The present study described the effects of PM2.5 exposure on the RPE and choroid for the first time, and provides a detailed description of the pathological changes under two different scenarios of short-term and long-term exposure, providing evidence to support the association of air pollution with oBRB injury-related eye diseases. Acute PM2.5 exposure was found to cause fundus changes that are very similar to the pathogenesis and manifestations of CSC. Under continuous PM2.5 exposure, AMD-related pathological changes were also observed. Moreover, this study pioneered an indirect co-culture model of stretched cells, which provided insight into the changes in choroidal hemodynamics as a key mechanism of RPE damage induced by PM2.5 exposure.
In this study, acute PM2.5 exposure caused choroidal vasodilation, thickening, and inflammation in mice, along with disruption of TJs between RPE cells, leading to the appearance of retinal edema above the RPE layer (Fig. 5F). Such pathological changes are very similar to what is seen in pachychoroid disease [28, 29], which is a recent, general term for a specific group of diseases that covers diseases with the common features of choroidal hypertrophy, choroidal vasodilatation, and impaired normal RPE function, and of which CSC is the most prominent disease. In patients with CSC, it has been found that pachychoroid may be caused by focal or diffuse dilated large choroidal vessels [21, 22], which is similar to our findings in the mouse choroid. CSC tends to have an acute onset, with spontaneous healing achieved in approximately 60% of patients [23]. This is consistent with the present observations, where damage to the RPE was repaired, to some extent, after 3 weeks. Although no epidemiological studies have explored the association between air pollution and CSC, a smoking habit is an independent risk factor for CSC [23], and previous studies have also found that cigarette smoking is related to increased subfovea choroidal thickness in patients with CSC [21, 24]. Since PM2.5, like the main components of cigarette smoke, can induce oxidative stress damage [30, 31], it can be hypothesized that acute PM2.5 exposure may be correlated with the development of CSC in conjunction with the findings in this study. In the future, well-designed cohort studies might be conducted to validate this association.
Unlike CSC, the association between PM2.5 exposure and AMD has been confirmed by numerous epidemiological studies [9, 10, 11, 12]. Analysis of data from UK Biobank found higher odds of self-reported AMD among those exposed to higher PM2.5 levels, and that elevated PM2.5 concentrations were associated with a thinner RPE layer [10]. A Korean cohort study of older adults showed that nearly 5 years of air-pollution exposure was significantly related to increased morbidity of early AMD [11]. In addition, a decade-long cohort study in Taiwan revealed that long-term exposure to PM2.5 increased the risk of AMD development [12]. However, there were no previous studies that investigated the signs of AMD in animal models under PM2.5 exposure. In this study, the characteristic early pathological changes of AMD, including retinal neovascularization and Bruch's membrane thickening, were found in the retinas of mice exposed to PM2.5 for the first time (Fig. 5F), which strongly supports the view that long-term PM2.5 exposure is an important risk factor for the development of AMD. RPE is the main lesion site of AMD, and oxidative stress damage in RPE cells is the main mechanism causing RPE atrophy and loss of function [8, 32]. It is potent oxidants such as benzodiazepines and nicotine in cigarette smoke that make smoking a modifiable risk factor for AMD [33, 34]. Moreover, the exposure of mice to cigarette smoke has become a highly recognized way to establish AMD disease models, and more prolonged smoking exposure can induce more severe RPE apoptosis and retinal degeneration [35, 36]. Notably, the present study found that characteristic AMD changes in PM2.5-exposed mice were similar to those found in cigarette-smoke-exposed mice. Considering the similarity between PM2.5 and smoking-induced cellular damage [37], perhaps the oxidative damage in RPE cells is also an important pathological mechanism of PM2.5 exposure-induced AMD. Furthermore, it can be speculated that long-term exposure to PM2.5 has the potential to be used as a way to construct AMD animal models.
Several previous studies have been conducted to explore the pathological mechanisms of AMD triggered by PM2.5 exposure in cellular models [38, 39, 40, 41]. These studies exposed ARPE-19 cells to appropriate concentrations of PM2.5 suspensions, thereby analyzing the mechanism of PM2.5 damage to RPE. The results showed that the cell viability of ARPE-19 cells decreased and epithelial-mesenchymal transition through the PI3K/AKT/mTOR pathway was promoted after PM2.5 stimulation [40]. It was also found that PM2.5 inhibited ciliogenesis in ARPE-19 cells, and primary ciliogenesis inducer effectively attenuated reactive oxygen species damage and inflammation [38, 39]. However, the major problem with these studies is that the RPE cellular model with direct PM2.5 exposure is not sufficiently realistic to reflect the in vivo microenvironment, mainly because the various layers of the ocular barrier prevent airborne as well as circulating PM2.5 from coming into direct contact with the RPE [42, 43]. In order to establish a more credible cellular model, the present study focused on the key pathological features of choroidal thickening and vasodilatation under PM2.5 exposure, and creatively simulated the choroidal vasodilatation process with cyclic mechanical stretching of HUVECs. We also investigated the alteration of the RPE by co-culturing stretching HUVECs with ARPE-19 cells. Recent studies have demonstrated that the mouse and monkey choroidal congestion model can be a reliable animal model of pachychoroid [44, 45], but to our knowledge there is no cellular model for this disease spectrum, and perhaps the introduction of a mechanical stretching device can provide a breakthrough to further investigate the molecular mechanism of oBRB injury under choroidal vasodilatation.
The reason for applying a co-culture cell model to study changes in the oBRB in response to PM2.5 exposure is that the choroid and RPE constitute a tightly linked complex [16, 26]. Together, they form the bulk of the oBRB and control the transportation of biological molecules between the retina and the blood. The RPE and choroid are highly interdependent during embryonic development. Previous experiments have revealed that the development of choriocapillaris depends on proper RPE differentiation [46], and choroidal vascular endothelial cells in turn secrete factors to remodel the TJ, basement membrane, and barrier function of the RPE [25]. The interaction between the RPE and choroid is not only limited to development, but is also significant in the maintenance of physiological states in adults. Histopathological studies found that choroidal dysfunction precedes RPE damage in wet AMD, whereas the causal relationship is reversed in dry AMD [47]. Various direct or indirect co-culture models based on primary, immortalized, and pluripotent stem cell-derived cells have been used to study the interaction between the RPE and choroid [48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53]. These studies indicated that direct contact between RPE cells and choroidal vascular endothelial cells promoted choroidal neovascularization [54, 55]. In turn, choroidal neovascularization drives RPE cells to proliferate and surround the new vessels in an attempt to reconstruct the oBRB [56, 57]. The present study is the first to introduce stretched vascular endothelial cells into an oBRB co-culture system, exploring the effects of choroidal hemodynamic changes on the RPE and supporting corroboration with findings on animal models under acute and continuous PM2.5 exposure.
There are some shortcomings in this study as well. The description of the effects of PM2.5 exposure on the oBRB remained at the phenotypic level, without exploring the signaling pathways and molecular mechanisms involved. For example, oxidative damage and non-programmed cell death in RPE cells, and inflammatory and biomechanical pathways in choroidal vascular endothelial cells, are likely to be the essential pathological mechanisms. Identifying the key molecular targets will provide potential intervention guidance for air-pollution-related fundus diseases. Additionally, although the present study systematically described the respective changes of RPE and choroid in mice exposed to PM2.5, it is still not clear which of the two is the driving factor. The present cellular experiment investigated the effect of the choroid on the RPE, but no suitable cellular model has been established to simulate the effect of the RPE on the choroid, which deserves investigation in future studies.