This study explores the associations among various factors, including demographic variables, occupational characteristics, psychosocial risk factors, and health status, with MSDs in a large Italian cohort of workers representing the national workforce. The findings suggest that workers experiencing psychosocial risks at work face a higher risk of MSDs. The study underscores the importance of considering both physical and psychosocial factors in preventing and managing MSDs in the workplace. According to the biopsychosocial model, MSDs are triggered by a wide range of work-related factors and are a significant issue in workplace prevention and management. They represent one of the most common work-related disorders with consequences such as disability, workday loss, and early retirement [1].
While some evidence from previous studies exists [10, 16, 20], a debate is ongoing on the relationships between workplace factors and MSDs to gain a comprehensive and complementary view of how different work-related risk factors affect the development and progression of various MSDs and to establish organizational strategies and actions with a prevention approach. Therefore, a comprehensive analysis of individual, occupational, and psychosocial risk factors associated with MSDs is needed to drive integrated actions at policy and organizational levels. Although previous studies have considered different factors related to MSDs, few studies have adopted a multiple-factor modelling approach to address the main individual, occupational, and work aspects that may have a combined significant association with such diseases [10, 20]. Our findings confirm the association between sociodemographic factors (gender, age, educational level, occupational position) and MSDs. Specifically, women, older people, lower educational level, and blue-collar workers showed a higher risk of musculoskeletal pain.
The study reveals a higher risk for females in developing MSDs than males, particularly related to shoulder, neck, and upper limb pain. These findings support existing literature that emphasizes a greater prevalence and impact of these disorders in females [38, 39], who often experience more severe conditions than males [40]. This discrepancy is primarily attributed to biological factors. However, the biopsychosocial model of MSD emergence suggests that other factors related to gender diversity may contribute to these disorders. Among these factors, workplace psychosocial risks play a significant role [15, 17, 19]. These risks can interact with physical stressors, increasing the risk of MSDs. An important finding is the link between workplace violence or harassment and MSDs. Women often face a higher risk of involvement in such incidents [41], leading to psychological stress, anxiety, and fear that impact musculoskeletal health. Stress and anxiety can cause muscular tension, increasing pain and discomfort in the shoulders, neck, and upper limbs. Additionally, women often bear more family responsibilities, affecting their work quality. Balancing personal and work life is crucial for overall health and contributes to MSD development. Increased conflict between family and work responsibilities heightens stress, making women more susceptible to MSDs. Women frequently hold jobs exposed to combined physical and psychosocial risks, such as roles involving customer, pupil, or patient interactions, or in sectors like healthcare, education, or public administration [17]. Our study also confirms that age is a significant individual risk factor for MSDs. This is an important priority in OSH due to the changing age profile in employment, with a higher prevalence of older adults in the workforce due to increased life expectancy and longer working age [4]. Age increases the risk of MSDs for biological reasons, and potential concurrent health problems in aging workers may contribute to a decreased likelihood of coping well. However, it is essential to recognize that physical and psychosocial risks associated with MSDs change differently for each age group, and the impact on the increase of MSDs risk depends more on work demands than age [42]. Previous studies have shown that manual work is more associated with the risk of developing MSDs in older workers and early retirement due to disability. However, the likelihood of developing diseases depends more on work demands than age [43].
Educational level and marital status were associated with Back, Lower limb, or Shoulder, neck, and/or upper limb pains. Specifically, those with lower education levels and those reporting being divorced or widowed showed a higher likelihood of experiencing MSDs than those without a partner. Education appears to have emerged as a protective factor for MSDs, possibly due to the association between higher levels of education and working positions. However, most of these sociodemographic factors correspond to non-modifiable aspects of an individual. Although recovery interventions can be implemented for those groups identified at higher risk, we are interested in identifying aspects that can be managed to eliminate the source of risk or protect exposed workers with a prevention approach, such as addressing psychosocial risks.
Regarding psychosocial risks, our study confirms a higher association with MSDs in cases of effort/reward imbalance [44] and shows a link with a moderate or very high risk of being the victim of violent behaviour and harassment at work. During the pandemic, violence and harassment at work have become growing risks in the workplace. They are important psychosocial risk factors affecting individual health and well-being, which are among the priorities for the future of work [22, 45]. Surprisingly, our multivariate models did not show any significant association between more traditional psychosocial aspects, such as control, support, job insecurity, and reported MSDs, as found in previous studies [20]. Nevertheless, according to Buruck and colleagues [20], other work factors may play a role in reducing the impact of stressors on health beyond traditional models of stress at work, particularly those that are becoming increasingly important in the future of work. Moreover, our findings indicate that those reporting major depressive symptoms have a higher likelihood of experiencing either Back or Lower limb pain, highlighting the comorbidity between MSDs and depressive symptoms that could account for the chronicity of the diseases over time, leading to an increase in early retirement from work [46]. This further reinforces the need to include psychosocial aspects in studying MSDs.
The multifactorial nature of MSDs and the associations found in our data with sociodemographic, occupational, and work-related factors, as well as health status, underscore the need for diverse and context-sensitive approaches to managing MSDs risk at work. Integrated risk assessment systems that consider both physical and psychosocial hazards are essential in defining the most effective prevention strategies. Although psychosocial risks have a negative impact on MSDs, they also offer potential solutions as they represent modifiable aspects of work and work organization that can be effectively managed. Additionally, diversity-sensitive risk assessment and management interventions can better cater to the specific needs and individual characteristics of workers, such as women and older workers. To achieve this, organizations should adopt an integrated model based on a participative approach to identify and address all potential hazards, including psychosocial ones, and to implement customized interventions [11]. Participation is crucial in this approach as it ensures the effectiveness of the assessment and management strategy, fostering reliable risk assessment. All stakeholders, including those not directly involved but who influence the jobs involved in the interventions, need to be engaged for interventions to succeed. Therefore, better integration of roles among employers, employees, line managers, and organizational and local OHS professionals is essential.
Embracing the total worker health approach [47], health promotion and training are essential components of this multidisciplinary and integrated approach, integrating public health interventions with occupational health interventions. This approach fosters a link between workers' health, work organization, and the work environment in terms of protection, prevention, and promotion. Our findings underscore the need for approaches and strategies that combine occupational safety and health prevention with health promotion actions. National policies and strategies reflecting this approach are taking shape, with initiatives to adopt healthy lifestyles alongside traditional workplace risk reduction efforts. However, more action is needed at the policy level to drive progress in this direction. Developing effective policies and strategies also relies on the availability of consistent data and analytics over time. Data are essential to monitor MSD prevalence over time, identify critical issues, and provide evidence for designing and delivering interventions tailored to different worker groups and their specific needs. This data-driven approach will support the establishment of a learning health system where feedback loops inform OSH specialists, policymakers, researchers, and enterprises in designing or redesigning effective interventions to tackle MSDs at work.
Limitations and future perspectives
Some limitations should be considered when interpreting the results of this study. Firstly, while the sample size represents a large and representative portion of the Italian workforce, the cross-sectional design of the study precludes establishing causal relationships. Future longitudinal studies would be necessary to explore causality further. Secondly, the study relied on self-reported measures for psychosocial risks, MSDs, and health outcomes, which may introduce recall and social desirability biases. To enhance the validity of MSDs diagnosis and assessment, it would be preferable to include interviews, medical examinations, and self-report questionnaires. Thirdly, the study did not encompass self-employed workers, military or civil protection personnel, potentially limiting the generalizability of the findings to these groups. Fourthly, the study could not demonstrate presumed interaction effects, such as those related to autonomy and professional position, on the biomechanical or psychosocial pathways. However, clear direct effects were observed in the model. To explore these interactions, future research may need to delve into specific areas of the work field and focus on particular factors, rather than employing an integrated model like the one presented here. Finally, it is important to note that the study was conducted before the COVID-19 pandemic, which has likely significantly impacted workers' perceptions of psychosocial risks and MSDs. The pandemic introduced new work practices, such as smart working, with benefits and challenges. Aspects such as increased reliance on technology and potential feelings of isolation have not been investigated in this study and warrant further exploration in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.