Factors associated with the Uptake of Immediate Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Devices(PPIUCD) in Rwanda: A Mixed Methods Study

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-32333/v2

Download PDF

Research article

Factors associated with the Uptake of Immediate Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Devices(PPIUCD) in Rwanda: A Mixed Methods Study

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-32333/v2

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Journal Publication

published 27 Oct, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth →

You are reading this older preprint version

Read the latest preprint version →

Background: Rwanda has a high unmet need for family planning which could be reduced by improving access to postpartum intrauterine contraceptives device (PPIUCD) insertion. The objective of the study was to assess the prevalence and factors associated with the uptake of PPIUCD among postpartum women in Muhima Hospital.

Methods: A concurrent mixed-method study was used. Three hundred eight three (383) immediate postpartum mothers, and 10 health services providers were interviewed using a structured questionnaire and in-depth interviews respectively. Logistics regression was done to assess for factors associated with PPIUCD uptake and thematic analysis was used for qualitative data.

Results: The prevalence for PPIUCD use was 28.1% , women who had spontaneous vaginal delivery were more likely to take up PPIUCD (Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR) 2.623, 95%CI=2.017-6.507 compared to those who had cesarean section; women who received PPIUCD counselling during the antenatal period were more likely to use PPIUCD ((AOR 2.072, 95%CI=1.018-4.218) as compared to those who didn’t receive any form of counselling; mothers who received spouse approval were more likely to use PPIUCD (AOR 2.591,95%CI= 1.485-4.492); as compared to those who didn’t receive any spousal approval; women who had more than one child were more likely to use PPIUCD (AOR =2.265, 95%CI=1.472-3.163) as compared to prime gravida; Mothers with birth to pregnancy interval less than two years were more likely to use PPIUCD (AOR =2.123, CI =1.477-2.706) as compared to those who had birth to pregnancy interval more than 2 years. From the qualitative findings, health education of mothers and partners on PPIUCD, training of health care providers, and availability of supplies to provide PPIUCD influenced the use of PPIUCD.

Conclusion: The acceptability to use for PPIUCD was high in this population. PPIUCD uptake was associated with normal birth, PPIUCD counselling, spousal approval, parity, birth interval, level of education. Health education of mothers and partners on PPIUCD, training of health providers, and availability of supplies to provide PPIUCD influenced uptake of PPIUCD.

Maternal & Fetal Medicine

Immediate postpartum women

PPIUCD

Long-acting Family planning method

Postpartum family planning (PPFP) is the prevention of unintended pregnancy and closed pregnancy through the first 12 months following childbirth and is recognized as a key life-saving intervention for mothers and their children(1). Globally, it is estimated that 214 million women of reproductive age in low-income countries want to avoid pregnancy but are not using a modern contraceptive(2). Data from 27 countries, shows 95% of women who are 0-12 months postpartum want to avoid pregnancy in the next 24 months; but 70% of them are not using contraception(1,3). In sub-Saharan countries, postpartum contraceptive intrauterine device (PPIUCD) still represents a small proportion of contraceptive service delivery (4,5).

The World Health Organization (WHO) recommended that birth to pregnancy interval should be 24 months (4); since short birth intervals are associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes such as induced abortions, miscarriage, preterm births, neonatal and child mortalities, stillbirths, and maternal depletion syndrome(5). Research has demonstrated that long-acting methods such as intrauterine devices (IUDs) are a cost-effective and sustainable way of reducing the unmet need and unintended pregnancy in low resources settings(8).

PPIUCD is one of the contraceptive methods which is safe and highly effective reliable and inexpensive, non-hormonal, reversible, and long-acting contraceptive(7). The WHO recommended can be initiated during the immediate postpartum period and it cannot interfere with breastfeeding (8,9). The PPIUCD has shown that when it is initiated after delivery it can improve maternal and newborn health by preventing obstetrics complications such as maternal and newborn mortality and other health-related complications associated with closed spaced pregnancy (10). The immediate postpartum period is an ideal time for PPIUCD when women are highly motivated to accept family planning methods (13,14). The immediate postpartum period is a great opportunity for PPIUCD services providers to introduce the method especially in a setting where women meet with health care providers is difficult due to geographical barriers (13). An intervention study done in Tanzania aimed to improve women’s access to PPIUCD focused on increasing counselling has revealed that universal counselling and provision of IEC Materials after admission for delivery were associated with high acceptability for PPIUCD(14), this evidence that improving quality of counselling, will result to increase the women’s accessibility to PPIUCD . Frequent exposures to formal health counselling classes and prior discussion with their husband and entire family members could improve the knowledge and the likelihood of acceptance of PPIUCD(15).

Lack of provision for PPIUCD can contribute to the occurrence of unintended pregnancies because most of the women do not return for postnatal services (10). The early initiation and provision of the postpartum family planning method (PPIUCD) during the immediate postpartum period protect women from unintended pregnancy as the majority ofwomen either resume early sexual activity or have early return to fertility (1,10).

A systematic review looking the safety and expulsion rates of postpartum IUDs has supported that the insertion of an intrauterine contraceptive within the first 48 hours of vaginal or cesarean delivery is safe(16), both vaginal and cesarean section should be encouraged , however early follow up should be encouraged to detect expulsions and tackle commons problems(16).

Another Cochrane systematic review looking at the effectiveness for IUD inserted immediately after placenta delivery showed that the benefits for effectives contraceptives immediately after delivery outweigh the disadvantages for increased risks for expulsion(17), there is need to strengthens the frequent prenatal visits during the third trimester hence it provides the opportunity to discuss the effective contraceptive methods and desired timing for initiation(17). Clinical follow up can help detect early expulsion, as can educating women about expulsion signs and symptoms(17).

Rwanda Demographics Health survey showed the women who attend ANC stands at 98% and delivery at facility 91% and family planning in Rwanda is free of charges (16,17) despite this, there is a high unmet of postpartum family planning at 19% of women with short birth to pregnancy interval, consequently, women don’t achieve their fertility preference which further indicates the need for strengthening PPFP/PPIUD at health facility level (19,16). There is a need to reach all postpartum women with unmet need for family planning.

The Ministry of Health in Rwanda has adopted the recommendations of WHO which stipulate the integration of PPIUCD services into the immediate postpartum care services which indicate attempts to initiate women on postpartum IUD after delivery. This would reduce the unmet need for postpartum family planning and reduce unplanned pregnancies through increasing access to long term FP/IUD for women after childbirth. In Rwanda, however, no study has been done to determine the current utilization and factors associated with the use of PPIUCD.

The aims of this study was to determine the prevalence and factors associated with use for PPIUCD among postpartum mothers within 48 hours after delivery.

Study area and period

The study was conducted at Muhima hospital, Department of Obstetrics and gynecology which is located in Nyarugenge District sector, Kigali city. Muhima is a 128-bed hospital specializing in gynecology and neonatology. This hospital oversees eight functional health centers. Muhima is the training site for all medical schools and schools of nursing and midwifery in Rwanda.

Muhima District Hospital was chosen because it has a high number of deliveries and it is also one of the hospitals where the implementation of PPIUD was initiated. It has an average of more than 500 deliveries monthly.

The Study design

Mixed-method concurrent design was employed to determine the use of PPIUCD and its associated factors. The cross-sectional design involved the use of an interviewer-administered questionnaire which was conducted among women who were in the immediate postpartum period. Immediate postpartum was defined as women who have given have given birth10 minutes after birth up to 48 hours of delivery(8) Also, in depth-interviews was conducted among health care providers at Muhima hospital to share their experiences about PPIUD service delivery.

Study participants and sampling procedures

The study population consisted of women who were in the immediate postpartum care within 48 hours after delivery before discharge at Muhima district hospital and Midwives who were working in the labor suite, immediate postpartum ward, and family planning department who were actively involved in the provision of PPIUCD.

The study used a consecutive sampling method to select the eligible participants who were within 48 hours after delivery. The participants were approached in the labor ward or postpartum ward where they were invited to take part in the study. The files of women who had delivered were checked to ensure that they had fulfilled the inclusion criteria of the study. The inclusion criteria for PPIUCD were Women aged 15-49 years, delivering either vaginally or by cesarean section, at Muhima hospital from January – February 2019 had received counselling for postpartum contraception and consented for postpartum use who were in the immediate postpartum period after delivery within 48 hours of birth and midwives who were working in FP services, labor suite, immediate postpartum ward who were providing FP services and other maternal health services on the days of the study were included in the study.

The exclusion criteria includes: The study excluded women who were within10 minutes after childbirth to 48 hours after delivery but clinically unstable such as: The women who had PPH, Women who have been diagnosed with chorioamnionitis, Women who have a fever ³37.5 degree Celsius during labor and delivery, Women who had active genital tract infections or were are at high risk for STD, Women are known to have ruptured membranes for greater than 24 hours before delivery. Women who have had 3rd and 4^th-degree tears, Women who had been diagnosed to have uterine abnormalities, Health care workers who were not providing the methods.

The participants were informed about the study including providing adequate information regarding the purpose, procedure, benefits, and risks of the study. The potential participants consented before they were interviewed for the study. Women who accepted to be inserted an IUD were considered to have used PPIUCD, while women who declined to use IUD were considered to have not used the PPIUCD.

Sample size determination

The sample size was powered to determine the prevalence of PPIUD. The sample size was calculated using a prevalence of 48 % for contraceptive prevalence, 95 % confidence interval, and an error margin of 5 %. A total of 383 mothers were recruited for this study(20).

The sample size for factors associated was calculated using α = Type 1 error 5%., Z = the standard normal statistic corresponding to 1.96; β = Type II error as 20%; Odds= 3.1. The odds were derived from literature; Percent of exposed with outcome=14; Risk/Prevalence ratio=2.8; Risk/Prevalence difference =9; Assuming a power of 80%, type 1 error of 5%, type II error of 20%, and odds of 3.10, the sample size of the study was estimated at 374 women. The study adopted a sample size of 383 to increase the statistical power of the study. Therefore, a sample size of 383 women was used in this study. The Fleiss formula in OpenEpi was used for determining the factors associated with the use of PPIUCD. (Ref: Fleiss, Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions, formulas pages 3.18 & 3.19). The OpenEpi Calculator was used to calculate the sample size and it was accessed from https://www.openepi.com/SampleSize/SSCohort.htm

Variables measurements

Data were collected through face to face interviewer-administered questionnaires, mixed-method were applied to collect data. The data collected include Social demographic factors;(age, level of education, marital status religious beliefs) knowledge about PPIUCD; Social-cultural factors:, (myths cultural norms, partner, support, peer influence) social-economic factors; (poverty, source of income, occupation), Reproductive factors: (parity, number of living children desired, mode of delivery, fertility desire, side effects of methods), Service delivery related factors; (availability for suppliers and IUCD, health care worker knowledge and skills, access to the health facility, knowledge for health care providers, quality of care delivered to the women, Family planning information and counselling during antenatal care ). The prevalence of participants who used PPIUCD was measured. The tools were piloted and pretested before starting data collection to assess appropriateness, content clarity, and comprehensiveness of the questions and time taken to fill the questionnaires.

Data collection

Quantitative data collection

The interviewer-administered structured questionnaires were used to collect quantitative data. The questionnaires included questions regarding the social demographics, knowledge about PPIUD use, social-cultural, social-economic and reproductive factors.

The study used a consecutive sampling method to select the eligible participants who were within 10 minutes to 48 hours after childbirth. The participants were approached in the labor ward or postpartum ward where they were invited to take part in the study at Muhima hospital. The files of women who had delivered were checked to ensure that they had fulfilled the inclusion criteria of the study. The participants were informed about the study including providing adequate information regarding the purpose, procedure, benefits, and risks of the study. The potential participants consented before they were interviewed for the study. Women who accepted to be use an IUD were considered to have used PPIUCD, while women who declined to use IUD were considered to have not used the PPIUCD.

Qualitative data collection

An in-depth interviews (IDI) were used on one to one to explore the health care provider's experience regarding PIUCD service provision. An IDI was used because it was able to capture detailed information and offers participants opportunities to share their personal experiences regarding provision for PPIUCD including the mode of supply, the training opportunity, and the institution support through PPIUCD provision. The approach has helped to distinguish an individual's opinions about provision for PPIUD.

Participants were purposively selected among the team of midwives working in antepartum, labor suite, postpartum and family planning for the time of data collection. The study purposively selected midwives for an interview until saturation was met, which was reached after interviewing 10 midwives. The IDI was conducted at the workplace in the Muhima hospital.

The IDI was conducted among selected health care providers in a convenient place where she or he was working at the time for data collection. An interview guide containing questions related to experience and practice and their perception regarding provision for PPIUCD was used in this facility-based. The interview was audiotaped and notes were taken by the research assistant.

Quantitative Data analysis

The outcome variables in this analysis is a binary variable for postpartum intrauterine contraceptive use and proportions were used to summarize participants who used PPIUCD. PPIUCD use is defined as any participant who chose IUD as postpartum family planning. Those women who did not choose to use IUD as postpartum contraceptive were classified as non-user. The prevalence of PPIUCD use was determined by dividing the number of women who had accepted to use PPIUCD by the total number of all postpartum women who participated in the study.

To determine the factors associated with the use of PPIUCD, chi-square tests, and binary logistics regression were used. The bivariate analyses were conducted to determine the independent variables that were significantly associated with PPIUCD use. The significant variables were of value less than p<.05 at the 95% confidence interval. The variables that were p<0.2 were subjected to multivariate analyses in the binary logistic model to obtain the adjusted odds ratios of the statistically significant variables.

Qualitative Data analysis

The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim in Kinyarwanda, after validating the transcription, the typed narratives were then translated into English and verified the accuracy. Analysis of the data was conducted by the primary author and included several iterative steps. Using thematic analysis, the transcripts were reviewed several times, and a set of codes were developed to describe groups of words or categories with similar meanings. The transcripts were then coded and managed using Atlas’s version 7. The grouped categories were refined and used to generate themes emerging from the data. Direct quotations from midwives are presented in italics to highlight key findings.

Ethical review and approval

Ethical review and approval were obtained from the Higher Degrees and Research Ethics Committee of the College of Health Sciences at Makerere University #SHSREC REF NO: 2018-045 and Research Ethics Committee of the College of Medicine and Health Sciences University of Rwanda No 404/CMHS IRB/2018. The administrative clearance and permissions were obtained from Muhima hospital ethical committee. Written informed consent was obtained from the mothers and the midwives. Participation was voluntary and all the interviews were conducted in private settings to ensure participant’s confidentiality.

Social demographic characteristics

Table 1. Shows that the mean age of study participants was 28.6 years (SD± 4.3 years). More than one-half (58.7%) of the respondents had a tertiary level of education and 10.4% had no formal education (Illiterate). Nearly one-half (47.5%) of the participants were Catholic, 82% were legally married, and more than one-third (37%) were employed (37%). More than three-quarters (77.5%) of the women were living in urban areas.

Table 1. Social demographic characteristics

Variable

Frequencies (%)

Age in years (Mean age X=28.9, SD±4.3

18-24

25-34

35-40

94(24.5%)

194(50.7%)

95(24.8%)

Occupation

Unemployed

Employed

Student

125(32.6%)

143(37.3%)

115(30%)

Education level

No formal education

Primary

Tertiary

42(10.9%)

116(30.28%)

225(58.7%)

Religious beliefs

Catholic

Protestant

Muslim

182(47.5%)

68(34.7%)

133(17.8%)

Marital status

Single

Married

76(19.8

307(80.1%)

Place of residence

Urban

Rural

297(77.5%)

86(22.5%)

Knowledge and Use of PPIUCD

Table 2. Shows that the majority of the women 324 (84.6%) reported that they had ever heard about the PPIUCD. The reasons for using PPIUCD included the associated fewer side effects (14.9%), non-interference with breastfeeding (10.2%), and is a long-acting method (9.1%). Some of the women did not use the method due to fear of the side effects (10%), inadequate knowledge on the method (12%), and partner’s disapproval (10%) for the method. A significant number of women were informed on PPIUCD used during antenatal care (39.9%), while others got the information during family planning services (37.1%). The majority of women 239 (62.4%) were para 2-5; and those who had normal delivery 62.9% and cesarean section, the proportion using postpartum IUCD among women who were attending Muhima Hospital were determined to be 28.1%.

Table 2. Reproductive actors and source of knowledge

Variable

Frequency (%)

Parity

2-4

91(23.8%)

239(62.4%)

53(13.8%)

Mode of delivery

Normal delivery

Cesarean section

241(62.9%)

142(37.1%)

Ever heard PPIUCD

Yes

324(84.6%)

59(15.4%)

Reason to use PPIUCD

Long-acting

Child spacing

Does not interfere with breastfeeding

No hormonal related sides effects

Fewer routine visits

Preference of other methods

35(9.1%)

15(3.9%)

38(9.9%)

56(14.9%)

14(3.9%)

225(58.4%)

Reason for don’t to use PPIUCD.

Don’t want contraceptives

Satisfied with the previous method

Afraid of sides effects

Husband disapproval

No knowledge about PPIUCD

Preference for other methods

30(8.2%)

24(6.3%)

76(20%)

31(10%)

38(12%)

184(48.0%)

Sources of knowledge

Media

Antenatal clinic

Family planning clinic

Friends

19(4.9%)

153(39.9%)

142(37.1%)

69(17.8%)

Preferred other methods

Contraceptives pills

Male condom

Implant

Injectable

14(3.6%)

19(5.0%)

75(19.5%)

31(8.0%)

Factors Associated with Postpartum IUD Use

The table 3 shows that the women who had normal delivery were three times more likely use of PPIUCD (aOR = 3.623; 95% CI 2.017–6.507) compared to cesarean delivery; participants who have PPIUCD counselling were two times more likely to use PPIUCD (aOR =2.072; 95%CI 1.018-4.218) compared their counterpart who did not receive counselling, women who got the Spouse approval were two times more likely using PPIUCD (aOR= 2.583; 95% CI 1.485-4.492) compared with women who did not get approval; participants who have P2-P4 were two times more likely to the use PPIUCD (aOR =2.265; 95% CI 1.472-3.163); pregnancy interval was significantly associated with use of PPIUCD (aOR=2.123; 95% CI 1.477-2.706 ); The level of education was associated, women with a higher level of education were significantly associated (aOR= 2.591; 95% CI 1.329- 3.062).

Table 3.: Multivariate Logistic Regression Examining Factors Associated with the uptake of Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Device Use

Variable	C.O.R. (95% CI) p -value**		a.O.R. (95% CI)*	p- Value
Parity
P1	1		1
P2-p4	3.450(1.868-6.370)	0.001*	2.265(1.472-3.163)	0.004 *
P4	5.260(2.472-11.194)	0.001*	3.524(1.711-7.257)	0.001*
Mode of delivery
Cesarean section	1		1	1
Normal delivery	0.285(0.166-0.489)	0.001*	2.623(2.017-6.507)	0.001*
Pregnancy interval
>24 months	1		1	1
12-24months	1.115(0.662-1.877)	0.682	1.517(1.293-3.115)	0.101
6-12 months	1.934(1.086-3.445)	0.025*	2.123(1.477-2.706)	0.001*
PPIUCD counselling
Yes	1.733(1.919-3.265)	0.001*	2.072(1.018-4.218)	0.001*
No	1		1
Age
35-40	4.740(2.393-9.387)	0.001*	3.560 (1.660-7.632)	0.001
25-34	2.737(1.630-4.596)	0.001*	2.515 (1.401-4.515)	0.002
15-24	1		1
Level of education
No formal education	1		1
Primary	1.281(0.776-2.116)	0.333	1.691(0.941-3.037)	0.079
Tertiary	2.132(1.900-3.050)	0.333	2.530(1.401-4.260)	0.045*
Spouse approval
Yes No	0.388 (0.237-0.638) 1	0.001*	2.591(1.485-4.492) 1	0.001*

*p<0.05: significant variables; **COR: crude odds ratios ***aOR: Adjusted odds ratio

In-depth Interviews (IDI)

In this study, midwives were providing the PPIUCD and they were supported by the Ministry of Health through training and supply for the methods at the health facility level, the investigator wanted to understand the midwives’ experiences and perceptions regarding the PPIUCD provision. A total of 10 in-depth interviews was conducted with the midwives who work on the labor suite, immediate postpartum ward, antenatal, and family planning service. From the analysis the following themes emerged:

Code	Categories	Theme

ANC counselling
Teaching mothers in labor
Teaching mother in postpartum	Education of the mothers and their partners on PPIUCD	Counselling of couples
Teaching couple
Discuss about the method
Tell mother about side effect
Emphasize mother preference
Correct myths
Correct misconception
Inform about availability
Code	Categories	Theme
Training has shaped my ability
Trained to provide counselling	Training health care providers on PPIUCD	Training of Midwives
Before was not familial
Competence training
Working with confidence
Improved quality service
Regular training
Code	Categories	Theme

	Midwives perception and behaviors about PPIUCD provision	Midwives attitudes
Inform mothers about method
Hear mother preference
Respect mothers choice
Encourage mother to use method
Tell mother about benefits for PPIUCD
Teach mothers on how it works
Code	Categories	Theme

Doubt on effectiveness of the method
Resistant to use the method
Mistaken belief that it can interfere with their life	Clients misconception on the use of PPIUCD	Clients misperception
Rumors and myths from friends and relatives
Method will interfere with sexual intercourse
Prefer to use other familial method use previously

Code	Categories	Theme
The health facility facilitate the availability of methods
High number of clients with high demand	Availability and supply of commodities	Availability of contraceptives
The health facility support the supply for PPIUCD
Regular supply for methods in labor, ANC,postpartum
All methods are available in health facility
We provide postpartum FP every day
Make sure no one miss opportunity

Theme I: Counselling for couples

Health care providers suggested that the health education of women and their husbands during antenatal care was important in increasing the acceptability and the use of PPIUCD. The midwives asserted that women come with wrong cultural beliefs which hinders the use of PPIUCD among postpartum women, through educating the couple during antenatal care corrected the myths and misconception regarding PPIUCD use and gave adequate time for women and their partners to decide earlier and make an informed choice on using PPIUCD before the delivery. This was evidenced in one of the quotes by health care providers below:

“The counselling starts from antenatal care, during labor and after delivery, we teach mothers about family planning, and we emphasize a lot on family planning after delivery. Most of the women are not aware of immediate postpartum family planning, we focus on it a lot during antenatal care and give to women the time to think about it and they come to deliver when they have already made their choice, it is also the right time for us … as we have a lot of time to discuss with women, we told them that they can get the method PPIUCD within 48 hours before discharge, we explain about all side effects for the methods and let them make choice, but most of the time we emphasize a lot on methods depending on mother preference and the methods that can fit the mother”. IDI 3

Theme II: Training for midwives

Training on PPIUCD services increases the confidence and competence among health care providers to provide the methods. The majority of participants reported that they had been trained in post-partum family planning.

“. At the beginning for PPIUD implementation I was not comfortable and having fear for providing the method due to different side effects that can occur like perforation of the uterus, expulsion …, but now because of competence from the training we got, I provide the methods with confidence and it has improved the quality care service delivery.” IDI 3

The effective training for a health care provider, increase the quality of provision:

“The training effects me as a midwife I have been trained and provide PPIUD counselling, but those who have not yet trained, it’s hard for them to give, because they don’t want to provide the method they are not conversant with, and affect the acceptability and use of the method to women, the facility facilitates us in terms of the regular training provision but there is need to increase training”. (IDI 2).

Theme III: Midwives attitudes The midwives perceived that the use of PPIUCD was a suitable and preferred family planning method for women in the immediate postpartum period. The midwives perceived that the method was less painful for the women and that it required no additional need for frequent re-visits by the client after insertion to the hospital.

“I teach the mother about all methods we have, I do hear her preference, and I advise her depending on her preference, I respect mother choice when I am about to provide the method. I encourage women to use the PPIUCD because it is safe and less painful insertion considering with interval PPIUD method and will not require women to comeback frequently at the hospital and this is the right time when women are still the facility, motivated with health care providers and her husband to think about her next pregnancy spacing and make informed choice ”.( IDI 1..

Theme IV: Clients misperception

According to the midwives, women were hesitant to use the method because of the mistaken belief that it might interfere with sexual intercourse. This was captured in the following quote below:

“When we approach women during counselling on PPIUCD, they used to doubt methods whether it will work, different rumors and myth from their friends and relatives about PPIUD, have confusion whether her husband will be comfortable during sexual intercourse and because they are not familiar with using method immediately after delivery as they were routinely used to injectable and pills after six weeks or before based on this myth” (IDI 5).

Theme V: Availability of contraceptives

The availability and supply of commodities increase the consumption of a service. The midwives recognized that regular supply of the PPIUCD to ensure that no woman would miss getting the method because of stock out.

“The hospital administration ensures that all the training materials and the PPIUCD methods are available in the hospital. We have a high number of deliveries here at Muhima hospital, and there is a high demand for the method before discharge as women got counselling from ANC. The administration supports us in all ways to help us deliver the PPIUCD methods to women. They provide regular supply for the methods in labor and family planning services to make sure no woman can miss the opportunity for PPIUD insertion” (IDI 7).

The findings of the study showed that the uptake of PPIUCD was associated with normal birth, PPIUCD counselling, spousal approval, parity, birth interval, level of education. Health education of mothers and partners on PPIUCD, training of health care providers, and availability of supplies to provide PPIUCD influenced use PPIUCD.

Overall the prevalence rate of 28.1% for the use PPIUCD in this study was generally higher than other study done in Ethiopia 12.4%, in India 12.6%, Texas in 13.5% Brunson et al., ;Gonie et al.,; Rajasthan et al.,,(12,14) and this prevalence was in line with findings from Tanzania which found 27% (22) and was attributed on the fact that the health care providers from Tanzania setting were trained to provide PPIUCD and enhance women knowledge during ANC. The high prevalence rate in Rwanda could be attributed to the fact that Muhima Hospital is one of the piloting health facility for PPIUCD implementation in Rwanda and the Ministry of Health has put many resources such training of health care providers, supplying the methods in the facility which might have increased the use of the PPIUCD. The higher use of PPIUCD in the facility could be due attributed to the regular provision of all the resources required for training of midwives as well as regular supplies of IUD materials in the health facility. This shows that if there is a commitment from the government, there is the sustainability of any outcome.

The level of education influences health behavioral, in this study, it was observed that the use of immediate PPIUCD increased with the level of education. Women who are educated are empowered to decide fertility control and can better understand the health information offered to them regarding the use of PPIUCD It was also reported by midwives that women who are educated were more likely to visit a health facility and receive counselling for different methods available in the health facility.. This is in line also with a study done in Ethiopia where women with formal education were more likely to use PPIUCD compared with counterparts (10).

In this study Counselling for mothers during prenatal visits increased the awareness for mothers regarding the PPIUCD, Counselling the couple during antenatal was significantly associated with the use of PPIUCD, which was consistent with the various studies done in West-central Africa and Ethiopia (20,21) . The role of counselling was supported by midwives who reported that women couselled during antenatal care increased the demand and uptake of PPIUD because this creates an opportunity to have the mothers and their partners together. . Furthermore, the antenatal counselling also allows the client to have enough time to discuss with the family methods and also to have access information from health care providers which enables them to make an informed decision before the time of delivery as women may have more information on the benefits of initiating postpartum contraceptives utilizations on a timely manner and this can increase their intention to use immediately after delivery.

Male involvement in reproductive health is an essential component in promoting maternal and family health. In this study, women who received approval to use the method from their partners were more likely to use the method than their counterparts. Additionally, the midwives mentioned that when husbands/ partners attend the ANC, They understand well the role of initiating contraceptives immediately after birth and make it easy to take the decision at home before coming at facility. This was similar with the study done in Ethiopia which showed that the higher odds of women who accept the PPIUCD were women who have had a discussion with their partners(25) and a study in India (26) reported that 42.96% of women declined to use PPIUCD due to partners' non-involvement in decision making. This indicates that the male's involvement in the decisions making process is necessary to increase the use of PPIUCD and prolong the continuation of the method and also it should be explained the importance of male involvement during counselling and decisions making concerning to fertility and reproductive health decisions and the need for involving partners in issues related to health and specifically reproductive health.

To achieve optimal birth spacing and ultimately to improve birth outcomes, there is a need to have access to postpartum family planning services after birth. The short birth to pregnancy interval less than two years was significantly associated with the use of PPIUCD. These findings were in line with a study done in India(27) who got the same findings such as among women with short birth interval were more likely to use PPIUCD, this was also supported by World Health Organisation guidelines released that healthy timing and spacing of pregnancies have a positive effect on maternal health and newborn outcomes, when promoted in countries with high birth rates, 32% of all maternal deaths and over 1 million deaths of children under five could be prevented (28).

The number of children has been identified as an important individual characteristic influencing women’s reproductive health behaviors including uptake for postpartum family planning. The parity was associated with the use PPIUCD, women with a higher parity were more likely to use PPIUCD, this simply reflects that women with high parity required long term contraceptives for spacing secondly women who are multipara were more likely to meet the health service provider and obtained suitable information regarding mode of family planning. The findings were consistent with the study done in Ghana which reported ahigh acceptance rate to use PPIUCD among multipara women(29).

The mode of delivery either spontaneous vaginal delivery or cesarean section contributes to PPIUCD insertion, in this study women who delivered normally were more likely to use PPIUCD compared to women who had a caesarian section. The higher utilization of PPIUCD among women with normal delivery could partly be attributed to the fact that during the training sessions a lot of emphases were put on the midwives and the obstetricians were not trained so they lacked the knowledge and information. There is a need to train both Midwives and obstetricians so that the service could be provided by both. In India, both midwives and obstetricians were trained and the findings from the study, reported that 83% of PPIUD were inserted during normal delivery(30).

The findings from health care providers interview show that various measures need to be considered for effective PPIUCD delivery to the mothers who are in need including; the training of health services, the availability of the method in facility, providers respects to women, privacy, waiting and counseling time were predictors for PPIUCD use, this shows that the facility needs to make regular training and supply of the method at the facility level, these predict the use of the PPUCD and increases the provider confidence to counsel and to provide the method and hence it impacts the client satisfaction. Similar findings were reported by Melissa et al., which shows that the competence of the health service provider is linked to the client’s satisfaction(31).

This study has explored experience and perceptions for services providers offering PPIUCD services at Muhima hospital, the study has highlighted the perception and experiences of providers about PPIUCD. The participants show positive perceptions and experiences about PPIUCD which can be critical advocate for this methods in all level of facilities across the country.

In the current study shows that participants were comfortable for counselling the clients about PPIUCD; during antenatal visit, labor and immediate after delivery. This is due to that majority of providers from the facility participating in this study have got the competence training which helped them to correct the myth and misconception related to PPIUCD to help women understand the method, this finding is in line with guidelines from (K4health 2014), recommending that health care providers competence is critical in effective service delivery for effective use(32). The ANC period was the suitable period for counseling the women on PPIUCD. The reason stated by midwives was that it give time for reinforcement of the messages and allows enough time to the client for discussion with family to arrive at an informed decision after delivery, this finding are in line with valliappan et al (2018) study done in Indi(15), stated that health care providers should be continue health counseling to the pregnant women, especially in the last trimester and in every visit to reinforce the uptake for PPIUCD(15).

Additionally , other participants shows that the immediate PPIUCD counselling after delivery was also suitable for counselling as the women is most receptive for family planning during this period, the implication of counselling during this period define that mother is more likely to accept a method as she is motivated and does not want to get pregnancy soon , provide a reliable contraceptive method and ensures that women leaves the facility safe and protected from pregnancy in the near the future, this finding are in line with study done by Melissa et al 2012 to assess uptake for PPFP and shows that women choose PPIUCD due is the long-term method and safe(33)

The findings from this study shows that the training of health services and the availability of the method in facility providers respects to women, privacy, waiting and counselling time were predictors for PPIUCD use, this shows that the facility need to make regular training and supply of the method at facility level , these predict the use of the PPUCD and increases the provider confidence to counsel and to provide the method thus impact the client satisfaction; similar findings were reported by Melissa et al (2012) show that the competence of health service provider is linked to client’s satisfaction(33)

Study strength and limitation

This study used a mixed-method approach that provided complementary findings. The weaknesses inherent in the quantitative or qualitative approach were supplemented by findings from either of the approaches.
The study has used a facility-based cross-sectional design, the investigator was able to collect data from the client at one point in time regarding the uptake for the method, however, there were no follow up made to assess the side effects for the method and client satisfaction.

Over a quarter (28%) of women in the postpartum period used PPIUCD. The use of PPIUCD was associated with spousal approval, normal vaginal birth, antenatal counselling for PPIUCD, higher parity, short birth interval, and level of education. Health education of women and partners on PPIUCD, training of health providers, misconceptions regarding PPIUCD use and availability of supplies to provide PPIUCD influenced the use of PPIUCD.

ACOG: American Congress for Obstetrician and Gynecologist; ANC: Antenatal Care; DHS: Demographic and Health Survey; FGDs: Focus Group Discussions’: International Federation for Gynecologist and Obstetricians; IUDs: Intrauterine Devices; LARC: long-acting reversible contraception; MOH: Ministry Of Health; NISR: National Institute of statistics of Rwanda; PPFP: postpartum Family planning; PPIUCD: Post-Partum Intrauterine Contraceptive Devices; TWFR (Total Wanted Fertility Rate); UNFPA: United Nations Fund for Populations Activities; USAID: United State Agency for International Development ;WHO: World Health Organization

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Consent for publication

Not applicable

Availability of data and materials

The datasets used and /or analyzed during the current study are not publicly available due to some privacy reasons but are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Competing interests

The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.

Funding

The work was supported by Grant Number D43TW010132 supported by Office of the Director, National Institutes of Health (OD), National Institute Of Dental & Craniofacial Research (NIDCR), National Institute Of Neurological Disorders And Stroke (NINDS), National Heart, Lung, And Blood Institute (NHLBI), Fogarty International Center (FIC), National Institute On Minority Health And Health Disparities (NIMHD). Its contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of the supporting offices.

Research reported in this publication was supported by the Fogarty International Center of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number 1R25TW011213. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.

Authors' contributions

KAC, SNM, DK, MP, Conceptualized and designed the study, developed the methodology, supervised the data collection, analyzed and interpreted the data and wrote the manuscript. KAC critically edited the manuscript, and all authors read and approved the final manuscript

Acknowledgements

We would like to acknowledge all those who participated in the study. we are also grateful to thank the study participants, research assistants, the management and staff for Muhima district hospital for their great contribution and support. Our gratitude also goes to TSAM Project for financial project.

WHO. Postpartum Family Planning. 2013.
WHO. WHO technical consultation on postpartum and postnatal care. World Heal Organ. 2010;1–56.
UNFPA. Trends in Contraceptive Use Worldwide. 2015.
WHO. Report of a WHO Technical Consultation on Birth Spacing. 2007;
Abraha TH, Gebrezgiabher BB, Aregawi BG, Belay DS. Predictors of postpartum contraceptive use in rural Tigray region , northern Ethiopia : a multilevel analysis. 2018;1–10.
Chakraborty NM, Murphy C, Paudel M, Sharma S. Knowledge and perceptions of the intrauterine device among family planning providers in Nepal: A cross-sectional analysis by cadre and sector. BMC Health Serv Res [Internet]. 2015;15(1):1–14. Available from: https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12913-015-0701-y?site=bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com
WHO. Medical eligibility criteria for contraceptive use. 5th editio. WHO; 2015.
USAID J. Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Device ( PPIUD ) Services Learner ’ s Handbook. 2010; Available from: https://toolkits.knowledgesuccess.org/sites/default/files/ppiud_learners_guide_update.pdf
WHO. Medical eligibility criteria for contraceptive use Fifth edition 2015 Executive summary. Who. 2015;(July):1–14.
Gonie A, Worku C, Assefa T, Bogale D, Girma A. Acceptability and factors associated with post-partum IUCD use among women who gave birth at bale zone health facilities ,. Contracept Reprod Med bmc. 2018;1–8.
RCOG. Best practice in postpartum family planning. R Coll Obstet. 2015;(1).
Rajasthan S, Sharma A, Gupta V. A study of awareness and factors affecting acceptance of PPIUCD in. nternational J Reprod ,contraception Obstet Gynecol. 2017;4(8):2706–10.
USAID J. PPIUD Services : Start-Up to Regional Meeting Burkina Faso. 2014;
Pearson E, Senderowicz L, Pradhan E, Francis J, Muganyizi P, Shah I, et al. Effect of a postpartum family planning intervention on postpartum intrauterine device counseling and choice: Evidence from a cluster-randomized trial in Tanzania. BMC Womens Health [Internet]. 2020;20(1):1–13. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7218519/pdf/12905_2020_Article_956.pdf
Valliappan A, Dorairajan G, Chinnakali P. Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Device : Knowledge and Factors Affecting Acceptance among Pregnant / parturient Women Attending a Large Tertiary Health Center in Puducherry , India. 2017;69–74. Available from: http://www.ijamhrjournal.org/temp/IntJAdvMedRes4269-3843748_104037.pdf
Hooda R, Mann S, Nanda S, Gupta A, More H, Bhutani J. Immediate Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Device Insertions in Caesarean and Vaginal Deliveries : A Comparative Study of Follow-Up Outcomes. 2016;2016(7695847):5. Available from: https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijrmed/2016/7695847/
Lopez LM, Bernholc A, Hubacher D, Stuart G, Van Vliet HA. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews Immediate postpartum insertion of intrauterine device for contraception (Review) Immediate postpartum insertion of intrauterine device for contraception (Review). Cochrane Database Syst Rev [Internet]. 2015;(6). Available from: https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD003036.pub3/full
RDHS M 2016. Rwanda [Internet]. 2015. Available from: https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR316/FR316.pdf
MOH Rwanda. The Government of Rwanda The Ministry of Health. 2014;(April 2014):19.
Leslie K. Analysis of sample size in consumer surveys Analysis of sample size in consumer surveys , GfK Polonia 2. 2013; Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/db_indicators/surveys/documents/workshops/2013/pl-gfk_k._pusczak_-_sample_size_in_customer_surveys_v2_2.pdf
Brunson MR, Mph DAK, Drph CHO, Weir LF, Mph TAR. a large universal healthcare system. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2017;217(1):55.e1-55.e9.
Abdulwahab R, Ali M, Sciences a. acceptability and safety of postpartum intrauterine contraceptive device among parturients at muhimbili national hospital , tanzania. 2012;(November).
Tsigue Pleah, a Yolande Hyjazi, b Suzanne Austin, b Abdoulaye Diallo, b Blami Dao, a Rachel Waxman a PK. Increasing Use of Postpartum Family Planning and the Central Africa. 2016;4:140–52.
Taye EB, Mekonen DG, Debele TZ. Prevalence of post partum modern family planning utilization and associated factors among postpartum mothers in Debre Tabor. BMC Res Notes. 2019;1–7.
Wulifan JK, Brenner S, Jahn A, Allegri M De. A scoping review on determinants of unmet need for family planning among women of reproductive age in low and middle income countries. BMC Womens Health. 2016;
Sujnanendra M. Evaluation of Safety , Efficacy , and Expulsion of Post-Placental and Intra-Cesarean Insertion of Intrauterine Contraceptive Devices ( PPIUCD ). 2014;
Deshpande S, Gadappa S, Yelikar K, Wanjare N, Andurkar S. Awareness , acceptability and clinical outcome of post-placental insertion of intrauterine contraceptive device in Marathwada region , India. 2017;4(2015):77–82.
WHO. Working together for health. 2006;
Apanga PA, A MA, Dam. Factors influencing the uptake of family planning services in the Talensi District, Ghana. PanAfrican Med. 2015;8688:1–9.
Borthakur S, Sarma AK, Bhattacharjee AK, Deka N. acceptance of post partum intra-uterine contraceptive device ( ppiucd ) among women attending gauhati medical college and hospital ( gmch ) for delivery between january 2011 to december 2014 and their follow up. 2015;4(92):15756–8.
Chen MJ, Gaffield ME. Use of the World Health Organization ’ s Medical Eligibility Criteria for Contraceptive Use Guidance in sub-Saharan African Countries : A Cross-Sectional Study. 2016;4(3):506–10.
Report M. PPIUD Services : Start-Up to Regional Meeting Burkina Faso. 2014; Available from: https://toolkits.knowledgesuccess.org/sites/default/files/burkina_ppiud_regional_meeting_report_final.pdf
A, Magnitude S. Factors Influencing Uptake of Intrauterine Devices among Postpartum Adolescents: A Qualitative Study. NIH Public Access [Internet]. 2013;31(9):1713–23. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3890255/pdf/nihms535257.pdf

Download PDF

Journal Publication

published 27 Oct, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth →

Editorial decision: Minor revision
30 Sep, 2020
Editor assigned by journal
28 Sep, 2020
Editor invited by journal
27 Sep, 2020
Submission checks completed at journal
09 Jun, 2020

You are reading this older preprint version

Read the latest preprint version →

Factors associated with the Uptake of Immediate Postpartum Intrauterine Contraceptive Devices(PPIUCD) in Rwanda: A Mixed Methods Study

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 2

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Abbreviations

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Consent for publication

Availability of data and materials

Competing interests

Funding

Authors' contributions

Acknowledgements

References

Supplementary Files

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 2