This study showed that the incidence of peritonitis declined gradually in recent years. Interestingly, this decline was most significant in young children under 2 years of age. Contrary to previous studies, this finding suggests that younger age may not be associated with a higher risk of infectious complications in pediatric patients on PD. Several previous studies have also shown a steady decline in the incidence of peritonitis in children over the past several decades. This decline may be attributed to improved adherence to quality improvement strategies [11]. Auron et al. reported a decline in the incidence rate of peritonitis from 0.56 episodes/patient year in 1997–2000 to 0.19 episodes/patient year in 2001–2004 in the United States with the application of an adequate combination of prophylactic measures [3]. In addition, the NAPRTCS, which included 3,363 children on PD from 1992 to 2010, reported a gradual decline in the incidence of peritonitis [6]. More recently, the Standardizing Care to Improve Outcomes in Pediatric End-Stage Kidney Disease Collaborative reported a significant decline in the incidence of peritonitis by implementing standardized care [15]. Furthermore, researchers in Turkey have reported a reduction in the peritonitis rate among children from 0.13 episodes/patient year during the 1998–2008 period to 0.09 episodes/patient year during the 2009–2018 period [17]. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to present comprehensive findings regarding the decline in the trends of peritonitis incidence in East Asia.
The cause of improvement in peritonitis over time may be multifactorial. The enhancement of training and follow-up practices may be one of the most important factors. However, this study could not include measurable values in standardized care, such as the compliance rate. In addition, the widespread use of APD in recent years may have contributed to this improvement. In Korea, the use of APD has dramatically increased since the Korean Ministry of Health and Welfare provided insurance benefits to patients with KF in 2008. Although a consensus has not been reached on this matter, many international and Korean studies favor APD over continuous ambulatory PD in terms of peritonitis [6, 8]. However, this study did not find a significant difference in the peritonitis-free survival rates between the two modalities. Moreover, laparoscopic catheter insertion or omentectomy has recently become more common. Previous studies on adult patients have shown no significant difference in peritonitis rates between laparoscopy and laparotomy [18, 19]. However, laparoscopy may be beneficial for children due to the smaller surgical incisions. Nevertheless, no studies have compared surgical methods and their impact on peritonitis outcomes in pediatric patients receiving PD.
This study showed a novel finding that children under 2 years of age showed a significant decline in the rate of peritonitis compared with adolescents. This finding is inconsistent with the findings of previous studies that showed an inverse relationship between age and the rate of peritonitis in children [4, 7]. Moreover, during the 2009–2017 period, patients under 2 years of age showed the highest rate of peritonitis-free survival. Extensive caregiver education may be beneficial for younger children, as patients 0–1 years of age have limited interactions with people other than their primary caregivers at school or daycare centers. In addition, APD may have a more apparent positive impact on younger children due to fewer connections and favorable outcomes of performing flush procedures [20]. Laparoscopic surgery with small surgical incisions might also offer advantages for younger children [21]. However, establishing conclusive evidence is challenging because no prior studies have assessed changes in the trend of peritonitis with respect to age groups. Compared with younger children, adolescents have demonstrated the lowest rate of peritonitis-free survival in recent years. Furthermore, adolescents’ poor adherence may result in elevated morbidity rates and an increased risk of complications. This resembles the common nonadherence observed in adolescents with kidney transplants [22].
Many previous studies have evaluated peritonitis-free survival rates in children in recent years. Bordador et al. analyzed the data of 167 children and reported a 2-year peritonitis-free survival rate of 36%, whereas Ponce et al. investigated 491 Brazilian children and reported a 2-year survival rate of 58.9% [12, 13]. The findings of Ponce et al.’s study are similar to those observed in our study. The most recent annual report of the NAPRTCS revealed an overall peritonitis-free survival rate of 49% at 2 years [6]. However, no direct comparisons were made with similar regions because no similar studies have conducted survival analysis in Eastern Asia. The incidence rates of PD-associated peritonitis in children vary from region to region [23]. The incidence rate of PD-associated peritonitis in Eastern Asia has been reported to be lower than that in other regions, with a rate as low as 0.19 episodes/patient year, as reported from Japan [24]. Nevertheless, peritonitis remains the most common complication and the primary cause of PD failure. Thus, it is important to collect regional epidemiological data to better plan for treatment and prevention options for peritonitis [7, 25].
Furthermore, in contrast to the results observed in North America, gram-positive bacteria, such as Staphylococcus, were found to be the most prevalent in South Korea, and this pattern remained consistent regardless of the period of PD initiation [6]. Furthermore, the sensitivity to methicillin of Staphylococcus has not changed significantly since the early 2000s, which is consistent with previous studies conducted in Eastern Asia [8, 25, 26].
This study has a limitation. This was a single-center retrospective medical chart review study. Thus, it was difficult to collect important data, including patient adherence, risk factors such as ostomy presence, in-depth details about peritonitis, such as specific antibiotic dosage, and the status of exit site care. These missing data might affect our overall understanding of peritonitis cases. Nevertheless, this study has important strengths as we collected data over a long period and showed changes in peritonitis characteristics, which were scarcely reported in children.
In conclusion, the incidence of peritonitis significantly decreased, mainly in young children, whereas the incidence has not changed significantly in adolescents. Further large-scale studies investigating peritonitis characteristics, including the incidence rate in relation to patients’ ages, microbiology, and outcomes, are needed to establish adequate center- and region-based guidelines for proper treatment and prevention of peritonitis.