Plumage color and feather development
Traits, such as plumage coloration, usually have lineage specificity, are commonly related to selection pressure, and reflect the adaptive characteristics of species [3]. Major changes in key genes or at the genomic level may drive plumage color differentiation on a larger evolutionary scale [3]. The plumage color of chicken is a complex trait controlled by several genes [49]. Research related to plumage color has been widely studied in birds based on different data types, such as transcriptomes and genomes, and identified several significant signaling pathways and genes [3, 36, 37, 50, 51]. For example, manakins are a family of small suboscine passerine birds characterized by a variety of plumage colors, their genome evolutionary features were analyzed to explore the possible genetic mechanism of color diversities, and four plumage color-related genes (TBC1D22A, EDA, SLC45A2 and GOLGB1) under positive selection were found [36].
For related signaling pathways on plumage coloration, several confirmed pathways involved in pigmentation, such as the BMP signaling pathway, and pathways of cAMP, SCF-KIT, Notch, ERK, CREB/MITF/tyrosinase, Wnt/β-catenin and MAPK, and genes, such as MC1R, TYR, SLC24A5, and DCT, played a role in melanin proportion synthesis [37]. Some signaling pathways and genes were commonly found in previous investigations of birds, such as the TYR gene in chicken [52], the crested ibis [53], and ducks [54]. The melanogenesis pathway found in PSGs of the Temminck's tragopan was also been identified in other birds [32, 37, 38, 55–57], such as the chicken based on transcriptome [57] and genomic SNP data [32]. The WNT10A gene was identified in melanogenesis pathway in PSGs of the Temminck's tragopan, and a previous study showed that miR-193b might participate in the adjustment of coat color in the skin tissue of Cashmere goats by targeting WNT10A and GNAI2 [58]. Some other genes were also found enriched in the melanogenesis pathway in previous studies. For example, integrative analysis of transcriptomic and metabolomic data of chickens, 25 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (such as TYRP1, PDZK1, and DCT) and 11 transcription factors (such as FOXA1 and SOX10) in the melanogenesis pathways were identified, and the dual physiological functions of the PDZK1 gene were revealed [55]. Based on transcriptomics and proteomics analyses, a total of eight DEGs, such as ASIP and WNT9A, and nine differentially expressed proteins (DEPs), such as DVL3 and CAMK2A, in chicken to be involved in the melanogenesis pathway was identified [37]. In addition, genes, such as MAPK1, the main member of MAPKs, were identified enriched in the MAPK signaling pathway in PSGs of the Temminck's tragopan. By comparing transcription and protein levels between the red and black skin of Plectropomus leopardus, ERK1/2 (corresponding to the MAPK1 gene) was interfered with after RNAi, and the local skin of the tail would turn black [59].
For related genes on plumage coloration, more than 200 genes associated with pigmentation have been found in mammals, and genes associated with plumage color mutations were increasingly identified in birds [51]. Multiple genes related to plumage color have been found in birds, such as TBC1D22A, EDA, SLC45A2, and GOLGB1 [36], EDNRB2 [51], GRM5, RAB38 and NOTCH2 [60], GPNMB, PMEL, TYRP1, GPR143, OCA2, SOX10, KRT75 and TYR [61], LATS1, MAPKAPK2, PBRM1 and TTBK2 [62], MC1R, TYR and ASIP [63]. For example, 18 candidate genes (such as CKMT1B and MIR1772) and 89 putative gene-gene combinations responsible for plumage color variation in chickens were distinguished [32]. The down-regulation of TYRP1, DCT, PMEL, MLANA, and HPGDS may result in reduced eumelanin and increased pheomelanin synthesis in yellow plumage in chicken [64]. The association between plumage color and genetic variation of MC1R, TYR, and ASIP in chicken was indicated [63].
Several candidate genes have been identified with color differentiation, such as SOX10 and MITF. For example, the light yellow phenotype in chicken is caused by a 7.6 kb non-coding deletion near the SOX10 gene [49], while this mutation has also been reported to lead to dark brown plumage in chickens with an 8.3 kb deletion upstream of the SOX10 gene [65]. The MITF gene seems to be primarily associated with loss of pigmentation and patterning [54], and a stop codon caused by a 2-bp deletion in exon 11 of this gene was responsible for the silver plumage color in Japanese quail [66]. In addition, the ASIP, MC1R, TYRP1, and BCO2 genes were found to play a potential role in the coloration of melanin and carotenoids in bird sexual dimorphism plumages [31] Based on the genome-wide association study, several candidate genes in chicken, such as TYR for pure white, GOLGB1, OSBPL3, PCDH15 and REEP3 for yellow, CAMKK1 and IFT22 for black, and CDKN2A for barred plumage in adults were found [52]. The white color feathers in chickens were due to the recessive insertion mutation of TYR, while the formation of black area size and color depth may be caused by the expression levels of GPNMB, PMEL, TYRP1, GPR143, OCA2, SOX10, SLC45A2, KRT75, and TYR [61]. MITF and EDNRB2 genes were functional candidate genes that contributed to white and black plumage due to their indirect involvement in the melanogenesis pathway in ducks based on genome-wide analyses [56], and the EDNRB2 gene was responsible for tyrosinase-independent recessive white and mottled plumage colors in chickens [51]. The MC1R gene was also associated with the extended black color in chickens [67].
Candidate genes related to plumage coloration found in PSGs of the Temminck's tragopan have been also found in the other birds, such as MAPKAPK2 [62], SLC6A6 and SMAD6 [56]. The PDGFRA gene was identified as associated with the coat color of mammals, such as cattle and goats. For example, genes (e.g., PDGFRA and MITF) were promising candidates for black and teat color in Holstein cattle [68]. According to previous studies, the PDGFRA gene was related to a proportion of black [68], SLC6A6, CHCHD6, RPN1, and PSMD6 genes were associated with white plumage, BTK, Cnot6l, and SMAD6 genes were correlated with grey plumage [56], MAPKAPK2, PBRM1, and TTBK2 genes were associated with melanogenesis [62], and the SLC45A2 gene played an important role in vesicle sorting in the melanocytes [50], respectively. Among them, the SLC45A2 gene encoded a transporter protein, which mediated melanin synthesis, and has been also reported as related to plumage color in birds [36, 50, 69]. Besides, the SLC45A2 gene played a significant role in vesicle sorting in the melanocytes, and two independent missense mutations (Tyr277Cys and Leu347Met) of this gene were associated with the silver plumage color in chicken [50]. Furthermore, the SLC45A2 gene was also found to be positively selected in Machaeropterus deliciosus, and may explain its unique reddish-brown body plumage among other studied manakins [36]. The identified protein-coding and cis-regulatory mutations in TYRP1, SOX10, and SLC45A2 underlay classical color phenotypes of pigeons [70].