The present meta-analysis incorporates MR studies that examine the genetic prediction of insomnia in association with 57 chronic diseases. The data reveals compelling evidence supporting a causal link between insomnia and heightened risk of 13 circulatory ailments, 7 neuropsychiatric afflictions, type 2 diabetes, lung cancer (including squamous lung cancer and lung adenocarcinoma), 3 digestive diseases, 10 pain conditions, asthma, and OA. Conversely, MR evidence suggests that 3 circulatory disorders (comprising atrial fibrillation, heart attack, and hemorrhagic stroke), 8 neuropsychiatric disorders (including Alzheimer's disease, traumatic stress disorder, epilepsy, attention deficit, schizophrenia, age-related macular degeneration, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson's, and alcohol dependence), 4 digestive disorders (such as nonalcoholic liver disease, IBD, ulcerative colitis, Crohn's disease), tuberculosis, abnormal heel bone density, and rheumatoid arthritis are improbable to be causally related to insomnia.
Previous research suggests that insomnia may have a significant impact on the likelihood of developing type 2 diabetes, as it activates sympathetic nerves, increasing insulin resistance[65]. Furthermore, insomnia is linked to chronic systemic inflammation, which could contribute to the onset of insulin resistance, ultimately leading to the development of type 2 diabetes[66, 67]. Increased inflammatory markers in individuals suffering from sleep deprivation also play a role in atherosclerosis[68, 69]. Mechanisms that may explain the relationship between short sleep duration and the elevated risk of peripheral arterial disease include activation of the autonomic nervous system, oxidative stress, endothelial dysfunction, impaired metabolic regulation, as well as coagulation system activity[70]. The development of intracranial aneurysms may be associated with alterations in cerebrovascular health, as a result of insomnia-induced increases in circulating catecholamine levels[71], sympathetic activity[71], inflammation[73–75], and endocrine or metabolic dysregulation[76, 77]. Insomnia is related to hypertension, brought about by increased sympathetic nervous system activity, heart rate, and abnormal hormone secretion[78], all of which could further contribute to the onset of intracranial hemorrhage. Moreover, insomnia may exacerbate atherosclerosis by abnormal regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis[79] and the renin-angiotensin system[80], irregular regulation of the autonomic nervous system, increased sympathetic nervous system activity[81], systemic inflammation, and abnormal lipid metabolites[82], which may result in plaque rupture and thrombosis, ultimately affecting the risk of coronary heart disease positively. Lastly, insomnia is linked to impaired glucose metabolism[83] and melatonin secretion[84], which could also contribute to the onset of coronary heart disease.
Research indicates that insomnia can impact the immune system through multiple pathways, such as pro-inflammatory cytokines, lymphocyte subsets, and telomere length[85]. This may be a significant factor in the increased risk of bloodstream infections[86] and immune responses that lead to sepsis associated with insomnia. Insomnia or sleep deprivation has been shown to decrease the number and function of natural killer cells and T cells, thus increasing vulnerability to allergens[87, 88]. Insomnia can also modulate both the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and the sympathetic nervous system, causing upregulation of pro-inflammatory responses[89, 90], β-adrenergic signaling activation, and increases in systemic inflammatory markers, such as NF-κB and pro-inflammatory cytokine production. Among these diseases, allergic asthma is particularly associated with changes in levels of IL-6[91], NF-κB[92, 93], and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (CRP)[94]. Additionally, insomnia can suppress melatonin, an endocrine hormone with circadian rhythm regulation, immunomodulatory, antioxidant, and cytoprotective effects. This suppression of melatonin also contributes to increased immune disorders and activation of inflammatory pathways[95].
Disturbances in melatonin secretion are commonly observed in patients with chronic primary insomnia. Furthermore, sleep quality impairment is associated with reduced levels of Klotho, a senescence-inhibitory protein that restrains lung cancer cell proliferation and promotes apoptosis[96–98]. Certain intermediate phenotypes may be implicated in the connection between insomnia and lung cancer. Indeed, a bidirectional causal relationship exists between insomnia and smoking[99], with smoking initiation and daily cigarette consumption positively correlated with insomnia. Insomnia is thought to promote heavy smoking while discouraging cessation, given the carcinogenic nature of smoking. Dependence on smoking may thus be an important mediator of the link between insomnia and lung cancer[100]. Multiple modern studies suggest that dysregulation of biological clock genes[101], immunosuppression due to sleep deprivation[Bollinger 2010], and changes in melatonin secretion[102–104] (i.e., timing, amount, and duration) as a result of circadian rhythm disruptions may all contribute to tumorigenesis and development. Melatonin has several antitumor effects, such as regulating the cell cycle and apoptosis, stimulating cell differentiation, antioxidant effects, and protection against dysbiosis, which often occurs in lung cancer patients and may be a potential underlying factor[105–107].
The brain-gut axis can influence intestinal dynamics, fluid secretion, the permeability of the intestinal epithelium, and the composition of the gut microbiota[108]. Disturbances in sleep patterns such as insomnia and short sleep duration can contribute to the pathogenesis of IBS through immune system dysfunction[109], brain-gut axis, and disruption of circadian rhythms[110]. Plasma levels of inflammatory cytokines such as CRP and IL-6 are notably higher in individuals with insomnia and short sleep durations, and medical research indicates that aberrant sleep patterns have negative effects on gastrointestinal function, increase the likelihood of peptic ulcers, and may be a crucial factor in the development of chronic inflammatory conditions such as PUD[111]. Sleep deprivation hinders the repair of the gastric mucosa, decreases blood flow to the gastric mucosa, inhibits cell proliferation, and weakens the ionic barrier of the gastric mucosa, potentially resulting in gastric mucosal erosion[112]. Studies show that deep sleep promotes gastric mucosal outflow and blood flow, as well as melatonin secretion while inhibiting gastrin secretion, which helps to prevent the onset and recurrence of PUD. Melatonin is believed to prevent the recurrence of PUD by promoting cell proliferation, scavenging oxidative free radicals, and enhancing the microcirculation of the gastric mucosa[113].
Psychiatric disorders, such as anxiety and depressive symptoms, often coincide with IBS, GORD, and PUD, and are associated with a range of biological and psychosocial mechanisms that mainly disrupt the gut-brain axis[114]. Additionally, sleep behavior plays a critical role in various brain functions, including nerve cell growth, synaptogenesis, and memory function[115, 116]. Freeman et al. conducted a large randomized controlled trial of insomnia-related mental health issues and showed that insomnia is a significant causal risk factor for mental health problems, and remediating sleep disturbance can aid mental health problems such as depression, anxiety, autism, and post-traumatic stress disorder[117]. Failure to do so may lead to the development of suicidal behavior[118].
The precise mechanism by which insomnia contributes to OA remains uncertain. However, it is postulated that sleep fragmentation and deprivation may modify the gut microbiota[119], potentially increasing the likelihood of OA development[120, 121]. Moreover, insomnia may elicit the secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-6, IL-1β, IL-17, and TNF-α[67, 85]. Sleep disorders also have close associations with melatonin production, which may establish a link between circadian rhythms and OA[122, 123]. Melatonin, in turn, may contribute to OA by regulating the release of chondrogenic degenerative enzymes, pro-inflammatory cytokines, and inflammatory mediators[124]. Additionally, the link between sleep deprivation, obesity, and OA may be mediated by certain metabolic disorders, such as elevated leptin levels in obese individuals leading to cartilage degeneration[125].
There is notable consistency in the genetically predicted associations between insomnia and various types of pain, indicating a shared causal pathway between the two conditions. Nitric oxide (NO) is believed to be a critical element in the regulation of sleep-wake balance, with a consequential role in both pain modulation and sleep. Elevated NO levels have been observed in sleep-deprived rats, with NO levels in the basal forebrain being elevated before the elevation of iNOS and NO levels in the frontal cortex. Moreover, raised NO levels promote nociceptive hypersensitivity, as demonstrated by the reduction of mechanical hypersensitivity with the use of neuronal-type nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) inhibitors. In a rat model, sleep deprivation was seen to exacerbate chronic pain, causing severe pain.[126–129] In addition, another study showed increased basal cortisol levels and hyperresponsiveness of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis to stressors in patients with insomnia, which correlated with the relationship between insomnia and mechanical hypersensitivity[130]. Prostaglandins (PG), a classic marker of inflammation that mediates inflammatory pain, were found to be significantly elevated in the cerebrospinal fluid of a mouse experiment[131]. The findings suggest that patients with insomnia experience over-activation of pain inhibitory pathways, leading to pain perception that is independent of pharmacological treatment[132]. This may be related to the significance of sleep in regulating neurodevelopment and maintenance. Insomnia is also linked to changes in the caudate nucleus neurons that are involved in pain inhibition[133, 134]. Thus, treating insomnia may be critical to mitigating pain.
Upon analysis of genetically predicted insomnia and various disease outcomes, including but not limited to GORD, depression, heart failure, smoking addiction, atrial fibrillation, intracranial hemorrhage, and coronary artery disease, heterogeneity was observed in the estimates obtained from individual studies. This heterogeneity appears to have been caused by varying levels of association across studies, which may be attributed to the use of different genetic instruments or to study populations with different characteristics or ethnicities.
This study is the first systematic review and meta-analysis based on insomnia-related MR studies, which aim to eliminate the potential effects of weak instrumental variables and verify results through multiple sensitivity analyses. While some causal relationships between diseases may be attributed to common risk factors, many MR analyses exclude SNPs that may be influenced by such factors and still support previously found causal relationships. However, this study has limitations, including a lack of sufficient MR studies related to some diseases and the fact that the included results are based on European ancestry and may not apply to other populations. In addition, the definition of insomnia in the GWAS data used in the study, which mainly included difficulty falling asleep and easy awakening, was a subjective classification of sleep characteristics by questionnaire; a more detailed and objective subtype classification would help to explore causal relationships and underlying mechanisms. The time-consuming nature of objective sleep EEG feature extraction and classification also limits the understanding of the causal relationship between insomnia subtypes and chronic diseases based on sleep staging. Finally, this study only examined one-way studies with insomnia as exposure and chronic diseases as outcomes and further meta-analyses are needed to explore reverse MR findings.