutant mice progressively decreased with age compared to Prph2WT/WT mice, with higher decays in Prph2KI/KI than in Prph2WT/KI mice. Concretely, Prph2KI/KI mutant mice showed VA values significantly lower than control mice from 3 months of age (28% of reduction, P < 0.0001), and VA scores were minimal in these animals from 12 months of age (78% of reduction, P < 0.0001). Meanwhile, Prph2WT/KI mutant mice showed VA values significantly lower than that of Prph2WT/WT mice from 6 months of age (24% of reduction, P < 0.0001), and VA scores were still relatively high at 20 months of age (32% of reduction, P < 0.0001).
Visual function in control and mutant mice was also assessed throughout ERG recording. Similarly to the optomotor test results, ERG responses in both Prph2KI/KI and Prph2WT/KI mutant mice progressively diminished with age in comparison to that registered in Prph2WT/WT mice, being ERG response more severely affected in Prph2KI/KI than in Prph2WT/KI mice (Fig. 3A, B). Specifically, maximum scotopic a-wave values recorded in Prph2KI/KI mutant mice significantly fell from 1 month of age (34% of reduction, P < 0.001) and practically disappeared from 9 months of age (83% of reduction, P < 0.0001) (Fig. 3C). Meanwhile, the reduction in a-wave values in Prph2WT/KI mice was significant from 6 months of age (33% of reduction, P < 0.05), and a-wave scores remained noticeable at 20 months of age (Fig. 3C). Scotopic b-wave responses showed similar results, even though the drop in b-wave values was later and smoother than that observed in a-wave responses in both Prph2KI/KI and Prph2WT/KI mice (Fig. 3D). This indicates that the loss of function caused by Prph2 mutation was earlier and more marked in the outer retina than in the inner retina. Photopic ERG responses also showed a progressive age-dependent diminution in a- and b-wave values of Prph2 mutant mice as compared to Prph2WT/WT mice, with a more severe effect in Prph2KI/KI than in Prph2WT/KI mice, and a slightly smaller effect on the photopic than on the scotopic response (Fig. 3E, 3F). This means that the point mutation in Prph2 similarly affects the cone (photopic) response and the mixed (scotopic) response, with a slightly greater effect on the rod response than the cone response.
Structural and cellular alterations in the retina of peripherin mutant mice
OCT images were obtained from Prph2WT/WT, Prph2WT/KI, and Prph2KI/KI peripherin mutant mice to study how the mutation affected the integrity of the retina. Figure 4 shows representative OCT images from each experimental group and Figure 5 shows the results of the measurement of total retinal, ONL, and INL thicknesses. In Prph2WT/WT mice, there were no differences in the retinal structure over time. Although a decrease in the total retina and the ONL thickness was present in both Prph2 mutant mice over time, changes in the ONL thickness were more prominent. The INL remained stable among the experimental groups for up to 12 months (Fig. 4).
The total retinal thickness was significantly thinner at 9 months in Prph2WT/KI mice (214 ± 3 µm, P < 0.05) and at 3 months in Prph2KI/KI (203 ± 5 µm, P < 0.01) compared to Prph2WT/WT (3 months: 231 ± 3 µm, P < 0.0001; 9 months: 233 ± 1 µm, P < 0.0001) (Fig. 5A). While the alteration of the total retinal thickness in Prph2WT/KI mice was smooth, the retina of Prph2KI/KI animals showed a marked decreased at 9 and 12 months of age compared to Prph2WT/WT mice. Differences in ONL thickness started to be significant from 6 months of age in Prph2WT/KI mice and from 3 months in Prph2KI/KI. Thus, these changes in total retinal thickness were mainly caused by the reduction of the ONL, since no changes were found in the INL among experimental groups, except for an increase in this layer at 20 months in the Prph2KI/KI mice (27 ± 1 µm, P < 0.0001) compared to Prph2WT/WT mice (21.5 ± 0.5 µm) (Fig. 5C). Unlike Prph2WT/WT mice, the ONL of Prph2KI/KI and Prph2WT/KI mice continued the degenerative process over time. ONL thickness diminished progressively and smoothly in the Prph2WT/KI retina with time (from 53.4 ± 0.8 µm to 32 ± 1 µm). Specifically, the ONL of Prph2KI/KI mice showed marked changes at 3 (38 ± 2 µm, P < 0.0001), 9 (22 ± 3 µm, P < 0.0001), 12 (10.5 ± 0.8 µm, P < 0.0001) and 20 (2.4 ± 0.8 µm, P < 0.0001) months compared to Prph2WT/WT animals.
Since this mutation in Prph2 affects the visual function and the structural integrity of the retina, specific markers were used to study morphological changes in photoreceptor cells associated with the mutation. As PRPH2 is a structural protein required for the organization of the disc membranes, we expected that OSs were unstructured and, herein, photoreceptor morphology altered. To check out this hypothesis, we performed immunolabelling in cryosections of the retina of Prph2WT/WT, Prph2WT/KI, and Prph2KI/KI mice at 9 months of age with anti-PRPH2 antibody, to visualize OS morphology and possible mislocalization of the protein; and anti-cone arrestin (CAR) antibody, that allowed us to visualize the entire morphology of cones; together with anti-rhodopsin (RHO) antibody, that immunolabels OS of rods. The immunolabeling with anti-PRPH2 and anti-RHO antibodies showed the well-structured OSs in the retina of Prph2WT/WT mice (Fig. 6A, B, G, H, M, N). PRPH2 immunostaining surrounds the immunolabelling of anti-RHO, due to PRPH2 localization being restricted to the rim region of the discs (Fig. 6B), the specialized hairpin loop that circumscribed the two closely spaced membranes of each disc. In the retina of Prph2WT/KI animals, OSs looked swollen (Fig. 6C, D, I, J, O, P). Nevertheless, in the retina of Prph2KI/KI animals, there were membranous aggregations of OSs that were completely disorganized (Fig 6E, F, K, L, Q, R). Also, RHO was mislocalized, which could be indicating a loss of compartmentalization of the disc membranes (Fig. 6F, L, R). The immunolabeling with anti-PRPH2 also confirmed that mutant PRPH2 was not mislocalized towards the inner segment (IS) or the cell body in the photoreceptor cells during the curse of neurodegeneration and the mutant protein remained confined in the OSs (Fig 6D, J, P; F, L, R). Cone morphology was affected in the retina of Prph2WT/KI and Prph2KI/KI mice, as shown in CAR immunostaining (Fig. 7). In the Prph2WT/KI retina, OSs of cones showed an unusual twisted appearance, losing the straight organization that is present in the OSs showed of the Prph2WT/WT mouse retina (Fig. 7J). Pedicles also showed some morphological alteration in the Prph2WT/KI retina, showing unusual telodendria. Cones in the retina of Prph2KI/KI animals were shortened and their OSs practically missing in contrast to Prph2WT/WT (Fig. 7E, F, K, L). ISs of cones were swollen in the retina of the Prph2KI/KI model. (Fig. 7E, F, K, L). Nuclei staining with TO-PRO-3 iodide confirmed the marked decline of ONL thickness in the retina of Prph2KI/KI mice observed with OCT, revealing a decreased number of photoreceptor rows (Fig. 7).
To deeply study the morphological changes in the OSs of photoreceptor cells in the C57BL/6J-Prph2em1Sal model and also to detect if there were any structural alterations in the photoreceptor cells before detectable changes in the ERG or optomotor test, we performed transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in the retina of Prph2WT/WT and Prph2KI/KI at 1 month of age. At this age, OSs are still conserved in the Prph2KI/KI. Because PRPH2 is necessary for the formation of photoreceptor discs and retinal immunostaining revealed a considerable impairment in OS structure, we decided to evaluate the ultrastructure of the OS discs. The Prph2KI/KI mice displayed disorganized and shortened OSs and ISs compared with the Prph2WT/WT mice (Fig. 8A, B). The normal parallel distribution of the OSs discs enclosure in a membrane in Prph2WT/WT mice (Fig. 8C) switched to major structural abnormalities of the OSs in Prph2KI/KI mice (Fig. 8D, E). One of the most abnormal structures found in the OSs was a pattern of spirals or concentric circles that contained darker stained membranes (Fig. 8D, E, arrowheads). These structures were similar to those described in other peripherin mutations leading to the loss of visual function and photoreceptor degeneration found in this model (Lewis et al., 2020; Tebbe et al., 2020). Additionally, we observed unusual intracellular vacuoles in the RPE (Fig. 8B, asterisk), and an increase in the paracellular space in the interphotoreceptor matrix (Fig. 8B, arrows). Both anomalies were also described by Tebbe and collaborators (Tebbe et al., 2022).
Considering the significant reduction in ONL thickness and photoreceptor nuclei in Prph2 mutant mice, we proceeded to examine the synaptic connections in the retinas of both normal (Prph2WT/WT) and dystrophic homozygous (Prph2KI/KI) animals. Retinal sections were subjected to immunostaining using anti-calbindin antibody, which specifically labels horizontal cells (Fig. 9A-F). Double labeling was performed with antibodies against bassoon, which highlights synaptic ribbons of photoreceptors (Fig. 9A-D, G, H). Images revealed a striking decrease in synaptic contacts between photoreceptors and horizontal cells. This decline in synaptic connectivity indicates that the mutation in Prph2 not only affected the OSs of photoreceptors but also disrupts the interactions between photoreceptors and the second-order neural cells in the visual pathways. Consequently, this loss of synaptic connectivity in the OPL contributes to the overall deterioration of the visual system in Prph2 mutant mice.
To investigate the synaptic contacts between photoreceptor cells and ON rod bipolar cells in the OPL, we conducted immunostaining of retinal sections using antibodies against synaptophysin, a specific marker of presynaptic vesicles. Additionally, double immunostaining with PKCα was performed to visualize the contacts between the axon terminals of photoreceptors and the dendrites of bipolar cells. In the retina of Prph2KI/KI mice, a noticeable reduction in synaptophysin-positive dots (Fig. 10B, D, H) and a loss of bipolar cell dendrites labeled with PKCα (Fig. 10B, D, E) were observed compared to normal mouse retinas (Fig. 10A, C, E, G). Moreover, upon closer examination at high magnification of the double immunolabelling, fewer synaptophysin immunoreactive spots paired with bipolar cell dendritic tips were observed in the peripherin mice compared to the control (Fig.10C, D).
We also investigated the inflammatory process and the involvement of activated microglial cells in the C57BL/6J-Prph2em1Sal model. For this purpose, we assessed the activity of Iba1+ cell populations in retinal sections (Fig. 11). Immunofluorescence images revealed an elevated presence of Iba1+ cells (shown in green) in the retina of Prph2KI/KI mice (Fig. 11B, D), compared to Prph2WT/WT animals (Fig. 11A, C). Furthermore, these cells exhibited migration towards the photoreceptor layers, including the ONL and OSs, specifically in the retinas of Prph2KI/KI mice. Conversely, in Prph2WT/WT animals, Iba1+ cells were not detected above the OPL. The Prph2KI/KI mice retinas exhibited an increased number of Iba1+ cells with an ameboid shape, indicating microglia activation in this particular model. To analyze the reactive gliosis of macroglial cells (astrocytes and Müller cells), we observed GFAP immunoreactivity. The retina of Prph2KI/KI mice demonstrated an elevated GFAP immunoreactivity (Fig. 11B, F), that was higher than in Prph2WT/WT animals (Fig. 11A, E). Interestingly, the retinas of Prph2KI/KI mice exhibited GFAP immunoreactivity not only at the inner margin but also throughout the entire length of Müller cells.
To analyse the inflammation- and immune-related cell populations in the different stages of the degenerative process, we examined the expression of several surface markers by flow cytometry in mice retinas at different ages. After excluding doublets and cellular debris (Fig. 12A) CD45 or CD11b immunopositive populations were selected (Fig. 12A, B). Among the CD45 immunoreactive cells (CD45all), two different populations were observed, one with medium reactivity (CD45med) and another one highly immunopositive (CD45high) (Figure 12B, C). CD45high population has previously described as corresponding to an activated phenotype of microglia and also to macrophages, consistent with the invasion of peripheral cells (Jurga et al., 2020; Martin et al., 2017; Rangaraju et al., 2018; Ronning et al., 2019). In Prph2KI/KI mouse retinas, the percentage of population with this phenotype was increased in advanced ages (9 m and 12 m), and reached significance at 12 months of age (2 ± 1% in Prph2WT/W , 3.2 ± 0.7% and 11.00 ± 5% in Prph2WT/KI and Prph2KI/KI respectively). In Prph2WT/KI mouse retinas, the population was also inscreased with respect to the wild type strain although no significance was reached (Fig. 12D). On the other side, CD11b+ cells were analyzed for their immunoreactivity against CD11c and MHC-class II (Fig. 12E) or against CD169 (Fig. 12F) antigens. A significant increase of activated immune-related cells (CD11b+CD11chighMHC class II+) was observed in Prph2KI/KI mice compared to control mice at all conditions tested (4 ± 2% to 1.0 ± 0.6% in age 3 months, 3 ± 2% to 1.0 ± 0.6% in age 6 months, 5 ± 2% to 1.00 ± 1% in age 9 months, 4.4 ± 0.6% to 1.0 ± 0.6% in age 12 months) (Figure 12E, G). In Prph2WT/KI mouse retinas, CD11b+CD11c+MHC class II+ population was increased, although no statistical significance was reached. CD169 immunopositive population was significantly increased in Prph2KI/KI mice at 12 months of age (7.53 ± 1.80%) with respect to Prph2WT/WT and Prph2WT/KI (4 ± 2% and 6 ± 1% respectively) (Fi. 12F, H), a marker of pathogenic phagocytes (Hughes et al., 2003; Linnartz-Gerlach et al., 2014).